The Blue Diamond in the Goose
I visited my friend Sherlock Holmes on the second morning after Christmas to wish him a happy holiday.
He was stretched out on the sofa in a purple dressing gown, smoking his pipe. A pile of freshly read newspapers lay beside him.
Next to the sofa stood a wooden chair. Hanging from the back was a battered old felt hat, cracked and badly worn. A magnifying glass and a pair of forceps lay on the seat, making it obvious that Holmes had been examining it.
“You’re busy,” I said. “Perhaps I’m interrupting you.”
“Not at all. I’m actually glad to have someone to discuss my findings with.”
He pointed at the hat.
“The matter is completely trivial. But there are a few interesting things we can learn from it.”
I sat down beside the fire and warmed my hands. The frost outside was so severe that the windows were covered with ice.
“I suppose that miserable-looking hat must be connected with some terrible crime,” I said. “Perhaps it’s the clue that will lead you to a criminal.”
Holmes laughed.
“No crime this time. It’s simply one of those strange little incidents that happen when four million people are crowded together in one city.”
“When that many people are constantly crossing paths, almost anything can happen. Some problems may be strange and fascinating without involving any crime at all.”
“That’s true,” I said. “Three of the last six cases I’ve written about involved no crime whatsoever.”
“Exactly. You mean the Irene Adler affair, the strange case of Miss Mary Sutherland, and the adventure of the man with the twisted lip.”
He pointed at the hat.
“This little problem will probably be just as innocent.”
“You know Peterson, the commissionaire?”
“Yes.”
“This hat belongs to him.”
“It’s his?”
“No. He found it. We don’t know who actually owns it.”
Holmes smiled.
“I want you to stop thinking of it as an old, battered hat. Think of it as a puzzle.”
“How did it come into your possession?”
“It arrived here on Christmas morning, together with a fine goose.”
“I assume that goose is being roasted at Peterson’s house right now.”
“Almost certainly.”
Holmes settled deeper into the sofa.
“Here is what happened. At about four in the morning, Peterson was walking home along Tottenham Court Road after attending a small Christmas celebration.”
“He saw a fairly tall man walking unsteadily down the street. The man had a white goose hanging over his shoulder.”
“When they reached Goodge Street, a group of rough-looking men started arguing with him.”
“One of them knocked off the man’s hat.”
“The man raised his walking stick to defend himself. As he swung it over his head, he smashed the window of a shop behind him.”
“Peterson rushed forward to protect him.”
“But the man was terrified when he realized what he had done. Then he saw Peterson, a uniformed official, coming toward him.”
“He dropped the goose, turned around, and ran into the maze of little streets behind Tottenham Court Road.”
“The roughs ran away too.”
“So Peterson was left standing there with the broken shop window, the abandoned goose, and this battered hat.”
“Surely he tried to return them to their owner?”
“That is where the problem begins.”
“There was a little card tied to the goose’s leg. It said, ‘For Mrs. Henry Baker.’”
“The initials ‘H. B.’ were also visible inside the hat.”
“But there are thousands of Bakers in London, and hundreds of men named Henry Baker.”
“So finding the right man isn’t as easy as it sounds.”
“What did Peterson do?”
“He brought both the hat and the goose to me on Christmas morning.”
“He knew I enjoy even the smallest puzzles.”
“We kept the goose until this morning. But it was beginning to look as though it needed to be eaten immediately, even with the cold weather.”
“So Peterson took it home.”
“And I kept the hat belonging to our unknown gentleman.”
“Did he advertise for the owner?”
“No.”
“Then what clue do you have?”
“Whatever we can deduce.”
“From the hat?”
“Precisely.”
“You’re joking. What could anyone possibly learn from an old hat?”
Holmes picked it up.
“You know how I work. Look at it yourself.”
“What can you tell me about the man who wore it?”
I examined the hat carefully.
It was an ordinary black felt hat, round and hard, but badly worn. The lining had once been red silk, though most of the color had faded. There was no maker’s name.
The initials “H. B.” were written inside.
There was a hole in the brim where a hat-securer had once been attached, but the elastic was gone.
