Zhuge Liang Outwits Zhou Yu for Three Cities
Zhuge Liang was about to execute Guan Yu for breaking military rules. But Liu Bei stopped him at once.
“The three of us swore to live and die together in our peach garden oath,” Liu Bei pleaded. “Even though Guan Yu has violated military law, I cannot bear to break our old promise. Let him keep his punishment on record for now, and allow him to atone for his mistakes with future deeds.”
Only then did Zhuge Liang spare Guan Yu’s life.
Meanwhile, Zhou Yu counted his troops and rewarded his soldiers after the battle. He reported all merits to Sun Quan, resettled all surrendered enemy soldiers across the river, and feasted his entire army generously. After resting his men, he prepared to march forward and capture Nan Commandery.
His vanguard set up camp along the river, forming five connected outposts with Zhou Yu commanding the central unit.
As Zhou Yu was discussing battle strategies with his generals, a scout rushed in with a report.
“Sun Qian, an envoy from Lord Liu Bei, has arrived to congratulate you, General.”
Zhou Yu ordered the envoy to be brought in. After exchanging formal greetings, Sun Qian spoke.
“My lord has sent me to thank you for your great kindness in the Chibi campaign. I bring small gifts as a token of our gratitude.”
“Where is Liu Bei now?” Zhou Yu asked sharply.
“He has moved his troops to station at Youjiangkou,” Sun Qian replied.
Zhou Yu’s expression turned serious. “Is Zhuge Liang with him at Youjiangkou?”
“They are there together,” Sun Qian confirmed.
“You may return first,” Zhou Yu said. “I will come personally to thank your lord.”
He accepted the gifts and sent Sun Qian back. Lu Su immediately stepped forward with a question.
“General, why did you look so startled just now?”
“Liu Bei has camped at Youjiangkou for one reason only,” Zhou Yu snorted. “He wants to seize Nan Commandery for himself. We have spent countless troops, money and supplies to win this war. Nan Commandery is ours for the taking. Yet they seek to reap the rewards of our hard work for free. I will never let this happen, not while I live!”
“What plan do you have to drive them away?” Lu Su asked.
“I will go speak to Liu Bei face to face,” Zhou Yu said coldly. “If he is reasonable, all is well. If not, I will kill him before he gets a chance to take Nan Commandery.”
“I will accompany you,” Lu Su offered.
Zhou Yu and Lu Su then led three thousand light cavalry straight to Youjiangkou.
Back at Youjiangkou, Sun Qian reported to Liu Bei that Zhou Yu was coming in person. Liu Bei turned to Zhuge Liang, confused.
“What is Zhou Yu’s intention with this visit?”
Zhuge Liang smiled faintly. “He is not coming to thank us for trivial gifts. He is coming for Nan Commandery.”
“If he comes with his army, how should we respond?” Liu Bei asked anxiously.
Zhuge Liang told him exactly what to say and do to handle the situation.
Liu Bei then arranged warships along the river and lined up his troops on the bank. When scouts reported Zhou Yu and Lu Su’s arrival, Zhuge Liang sent Zhao Yun with a few cavalrymen to greet them.
Zhou Yu was unsettled by the impressive display of Liu Bei’s forces. He entered the military camp with Lu Su, where Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang welcomed them into the main tent. After formal greetings, a feast was served. Liu Bei raised his cup to thank Zhou Yu for the victory at Chibi.
After several rounds of wine, Zhou Yu cut straight to the point.
“Lord Liu, you have moved your troops here. Are you planning to take Nan Commandery?”
“I heard you intend to capture it, so I came to assist you,” Liu Bei replied. “If you choose not to take it, then I will.”
Zhou Yu laughed confidently. “Our Wu kingdom has long aimed to control the Han River region. Nan Commandery is already in our grasp. Of course we will take it.”
“No battle’s outcome is certain,” Liu Bei countered. “Before he left, Cao Cao left Cao Ren in charge of Nan Commandery, surely with secret strategies in place. Cao Ren is also a fierce and formidable general. I fear you may not succeed.”
“If I fail to capture it,” Zhou Yu declared, “you are free to take it for yourself.”
“Zijing and Kongming are here as witnesses,” Liu Bei said. “Do not regret this promise, General.”
Lu Su hesitated and said nothing.
“A true man stands by his word,” Zhou Yu insisted. “I have no regrets.”
