← The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes 2026 Edition
Chapter 11 · The Missing Beryl Coronet

The Missing Beryl Coronet

Chapter 11 of 12 · 5,992 words · Free

“Holmes,” I said one morning as I stood by the window, “there’s a madman coming down the street. It seems rather cruel that his family should let him wander around alone.”

Holmes got up from his chair and looked over my shoulder.

It was a bright, freezing February morning. Snow covered the ground, and the winter sun made it shine. The road had been cleared in the middle, but thick snow still lay along the sides. The pavement was slippery, so hardly anyone was outside.

The only person coming from the direction of the station was the strange man who had caught my attention.

He was about fifty, tall, broad, and dignified. His black coat was expensive, his hat was polished, and his clothes were carefully chosen.

But his behavior was completely different.

He was running down the street, sometimes jumping forward as though he had forgotten how to walk normally. His hands jerked wildly, his head moved from side to side, and his face twisted with grief.

“What could possibly be wrong with him?” I asked.

“He’s coming here,” Holmes said.

“Here?”

“Yes. I believe he wants my help. And I think I know why.”

The man suddenly rushed to our door and pulled the bell so hard that the whole house rang.

A few moments later he entered our room.

He was still gasping for breath and waving his hands, but the despair in his eyes was so terrible that neither Holmes nor I felt like smiling.

He tried to speak, but no words came.

He swayed from side to side and pulled at his hair.

Then he suddenly jumped up and struck his head against the wall.

Holmes and I grabbed him and pulled him away.

Holmes pushed him into a chair.

“Please sit down,” he said gently. “You came here to tell me your story, didn’t you? Take a moment to recover. Then tell me what has happened.”

The man sat there breathing heavily.

After a while he wiped his forehead, tightened his lips, and looked at us.

“You probably think I’m mad,” he said.

“I can see that something terrible has happened to you,” Holmes replied.

“Terrible? God knows it is. It happened so suddenly and is so awful that I can hardly think clearly. I could face public disgrace, although my reputation has always been clean. I could also endure a private tragedy, as every man must at some point. But both together, in such a terrible form, have nearly destroyed me.

“And it isn’t only my own reputation that is at stake. Some of the most important people in this country could suffer if this matter is not solved.”

“Please calm yourself,” Holmes said. “Tell me who you are and what has happened.”

“My name is Alexander Holder. I am a senior partner in Holder & Stevenson, the banking firm on Threadneedle Street.”

We knew the name well. Holder was one of the most respected bankers in London.

It was difficult to imagine what could have brought such a man to this condition.

“I knew time was important,” he continued. “That is why I came here as soon as the police inspector advised me to ask for your help.

“I took the Underground from the bank and walked from the station. The snow made the cabs slow, which is why I arrived so out of breath.

“I feel better now. I’ll tell you everything as clearly and briefly as I can.

“As you know, a successful bank must find good ways to invest its money. One of our best methods is lending large sums when we have excellent security.

“We have often lent money to wealthy and noble families against valuable paintings, libraries, silverware, and other possessions.

“Yesterday morning I was in my office when one of my clerks brought me a visitor’s card.

“I recognized the name immediately.

“It belonged to one of the highest and most respected men in England.

“When he entered, I wanted to express how honored I was, but he immediately began talking about business.

“‘Mr. Holder,’ he said, ‘I understand that you lend money.’

“‘The bank does, provided the security is satisfactory,’ I replied.

“‘I urgently need £50,000.’

“‘For how long?’

“‘Until Monday. I will repay everything then, with whatever interest you consider fair. But I need the money immediately.’

“‘I could lend you the money personally,’ I said, ‘but it would place too much pressure on me. If the bank is involved, I must follow the usual rules and require proper security.’

“‘That is exactly what I want.’

“He then picked up a small black leather case that had been beside his chair.

“‘You have heard of the Beryl Coronet?’ he asked.

“‘Of course. It is one of the most valuable treasures in the country.’

“He opened the case.

“Inside, resting on soft velvet, was the magnificent coronet.

“‘There are thirty-nine huge beryls in it,’ he said. ‘The gold itself is extremely valuable. The coronet is worth at least twice the amount I am asking for. I will leave it with you as security.’

“I held the case and stared at him.

“‘You doubt its value?’ he asked.

“‘Not at all. I only wonder whether it is wise for you to leave it here.’

