The Escape at Huarong Path
That night, Zhang Liao shot Huang Gai with an arrow, knocking him into the river. He got Cao Cao safely onto the bank, and by the time they found horses to flee, Cao’s army was already thrown into total chaos.
Han Dang charged toward the enemy water camp through flames and smoke. Soon one of his soldiers called out, “There’s a man on the stern rudder shouting your courtesy name, General.”
Han Dang listened closely. The voice cried, “Yigong, save me!”
“That’s Huang Gongfu!” Han Dang exclaimed. He quickly ordered his men to pull him out of the water. Huang Gai had been hit by an arrow. He had bitten off the shaft himself, but the arrowhead was still stuck deep in his flesh.
Han Dang rushed over, stripped off Huang Gai’s soaked clothes, cut out the arrowhead with a blade, tore a banner to bind the wound, and gave him his own battle robe to wear. He sent Huang Gai away on another boat back to the main camp to recover. Huang Gai was a strong swimmer, so even with armor on and in the bitter cold river, he had survived.
Flames rolled across the whole river that day, and shouts shook the earth. To the left, Han Dang and Jiang Qin’s troops attacked from the west of Chibi. To the right, Zhou Tai and Chen Wu’s men closed in from the east. Right in the center, Zhou Yu, Cheng Pu, Xu Sheng and Ding Feng’s main fleet arrived. Fire backed the soldiers, and soldiers amplified the terror of fire. This was the great river battle at Chibi. Countless Cao’s soldiers fell to spears and arrows, burned to death, or drowned in the river.
We leave the river fighting for a moment. Gan Ning took Cai Zhong as his guide and slipped deep inside Cao’s camp. In one stroke, Gan Ning cut Cai Zhong down on his horse, then set fire to the dry grass around them. When Lü Meng saw the flames rising in the middle of the camp, he lit more than a dozen fires to back Gan Ning up. Pan Zhang and Dong Xi spread out, starting fires and yelling battle cries. Drums boomed all around.
Cao Cao rode through burning woods with Zhang Liao and a hundred riders. Everywhere they looked, everything was on fire. As they fled, Mao Jie brought Wen Pin and a dozen cavalrymen to join them.
“Find us a way out!” Cao Cao ordered his men.
Zhang Liao pointed ahead. “Only Wulin is open and clear enough to pass through.”
Cao Cao turned his horse toward Wulin.
Then shouts erupted behind them. “Cao thief, stop!” The banner of Lü Meng appeared through the firelight. Cao Cao pushed his men forward and told Zhang Liao to hold Lü Meng back.
But more torches flared up ahead. Troops poured out of the valley. “Ling Tong is here!”
Cao Cao’s heart nearly burst with fear. Suddenly another group of soldiers charged in from the side. “Prime Minister, do not panic! Xu Huang is here!”
They fought a messy skirmish and broke through to head north.
Soon they spotted soldiers camped on a hillside. Xu Huang rode over to ask who they were. They were Ma Yan and Zhang Yi, former generals under Yuan Shao, with three thousand northern troops. They had watched the huge fire all night and not dared move, and now they met Cao Cao.
Cao Cao told the two generals to take a thousand men to lead the way. The rest would stay close to guard him. With this fresh unit, Cao Cao felt a little safer. Ma Yan and Zhang Yi galloped forward at the head of the column. Less than ten li later, battle cries rang out. A warrior burst out from the shadows. “I am Gan Xingba of Eastern Wu!”
Ma Yan tried to fight, but Gan Ning cut him down in one blow. Zhang Yi raised his spear to meet him. Gan Ning roared, and Zhang Yi fell off his horse before he could react.
Runners brought the news back to Cao Cao. He had hoped reinforcements from Hefei would come. But Sun Quan had seen the fire on the river from the Hefei road. He told Lu Xun to light signal fires. When Taishi Ci saw the signal, he joined forces with Lu Xun and attacked. Cao Cao had no choice but to flee toward Yiling. He met Zhang He along the way and ordered him to cover their retreat.
Cao Cao whipped his horse onward. By the fifth watch, the glow of the fires faded behind them, and he finally calmed down.
“Where are we?” he asked his men.
“West of Wulin, north of Yidu,” someone answered.
Cao Cao looked around. Trees grew thick, and mountains rose steeply. He threw back his head and laughed loudly on horseback.
His generals asked, “Prime Minister, why do you laugh?”
“I laugh not at others, but at Zhou Yu who has no strategy and Zhuge Liang who lacks wisdom,” Cao Cao said. “If I were commanding this battle, I would hide soldiers right here. What would become of us then?”
Before his words faded, drums thundered on both sides, and flames shot toward the sky. Cao Cao nearly fell off his horse. Troops rushed out from the side. “Zhao Zilong waits here by the military advisor’s order!”
Cao Cao told Xu Huang and Zhang He to fight Zhao Yun together. He raced away through smoke and fire. Zhao Yun did not chase them. He only sent his men to seize banners and weapons. Cao Cao escaped.
