The First Step Into Crime
There is a lesson in every criminal career: once a person takes the first step down the wrong road, it is dangerously easy to keep going.
Anyone who thinks, “I can break one rule and stop there,” should think again.
The story of Edwin James is a perfect warning. He had everything a man could want—fame, money, talent, and a brilliant future. Yet one crime destroyed it all.
In 1865, Edwin James was one of the most famous lawyers in London.
He was a Queen’s Counsel, a gifted scholar, and a powerful speaker. He had risen from the bottom of the legal profession to almost its highest position.
By the age of forty, he was considered one of the leading lawyers in England.
People were already talking about him as the future Attorney-General. Once he reached that position, the path to becoming Lord Chancellor would be open to him.
It was an extraordinary future.
The Lord Chancellor stood among the highest officials in the country, just below royalty in matters of official precedence. The position had enormous power and prestige.
James seemed destined for it.
Then the rumors began.
At first, they were only whispers in London's clubs.
Then people started saying openly that Edwin James, the man expected to become Lord Chancellor, was in serious trouble.
His legal income was enormous—close to £20,000 a year. But even that was not enough to support the life he had chosen.
He was drowning in debt.
James maintained what polite society called “two households.”
One of them was run by a remarkably beautiful woman whose extravagance was almost as famous as her beauty.
James also enjoyed the company of younger men and had become involved with a fast crowd of young aristocrats and army officers.
At his club, he had lost heavily at baccarat and loo.
His debts kept growing.
Then, in a moment of desperation, he committed a crime.
One of his clients was a young aristocrat—the heir to an ancient title and a very large estate.
The young man spent money recklessly and constantly needed cash.
To finance his lifestyle, he borrowed from moneylenders.
These lenders were happy to give him money against what were known as post-obits.
The interest was extraordinary—around 100 percent a year.
James knew about his client's debts.
Perhaps he believed that the young heir was so careless with money that he would never remember exactly how much he had borrowed or how many post-obits he had signed.
A post-obit was essentially a promise to pay that became due when the heir inherited his father's estate.
In simple terms, the young man was borrowing money against his father's future death.
James saw an opportunity.
He prepared two post-obits, each for £5,000.
Then he forged his client's signature on both documents and gave them to the moneylenders.
The lenders believed the documents were genuine.
They handed James the money.
James had now taken his first real step into serious crime.
But he had no idea where that step would lead.
He imagined he was merely solving a financial problem.
Instead, he had opened the door to something much darker.
He was soon to discover that crime was not a shallow stream he could simply step out of.
It was an ocean.
And once he was in it, the waves would carry him farther and farther from everything he had once been.
Then something happened that James could never have anticipated.
His client's father suddenly died.
The young heir returned home and inherited the estate.
As soon as he took control of his property, he began examining his financial affairs.
The various post-obits were placed before him.
He immediately recognized the two £5,000 documents as forgeries.
The crime was traced straight back to Edwin James.
The young heir was furious.
He refused to forgive him.
He told a few people what had happened.
Within a month, everyone in London's clubs knew.
Soon the newspapers knew too.
They avoided using James's name directly and referred to him only as a “distinguished member of the Bar,” but the facts were clear enough.
James's former client eventually gave him a choice.
He could avoid prosecution if he left England.
If he refused, the young man would take the matter before the Grand Jury and have him indicted.
James would then stand in the dock at the Old Bailey and face trial like any other criminal.
James chose flight.
Like many fugitives before him, he crossed the Atlantic and sought refuge in America.
He eventually arrived in New York and applied for admission to the New York Bar.
But there was a serious problem.
Everyone knew his history.
There was strong opposition to admitting him.
Then James found an unlikely champion: Richard O'Gorman, one of the most respected lawyers in New York.
O'Gorman was a remarkable man.
He had a powerful mind, a magnificent voice, and a generous heart.
When he decided to defend James, he defended him as though he were defending his own brother.
Many members of the New York Bar knew exactly who Edwin James was.
But once they learned that O'Gorman had taken up his cause, some began to soften.
“Perhaps the poor fellow deserves another chance,” they said.
At the next meeting of the Bar Association, O'Gorman delivered a passionate speech on James's behalf.
His eloquence carried the day.
James was admitted.