“‘You need not worry. I would never do this unless I was certain I could reclaim it within four days. It is simply a business arrangement. Is the security sufficient?’

“‘More than sufficient.’

“‘Then you understand that I am placing great trust in you. I expect you to keep this matter completely private. Above all, you must protect the coronet carefully.

“If anything happens to it, there will be a terrible public scandal. The stones are unique and cannot be replaced.

“I shall return for it personally on Monday morning.’

“He clearly wanted to leave, so I called my cashier and ordered him to pay the £50,000.

“Once I was alone, however, I began to feel the weight of the responsibility I had accepted.

“The coronet was effectively a national treasure. If anything happened to it, the scandal would be enormous.

“I locked it in my private safe and returned to my work.

“But that evening I became worried.

“Bank safes had been broken into before. What if someone robbed mine?

“I decided that for the next few days I would carry the coronet home with me every night.

“I took a cab to my house at Streatham, carrying the case.

“I did not feel safe until I had taken it upstairs and locked it inside the bureau in my dressing room.

“Now I must tell you about my household.

“My groom and page sleep outside the house, so they are not important to this matter.

“I have three maids who have worked for me for years. I trust them completely.

“There is also Lucy Parr, my second waiting-maid. She has only been with me a few months, but she came with excellent references and has always done her work well.

“She is a pretty girl, and several young men have sometimes waited around the house hoping to see her. That is the only thing about her that has ever concerned us.

“As for my family, I am a widower and have one son, Arthur.

“Arthur has been a terrible disappointment to me.

“I suppose I spoiled him.

“When his mother died, he was the only person I had left to love. I could not bear to see him unhappy, so I gave him almost everything he wanted.

“I intended him to take over my business, but he had no interest in banking.

“He was reckless, and I could not trust him with large amounts of money.

“When he was young, he joined an expensive club and became friends with wealthy young men who spent money freely.

“He began gambling heavily at cards and betting on horse races.

“Again and again he came to me asking for money to pay his debts.

“He tried several times to leave that dangerous crowd, but his friend Sir George Burnwell always managed to pull him back.

“I understood why Arthur admired Sir George.

“Sir George was older, charming, handsome, confident, and experienced. He had traveled everywhere and could make anyone feel important.

“Even I found his personality difficult to resist when he was in the room.

“But whenever I thought about him afterward, I distrusted him.

“His cynical words and cold eyes told me there was something dangerous beneath the charm.

“My niece Mary felt the same way.

“Mary is the daughter of my late brother. When he died five years ago, I took her into my home and raised her as my own daughter.

“She is the joy of my house.

“She is kind, beautiful, calm, intelligent, and an excellent housekeeper. I depend on her completely.

“She has only ever disagreed with me about one thing.

“Arthur has asked her twice to marry him.

“She refused him both times.

“I believed that Mary might have changed Arthur's life if she had married him.

“But now it was too late.

“That evening, after dinner, we were drinking coffee in the drawing room.

“I told Arthur and Mary that I had received the coronet and explained how valuable it was. I did not tell them the identity of the man who had left it with me.

“Lucy had brought us the coffee, and I believe she left the room, although I cannot be certain that she closed the door.

“Arthur and Mary were fascinated and wanted to see the coronet.

“I refused to take it out.

“‘Where have you put it?’ Arthur asked.

“‘In my bureau.’

“‘I hope we don't get robbed tonight.’

“‘It's locked,’ I said.

“‘That bureau is easy to open. When I was younger, I once opened it with the key to the box-room cupboard.’

“I thought nothing of the remark because Arthur often spoke carelessly.

“But later that night he followed me upstairs.

“‘Dad,’ he said quietly, ‘could you give me £200?’

“‘No.’

“‘You've been very generous with me already, but I need it. If I don't pay this debt, I can never show my face at the club again.’

“‘Then perhaps you shouldn't show your face there.’

“‘But I can't leave the club as a dishonored man.’

“‘You will get no more money from me.’

“He left without another word.

“It was the third time that month he had asked me for money.

“After he left, I opened the bureau and checked the coronet.

“It was still there.

“I locked the bureau again.

“Then I decided to check the house myself.

“As I came downstairs, I saw Mary closing a side window in the hall.

“‘Dad,’ she said, ‘did you give Lucy permission to go out tonight?’

“‘No.’

“‘She just came in through the back door. I think she only went to the side gate to meet someone, but I don't think it is safe.’

