The Labor Question
Business prosperity depends heavily on keeping a healthy relationship between employers and workers. When labor becomes less productive or conflict between the two sides becomes severe, the effects spread far beyond individual companies. They can damage national prosperity, financial markets, investors, and ultimately the workers themselves.
Some people argue that because modern businesses have grown larger and capital has become concentrated in powerful corporations, workers must also organize into large unions to protect themselves. But I do not find this argument convincing.
The theory assumes that large employers have greater power to force wages down than small employers. But for that to happen, employers would first have to stop competing with one another for workers. That is impossible under normal economic conditions.
Capitalists will generally expand production as long as they can earn an ordinary profit. The more production they undertake, the more workers they need. Competition for labor therefore pushes wages upward.
If manufacturers somehow joined together and deliberately forced wages down, they might succeed for a short time. But the lower wages would make manufacturing unusually profitable. New investors would quickly put their money into the industry, creating new demand for workers. Wages would then rise again, and the original employers would have no choice but to pay more.
There is another reason manufacturers cannot maintain such an agreement. They are competitors. Their interests are never completely identical, and their rivalries would eventually destroy any attempt to maintain a permanent wage-fixing arrangement.
So if employers are already forced by competition to pay what labor is worth, and if they cannot permanently unite to push wages downward, I see little reason why workers must organize to defend themselves against capital.
Workers are protected by the natural forces of competition far more effectively than they can be protected by artificial arrangements.
Trade unions, in my view, interfere with those forces. They cannot improve the basic laws of the labor market, but they can distort them and create trouble for both employers and employees.
A union may sometimes win higher wages through a strike. But those higher wages would often have arrived naturally through competition among employers anyway. The increase might have come later, but if we count the wages lost and the suffering caused by a strike, workers may actually be better off by waiting for the natural increase.
John Stuart Mill made much the same argument.
He pointed out that many critics of competition see only one side of it. They notice that competition can push wages and prices downward, but they forget that competition among buyers pushes them upward as well.
If employers compete for workers, they must bid against one another for labor. Competition therefore does not simply reduce wages. It prevents wages from falling even further and tends to bring wages toward a general market level.
The same principle applies to goods.
Competition may force producers to lower their prices, but that benefits workers because workers must spend their wages on those goods. Lower prices increase what their wages can actually buy.
Some socialists have argued that competition eventually allows the richest competitor to destroy all the others and become a monopoly. But ordinary experience does not support this idea.
In most industries, one wealthy competitor cannot simply eliminate every rival.
There are exceptions in industries such as railroads, where enormous amounts of capital are required and only a few companies can realistically compete. In such cases, government regulation may be necessary to protect the public.
But in ordinary industries, large companies usually become successful because their greater capital allows them to use better machinery, more efficient methods, or better organization. Those advantages enable them to produce goods more cheaply.
Consumers benefit from those lower costs, and workers benefit as consumers.
Even when an industry becomes concentrated in the hands of fewer large companies, competition generally remains among those companies. The savings created by large-scale production can therefore continue to reach consumers through lower prices.
So competition is not an illusion. It genuinely keeps prices down, and its importance is increasing rather than disappearing.
There is another serious problem with the union system.
Unions often begin with the assumption that workers are essentially equal in their ability, productivity, and quality of work. From that assumption comes the demand for a uniform wage.
But workers are not equal.
Some are more skilled. Some are more energetic. Some are more reliable. Some produce much more than others.
Why should a highly capable worker receive exactly the same pay as someone who produces far less?
That is a serious injustice.
A person who has greater ability and works harder has earned the right to benefit from those qualities. He may also have a family depending on him, and he has a responsibility to make the best use of his abilities.
A rigid wage system takes away that opportunity.
It ignores the natural differences among people and attempts to force the entire working population into the same mold.
That can prevent workers from improving their position.
There was a time when an American worker could rise from the lowest level of employment to wealth, social influence, or political power. Many successful merchants—and even some millionaires—began as ordinary workers.
They advanced because they were more capable, more faithful, or more ambitious than others. Their abilities allowed them to move step by step into better positions.
A worker could once determine his own future.
But the tendency of trade unions, as I see it, is to erase these distinctions. By imposing uniform conditions and restricting individual advancement, they can prevent a worker from being rewarded according to his own ability.
That is a dangerous development.
If a worker is no longer free to rise through superior skill and effort, one of the most important paths to social advancement disappears.
Political leaders and some economists may regard unions as a permanent necessity of modern society. I cannot share that confidence.
I believe the union movement has already reached its high point and will gradually weaken unless its principles are substantially changed.
The power of a union ultimately depends on its ability to force employers to accept the workers' demands.
For many years, strikes gave unions that power.
Employers often agreed to demands simply because a strike was too costly. Even when they disliked the demands, they might decide that giving in was cheaper than shutting down their businesses.
But eventually the demands became so extensive that employers decided they could no longer surrender.
The spring of 1886 became the great test.
Strikes erupted across the railroads, western factories, and major industries in the Middle States.
Workers demanded higher wages.
They demanded an eight-hour working day.
And, more importantly, they demanded that employers recognize union leaders as representatives of the workers and submit disputes to arbitration.
Employers finally decided to resist.
They refused to accept the demands.
In many cases, they refused to recognize union officials.
They hired non-union workers to replace the strikers.
They refused to guarantee returning strikers their old positions.
