← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 44 · The Silver Problem

The Silver Problem

Chapter 44 of 90 · 2,068 words · Free

“What financial question matters more to the future of the world’s money than the place silver should occupy alongside gold?”

“Very few. Nearly half of the world’s metallic money consists of silver, with the other half in gold. If silver is to remain useful as money, its value must be stable.”

“And how can that stability be secured?”

“Only through an international agreement. The major nations would have to establish a fixed relationship between silver and gold, so that a given weight of silver could always be exchanged for a given weight of gold.”

“Would that be enough?”

“Yes. If the leading nations agreed to coin silver freely at their mints, anyone could bring silver bullion to a mint and receive silver coins for it. The value of the bullion would then stay close to the value of the coins, and the value of silver money would remain stable.”

“Then why has this not been done?”

“Because governments have been unwilling to act together. Each country has hoped that the others would take responsibility for maintaining free silver coinage.”

“Did any group of countries actually try it?”

“Yes. The Latin Union did. As long as its members maintained free coinage, the union was capable of absorbing the world’s growing supply of silver and keeping its value relatively stable.”

“What changed?”

“Germany abandoned silver.”

“Why was that so important?”

“German theorists persuaded Chancellor Bismarck to demonetize silver. Germany suddenly sent a large amount of silver into the markets and mints of the Latin Union. The member countries became alarmed. First they limited silver coinage, and eventually they suspended it.”

“And what happened after that?”

“Once the demand for silver coinage disappeared, silver bullion was no longer supported by its legal relationship with gold. It became an ordinary commodity whose price depended on supply and demand. Because the supply was greater than the demand, its price fell.”

“So that is the basic reason silver has depreciated?”

“Exactly.”

“Then how can its value be restored?”

“I see only one practical solution: create a new international monetary union, similar to the old Latin Union but much broader. The United States, England, and Germany would be especially important members.”

“Would the world have enough gold to operate without silver?”

“Perhaps there would be enough gold for bank reserves and international payments. But gold is too valuable and scarce to serve all the needs of everyday commerce. Silver is indispensable for ordinary transactions.”

“So you believe gold and silver must continue to be used together?”

“Absolutely. A properly regulated silver currency must exist alongside gold.”

“Would you support an international coinage union?”

“Yes. If the leading nations agreed on a fixed value between silver and gold, required their mints to coin silver on demand, and made those coins legal tender, silver bullion would acquire a stable value throughout the world.”

“Would the experience of the Latin Union support that conclusion?”

“Certainly. The Latin Union kept silver near sixty pence an ounce for years. The moment its members stopped supporting silver coinage, that protection disappeared and silver fell toward its value as a mere commodity.”

“What if the international ratio were fixed at fifteen and a half ounces of silver to one ounce of gold?”

“If every member country agreed to coin silver at that ratio whenever bullion was presented, the free conversion of bullion into legal-tender coins would force bullion and coin to have essentially the same value. Apart from small minting costs, silver would return to roughly sixty pence an ounce.”

“Some people have suggested that the United States should suspend silver-dollar coinage in order to force Europe to cooperate. Would that be wise?”

“I believe it is necessary.”

“Why?”

“European governments disagree sharply over the monetary standard, and England remains strongly committed to gold. They may not act until they are forced to deal with the consequences of the enormous amount of silver we are producing.”

“How would the United States force them to act?”

“If we continue sending twenty-five to thirty million dollars’ worth of silver bullion to Europe every year, the pressure on Asian trade and on the huge silver circulation of Latin countries will become impossible to ignore. Those nations would eventually have strong reasons to cooperate in restoring silver.”

“Would suspending silver coinage create problems for the United States?”

“Continuing it creates the greater danger. The government is already dangerously close to losing its ability to maintain gold payments.”

“How close?”

“We have already reached a point where the Treasury had to negotiate with banks for six million dollars in gold to prevent such a crisis. Only a very small reserve separates us from another emergency.”

“What would happen if the government could no longer redeem its currency in gold?”

“Gold would command an unlimited premium. People would rush their greenbacks to the Treasury for redemption, while paper money redeemable in silver would fall toward the purchasing power of the silver behind it.”

“Do you think that danger is immediate?”

“Much closer than most people realize. It is irresponsible to continue a policy that keeps the country in such a vulnerable position.”

“Then should silver-dollar coinage be suspended temporarily?”

“No. It should be suspended completely and without conditions.”

“Why not suspend it only for a short time?”

“Because a partial or temporary suspension would accomplish neither objective. It would not remove the danger at home, and it would not create enough pressure to make Europe participate in an international settlement.”

“What happens if nations continue coining silver without an international agreement?”

“No country can safely do so. It would be continually increasing its supply of money without knowing what that money would be worth in the future. That could create serious injustice between debtors and creditors.”

“Yet the United States has continued to mint silver.”

“Yes. The political influence of the silver-producing states persuaded Congress to require the annual coinage of at least twenty-four million dollars in standard silver dollars.”

“Did that policy at least stop silver from falling?”

“To some extent. But the price was high. We had already added about $230 million of badly depreciated legal-tender money to the currency system.”

“And what effect did that have on the rest of the currency?”