“‘You should speak to her tomorrow.’

“‘I will.’

“‘Is everything locked?’

“‘Yes.’

“I kissed her good night and went to bed.

“I have told you everything I can think of, Mr. Holmes. Please ask me anything that is unclear.”

“Your story is very clear,” Holmes said.

“The important part comes next.

“I am not a heavy sleeper, and my anxiety probably made me sleep even more lightly than usual.

“At about two in the morning, I woke because of a sound.

“It stopped before I was fully awake.

“It sounded as though a window had been gently closed somewhere in the house.

“I lay still and listened.

“Then I heard footsteps in the next room.

“I jumped out of bed and looked around the door of my dressing room.

“‘Arthur!’ I shouted. ‘You thief! What are you doing with that coronet?’

“The gaslight was still burning low.

“Arthur was standing beside it.

“He was wearing only his shirt and trousers.

“He had the coronet in his hands and appeared to be pulling at it with all his strength.

“When he heard me, he dropped it.

“He turned white.

“I picked it up immediately.

“One corner of the gold, containing three of the beryls, was gone.

“‘You have ruined it!’ I shouted. ‘You've destroyed my reputation! Where are the missing stones?’

“‘Missing?’

“‘Yes! You stole them!’

“‘There are no missing stones.’

“‘Three are missing! I saw you trying to tear off another part.’

“‘You've already called me a thief and a liar. I won't say another word.’

“‘You are leaving this house in the hands of the police!’

“‘Do what you want. You won't hear anything from me.’

“By then the whole house was awake.

“Mary rushed into the room.

“When she saw Arthur and the damaged coronet, she understood what had happened.

“She screamed and collapsed.

“I sent for the police.

“When the inspector arrived, Arthur stood there with his arms folded.

“‘Are you going to accuse me of theft?’ he asked.

“‘This is no longer a private matter,’ I told him. ‘The coronet is national property.’

“‘At least let me leave the house for five minutes,’ he said. ‘It would help both of us.’

“‘So you can escape? Or hide what you stole?’

“I begged him to think about what he had done.

“‘This scandal could destroy not only me but people far more important than me. Tell me where the three stones are, and everything can still be forgiven.’

“‘Keep your forgiveness,’ he said bitterly. ‘I didn't ask for it.’

“I knew then that I could get nothing from him.

“I had the inspector arrest him.

“They searched Arthur, his room, and the whole house.

“They found nothing.

“Arthur refused to explain anything.

“This morning he was taken to a cell.

“I came directly to you.

“The police admit that they have no idea what happened.

“I will pay whatever is necessary.

“I have already offered a reward of £1,000.

“My God, Mr. Holmes, what am I going to do?

“I have lost my reputation, the coronet, and my son in one night.”

Holder covered his face with his hands and rocked back and forth.

Holmes sat silently for several minutes.

Then he asked, “Do you receive many visitors?”

“Only my business partner, his family, and some of Arthur's friends.”

“Has Sir George Burnwell visited recently?”

“Yes. Several times.”

“Do you go out socially?”

“Arthur does. Mary and I rarely go anywhere.”

“That is unusual for a young woman.”

“She is quiet. Besides, she is twenty-four.”

“Was Mary badly affected by what happened?”

“Terribly. Perhaps even more than I was.”

“You have no doubt that Arthur is guilty?”

“How could I doubt it? I saw him holding the coronet.”

“That is not necessarily proof.”

“The coronet was damaged.”

“Could Arthur have been trying to repair it?”

Holder stared at Holmes.

“God bless you,” he said. “You are trying to find a way to save him. But what was he doing there?”

“Exactly. If he was innocent, why didn't he explain?”

“I don't know.”

“And if he was guilty, why didn't he invent some excuse? His silence can be understood in either direction.”

Holmes continued.

“What did the police think caused the noise that woke you?”

“They said perhaps Arthur had closed his bedroom door.”

“A man trying to commit a robbery would hardly slam a door loudly enough to wake everyone.”

“They are searching the house for the missing stones.”

“Have they searched outside?”

“Yes. The garden has been examined carefully.”

Holmes leaned forward.

“Mr. Holder, don't you see that this is far more complicated than you and the police have assumed?

“Your theory is that Arthur got out of bed, opened your bureau, took the coronet, broke off part of it, somehow hid three stones, and then returned with the rest of the coronet to the very room where he was most likely to be discovered.