The hat was cracked, dusty, and stained in several places. Someone had even tried to hide some of the stains with ink.
“I can’t see anything useful,” I said, handing it back.
Holmes smiled.
“On the contrary, Watson. You can see everything.”
“You simply don’t reason from what you see.”
“Then tell me what you can deduce.”
Holmes picked up the hat and studied it thoughtfully.
“It tells us several things.”
“First, the man is highly intelligent.”
“He was also reasonably well-off until about three years ago, but his financial situation has declined.”
“He used to be careful and prepared. He isn’t anymore.”
“That suggests a decline in his character as well, perhaps caused by alcohol.”
“And that may explain why his wife has stopped loving him.”
“My dear Holmes!”
He ignored my protest.
“He still has some self-respect.”
“He lives a sedentary life and rarely goes outside.”
“He is middle-aged and badly out of shape.”
“His hair is turning gray. He had it cut within the last few days, and he uses lime-cream on it.”
“There is one other interesting point.”
“It is highly unlikely that he has gas lighting in his house.”
I stared at him.
“You must be joking.”
“Not at all.”
“Surely you can see how I reached these conclusions?”
“I admit I can’t.”
“For example, how did you know he was intelligent?”
Holmes put the hat on his own head.
It dropped almost to the bridge of his nose.
“It’s a matter of head size,” he said.
“A man with a head this large must have a large brain.”
“And how do you know his financial situation has declined?”
“This hat is about three years old. These flat, curled brims became fashionable around that time.”
“It was a very expensive hat.”
“Look at the silk band and the quality of the lining.”
“If he could afford such a hat three years ago and hasn’t replaced it since, then his finances have clearly gone downhill.”
“That makes sense.”
“But what about his foresight and moral decline?”
Holmes laughed.
“Here is the evidence of his old foresight.”
He pointed at the small disc and loop on the hat.
“Hat-securers were not normally sold already attached to hats.”
“If he had one fitted, it means he took precautions against the wind.”
“But the elastic has broken, and he never replaced it.”
“So he is less careful now than he once was.”
“That suggests a decline in his character.”
“And look here.”
He pointed to the stains.
“He tried to hide some of them with ink.”
“That tells us he still cares about his appearance.”
“Your reasoning is certainly possible.”
“The other details are easier.”
“The gray hair, recent haircut, and lime-cream can all be found by examining the lower part of the lining.”
“The magnifying glass reveals many short pieces of hair.”
“They were cleanly cut by scissors.”
“They also have something sticky on them, and there is a clear smell of lime-cream.”
“And this dust isn’t the rough gray dust of the street. It is soft brown household dust.”
“That means the hat has spent most of its time hanging indoors.”
“There are also marks of moisture inside.”
“That tells us the man sweats heavily, so he is certainly not in good physical condition.”
“But you said his wife had stopped loving him.”
“This hat hasn’t been brushed for weeks.”
“If I saw you walking around with a week’s worth of dust on your hat, Watson, and your wife allowed you to do so, I would begin to suspect that she no longer cared about your appearance.”
“He could be unmarried.”
“No. He was taking the goose home as a peace offering.”
“Remember the card attached to the bird.”
“You have an explanation for everything.”
“But how did you know he has no gas lighting?”
“One tallow stain might mean nothing.”
“Two might still be an accident.”
“But there are five.”
“That means the man often comes into contact with burning tallow.”
“Perhaps he walks upstairs at night carrying a candle in one hand and his hat in the other.”
“He certainly doesn’t get those stains from a gas lamp.”
“Are you satisfied?”
“It is very clever,” I said with a laugh.
“But since there is no crime and only a lost goose, all this seems like a great deal of effort for nothing.”
Holmes opened his mouth to answer.
At that exact moment, the door burst open.
Peterson rushed into the room, red-faced and breathing heavily.
“The goose, Mr. Holmes!”
“The goose!”
“What about it?”
Holmes turned toward him.
“Has it somehow come back to life and escaped through the kitchen window?”
“Look, sir!”
“Look what my wife found inside it!”
Peterson opened his hand.
In the center of his palm lay a brilliant blue stone.