Dawn broke. Dark clouds covered the ground, and the southeast wind still blew hard. Then heavy rain poured down, soaking every soldier’s armor. Cao Cao and his men marched through rain. All of them looked starved. Cao Cao sent men to nearby villages to steal grain and find fire to cook. Just as they were about to light fires, enemy troops came after them.
Cao Cao panicked, but it was Li Dian and Xu Chu, guarding his advisors. Greatly relieved, Cao Cao ordered the army to keep moving.
“What lies ahead?” he asked.
“One road leads south to Yiling, the other north to Yiling through Calabash Gorge.”
“Which gets us to Jiangling in southern Jingzhou fastest?”
“The northern Yiling road through Calabash Gorge is the quickest.”
Cao Cao took the northern route.
They reached Calabash Gorge. The soldiers were too hungry to walk. Horses were worn out, many collapsed on the road. Cao Cao called for a halt. Some men still had pots strapped to their horses. Others had stolen grain from villages. They set up camp on dry ground beside the hills, lit fires, cut horse meat to eat. They took off their wet clothes and hung them in the wind to dry. Horses had their saddles removed to graze on grass.
Cao Cao sat under thin trees and laughed again.
His officers said, “Earlier you laughed at Zhou Yu and Zhuge Liang, and Zhao Zilong came after us, costing us many men. Why laugh now?”
“I laugh that Zhuge Liang and Zhou Yu still lack good judgment,” Cao Cao replied. “If I planned this battle, I would place an ambush right here, rested and ready. Even if we escaped with our lives, we would suffer heavy losses. They failed to think of this. That is why I laugh.”
At once, shouts erupted from front and rear. Cao Cao jumped, threw off his armor and mounted his horse. His men had no time to collect their horses. Fire closed in from all directions. Troops lined up across the mouth of the valley. Zhang Yide of Yan stood with spear raised on his horse.
“Cao thief, where do you think you’re going?”
All Cao’s men trembled at the sight of Zhang Fei. Xu Chu rode out against him without a saddle. Zhang Liao and Xu Huang charged in to join the fight. The armies clashed wildly. Cao Cao turned and fled first. His generals broke away one by one. Zhang Fei chased them. Cao Cao kept running, until the pursuit fell back. He looked back; most of his generals bore wounds.
Soon a soldier reported. “There are two roads ahead. Which should we take, Prime Minister?”
“Which one is shorter?”
“The main road is flatter, but fifty li longer. The small Huarong Path is fifty li shorter. Yet it is narrow, rough, full of pits and hard to travel.”
Cao Cao sent men up the hill to look. They returned. “There are plumes of smoke beside the hills on the small path. No sign of movement on the main road.”
“Take the small Huarong Path,” Cao Cao ordered.
His generals protested. “Where there is smoke, there must be enemy soldiers. Why take that road?”
“Have you not read the military texts? When the enemy appears empty, they are ready. When they appear ready, they are empty,” Cao Cao answered. “Zhuge Liang is clever. He set those fires in the remote hills to scare us off the small path, while he hides his army on the main road. I see through his trick. I will not fall for it.”
His generals praised his brilliant judgment.
They turned onto Huarong Path. By now, men were collapsing from hunger. Horses were exhausted. Burned and wounded soldiers helped each other along. Men hit by arrows limped forward. Their armor was soaked and ragged. Banners and weapons were broken. Most had thrown away saddles and clothes when they fled the pursuit at Yiling. It was bitter winter, and their suffering was terrible.
Cao Cao saw the front ranks stop. “What is wrong?”
“The path is narrow and rough. Rain earlier filled the holes with mud. Horses sink in and cannot move forward.”
Cao Cao flew into anger. “When an army marches, we cut through mountains and cross waters. Mud cannot stop us!”
He ordered the weak and injured to march slowly behind. Stronger men carried soil, brush and reeds to fill the muddy holes. They must work at once. Anyone who disobeyed would be executed.
The soldiers climbed down to cut trees and fill the ruts. Afraid enemy troops would catch up, Cao Cao sent Zhang Liao, Xu Chu and Xu Huang with a hundred riders to stand guard with swords. They killed anyone who slowed down. The men were already starving. Many fell to the ground. Cao Cao ordered his horses and men to trample over them. Countless died. Wailing filled the air.
“Life and death are fate,” Cao Cao roared. “Stop crying! Cry again and you die!”
Of every three groups of soldiers, one fell behind, one was buried in the mud pits, and only one stayed with Cao Cao.
Past the rough stretch, the road grew a little smoother. Cao Cao looked back. Only three hundred riders remained with him. None still wore intact armor.
“Keep moving fast,” Cao Cao urged.
His generals begged. “The horses are worn out. Let us rest a while.”
“Rest only once we reach Jingzhou,” Cao Cao said.
They rode less than a few li farther. Cao Cao raised his whip and laughed on horseback.
His generals asked again. “What makes you laugh this time?”
“Everyone says Zhou Yu and Zhuge Liang are master strategists. To me, they are still incompetent,” Cao Cao said. “If they hid soldiers here, all of us would be captured.”