“Does that really make sense?”

“But what other explanation is there?” Holder cried.

“If Arthur was innocent, why won't he explain himself?”

“That is exactly what we must discover,” Holmes said.

“We'll go to your house and examine everything ourselves.”

I insisted on going with them.

Although I believed Arthur was probably guilty, I trusted Holmes enough to know that his doubts mattered.

During the journey, Holmes said almost nothing.

He sat with his chin on his chest and his hat pulled low over his eyes, deep in thought.

Holder, however, seemed encouraged by Holmes's confidence and began talking quietly to me about his business.

Soon we reached Streatham and walked to Fairbank, Holder's house.

It was a large square building of white stone, set back from the road.

A snowy lawn stretched between the house and two large iron gates.

On one side was a narrow path leading to the kitchen door.

On the other was a public lane leading toward the stables.

Holmes told us to wait at the door.

He then slowly walked around the entire house.

He examined the front, the servants' entrance, the garden, and finally the stable lane.

He took so long that Holder and I went inside and waited by the fire.

After some time, a young woman entered.

She was tall and slim, with dark hair and dark eyes.

Her skin was extremely pale.

Her lips were almost colorless, and her eyes were red from crying.

She went straight to Holder and gently placed her hand on his head.

“Dad, you told them to release Arthur, didn't you?”

“No, Mary. We have to find out the truth.”

“But I know he's innocent.

“You know what a woman's instincts can tell her.

“He didn't do this.

“You will regret having treated him so harshly.”

“Why won't he explain himself if he's innocent?”

“Perhaps because he was furious that you suspected him.”

“How could I not suspect him? I saw him holding the coronet.”

“He only picked it up to look at it.

“Please believe me.

“Let this go.

“It's terrible knowing Arthur is in prison.”

“I will not let it go until the missing stones are found.

“Your affection for Arthur is making you forget what this means for me.

“I've brought a gentleman from London to investigate.”

“This gentleman?”

Mary looked toward me.

“No. His friend. Holmes is outside near the stable lane.”

“The stable lane?”

She looked surprised.

“What could he possibly find there?”

At that moment Holmes entered.

“I hope I can prove what you believe,” he said.

“You are Miss Mary Holder, I presume?”

“Yes.”

“May I ask you a few questions?”

“Of course, if it helps save Arthur.”

“You heard nothing last night?”

“No. Not until my uncle shouted.”

“You checked the windows and doors before going to bed?”

“Yes.”

“And you locked all the windows?”

“Yes.”

“You have a maid who has a sweetheart?”

“Yes.”

“You told your uncle she had gone outside?”

“Yes.”

“She may have heard about the coronet and told her sweetheart.”

Holder interrupted impatiently.

“But what good are these theories? I saw Arthur holding the coronet!”

“We will return to that,” Holmes said.

“Miss Holder, when you saw Lucy come back through the kitchen door, was her sweetheart with her?”

“Yes.”

“Do you know him?”

“Yes. He is the greengrocer who supplies us. His name is Francis Prosper.”

“Where was he standing?”

“Near the door.”

“Was he farther up the path than the door itself?”

“Yes.”

“Does he have a wooden leg?”

Mary's eyes widened.

“How could you possibly know that?”

Holmes smiled faintly.

“I have my methods.”

He then examined the windows before going upstairs.

In the dressing room, Holmes studied the bureau.

“Which key opened it?”

“The key to the box-room cupboard.”

“Where is it?”

“On the dressing table.”

Holmes picked it up and opened the bureau.

“This lock makes almost no sound. That explains why you weren't awakened.

“Now let's examine the coronet.”

He opened the case.

The damaged coronet lay inside.

Thirty-six magnificent stones remained.

One corner was broken away.

“Mr. Holder,” Holmes said, “please try to break off the matching corner.”

Holder stared at him in horror.

“I couldn't possibly do that.”

“I'll try.”

Holmes gripped the coronet and pulled.

It barely moved.

“I can feel it giving way,” he said, “but it would take me considerable effort to break it.

“An ordinary man certainly could not do it quietly.

“If I succeeded, it would make a sound like a pistol shot.

“You say Arthur broke this off only a few feet from your bed, and you heard nothing?”

“I don't know what to think anymore.”

“Perhaps things will become clearer.”

Holmes looked at Mary.

“What do you think?”

“I am just as confused.”

“Arthur wasn't wearing shoes?”