O'Gorman had helped him over the fence, but unfortunately, the man he had rescued had not changed.
It would not be long before Edwin James stumbled again.
This time, the consequences would be even worse.
In New York, James opened a law office in a comfortable building on Broadway, directly opposite City Hall.
The sign on the door read:
Edwin James, Counselor-at-Law and Register in Bankruptcy.
But his legal career never recovered.
O'Gorman's brilliant speech had created a favorable impression for a while.
Then people had to deal with James himself.
His past followed him everywhere.
Other lawyers distrusted him.
Many people believed that his criminal adventures were not over.
They were right.
James continued living beyond his means.
Soon his creditors were demanding money again.
He was so deeply in debt that he sometimes entered and left his house at night simply to avoid them.
Once again, he began looking for a criminal way out.
One of the men involved was Brea.
Brea had married the second daughter of a wealthy New York family.
The family was rich, but not particularly respectable.
Brea had carefully arranged for James to become the family's lawyer.
As the family lawyer, James had prepared the mother's will.
The old woman was extremely wealthy and equally difficult.
She had a violent temper and hated her second daughter.
She had no sons.
In her will, she left that daughter exactly one dollar.
Her name appeared nowhere else in the document.
Everyone who knew the old woman believed she would never change her mind.
Brea saw an opportunity.
James had secretly prepared another will.
This one was completely false.
Under its terms, Brea's wife would inherit $750,000.
The genuine will remained in James's possession.
The plan was simple.
If the old woman died, James would destroy the real will.
The forged will, meanwhile, was stored in a safety-deposit vault.
After her death, it would be produced as though it were genuine.
Brea had also cultivated three other men.
He believed they might prove useful someday.
A few days earlier, he had introduced them to James.
He did not tell them about the forged will at first.
Instead, he hinted that a major opportunity was coming.
But they needed money immediately.
James needed it badly.
Brea needed it too.
Finally, James decided to trust the three men.
He showed them the genuine will and explained the entire scheme.
“This is practically a fortune waiting to be collected,” he told them.
“The old woman is already elderly and in poor health. Once she dies, the money will be ours.”
He offered them $100,000 to divide among themselves if they would help defend the forged will if the other heirs challenged it.
“But I need money now,” James said.
“I need at least $5,000. Ten thousand would be better.”
The men agreed to help.
The next day they rented an office downtown under a false name.
They also hired an innocent young man as a porter and messenger.
Then they began studying the customers of Jay Cooke & Company, one of the most important banking firms in New York.
Four days later, their first major operation began.
A messenger walked into Jay Cooke & Company's banking house carrying a $20,000 check.
The check appeared to have been issued by another firm that kept an account there.
It was accompanied by a letter bearing a signature the cashier recognized.
The letter instructed the bank to pay the check to the bearer.
The bank accepted it.
Five minutes later, we were walking casually up Broadway with $20,000.
We sent word to James.
“Meet us at Delmonico's.”
We sat down and waited.
James arrived almost immediately.
He looked nervous and impatient.
But when he saw our faces, his expression changed.
He smiled and reached out his hand.
After we greeted one another, I produced the money.
I handed James ten five-hundred-dollar bills.
He was delighted.
The next day I returned to the office.
I paid the messenger a week's wages, gave him a small extra gift, and dismissed him.
We honestly believed the worst was over.
We had several thousand dollars in our pockets.
That money should carry us until the forged-will scheme paid off.
We imagined that the old woman's death would soon make all of us wealthy.
For a while, we enjoyed ourselves.
We spent money around town and congratulated ourselves on how clever we were.
Then winter passed.
Summer arrived.
Our thousands had shrunk to hundreds.
And the old woman whose estate we had already divided among ourselves showed no sign of dying.
In fact, she seemed healthier than ever.
One day, my friend Mac finally said what several of us had been thinking.
“This is a rotten business,” he said.
“We're planning to steal an inheritance from women who haven't done anything to us.”
George and I agreed.
“We're done with it,” we said.
“We'll abandon James and Brea.”
But before cutting them loose completely, we decided to use them for one last operation.
Once again, we began planning a robbery on Wall Street.
This time, we chose Jay Cooke & Company as our target again.
Irving and his honest-looking associates would cooperate by watching for trouble.
If anyone was arrested, they would step in, make the arrest, and then quietly let the prisoner escape.
