The Last Step Before Ruin
“Eastward, Ho!”
Those words were not just a toast. They were the beginning of another plan we had discussed many times—a plan to make money in Europe.
Looking back, I can see clearly how we had reached that point.
When I first returned from Europe with my $10,000 commission, I had sworn that I would never again take part in anything illegal.
“I've had enough,” I told myself. “No more crime. I'm finished with it.”
Then came the $20,000 operation.
We succeeded, made money, and congratulated ourselves.
“This will be our last unlawful act,” we told ourselves.
It wasn't.
Soon afterward, we planned the $240,000 scheme.
We spent money preparing it. We worked out every detail. We convinced ourselves that our plan was clever enough to succeed.
We even discussed investing our profits in legitimate businesses afterward.
“We'll become respectable men,” we said.
“And someday we'll make everything right.”
But criminals always seem to imagine that someday will come.
It rarely does.
The strangest part was that we did not think of ourselves as bad men.
While planning crimes, we still despised other criminals.
We believed our own actions were different.
Every crime was supposed to be the last one.
But after each one, circumstances somehow gave us another reason to continue.
My $13,000 commission from the European trip had disappeared.
Our share of the $20,000 taken from Jay Cooke & Company was disappearing quickly too.
Then our carefully planned attempt to obtain $240,000 had failed.
We needed money again.
For several days, we did little except eat, drink, and discuss our next move.
“We won't do another operation like this in America,” we agreed.
Finally, we came up with what seemed like the perfect solution.
“We'll go back to Europe,” one of us suggested.
“There's plenty of money over there.”
We decided to tell Irving that we were going to Europe to make money.
We would promise him and his two associates their usual percentage.
That would give us another advantage.
If we committed a forgery in Europe and the authorities discovered that we were Americans, the foreign police would probably contact the New York police.
And who would they contact?
Irving.
Since he was part of our arrangement, we thought he would protect us.
It was a dangerous fantasy, but at the time it seemed perfectly reasonable.
Before leaving, however, there is one part of the story I must finish.
My readers will naturally want to know what happened to Edwin James and Brea.
The day our Jay Cooke scheme collapsed, the bank manager left James's office after telling Brea that he would have to pay cash for the bonds.
We immediately knew the operation was dead.
Our only concern now was protecting James.
Brea left the office.
Before going, he told the clerk:
“When the messenger arrives, tell him I've gone to get the money. I'll return for the bonds.”
The clerk followed his instructions.
The messenger eventually arrived.
Detective Elder was still with him.
When they discovered that Brea was gone, they took the bonds back to the bank.
At two o'clock that afternoon, James went to Jay Cooke & Company's office.
He was well known there.
“I'm here to meet Mr. Newman,” he said.
The manager invited him into a private room.
“Mr. James,” he asked, “do you actually know this Mr. Newman?”
James shook his head.
“Only as a client. He came to my office, paid me a $250 retainer, and hired me as his lawyer.”
The manager then produced a telegram.
He had sent a message to Jay Cooke's Philadelphia office asking whether the letter of introduction given to Newman was genuine.
The reply was clear.
The letter was genuine.
But the Philadelphia office knew absolutely nothing about Newman.
They had warned the New York branch to be careful.
James pretended to be shocked.
“That's extraordinary!”
Then he became angry.
“If Mr. Newman doesn't appear within half an hour,” he declared, “I'll begin to suspect that someone has tried to commit a fraud.”
When the bank closed at three o'clock, the manager told James:
“I'm going to give the whole matter to the newspapers.”
“But I'll leave your name out of it.”
The two men parted politely.
The manager acted as though he believed James had been an innocent victim.
But I doubt he was completely convinced.
He probably suspected that James had intended to have a hand in the operation if it had succeeded.
The newspapers had a field day.
The next morning, they published long accounts of the attempted fraud.
Most of the details were wrong.
But every newspaper praised the bank manager for his cleverness and claimed that he had personally detected the danger.
Poor Detective Elder received almost none of the credit.
He had actually discovered the suspicious document and uncovered the scheme.
Still, Elder soon had reason to feel better.