“No. Only his shirt and trousers.”

Holmes nodded.

“We've been very fortunate. It would be our own fault if we failed to solve this now.”

He went outside alone.

He explained that too many people walking around would destroy the footprints in the snow.

For more than an hour he searched the grounds.

Eventually he returned.

“I believe I've seen everything I need to see.”

“But the gems?” Holder cried.

“Where are they?”

“I don't know yet.”

Holder looked devastated.

“I'll never see them again.”

“And my son?”

“My opinion has not changed.”

“Then what happened here?”

“Come to Baker Street tomorrow morning between nine and ten.

“I should be able to explain more by then.”

“You have permission to spend whatever is necessary to recover the stones.”

“Of course.”

“I would give my entire fortune to get them back.”

“Very well.

“I'll do everything I can.”

We returned to Baker Street.

I could tell that Holmes had already formed a theory, but he refused to explain it.

Before three o'clock, he changed into the clothes of a poor street beggar.

His collar was turned up, his coat was old and dirty, his boots were worn, and he wore a cheap red scarf.

“I wish you could come with me, Watson,” he said.

“But it would be better if I went alone.

“I may be following the right trail, or I may be chasing nothing.

“I'll know soon enough.”

He cut some beef from the sideboard, put it between two pieces of bread, and pushed the sandwich into his pocket.

Then he left.

He returned several hours later in excellent spirits.

He was carrying an old boot.

He threw it into the corner and poured himself some tea.

“I only stopped here briefly,” he said.

“Where are you going now?” I asked.

“The other side of the West End.

“It may take me some time.

“Don't wait for me.”

“How is the investigation going?”

“Very well.

“I went back to Streatham, but I didn't enter the house.

“It is a fascinating little problem.”

He smiled.

“I must get out of these ridiculous clothes and become respectable again.”

His eyes were bright with satisfaction.

A few minutes later he left again.

I waited until midnight, but he did not return.

It was not unusual for Holmes to disappear for a night or two when he was following a clue.

The next morning, when I came downstairs, I found him already at breakfast.

He looked perfectly fresh.

“You'll forgive me for starting without you, Watson,” he said. “Our client is due here early.”

“It is after nine.”

“I wouldn't be surprised if that's him.”

A moment later the door opened.

Holder entered.

I was shocked by how much he had changed.

His face looked thin and exhausted.

His hair seemed whiter.

He dropped into the chair.

“I don't know why I have been punished so severely,” he said.

“Two days ago I was a happy and successful man.

“Now I am old, alone, and disgraced.

“And another tragedy has happened.

“Mary has left me.”

“Left you?”

“Yes.

“She did not sleep in her bed last night.

“Her room was empty.

“She left me a note.

“I told her last night that if she had married Arthur, perhaps none of this would have happened.

“Perhaps I should not have said it.

“This is what she wrote.”

Holder handed Holmes the note.

“‘My dearest uncle,

‘I feel that I have brought trouble upon you.

‘If I had acted differently, perhaps this terrible disaster would never have happened.

‘I can never be happy in your house again with that thought in my mind.

‘I must leave you forever.

‘Do not worry about my future. It is already arranged.

‘Most importantly, do not search for me. It will do you no good and will only cause me trouble.

‘In life or death, I remain your loving Mary.’”

Holder looked at Holmes.

“What does it mean?

“Do you think she killed herself?”

“No,” Holmes said quickly.

“Nothing like that.

“In fact, this may be the best possible outcome.

“I believe your troubles are nearly over.”

Holder stared at him.

“You know something!

“Where are the gems?”

Holmes looked at him calmly.

“You wouldn't consider £1,000 per stone too much?”

“I would pay ten times that.”

“You won't need to.

“£3,000 will be enough.

“And I think you owe someone a reward as well.

“Do you have your checkbook?”

Holder, confused, took it out.

Holmes handed him a pen.

“Make it for £4,000.”

Holder wrote the check.

Holmes went to his desk.

He returned carrying a small triangular piece of gold containing three beryls.

He dropped it onto the table.

Holder cried out and grabbed it.

“You found them!

“I am saved!”

His joy was as extreme as his grief had been.

He held the gems against his chest.

“There is one more debt you must pay,” Holmes said firmly.

“A debt?”

Holder reached for his pen.

“Name the amount.”

“It isn't money.

“You owe your son a sincere apology.

“Arthur behaved exactly as I would hope my own son would behave, if I ever had one.”