The most important part of the plan involved James.
When the bankers rushed to Police Headquarters to report the robbery, James would already be there.
He would act like an honest lawyer helping the police.
He would call in two trusted men and collect every detail about the stolen money and the criminals.
Then he would tell the bankers:
“Don't worry. We know these men. We'll catch them.”
He would also warn them to keep the robbery secret so the police could catch the thieves more easily.
If everything worked, the detectives involved would receive 25 percent of the money.
James was taking a serious risk.
Even if no one could prove that he was part of the conspiracy, suspicion would almost certainly destroy whatever remained of his reputation.
But James no longer cared much about America.
He planned to leave for Paris with his share of the money.
We always met him in his private office.
His clerks had never seen us or Brea.
That made his office the perfect place for our next operation.
James still had a strange reputation.
The legal profession distrusted him, but the public continued to think of him as a brilliant lawyer.
He had volunteered as counsel in several murder trials and had made speeches powerful enough to attract considerable attention in the newspapers.
We intended to use that reputation to our advantage.
One day, Brea traveled to Philadelphia.
The headquarters of Jay Cooke & Company was there.
Through a combination of confidence and clever manipulation, Brea managed to obtain a letter of introduction from Jay Cooke himself.
The letter was addressed to the manager of the New York branch.
Brea claimed that he needed investment advice because he was acting as executor for an estate.
He made the proposed business sound extremely profitable.
The commissions alone would be substantial.
The letter from Jay Cooke gave the scheme an excellent start.
We immediately began deciding how we would spend the money.
That was exactly the kind of thinking that made us fools.
We had found the name of a Newark manufacturer who had recently gone bankrupt.
For the purposes of our scheme, I will call him Newman.
The morning after Brea returned from Philadelphia, he went to James's office.
James was deliberately absent.
Brea told the clerk:
“My name is Newman. I recently failed in business, and I want Mr. James to handle my bankruptcy.”
The clerk told him to return at noon.
Brea came back exactly on time.
The clerk introduced him to James.
James kept the clerk close enough to hear everything.
Brea began his story.
“I used $240,000 belonging to my wife and her mother in my business,” he said.
“When I file my bankruptcy papers, I intend to hide that fact from my creditors.”
He claimed that he planned to invest the money in bonds and deposit the funds in a bank that afternoon.
Then he produced the letter from Jay Cooke.
Everything had been carefully staged for the clerk to hear.
Brea even paid James a $250 retainer fee in front of him.
James later returned the money privately.
Then Brea said:
“I'd like to have some money available at a bank. Could you introduce me to yours?”
“My bank is in Jersey City,” James replied.
Before James could say anything more, the clerk spoke up.
“My brother is a paying teller at the Chemical Bank,” he said. “I can introduce Mr. Newman there.”
Perfect.
Brea and the clerk went to the Chemical Bank.
Within ten minutes, Brea had a checkbook and $5,000 credited to his account.
That afternoon he went to Jay Cooke & Company's office.
This time, he told a completely different story.
“A recently deceased relative left me a very valuable estate,” he explained.
“I'm selling some of the real estate and investing the proceeds in bonds.”
He said he intended to invest as much as a million dollars in railway bonds.
“For now, I have $240,000 available,” he said. “I'd like to invest that in government bonds.”
He left the office after making an excellent impression.
His appearance, manners, and confidence made the story believable.
Everything was going exactly as planned.
Over the next few days, Brea visited the Chemical Bank several times.
He withdrew small amounts—$500 here, $1,000 there.
Eventually, his account contained only about $1,000.
The day before the planned robbery, he visited Jay Cooke & Company again.
“I'll take $240,000 worth of seven-thirty bearer bonds,” he told them.
“I'll come tomorrow and pay for them.”
The bankers prepared a pro forma bill for the transaction.
The final day had arrived.
James needed his head clerk out of the office.
So he sent him to the Admiralty Court to take notes on a case.
At ten o'clock, Brea sent a messenger to the bankers.
The note said:
“Please send the bonds to Mr. James's office. I'll pay for them when they arrive.”
He explained that he was unable to come because he was meeting with the executors of the estate.
Meanwhile, we had prepared a check for the full $240,000.
It looked exactly like the sort of check bankers commonly used in bond transactions.