It was slightly smaller than a bean, but it shone so brightly that it seemed to glow in the dim room.
Holmes sat upright.
“Good heavens, Peterson!”
“This is quite a discovery.”
“I suppose you know what you’re holding?”
“A diamond, sir?”
“A precious stone?”
“It’s more than that.”
“It is the precious stone.”
I stared at him.
“You don’t mean the Countess of Morcar’s blue carbuncle?”
“Exactly.”
“I ought to recognize it. I’ve been reading about it in The Times every day.”
“It is completely unique.”
“No one can say exactly what it is worth, but the reward of £1,000 is probably less than one-twentieth of its true market value.”
“A thousand pounds!”
Peterson collapsed into a chair.
“Good Lord!”
“That is only the official reward.”
“I have reason to believe there are personal reasons behind it as well.”
“The Countess might give away half her fortune to recover that stone.”
“It was stolen from the Hotel Cosmopolitan, wasn’t it?” I asked.
“Exactly.”
“Five days ago, on December 22nd.”
“A plumber named John Horner was accused of stealing it from the Countess’s jewel case.”
“The evidence against him was strong enough for the case to be sent to the Assizes.”
Holmes searched through the newspapers.
“I believe I have the report here.”
He finally found it, flattened the paper, and read aloud.
“John Horner, twenty-six, a plumber, was accused of stealing the Countess of Morcar’s famous blue carbuncle on December 22nd.”
“James Ryder, a senior hotel attendant, stated that he had taken Horner to the Countess’s dressing room so that Horner could repair a loose bar on the fireplace.”
“Ryder left the room for a short time.”
“When he returned, Horner was gone.”
“The jewel case had been forced open, and the small leather box containing the Countess’s jewel was lying empty on the dressing table.”
“Ryder immediately raised the alarm.”
“Horner was arrested later that evening, but the missing stone was not found on him or in his rooms.”
“The Countess’s maid, Catherine Cusack, confirmed hearing Ryder’s alarm and entering the room.”
“Inspector Bradstreet testified about Horner’s arrest.”
“Horner had struggled violently and insisted that he was innocent.”
“A previous conviction for theft was also mentioned.”
“Because of that history, the magistrate refused to settle the matter immediately and sent the case to the Assizes.”
“Horner became extremely emotional and fainted when the hearing ended.”
Holmes tossed the newspaper aside.
“That is the official story.”
He looked thoughtful.
“Our real problem is much more interesting.”
“How did a stolen jewel leave a locked jewel box and end up inside the crop of a goose in Tottenham Court Road?”
He looked at me.
“You see, Watson, our harmless little deductions have suddenly become rather important.”
“We have the stone.”
“The stone came from the goose.”
“The goose belonged to Henry Baker.”
“And Henry Baker is the man who wore that battered hat.”
“So we need to find him and discover whether he had anything to do with the affair.”
“The simplest approach is to place an advertisement in the evening newspapers.”
“If that fails, I’ll try something else.”
“What will the advertisement say?”
“Give me a pencil.”
Holmes wrote:
“Found near the corner of Goodge Street: a goose and a black felt hat. Mr. Henry Baker may collect them at 6:30 this evening at 221B Baker Street.”
“Simple and clear.”
“But will he see it?”
“He should.”
“The loss of the goose would have been serious for a poor man.”
“He was so frightened by the broken window and Peterson’s arrival that he probably thought only of escaping.”
“But afterward, he must have regretted abandoning his Christmas dinner.”
“Once he sees his own name in the newspaper, he will certainly respond.”
He handed the note to Peterson.
“Take this to the advertising agency.”
“Have it placed in the evening papers.”
“Which ones, sir?”
“The Globe, Star, Pall Mall, St. James’s Gazette, Evening News, Standard, Echo, and any others you think suitable.”
“Yes, sir.”
“And the stone?”
“I’ll keep that here.”
“Thank you.”
“And Peterson?”
“Yes, sir?”
“Buy another goose on your way back.”
“We need something to give Mr. Baker when he comes.”
Peterson left.
Holmes held the blue stone up to the light.
“It’s a beautiful thing.”
“Look at how it catches the light.”