Irving later told us that Elder had been included in another profitable deal and had made a handsome amount of money.
As for James, the $5,000 we had given him helped for a while.
But he had almost no legal practice.
He remained in New York, hoping that the forged-will scheme would eventually make him rich.
Instead, his debts continued to grow.
Four years passed.
Then the old woman at the center of the will scheme died.
Her final days had been as violent as her life.
One evening, she became unusually furious and attacked the three daughters who still lived with her.
She beat them badly.
The eldest daughter was seriously injured.
After the attack, the old woman stormed into her bedroom.
The next morning, she did not come down for breakfast.
One of her daughters went to look for her.
She wasn't in her bedroom.
The bed had not even been disturbed.
The daughters went to the room she used as both an office and library.
As usual, the door was locked.
They broke it open.
Their mother was lying dead in a corner.
For the daughters, her death was almost a release.
Their mother had made their lives miserable.
She had driven away every man who tried to court them.
She had spent almost nothing on their education.
They had grown up completely unprepared for the outside world.
Sadly, each of the three women eventually became the target of men interested mainly in their money.
They escaped one form of control only to fall under another.
Their husbands were uncultured men who had married them for their wealth.
It was a miserable fate.
But the death of their mother changed everything.
The funeral was over.
Then James, acting as the family lawyer, produced the forged will.
He read it aloud to the family.
Brea's wife, Sarah, was named the principal heir.
She was to inherit the fortune.
Sarah was stunned.
The rest of the family was even more shocked.
The will also provided smaller gifts to various relatives.
The three other sisters were to receive a property in Harlem and $3,000 a year for life.
Almost no one questioned the will.
There was only one exception.
A poor nephew named Eagan had been left just $500.
He was furious.
“I won't accept this,” he announced.
The next day, he hired a young lawyer named Ezra.
Ezra had little business and no established reputation, but he had plenty of confidence and ambition.
He immediately decided to challenge the will.
Meanwhile, Brea and Sarah acted as though the estate already belonged to them.
On the very day of the funeral, they moved into the family home.
Brea intended to stay there until the forged will was formally approved.
More than $200,000 in cash and securities were still held by the family's bank.
Once the will was probated, he expected to control the fortune.
He believed he was safe.
He was wrong.
There was one thing he did not know.
A single dirty sheet of paper was lying in the library.
It had been casually slipped inside a book.
Brea had spent hours in that room.
He could have found it at any moment.
If he had, he could have destroyed it.
That little piece of paper was about to destroy his entire fortune.
The executors named in the will were two ordinary shopkeepers who lived nearby.
When Ezra notified them that Eagan intended to challenge the will, they were surprised.
Ezra also warned them not to allow Brea to take possession of the house until the court determined who actually owned it.
Ezra knew James's reputation as a lawyer.
He also had a sharp legal mind of his own.
For reasons he could not fully explain, he became suspicious.
“I believe this will is a forgery,” he said.
The three sisters initially refused to challenge it.
Brea could have settled the matter easily.
He could have offered Ezra a generous fee and given Eagan perhaps $1,000.
But Brea felt too confident.
Instead, he insulted Ezra.
“You're nothing but a shyster and a blackmailer,” he told him.
That was a terrible mistake.
Ezra's anger exploded.
He persuaded the sisters to support the challenge.
Then he had Brea and Sarah removed from the house.
The sisters moved back in.
Brea tried to negotiate with Ezra.
He was careful, but he said enough to make Ezra realize that he desperately wanted to keep the case out of court.
For a moment, Ezra considered cooperating with him.
But by then, Ezra had become the sisters' protector.
And he had another plan.
He began paying special attention to Jane, the youngest sister.
Jane was over thirty, poorly educated, and inexperienced with the world.
But she was warm-hearted and deeply romantic.
She quickly became convinced that Ezra was a wonderful man.
In her imagination, the thin, narrow-chested, sharp-tongued lawyer became a heroic figure.
After only a month, Ezra asked her to marry him.
They were alone in a small sitting room when he finally proposed.
Jane burst into tears.
“I've loved you since the first day we met,” she told him.