The instant he finished speaking, a cannon boomed. Five hundred elite swordsmen lined up on both sides. Guan Yunchang sat on his Red Hare horse, Green Dragon blade in hand, blocking the road. Cao’s men turned pale with terror, staring at each other helplessly.
“Now we have no choice but to fight to the death!” Cao Cao said.
His generals replied, “Even if the men will fight, our horses are spent. How can we battle?”
Cheng Yu spoke. “I have always known Guan Yu respects those above him but pities the weak. He stands firm against the strong and spares the vulnerable. He keeps faith and remembers favors. Prime Minister, you once showed him great kindness. Speak to him now, and we may escape.”
Cao Cao rode forward and bowed. “General, I hope you have been well.”
Guan Yu bowed in return. “I wait for you here by the order of our military advisor.”
“Cao Cao has lost everything and has nowhere left to run. I beg you to remember our old bond.”
Guan Yu said, “I was blessed by your kindness long ago. But I repaid you by slaying Yan Liang and Wen Chou and lifting the siege at Baima. Today’s mission is official duty. How can I put personal ties above my orders?”
“Do you still remember when I let you pass through five passes and kill my generals?” Cao Cao said. “A true man honors his word. You know the Spring and Autumn Annals. Have you not heard the tale of Yu Gong zisi chasing Zi Zhu Ruzi?”
Guan Yu valued loyalty above all. He thought of all the favors Cao Cao had given him, and that journey through five passes. His heart softened. He looked at Cao’s terrified soldiers, many near tears. He could not bear it.
He turned his horse’s head and told his men, “Spread out and make way.”
This was clear permission to let Cao Cao go. Cao Cao and his generals rushed past at once. When Guan Yu turned back, they were already through. Guan Yu shouted. The remaining Cao soldiers all dismounted and knelt weeping. Guan Yu felt even more pity. While he hesitated, Zhang Liao galloped up. Guan Yu’s old affection stirred. He sighed deeply and let all of them leave.
Cao Cao escaped the Huarong Path trap. When he reached the valley exit, he turned and saw only twenty-seven riders still with him. Night was coming. Torches suddenly lit up ahead, blocking the road.
Cao Cao cried out, “My life ends here!”
Scouting riders rushed forward. They were Cao Ren’s troops. Cao Cao’s heart settled. Cao Ren came to meet him.
“I heard of your defeat, but dared not go far. I waited nearby to receive you.”
“I nearly never saw you again!” Cao Cao said. He led his remaining men into Nanjun to rest. Soon Zhang Liao arrived and told them how Guan Yu had spared them.
Cao Cao counted his officers. Many were wounded. He sent them to heal. Cao Cao held a feast to calm his spirits, with all his advisors present. Suddenly Cao Cao lifted his head and wept aloud.
His advisors asked, “Prime Minister, you feared nothing while fleeing through enemy lines. Now we are safe in the city, with food for men and fodder for horses. We should regroup our army to avenge this defeat. Why weep?”
“I weep for Guo Fengxiao!” Cao Cao said. “If Fengxiao still lived, he would never have let me suffer this terrible defeat!”
He beat his chest and cried. “Fengxiao, alas! Fengxiao, my grief! Fengxiao, what a loss!”
All his advisors fell silent, ashamed.
The next day, Cao Cao spoke to Cao Ren. “I will return to Xudu to gather troops and will come back for revenge. Hold Nanjun safely. I leave a secret plan for you. Do not open it unless in extreme danger. Follow it when crisis comes, and Eastern Wu will not dare threaten Nanjun.”
Cao Ren asked, “Who will guard Hefei and Xiangyang?”
“Jingzhou is in your care. I have sent Xiahou Dun to defend Xiangyang. Hefei is most critical. Zhang Liao will lead there, with Yue Jin and Li Dian as his lieutenants. Send word quickly if trouble arises.”
Once Cao Cao assigned all duties, he mounted his horse and headed back to Xudu with his men. The civil officials and generals who had surrendered in Jingzhou went back with him to serve. Cao Ren sent Cao Hong to hold Yiling and Nanjun against Zhou Yu.
Guan Yu took his men back after releasing Cao Cao. All the other armies had returned to Xiakou with captured horses, weapons and supplies. Only Guan Yu came back empty-handed, without a single prisoner or steed. Liu Bei and Kongming were celebrating the victory when word came Guan Yu had arrived.
Kongming rose from his seat, cup in hand, to greet him. “Congratulations, General. You have won a glorious victory and rid the world of a great villain. We should welcome you with celebration.”
Guan Yu said nothing.
Kongming said, “Are you upset we did not come out to greet you?” He turned to his attendants. “Why did you not tell us sooner?”
Guan Yu said, “I come to accept my death sentence.”
Kongming said, “Did Cao Cao not take Huarong Path?”
“He did,” Guan Yu replied. “I failed. He escaped.”
“Did you capture any of his officers?”
“I captured none.”
Kongming said, “You spared him on purpose, remembering his past kindness to you. But you signed a military pledge. I cannot overlook the law.”
He called his guards forward to take Guan Yu out for execution.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!