“Your words are fair indeed,” Zhuge Liang interjected. “Let Wu attack first. If they cannot win the city, my lord may take it. There is no fault in this arrangement.”
Zhou Yu and Lu Su then took their leave and rode back to their camp.
As soon as they were gone, Liu Bei turned to Zhuge Liang with worry.
“Sir, I spoke as you instructed, but now I see flaws in my words. I have no territory to call my own and only want Nan Commandery as a temporary base. If Zhou Yu seizes it first, the city will belong to Wu, and I will have nowhere to go.”
Zhuge Liang laughed loudly.
“I once advised you to take Jingzhou, but you refused. Now you finally see the value of these lands?”
“I refused before because the land belonged to Liu Biao,” Liu Bei explained. “Now it is Cao Cao’s territory, so it is only right for us to claim it.”
“Do not worry, my lord,” Zhuge Liang assured him. “Let Zhou Yu wear out his troops fighting the battle. Before long, you will be sitting comfortably on the throne of Nan Commandery.”
Liu Bei asked eagerly, “What is your plan?”
Zhuge Liang whispered his detailed strategy. Overjoyed, Liu Bei ordered his troops to hold their position at the river mouth and make no move.
Back in Wu’s camp, Lu Su questioned Zhou Yu.
“General, why did you agree to let Liu Bei claim Nan Commandery if we fail?”
“I can take Nan Commandery with a single snap of my fingers,” Zhou Yu scoffed. “I only made the promise to be gracious.”
He then turned to his generals. “Who will lead the attack on Nan Commandery?”
Jiang Qin stepped forward at once.
Zhou Yu appointed him vanguard, with Xu Sheng and Ding Feng as lieutenants, sending five thousand elite soldiers across the river first, while he prepared to follow with reinforcements.
Meanwhile in Nan Commandery, Cao Ren ordered Cao Hong to guard Yiling, forming a coordinated defensive position. When scouts reported Wu’s army had crossed the Han River, Cao Ren chose a cautious strategy.
“We will hold our defenses and avoid battle for now.”
But Niu Jin, one of his brave generals, objected fiercely.
“Hiding behind walls while the enemy marches on us is cowardly! Our army has just suffered defeat, and we need to restore our morale. Give me five hundred elite soldiers, and I will fight them to the death.”
Cao Ren agreed and let Niu Jin lead the small force out to battle.
Ding Feng rode out to meet him. After fighting four or five rounds, Ding Feng feigned defeat and retreated. Niu Jin chased after him recklessly and charged straight into Wu’s formation, only to be surrounded on all sides.
Trapped, Niu Jin fought desperately but could not break free. Watching from the city wall, Cao Ren donned his armor, mounted his horse, and led hundreds of elite soldiers out to rescue him.
Xu Sheng tried to block his path but was no match. Cao Ren cut through the enemy ranks, freed Niu Jin, and then charged back into the fray a second time to rescue his remaining trapped soldiers.
Jiang Qin attempted to stop their retreat, but Cao Ren and Niu Jin fought fiercely and broke through his lines. Cao Chun, Cao Ren’s brother, also led troops to assist them. In the chaotic battle, Wu’s army was defeated and forced to retreat. Cao Ren marched victoriously back into the city.
Jiang Qin returned to camp in disgrace. Enraged, Zhou Yu ordered his execution. Only the desperate pleas of all his generals saved Jiang Qin’s life.
Zhou Yu then prepared to lead his army against Cao Ren personally. Gan Ning stepped forward to stop him.
“Do not be reckless, General. Cao Ren has stationed Cao Hong in Yiling to support Nan Commandery. Let me take three thousand elite soldiers to capture Yiling first. Then you can easily seize Nan Commandery.”
Zhou Yu approved the plan and sent Gan Ning to attack Yiling.
Cao Ren’s scouts quickly reported Wu’s advance. Cao Ren consulted Chen Jiao, his advisor.
“If Yiling falls, Nan Commandery cannot hold,” Chen Jiao warned. “We must send reinforcements at once.”
Cao Ren ordered Cao Chun and Niu Jin to lead troops secretly to aid Cao Hong. Before arriving, Cao Chun sent a message to Cao Hong, telling him to lure the enemy into a trap by feigning defeat.