“Of course, a stone like this is often at the center of crime.”
“Precious stones have a way of attracting trouble.”
“This one is less than twenty years old.”
“It was discovered near the Amoy River in southern China.”
“It has every characteristic of a carbuncle, except for its blue color rather than the usual deep red.”
“Despite being so young, it already has a terrible history.”
“Two murders.”
“One acid attack.”
“A suicide.”
“And several robberies.”
“All committed because of this tiny piece of crystallized carbon.”
Holmes shook his head.
“It’s remarkable that something so beautiful can bring people to prison or even to the gallows.”
“I’ll lock it away now and write to the Countess.”
“Do you think Horner is innocent?”
“I don’t know.”
“What about Henry Baker?”
“Do you think he was involved?”
“I strongly suspect Henry Baker is completely innocent.”
“He probably had no idea that the bird he carried was worth far more than its weight in gold.”
“I can test that very easily if he responds to our advertisement.”
“And until then?”
“There is nothing we can do.”
“In that case, I’ll continue with my medical rounds.”
“But I’ll return this evening. I want to see how this mystery ends.”
“I’ll be glad to have you.”
“I dine at seven.”
“I believe there’s a woodcock.”
Holmes smiled.
“Given what has happened lately, perhaps I should ask Mrs. Hudson to check its crop first.”
I was delayed by another case, so it was after half past six when I finally reached Baker Street.
As I approached the house, I saw a tall man wearing a Scottish cap and a coat buttoned tightly to his chin waiting outside.
The fanlight above the door cast a bright circle of light around him.
Just as I arrived, the door opened.
We were shown upstairs together.
“Mr. Henry Baker, I presume?”
Holmes rose and greeted him warmly.
“Please sit here by the fire, Mr. Baker.”
“It’s a bitterly cold night.”
“I notice that you seem much better suited to warm weather.”
Then he turned to me.
“Ah, Watson. You’ve arrived at exactly the right moment.”
Holmes looked at the visitor’s head.
“Is that your hat, Mr. Baker?”
“Yes, sir.”
“That is certainly my hat.”
He was a large man with rounded shoulders, a broad head, and an intelligent face.
A pointed beard covered his chin.
His hair was gray-brown.
His cheeks and nose were slightly red, and his hand trembled a little.
His old black coat was buttoned tightly to the neck.
His wrists stuck out from the sleeves without cuffs or visible shirt.
He spoke slowly and carefully, giving the impression of a well-educated man whose life had not treated him kindly.
“We have kept these things for several days,” Holmes said.
“We expected you to advertise for them and give us your address.”
“Why didn’t you?”
Baker gave an embarrassed little laugh.
“I haven’t had as much money lately as I used to.”
“I assumed the men who attacked me had taken both my hat and the goose.”
“I didn’t want to spend money trying to recover things I thought were probably gone forever.”
“Quite understandable.”
“As for the bird, I’m afraid we had to eat it.”
“Eat it?”
Baker half rose from his chair.
“Yes.”
“It would have been wasted otherwise.”
“But I have another goose here.”
Holmes pointed toward the sideboard.
“It is roughly the same size and completely fresh.”
“Would that be acceptable?”
“Oh, yes.”
“Absolutely.”
Baker sat back down with obvious relief.
“We still have the feathers, legs, and other remains from your original bird.”
“If you want them, you may take them.”
Baker burst out laughing.
“They might make amusing souvenirs.”
“But I can’t imagine what use the remains of my old dinner would be to me.”
“I’ll take the fresh goose, if you don’t mind.”
Holmes glanced at me.
“There is your hat.”
“And there is your bird.”
“By the way, would you mind telling me where you got the goose?”
“I’m rather fond of poultry, and that was an unusually fine bird.”
“Certainly,” Baker said.
“There are several of us who regularly visit the Alpha Inn near the Museum.”
“We spend much of the day at the Museum.”
“This year, the landlord, Windigate, started a goose club.”
“We each paid a few pennies every week, and at Christmas we received a goose.”
“I paid all my contributions.”
“The rest you already know.”
“I’m very grateful for the return of my property.”