“I've never been so happy.”
Then she suddenly remembered something.
She ran to a bookshelf.
She pulled down a book.
Opening it, she found a dirty sheet of paper.
“What is this?” she asked Ezra.
He took the paper.
The moment he saw it, he understood its importance.
It was a draft of a new will.
It was written in the handwriting of Jane's mother.
And it was dated the very night she died.
The document was only a rough draft.
There were no witnesses' signatures.
But across the bottom was the unmistakable signature of the old woman herself.
Ezra immediately understood what he was looking at.
“This changes everything,” he said.
He called Jane's two older sisters into the room.
He read the document aloud.
They were stunned.
Ezra then wrote down exactly how and where the document had been discovered.
All four sisters signed the statement.
That evening, Ezra went home with the dirty sheet of paper safely tucked inside his vest.
He could hardly feel his feet touching the pavement.
He had just discovered a fortune.
And once he married Jane, he believed his future was secure.
The truth was now becoming clear.
After her violent argument with her daughters, the old woman had gone into the library in a rage.
There, she had begun drafting a new will.
The new document changed several things.
Most importantly, it favored Jane.
But one detail pleased Ezra more than anything else.
Brea's wife, Sarah, was left exactly one dollar.
The new will was quickly filed and admitted to probate.
Ezra posted the required bond and was appointed one of the executors.
He now had the enormous satisfaction of confronting Brea.
“You're a forger,” he told him.
“And you're a fraud.”
Brea's fortune had disappeared overnight.
Before the new will was discovered, Brea and Sarah had borrowed heavily because everyone believed Sarah was about to inherit a huge estate.
Brea had even persuaded Sarah to guarantee a $10,000 note.
He borrowed the money from bankers.
Now the truth had come out.
His creditors immediately demanded payment.
Brea was arrested in civil proceedings.
He couldn't raise bail.
So he was sent to Ludlow Street Jail.
He remained there for six months.
Eventually, Ezra advised the sisters to settle the matter.
They agreed to pay Brea's debts and give both him and Sarah $1,000.
There was only one condition.
“They must live west of Chicago,” Ezra said.
Brea had no choice.
He and Sarah left for Montana.
Brea opened a saloon in Butte City.
But he was never the same man again.
He began drinking heavily.
Eventually, he became his own best customer.
The business collapsed.
But the money was not what destroyed him.
What haunted him was something much simpler.
He kept remembering the old house.
He had possessed it for weeks.
He had spent countless hours alone in the library.
And the new will had been sitting there the entire time.
He could have found it.
He could have destroyed it.
He had simply failed to look.
That thought consumed him.
The sheriff eventually sold the saloon.
Then Sarah ran away with Brea's closest friend.
Brea had lost his money, his health, his wife, and whatever remained of his reputation.
He became a homeless outcast.
One morning, as the sun rose over the town, several gamblers were leaving Ned Wright's saloon after a night of drinking and gambling.
They stopped when they saw something lying across the doorway.
It was the body of a man.
He was thin, ragged, and almost unrecognizable.
It was Brea.
He had finally lost everything.
James's fate was hardly better.
When he first saw the forged will, he had demanded $5,000 from Brea.
Brea paid him.
But when the new will was discovered, James immediately understood what had happened.
His last hope of becoming wealthy was gone.
“Fortune and I are finished,” he must have thought.
He decided to return to London before the $5,000 was gone.
So he left America.
But London offered him no salvation.
He lived there for several years in terrible poverty.
He survived by taking whatever miserable work and opportunities came his way.
Eventually, he died.
Edwin James had once seemed destined for greatness.
He had possessed the talent to become Attorney-General.
He might even have risen to the office of Lord Chancellor.
A man who should have ended his life honored and remembered could instead have become one of the most respected figures in English legal history.
Instead, he took that first step into crime.
Then another.
Then another.
And each time, he told himself that circumstances had forced him to do it.
In the end, he lost his reputation, his fortune, his country, and his future.
He died alone and was buried in a pauper's grave.
That was the final price of the first step he had once believed he could take without ever taking a second.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!