When Gan Ning’s army reached Yiling, Cao Hong rode out to fight. After more than twenty rounds of combat, Cao Hong pretended to lose and fled. Gan Ning took control of Yiling.
As dusk fell, Cao Chun and Niu Jin arrived with their troops, surrounding Yiling and trapping Gan Ning inside. A scout rushed to inform Zhou Yu of the crisis.
“Gan Ning is surrounded in Yiling!”
Cheng Pu urged immediate action. “We must send troops to rescue him at once!”
“This position is critical,” Zhou Yu hesitated. “If we split our forces to rescue Yiling, Cao Ren will attack our main camp.”
“Gan Ning is one of our greatest generals,” Lü Meng argued. “We cannot abandon him.”
“I will lead the rescue myself,” Zhou Yu decided. “But who will guard our camp in my absence?”
“Leave Ling Tong in command here,” Lü Meng suggested. “I will lead the vanguard, and you will bring up the rear. We will return victorious in ten days at most.”
Zhou Yu asked Ling Tong if he could hold the camp. Ling Tong replied honestly.
“I can manage for ten days. Beyond that, I cannot guarantee safety.”
Satisfied, Zhou Yu left over ten thousand soldiers with Ling Tong and marched his main force toward Yiling at once.
On the way, Lü Meng offered a valuable tactic.
“South of Yiling lies a narrow path leading to Nan Commandery. Send five hundred soldiers to cut down trees and block the road. When the enemy retreats, they will be forced to abandon their horses, and we can seize all their mounts.”
Zhou Yu followed his advice and dispatched soldiers to block the path.
As Wu’s army neared Yiling, Zhou Yu asked for a volunteer to break through the siege and contact Gan Ning. Zhou Tai stepped forward without hesitation.
He charged alone through Cao’s army straight to the city gates. Gan Ning saw him and rushed out to meet him.
“General Zhou Yu is leading the main army to rescue us,” Zhou Tai told him.
Gan Ning ordered his soldiers to fully prepare for a coordinated attack from inside the city.
Cao Hong, Cao Chun and Niu Jin learned Zhou Yu’s army was approaching. They sent an urgent message to Cao Ren in Nan Commandery while splitting their troops to defend against the incoming attack.
When Wu’s forces arrived, the two armies clashed fiercely. Gan Ning and Zhou Tai led their troops out of the city in two separate flanking attacks, throwing Cao’s army into total chaos. Wu’s soldiers slaughtered the fleeing enemy troops.
True to Lü Meng’s prediction, Cao’s generals fled toward the narrow path, only to find it blocked by fallen trees. Unable to ride their horses, they abandoned them and fled on foot. Wu’s army seized more than five hundred enemy horses.
Zhou Yu led his troops overnight toward Nan Commandery and met Cao Ren’s reinforcement army on the way. The two sides fought a brutal battle until nightfall, when both armies retreated to rest.
Back in Nan Commandery, Cao Ren held a military conference. Cao Hong spoke up urgently.
“We have lost Yiling, and our position is crumbling. We should open and read Prime Minister Cao’s secret letter left for emergencies!”
Cao Ren agreed at once. When they opened the letter and read its contents, they broke into smiles of relief. He immediately issued orders.
All troops would prepare food before dawn. At sunrise, the entire army would abandon the city through three different gates. They would leave flags standing on the city walls to create the illusion of heavy defense.
After rescuing Gan Ning, Zhou Yu lined up his troops outside Nan Commandery. He watched Cao’s army march out from three city gates and studied their movements carefully.
He saw empty flags fluttering on the walls with no soldiers guarding them, and noticed all enemy soldiers had bundles tied to their waists, clearly preparing to flee.
Convinced Cao Ren was running, Zhou Yu ordered his troops to split into left and right flanks. The front line was ordered to chase and attack relentlessly, only retreating if the signal bell rang. He placed Cheng Pu in charge of the rear guard and prepared to storm the city himself.
The battle drums sounded. Cao Hong rode out to challenge Wu’s army. Zhou Yu sent Han Dang to fight him. After thirty rounds, Cao Hong feigned defeat and retreated.
Cao Ren then joined the fight personally. Zhou Tai rode forward to meet him. After more than ten rounds, Cao Ren also retreated, and his army’s formation collapsed entirely.
Zhou Yu signaled his flanks to charge forward. Cao’s troops were thoroughly routed. Wu’s soldiers chased the fleeing enemy all the way to the city walls.