“This Scottish cap is hardly suitable for a man of my age or dignity.”
He bowed with exaggerated seriousness and left.
Holmes closed the door behind him.
“Well, that settles Henry Baker.”
“He clearly knows nothing about the crime.”
“Are you hungry, Watson?”
“Not particularly.”
“Then let’s turn dinner into supper.”
“We should follow this clue while it is still fresh.”
“Agreed.”
It was a brutally cold night.
We pulled on our heavy coats and wrapped scarves around our necks.
The sky was clear, and the stars shone sharply overhead.
Every passer-by breathed out clouds of white vapor.
Our footsteps echoed on the frozen streets as we walked through the doctors’ district, along Wimpole Street and Harley Street, then through Wigmore Street into Oxford Street.
Fifteen minutes later, we reached Bloomsbury and the Alpha Inn.
It was a small public house near Holborn.
Holmes entered the private bar and ordered two beers from the red-faced landlord in a white apron.
“Your beer must be as good as your geese,” Holmes said.
“My geese?”
The landlord looked puzzled.
“Yes.”
“I was speaking to Henry Baker less than half an hour ago.”
“He told me he belonged to your goose club.”
“Oh, yes.”
“I understand.”
“But those aren’t our geese.”
“Really?”
“Whose are they?”
“I bought two dozen from a salesman at Covent Garden.”
“Who was he?”
“Breckinridge.”
“Do I know him?”
Holmes shook his head.
“Which salesman?”
“Breckinridge.”
“I see.”
“Here’s to your health and prosperity.”
“Good night.”
As we left, Holmes buttoned his coat.
“Now we find Mr. Breckinridge.”
“Remember, Watson, we have a goose at one end of this chain.”
“At the other end is a man who may spend seven years in prison unless we can prove him innocent.”
“We may discover that he is guilty.”
“But we have stumbled onto a line of investigation the police completely missed.”
“And by sheer chance, it has fallen into our hands.”
“We must follow it to the end.”
“South, then.”
“And quickly.”
We crossed Holborn, walked down Endell Street, and made our way through a maze of narrow streets toward Covent Garden Market.
One of the largest stalls had the name Breckinridge above it.
The owner was a rough-looking man with a sharp face and neat side-whiskers.
He was helping a boy close the stall for the night.
“Good evening,” Holmes said.
“Cold night, isn’t it?”
The salesman nodded and looked suspiciously at him.
“You’ve sold all your geese, I see.”
Holmes pointed at the empty marble counter.
“I can supply five hundred tomorrow morning.”
“That’s no use to me.”
“There are still some under the gaslight.”
“Ah.”
“But I was told to come to you.”
“By whom?”
“The landlord of the Alpha Inn.”
“Oh, yes.”
“I sold him two dozen.”
“They were excellent birds.”
“Where did you get them?”
The question immediately angered the salesman.
“Now listen,” he snapped.
“What exactly are you getting at?”
“I only want to know who supplied the geese you sold to the Alpha.”
“Well, I’m not telling you.”
“Is that clear?”
“It’s really not important.”
“I just don’t understand why you’re getting so angry.”
“Angry?”
“You’d be angry too if people had been bothering you all day.”
“I buy good goods with my own money.”
“Then I should be able to sell them without answering a hundred questions.”
“Where are the geese?”
“Who bought them?”
“Who sold them?”
“How much do you want?”
“You’d think those were the only geese in London.”
Holmes shrugged.
“I’m not connected with any of the other people who have been asking.”
“If you won’t tell me, that’s fine.”
“But I’m willing to bet that the goose I ate was country-bred.”
“Well, you’ve just lost your money.”
“It was town-bred.”
“No, it wasn’t.”
“I say it was.”
“I don’t believe you.”
“Do you know more about geese than I do?”
“I’ve been dealing with them since I was a boy.”
“All the birds I sold to the Alpha were town-bred.”
“I still don’t believe you.”
“Then bet me.”
“I’d be taking your money.”
“But I’ll bet a sovereign just to prove my point.”
The salesman gave a grim chuckle.
“Bring me the books, Bill.”
The boy brought over two ledgers.
One was small and thin.