They used conspiracy laws against strike leaders.
They also took people accused of organizing boycotts to court.
The result was devastating for the unions.
The strikes failed almost everywhere.
Courts declared many of the unions' coercive methods illegal.
Tens of thousands of union workers lost their jobs.
And the unions spent enormous amounts of money trying to maintain their strikes.
Within a single month, the unions discovered that their much-feared power was far weaker than everyone had believed.
Employers learned that they had less reason to fear organized labor.
Many respectable union members themselves became discouraged. Their confidence in the union system was shaken, and the public increasingly viewed the movement with suspicion.
A defeat of this scale was likely to be followed by the gradual breakup of the organizations.
In my judgment, this was the natural result of a system built on mistaken ideas about how society and the labor market actually work.
During the strikes, I repeatedly commented on what was happening.
On May 3, I wrote that the Knights of Labor were attempting to answer a fundamental question: would capital or labor ultimately control the conditions under which the nation's invested wealth was used?
For employers, the issue was whether they would remain free to control their own property and businesses.
For workers, the issue was whether they could use collective pressure to take control that had traditionally belonged to the owners.
That was an extremely radical challenge to the existing relationship between labor and capital.
It inevitably disrupted business.
Companies became reluctant to enter into long-term contracts or begin new projects when they could not be sure whether their operations would continue.
I never believed that such a movement could ultimately succeed in America as long as citizens understood their legal rights and economic interests.
But the strikes could still do enormous damage.
They could divide society into hostile classes.
They could hold back ordinary business.
They could discourage new investment.
And they could create serious problems in the financial markets.
Still, this crisis could not continue forever.
The demands of the Knights of Labor had become so extreme that much of the public concluded they had to be resisted.
The unions had also lost much of the sympathy they once enjoyed because of genuine injustices in certain industries.
Instead, they increasingly appeared unreasonable, reckless, and unwilling to compromise.
Their own tactics were beginning to destroy their cause.
They were also encouraging the growth of non-union labor.
Employers who had previously depended on union workers now had a powerful reason to look elsewhere.
Workers who remained outside the unions could negotiate directly with employers and potentially earn more according to their individual abilities.
That could actually create a new path of advancement.
A capable worker might rise from employee to employer instead of being permanently trapped within a rigid wage system.
The longer the strikes continued, the more dissatisfied ordinary union members became with their leaders.
Further strikes and even more serious violence were possible.
But I believed the American public would remain calm as long as it could see that the crisis had an eventual end.
The Missouri Pacific strike provided a striking example.
Before the strike, Jay Gould was one of the most hated men in America.
He wanted public respect.
He had already made more money than he needed and was willing to spend some of it trying to improve his reputation.
Ironically, the strike accomplished something for Gould that his money could not.
Public sympathy shifted.
People who had previously supported the strikers began sympathizing with Gould instead.
The strikers had apparently chosen the Missouri Pacific because Gould was so closely associated with it. They believed that attacking his railroad would turn public anger against him.
The opposite happened.
Instead of damaging Gould, the strike gave him an enormous public-relations victory.
Mayor Harrison's firm response in Chicago also helped restore order.
If public officials were willing to put aside political favoritism and enforce the law equally, the country could quickly suppress rioting and violence.
The workers involved in the strikes now had an opportunity to return home.
Away from the excitement of the streets, they could think more clearly.
They might eventually realize that they themselves had suffered most from the actions of their leaders.
Many positions had already been abandoned by striking workers.
Yet employers had little difficulty filling those jobs.
Workers from other countries were arriving in large numbers, and modern steamships had reduced the Atlantic journey to only a few days.
The separation between European workers and American employers was becoming smaller every year.
If American workers left their jobs, newcomers could quickly take their places.
The American worker, in my view, still possessed enormous advantages.
He had political rights.
His vote gave him influence over the government.
He lived in a country where personal advancement was possible.
Compared with workers in many other nations, he had far greater opportunities.
Why, then, should he destroy those opportunities through endless strikes and social conflict?
By encouraging disorder, he could actually prevent his own class from advancing.
Large-scale immigration also meant that peaceful strikes could accomplish little by themselves.
If workers left their jobs, employers could often replace them.
But when strikes turned violent, the situation became entirely different.
Then the issue was no longer simply wages or working hours.
It became a question of law and public order.
The violence in Chicago was especially damaging to the labor movement. Several policemen were killed when dynamite was thrown into their ranks.
Nothing could have hurt the cause of organized labor more.
Public sympathy disappeared.
At the same time, it was important to recognize that many American and Irish workers had refused to participate in such violence or support it.
If the labor crisis was only a temporary interruption, then the next question was obvious: what would happen once the disruption ended?
The answer was encouraging.
America still possessed the enormous resources that had made it one of the fastest-growing nations in the world.
Its population was still increasing.
Its undeveloped sources of wealth were still waiting to be opened.
The country still had the capital and labor needed to develop its farms, mines, forests, factories, and transportation systems.
American inventiveness had not disappeared.
The country's ability to apply science and technology to business remained unmatched in many fields.
New industries were still being created.
New sources of wealth were still being discovered.
And while European governments were competing to establish new colonies around the world, America was developing its own vast resources at home.
To the overcrowded populations of Europe, the United States still offered opportunities unmatched by almost any other country.
The renewed flood of immigrants arriving from Britain and continental Europe was the clearest evidence of that.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!