But there was one important detail.
Brea had also prepared a genuine check for only $240.
He kept the small check in his hatband alongside the fake $240,000 check.
The plan was simple.
When the messenger arrived with the bonds, Brea would say:
“Fine. I have the check ready. Come with me to the Chemical Bank and we'll have it certified.”
At the bank, he would pull out both checks.
He would make sure the messenger saw only the small $240 check.
He would pass that check through the bank window and ask the teller to certify it.
Once the certified check came back, Brea would secretly switch it for the forged $240,000 check.
The messenger would take the large check and hand over the bonds.
We thought the plan was almost impossible to stop.
If it worked, we would suddenly be wealthy.
Perhaps, before long, we might even gain entry into New York's most exclusive social circle.
But elaborate plans often collapse because of the smallest things.
The night before the robbery, we met James for one final rehearsal.
We went through every detail.
Once everything was settled, we went to Delmonico's uptown for supper.
By pure chance, Detective George Elder was there.
Elder was an intelligent man.
He belonged to another detective circle and had his own money, diamonds, and fashionable lifestyle.
He knew me slightly, but he did not know the others.
I did not notice him at the time.
Apparently, however, he had overheard pieces of our conversation.
Something about it made him curious.
Perhaps even suspicious.
Normally, that would not have mattered.
But then Brea made a careless mistake.
When we left, he accidentally left the pro forma bill for the $240,000 worth of bonds on the table.
The paper had been partly destroyed.
The heading, containing the bank's name and the purchaser's name, had been torn away.
But the main body of the document remained.
Elder picked it up.
He already had a vague suspicion that something was wrong.
Now he had something to investigate.
Instead of reporting immediately to his superiors, he decided to make his own quiet inquiry.
The next morning, at 9:30, Elder began visiting banks and brokers around Wall Street.
He carried the torn piece of the bond memorandum with him.
He asked questions.
He compared information.
He moved from one office to another.
For more than an hour, he investigated.
Then he walked into Jay Cooke & Company's office.
He arrived at exactly the wrong—or right—moment.
The messenger was just leaving with the bonds.
Elder showed the bankers the torn memorandum.
They immediately recognized it.
“That is our document,” they said.
Elder looked at them carefully.
“Do you know this man? Are you certain everything is legitimate?”
“Yes,” they replied.
“Mr. Newman was introduced by Mr. Jay Cooke himself. He's also a client of Edwin James.”
Elder pointed to the mutilated document.
“Then why was the bill torn apart?”
The manager began to look uneasy.
Elder told him:
“I believe someone is planning a fraud.”
He suggested that they accompany the messenger and investigate personally.
The manager agreed.
He told Elder and the messenger to wait.
Then he grabbed his hat and hurried toward James's office.
Meanwhile, James was there.
Brea—still pretending to be Newman—was waiting in the private office.
The two checks were ready.
They were expecting the messenger with the bonds at any moment.
We were nearby, waiting for the signal.
Then the bank manager walked in.
James immediately understood what had happened.
The plan was finished.
Any suspicion at this point would destroy everything.
Brea heard voices outside.
Thinking the messenger had arrived, he opened the private-office door.
Instead, he found the bank manager standing there.
Brea was visibly annoyed, but quickly recovered.
The manager shook his hand.
“The bonds will be here shortly,” he said.
Then he asked:
“I assume you'll be paying cash for them?”
Brea smiled calmly.
“I can go to the bank with you right now and have my check certified,” he said.
“Or I can leave the check here until the messenger arrives.”
His calmness seemed to reassure the manager.
“All right,” the manager said. “The messenger can go to the bank with you.”
He started to leave.
Then he stopped in the hallway.
A moment later, he turned around and went back into the office.
“By the way, Mr. Newman,” he said, “please withdraw the money in cash from your bank. Pay the messenger when the bonds are delivered.”
That was the end.
Our carefully prepared operation had collapsed.
And all because of one torn piece of paper left on a restaurant table.
The forged $240,000 check was still in our possession.
We destroyed it immediately.
There was nothing more to do.
So we walked casually up Broadway to dinner.
We drank wine and talked about what we would do next.
Eventually, we settled on a new plan.
We raised our glasses.
“To the East!” we said.
Our next adventure would take us across the Atlantic.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!