Seeing Cao’s soldiers fleeing northwest instead of entering the city, Han Dang and Zhou Tai led the front troops in relentless pursuit.
Zhou Yu saw the city gates wide open and the walls completely unguarded. He ordered his soldiers to rush in and seize the city. Dozens of cavalrymen charged into the outer city first, with Zhou Yu galloping in right behind them.
From the enemy tower, Chen Jiao watched Zhou Yu enter the city alone and praised Cao Cao’s brilliance silently.
“The Prime Minister’s strategy is truly divine!”
A wooden clapper sounded. Instantly, crossbow bolts rained down from both sides like a storm. The Wu soldiers rushing into the city fell straight into hidden trap pits.
Zhou Yu tried desperately to turn his horse around and escape, but a crossbow bolt struck his left rib. He tumbled off his horse in agony.
Niu Jin charged out of the city to capture him, but Xu Sheng and Ding Feng fought desperately to drag the injured Zhou Yu away to safety.
Cao’s soldiers swarmed out of the city, and Wu’s troops trampled each other in panic, with countless soldiers falling into the traps.
Cheng Pu struggled to regroup his army, but Cao Ren and Cao Hong launched a counterattack from two directions, defeating Wu’s forces completely. Only Ling Tong’s timely arrival with a detachment of troops managed to halt Cao’s advance.
Cao Ren marched victoriously back into Nan Commandery, while Cheng Pu led the shattered Wu army back to camp.
Ding Feng and Xu Sheng carried the wounded Zhou Yu back to his tent. Military doctors pulled out the arrow and applied healing ointment, but the wound was extremely painful, leaving Zhou Yu unable to eat or drink.
“The arrow is poisoned,” the doctors warned. “It will take a long time to heal. Any anger or excitement will reopen the wound and cause severe complications.”
Cheng Pu ordered all troops to hold their ground strictly and avoid any reckless action.
Three days later, Niu Jin led troops to challenge Wu’s camp, shouting insults nonstop until sunset. He returned to taunt them again the next day.
Fearing Zhou Yu’s wound would worsen from anger, Cheng Pu hid all news of the enemy’s provocations from him.
On the third day, Niu Jin marched right to the entrance of Wu’s camp, screaming insults and vowing to capture Zhou Yu alive. Cheng Pu gathered the generals to discuss a temporary retreat back to Jiangdong to let Zhou Yu recover.
Though bedridden with injury, Zhou Yu sensed the enemy’s constant taunts and realized his generals were hiding news from him.
One day, Cao Ren led his entire army to beat drums and shout challenges right outside Wu’s camp. Still, Cheng Pu refused to fight.
Zhou Yu summoned his generals and demanded an explanation.
“Why is there so much noise outside the camp?”
The generals lied. “The troops are only conducting drills.”
Zhou Yu flew into a rage. “Do not lie to me! I know Cao’s soldiers have been insulting us daily. Cheng Pu, you share command of this army—why do you let this happen?”
He summoned Cheng Pu at once. Cheng Pu explained helplessly.
“Your wound is still critical. The doctors warned you must not grow angry. I hid the enemy’s taunts to protect your health.”
“Why do you refuse to fight?” Zhou Yu demanded.
“All generals wish to retreat temporarily to Jiangdong,” Cheng Pu admitted. “We plan to resume the campaign once your injury heals.”
Enraged, Zhou Yu forced himself to stand up from his sickbed.
“A true soldier who serves his king should die on the battlefield and be buried in horsehide! How can we abandon state affairs because of my injury alone?”
He donned his armor and mounted his horse. All his generals stared at him in shock and awe.
Zhou Yu rode out of camp with several hundred cavalrymen. He saw Cao’s army lined up in full formation, with Cao Ren at the front, shouting mockingly.
“Boy Zhou Yu! You are doomed to die a violent death! You dare not face us anymore!”
Before Cao Ren finished his insult, Zhou Yu rode forward suddenly from his ranks.
“Cao Ren, you coward! Do you see me, Zhou Yu?”
All of Cao’s soldiers were terrified at the sight. Cao Ren shouted at his troops.
“Shout louder! Insult him!”
The entire Cao army erupted in furious insults.
Overcome with rage, Zhou Yu ordered Pan Zhang to fight. Before the battle even began, Zhou Yu let out a loud cry, blood gushed from his mouth, and he collapsed off his horse.