“It weakened the entire system. About $680 million of paper money could ultimately be redeemed in silver. If a serious flow of gold toward Europe occurred, the country could face a very dangerous monetary crisis.”

“Was all that silver actually needed for circulation?”

“No. That is obvious from the fact that less than one-third of the silver dollars could be put into circulation.”

“What did the government do with the rest?”

“It developed schemes to keep the silver in the Treasury while issuing paper certificates against it.”

“Was there a particularly important proposal?”

“Yes. A. J. Warner of Ohio proposed a plan to replace the monthly silver coinage with certificates backed by silver bullion deposited in the Treasury.”

“How would the plan work?”

“Anyone holding silver bullion could deposit any amount with the Treasury.”

“And what would the Treasury give him?”

“A certificate equal to the market value of the silver at the time of deposit.”

“Would those certificates circulate as money?”

“Yes. The government could use them to pay debts not specifically payable in gold. They would also be accepted for customs duties, taxes, and other public payments. National banks would have to accept them in their dealings with one another.”

“How could the certificates be redeemed?”

“They could be redeemed in lawful money—gold, silver, or U.S. notes—or, at the Treasury’s option, in silver bullion at its market value when redemption occurred.”

“Was the proposal sound?”

“No. It raised serious constitutional questions from the beginning.”

“Why?”

“Congress has the power to coin gold and silver and make those coins legal tender. But that does not mean the government has the power to operate a storage business for silver producers.”

“You mean the government would become a warehouse?”

“Exactly. The government has no more legitimate reason to store silver for its producers than it has to store cotton, wheat, or iron for private dealers.”

“And the certificates made the problem worse?”

“Much worse. The government would not merely hold the bullion. It would issue specially privileged pieces of paper that would become part of the national currency.”

“What was wrong with their redemption system?”

“It would expose the Treasury to enormous risks.”

“Explain.”

“Suppose someone deposited one million ounces of silver when silver was worth $1.10 an ounce. The Treasury would issue $1.1 million in certificates.”

“And what if silver later fell to $1.05?”

“The holder could return the certificates and demand their value in silver. At $1.05 an ounce, the Treasury would have to give him about 1,047,619 ounces of silver.”

“So the Treasury would have to return more silver than it received?”

“Exactly. It would lose 47,619 ounces in that transaction.”

“Would speculators take advantage of that?”

“Without question. Why would we expect speculators to ignore a system that offered them guaranteed profits?”

“How would they exploit it?”

“They could work with London bullion dealers. They could buy European silver, push the price higher, and send the silver to the United States Treasury at the inflated price.”

“And then?”

“After the price fell, they would redeem their certificates for a larger quantity of silver.”

“So the Treasury would lose money every time?”

“Yes. The government would become a gigantic target for speculative manipulation.”

“Could foreign silver also be brought into the system?”

“Absolutely. Nothing in Warner’s plan would prevent speculators from sending huge quantities of European silver to the United States.”

“What would that mean for the country?”

“First, we would effectively exchange American gold for European silver. Then the United States would become responsible for carrying the world’s surplus silver.”

“Would that make an international agreement easier?”

“No. It would make one harder. England, Germany, and other nations would have even less reason to negotiate because the United States would already be absorbing their unwanted silver.”

“And the Treasury would be overloaded?”

“Yes. It would carry an enormous quantity of silver while facing potentially huge losses. At the same time, the certificates issued against that silver would artificially expand the money supply.”

“What would that do to the economy?”

“It could create a dangerous inflation of the currency and damage almost every legitimate economic interest.”

“Then who would benefit from the plan?”

“The silver interests would benefit enormously. In the short run, it would protect silver producers even better than the existing Bland Act.”

“But would that protection last?”

“No. The system would eventually collapse under its own weight. When it did, the silver miners would suffer even more severely from the resulting monetary disorder.”

“So what should the government do instead?”

“The healthiest solution is to repeal the Silver Coinage Act.”

“What would repeal accomplish?”

“We would stop locking up about twenty-five million dollars of silver every year in the Treasury. Instead, that silver could be exported.”

“How would that help the United States?”

“The additional exports would strengthen our ability to obtain European gold. That would improve our international financial position.”

“And what about Europe?”

“Europe—especially England—would finally have to confront the silver problem seriously.”

“Why would they be forced to act?”

“Because the United States would no longer be willing to absorb the world’s surplus silver. European nations would have to participate in creating a broad and permanent international monetary arrangement.”

“Would silver fall immediately after repeal?”

“It might fall temporarily in the bullion market.”

“Would that destroy the silver producers?”

“Not necessarily. As Europe began to consider an international agreement, the silver market would respond favorably. The eventual recovery could more than compensate producers for their temporary losses.”

“So the silver problem is serious, but not hopeless?”

“Not at all.”

“What makes you optimistic?”

“The worse the disorder becomes, the stronger the pressure for a solution will become.”

“You mean the nations cannot avoid the problem forever?”

“Exactly. The disruption to trade and the enormous financial interests tied to silver will eventually become too serious to ignore.”

“And then?”

“The governments now resisting reform will be forced to act.”

“What do you think the final result will be?”

“I believe the great nations will eventually establish an international coinage union.”

“On what basis?”

“On a broad enough agreement to give silver a stable monetary value and prevent this problem from disturbing the world’s financial system again.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!