The other was large and covered in grease stains.
The salesman placed them beneath the hanging lamp.
“Now, Mr. Know-It-All.”
“I thought I was out of geese.”
“But before we finish, you’ll discover I still have one left.”
“You see this small book?”
“Yes.”
“It contains the names of the people I buy from.”
“Here are the country suppliers.”
“The numbers beside their names tell me where to find their accounts in the big ledger.”
“And this page, written in red, contains my town suppliers.”
“Now look at the third name.”
“Read it.”
Holmes looked down.
“Mrs. Oakshott, 117 Brixton Road—249.”
“Exactly.”
“Now find her in the ledger.”
Holmes turned to the correct page.
“Here it is.”
“Mrs. Oakshott, 117 Brixton Road, egg and poultry supplier.”
“What is the last entry?”
“December 22nd.”
“Twenty-four geese at seven shillings and sixpence each.”
“Exactly.”
“And underneath?”
“Sold to Mr. Windigate of the Alpha at twelve shillings each.”
The salesman grinned.
“Well?”
Holmes looked deeply annoyed.
Without saying a word, he took out a sovereign and placed it on the counter.
Then he turned away as though he couldn’t bear to discuss the matter.
A few yards away, beneath a street lamp, Holmes suddenly burst into silent laughter.
“When you see a man with whiskers like that and the Pink ’un sticking out of his pocket, you can always tempt him with a bet.”
“I doubt that even £100 would have made him give us information so quickly.”
“He simply couldn’t resist the idea of winning a wager.”
“We’re almost at the end of our search.”
“The only question is whether we visit Mrs. Oakshott tonight or tomorrow.”
“It’s clear from that unpleasant fellow that other people are also desperately interested in these geese.”
“I think we should—”
Holmes stopped.
A loud argument had broken out behind us.
We turned.
Under the yellow light of the stall, a small man with a rat-like face stood trembling while Breckinridge shouted angrily at him.
“I’ve had enough of you and your geese!”
“I wish the whole lot of you would disappear!”
“If you bother me again, I’ll let the dog loose on you.”
“Bring Mrs. Oakshott here and I’ll speak to her.”
“But what business is it of yours?”
“Did I buy the geese from you?”
“No,” the little man whined.
“But one of them was mine!”
“Then ask Mrs. Oakshott for it.”
“She told me to ask you.”
“Well, you can ask the King of Prussia for all I care.”
“I’ve had enough.”
“Get out!”
Breckinridge lunged toward him.
The little man disappeared into the darkness.
Holmes smiled.
“That saves us a trip to Brixton Road.”
“Come along.”
“We’ll see what this man knows.”
We hurried after him.
Holmes soon caught up and touched him on the shoulder.
The man spun around.
Under the gaslight, I saw that all the color had drained from his face.
“Who are you?”
“What do you want?”
“Forgive me,” Holmes said calmly.
“I couldn’t help overhearing your conversation.”
“I believe I may be able to help you.”
“You?”
“How could you possibly know anything about this?”
“My name is Sherlock Holmes.”
“It is my business to know what other people don’t.”
The man stared at him.
“But you can’t know anything about this.”
“On the contrary.”
“I know everything.”
“You’re trying to trace a group of geese sold by Mrs. Oakshott of Brixton Road to Breckinridge.”
“Breckinridge sold them to Mr. Windigate of the Alpha.”
“Windigate supplied them to his goose club.”
“One member of that club was Henry Baker.”
The little man grabbed Holmes’s hands.
“Oh, sir!”
“You’re exactly the man I’ve been desperate to find.”
“I can hardly explain how important this is to me.”
Holmes hailed a passing cab.
“Then we should discuss this somewhere warmer.”
“But first, tell me who I’m helping.”
The man hesitated.
“My name is John Robinson.”
Holmes smiled.
“No.”
“Your real name.”
“It’s always inconvenient to conduct business under a false name.”
The man’s face turned red.
“My real name is James Ryder.”
“Exactly.”
“Senior attendant at the Hotel Cosmopolitan.”
“Get into the cab.”
“I think I can soon tell you everything you need to know.”
Ryder stared at us nervously.