Cao’s army charged forward immediately. Wu’s generals rushed to block their attack, fought off the enemy, and carried the unconscious Zhou Yu back to camp.
Cheng Pu knelt beside him anxiously. “How do you feel, General?”
Zhou Yu whispered weakly, “This is all part of my plan.”
“What plan?” Cheng Pu asked in confusion.
“My wound was never life-threatening,” Zhou Yu explained. “I fainted on purpose to make Cao’s army believe I am dying and lower their guard. Send trusted soldiers to pretend to surrender and tell them I have passed away. Tonight, Cao Ren will surely raid our camp. We will lay ambushes everywhere and capture his entire army in one strike.”
“Brilliant strategy!” Cheng Pu praised.
News of Zhou Yu’s death was spread throughout the camp. Loud mourning sounds filled the tents, and all Wu’s soldiers hung mourning flags to honor their fallen general.
In Nan Commandery, Cao Ren and his generals discussed the day’s events. They believed Zhou Yu’s injury had worsened from rage, causing his wound to burst and leave him dying.
As they talked, scouts reported more than ten Wu soldiers had come to surrender, including two former Cao soldiers captured in earlier battles.
Cao Ren summoned the men to question them. The surrendering soldiers lied.
“General Zhou Yu’s wound burst open on the battlefield today. He died immediately after returning to camp. All our generals and soldiers are in mourning. We have been bullied and mistreated by Cheng Pu, so we came to surrender and bring you this news.”
Overjoyed, Cao Ren immediately planned a night raid to seize Zhou Yu’s body, behead it, and send the head to Cao Cao in Xudu.
“Act quickly, do not delay!” Chen Jiao urged.
Cao Ren ordered Niu Jin to lead the vanguard while he commanded the central army, with Cao Hong and Cao Chun guarding the rear. He left only a small number of soldiers with Chen Jiao to defend the city and marched out with his entire army after nightfall.
When Cao’s army reached Wu’s camp, they found only empty tents and standing flags—no soldiers in sight. Realizing they had walked into a trap, they tried to retreat at once.
Explosive signal cannons fired from all four directions. Han Dang and Jiang Qin charged from the east; Zhou Tai and Pan Zhang attacked from the west; Xu Sheng and Ding Feng advanced from the south; Chen Wu and Lü Meng blocked the north.
Cao’s army was utterly crushed, split into scattered groups with no way to coordinate or retreat. Cao Ren broke through the encirclement with dozens of cavalrymen and joined forces with Cao Hong to flee together.
By dawn, as they neared Nan Commandery, Ling Tong’s troops ambushed them. Moments later, Gan Ning’s army struck again. Terrified, Cao Ren dared not return to Nan Commandery and fled straight toward Xiangyang.
Wu’s army stopped their pursuit and marched back to Nan Commandery.
But when Zhou Yu and Cheng Pu reached the city walls, they saw enemy flags flying atop the towers. A general shouted down from the gate tower.
“Do not be angry, General! By order of Military Advisor Zhuge, I have already captured this city. I am Zhao Yun of Changshan!”
Furious, Zhou Yu ordered his troops to attack, but they were driven back by endless arrows from the walls.
Zhou Yu pulled back to discuss new plans. He ordered Gan Ning to attack Jingzhou and Ling Tong to attack Xiangyang, planning to retake Nan Commandery after seizing those two cities.
Before he could finalize his orders, urgent scouts arrived one after another with devastating news.
“After taking Nan Commandery, Zhuge Liang seized the official military tally from Chen Jiao. He used the fake tally overnight to order Jingzhou’s defenders to come rescue Nan Commandery. While Jingzhou’s troops were away, Zhang Fei marched in and captured Jingzhou!”
A second scout reported. “Zhuge Liang used the same trick on Xiahou Dun in Xiangyang! He forged an emergency message from Cao Ren begging for reinforcements. When Xiahou Dun led his troops out of the city, Guan Yu captured Xiangyang effortlessly!”
“How did Zhuge Liang get the military tally?” Zhou Yu asked in shock.
“He captured Chen Jiao when we defeated Cao’s army,” Cheng Pu replied. “Naturally, he seized all official military tokens.”
Overwhelmed by rage and frustration, Zhou Yu let out a deafening roar, and his poisoned wound burst open once again.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!