He seemed unable to decide whether he had just found salvation or walked into a trap.
Finally, he climbed into the cab.
Half an hour later, we were back at Baker Street.
During the entire journey, Ryder said nothing.
But his rapid breathing and constantly clasped hands revealed how terrified he was.
“Here we are,” Holmes said cheerfully.
“The fire should help.”
“You look frozen, Mr. Ryder.”
“Sit in the armchair.”
“I’ll change into my slippers, and then we’ll discuss your little problem.”
“You want to know what happened to those geese?”
“Yes, sir.”
“Or rather, you want to know what happened to one particular goose.”
“A white goose with a black bar across its tail.”
Ryder trembled.
“Oh, sir!”
“Can you tell me where it went?”
“It came here.”
“Here?”
“Yes.”
“And it turned out to be a very unusual bird.”
“I understand why you’ve been searching for it.”
“It laid an egg after it was dead.”
“The most beautiful little blue egg you could imagine.”
“I have it here in my collection.”
Ryder suddenly stood up.
He grabbed the mantelpiece to steady himself.
Holmes unlocked his safe.
Then he held up the blue carbuncle.
The stone flashed like a cold star.
Ryder stared at it.
His face had gone completely white.
He seemed unable to decide whether to claim it or deny knowing anything about it.
“The game is over, Ryder,” Holmes said quietly.
“Sit down before you fall into the fire.”
“Watson, help him.”
“He doesn’t have enough blood in him to commit a serious crime without collapsing.”
“Give him some brandy.”
A little color returned to Ryder’s face.
He sat trembling and stared at Holmes.
“I already have almost every piece of evidence I need.”
“So you don’t have to tell me much.”
“But I want the final details confirmed.”
“You had heard about the Countess of Morcar’s blue stone.”
“It was Catherine Cusack who told me,” Ryder whispered.
“The Countess’s maid.”
“I see.”
“The temptation of sudden wealth was too much for you.”
“It has ruined better men than you.”
“But you chose a particularly ugly way to get it.”
“You knew that Horner, the plumber, had previously been suspected of theft.”
“So you knew suspicion would fall easily on him.”
“What did you do?”
“You and Cusack arranged for Horner to be called to the Countess’s room.”
“You created some small repair job.”
“Once he was there, you made sure you could leave him alone.”
“Then you stole the jewel.”
“You raised the alarm.”
“And Horner was arrested.”
Ryder suddenly threw himself onto the floor and grabbed Holmes by the knees.
“For God’s sake, have mercy!”
“Think about my father!”
“My mother!”
“It would destroy them.”
“I’ve never done anything like this before.”
“I swear I never will again.”
“I’ll swear it on the Bible.”
“Please don’t take me to court!”
“Get back in your chair,” Holmes said sternly.
“It’s easy to beg for mercy now.”
“But you showed no mercy to Horner.”
“You let an innocent man face prison for your crime.”
“I’ll leave the country, Mr. Holmes.”
“I’ll disappear.”
“Then the case against Horner will collapse.”
“Perhaps.”
“We’ll discuss that.”
“But first, tell me exactly what happened next.”
“How did the stone get inside the goose?”
“And how did that goose end up being sold at the market?”
“Tell me the truth.”
“That is your only hope.”
Ryder swallowed.
His lips were dry.
“I’ll tell you exactly what happened.”
“After Horner was arrested, I realized I had to get rid of the stone immediately.”
“I was afraid the police might search me or my room.”
“There was nowhere safe to hide it in the hotel.”
“So I left as though I had some ordinary errand.”
“I went to my sister’s house.”
“She had married a man named Oakshott.”
“They lived on Brixton Road and raised geese for the market.”
“Everyone I passed on the way looked like a policeman or detective.”
“Even though it was freezing, I was sweating before I reached Brixton Road.”
“My sister asked why I was so pale.”
“I told her the jewel robbery had frightened me.”
“Then I went into the backyard, lit a pipe, and tried to think of a way out.”
“I once knew a man named Maudsley.”
“He became a criminal and had recently finished a prison sentence at Pentonville.”
“He had once told me about how thieves disposed of stolen goods.”
“I knew some secrets about him, so I trusted him.”
“I decided to go to Kilburn and ask him how I could turn the stone into money.”
“But I still had to get there safely.”
“I remembered how terrified I had been on the journey from the hotel.”
“At any moment, the police might stop and search me.”
“And the stone was sitting in my waistcoat pocket.”
“I was leaning against the wall, watching the geese wandering around my feet.”
“Then suddenly I had an idea.”
“I thought I had found a way to fool even the greatest detective in the world.”
“My sister had told me weeks earlier that I could choose one of her geese as a Christmas present.”
“She always kept her word.”
“So I decided to take one immediately.”
“I would hide the stone inside it and carry it safely to Kilburn.”
“There was a small shed in the yard.”
“I drove one of the geese behind it.”
“It was a large white bird with a barred tail.”
“I caught it.”
“I forced its beak open and pushed the stone down its throat as far as I could.”
“The goose swallowed.”
“I felt the stone move down into its crop.”
“But the bird suddenly began flapping and struggling.”
“My sister came outside to see what was happening.”
“As I turned to answer her, the goose broke free and disappeared among the others.”
“‘What were you doing with that goose, Jem?’ she asked.”
“I told her I was choosing my Christmas goose.”
“She reminded me that she had already set one aside for me.”
“She said it was the big white one over there.”
“There were twenty-six geese in all.”
“One for me.”
“One for the family.”
“And two dozen for the market.”
“I thanked her.”
“But I said I wanted the bird I had just been holding.”
“She told me the other goose was several pounds heavier and had been specially fattened for me.”
“I said I didn’t care.”
“I wanted the white one with the barred tail.”
“She finally told me to kill it and take it.”
“So I did.”
“I carried the bird all the way to Kilburn.”
“I told Maudsley what I had done.”
“He laughed so hard he could barely breathe.”
“Then we opened the goose with a knife.”
“My heart sank.”
“There was no stone.”
“I knew something had gone terribly wrong.”
“I left the dead bird there and rushed back to my sister’s house.”
“When I reached the backyard, there wasn’t a goose in sight.”
“Where are all the geese?” I asked my sister.”
“She said they had gone to the dealer.”
“Which dealer?”
“Breckinridge in Covent Garden.”
“I asked whether there had been another goose with a barred tail.”
“She said yes.”
“There had been two.”
“She could never tell them apart.”
“That was when I understood.”
“I ran to Breckinridge as fast as I could.”
“But he had already sold the entire lot.”
“He refused to tell me where they had gone.”
“You heard him yourselves tonight.”
“He has always treated me that way.”
“My sister thinks I’m going mad.”
“Sometimes I think she may be right.”
“And now…”
“Now I’m a branded thief.”
“I ruined my life for a fortune I never even possessed.”
“God help me!”
Ryder buried his face in his hands and began to sob.
For a long time, nobody spoke.
Only Ryder’s heavy breathing broke the silence.
Holmes tapped his fingers slowly against the table.
Then he stood.
He opened the door.
“Get out.”
Ryder looked up.
“Sir?”
“Get out.”
“God bless you!”
“No more words.”
“Go.”
Ryder rushed from the room.
His footsteps thundered down the stairs.
A door slammed.
Then we heard his footsteps disappear into the street.
Holmes reached for his clay pipe.
“After all, Watson, the police don’t pay me to do their work for them.”
“If Horner were still in immediate danger, that would be different.”
“But Ryder won’t testify against him.”
“The case will have to collapse.”
“I suppose I’m technically helping someone escape punishment for a felony.”
“But perhaps I’m also saving a man’s soul.”
“If we sent him to prison now, he might spend the rest of his life as a professional criminal.”
“He is already terrified enough to make sure he never goes down that road again.”
“And besides, Watson, it is Christmas.”
“Sometimes forgiveness matters more than punishment.”
“This strange little mystery fell into our hands purely by chance.”
“And solving it is reward enough.”
Holmes smiled and reached for the bell.
“If you would be so kind as to ring that, Doctor, we can begin another investigation.”
“Apparently, a bird will be involved in that one too.”
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!