Holder stared at him.

“Then Arthur didn't steal the gems?”

“I told you yesterday that he didn't.

“I tell you again today.”

“You're certain?”

“Completely.”

“Then we must go to him immediately.”

“He already knows the truth.

“After I solved the case, I spoke to him.

“He refused to tell me what happened, so I explained my theory.

“He finally admitted that I was right and filled in the few details I was still missing.

“Your news about Mary may finally persuade him to speak openly.”

“Please tell me what happened.”

Holmes nodded.

“I will.

“And I'll explain exactly how I discovered it.

“First, however, there is something painful you must hear.

“Your niece Mary and Sir George Burnwell have been secretly involved.

“They have run away together.”

Holder went white.

“My Mary?

“No.

“That is impossible.”

“I wish it were.

“But it is certain.

“You and Arthur never understood Sir George's true character.

“He is one of the most dangerous men in England.

“He is a ruined gambler and a completely ruthless criminal.

“He has no conscience.

“Mary knew nothing about men like him.

“When he told her he loved her, she believed him.

“He had probably said the same thing to many women before her.

“But she believed she was different.

“He became the center of her life.

“She was meeting him almost every evening.”

“I cannot believe it,” Holder whispered.

“Then let me explain what happened that night.

“After you went upstairs, Mary went downstairs and spoke to Sir George through the hall window overlooking the stable lane.

“His footprints were deeply pressed into the snow because he had been standing there for a long time.

“She told him about the coronet.

“Sir George immediately saw an opportunity.

“His greed took control of him, and he persuaded her to help him steal it.

“I believe Mary loved you.

“But some people become so obsessed with a lover that every other loyalty disappears.

“Mary was probably one of them.

“She had barely finished speaking to him when she saw you coming downstairs.

“She quickly closed the window.

“Then she told you about Lucy and the wooden-legged greengrocer.

“That story was true, which made her explanation believable.”

Holder listened silently.

“Arthur had gone to bed after speaking with you.

“But he was worried about his debts and could not sleep.

“In the middle of the night he heard someone moving quietly past his room.

“He got up.

“Looking into the hallway, he saw Mary walking quietly toward your dressing room.

“She entered.

“Arthur was shocked.

“He put on some clothes and waited in the darkness.

“After a while Mary came out.

“She was carrying the coronet.

“She walked downstairs.

“Arthur followed.

“He hid behind a curtain near the hall so that she would not see him.

“He watched as she opened the window and handed the coronet to someone waiting outside.

“Then she closed the window and hurried back upstairs.

“She passed very close to where Arthur was hiding.

“Arthur could not expose her while she was there.

“He loved her too much.

“But once she had gone, he understood what this would mean for you.

“He rushed downstairs.

“He was still barefoot.

“He opened the window and ran into the snow.

“He saw a dark figure in the moonlight.

“It was Sir George.

“Sir George tried to escape.

“Arthur caught him.

“They struggled over the coronet.

“Arthur pulled one side while Sir George pulled the other.

“Arthur struck him and cut his forehead.

“Then the coronet broke.

“Arthur found himself holding the main part of it.

“He ran back to the house.

“He closed the window.

“He went upstairs and tried to straighten the damaged coronet.

“That was when you found him.”

Holder stared at Holmes.

“Is that really possible?”

“Yes.

“And then you made things worse by accusing him.

“You called him a thief at the exact moment when he believed he had protected you.

“He could not explain the truth without exposing Mary.

“So he chose to remain silent.”

Holder suddenly understood.

“That was why Mary screamed when she saw the coronet.

“And when Arthur asked to leave the house for five minutes, he wanted to search for the missing piece!

“My God.

“What have I done?

“I treated my own son like a criminal.”

Holmes nodded.

“When I first arrived at your house, I carefully examined the snow.

“No new snow had fallen since the previous evening, and the frost had preserved the footprints.

“I checked the servants' path first.

“Most of it had been disturbed by people walking over it.

“But near the kitchen door I found clear evidence that a woman had stood there talking to a man.

“The man's footprints showed that he had a wooden leg.

“The woman had suddenly hurried back toward the house.

“The man stayed a little longer before leaving.

“I assumed it was Lucy and her sweetheart, and your family confirmed that.

“I then searched the garden.

“Most of the tracks were meaningless because the police had already walked through the area.

“But the stable lane was different.

“There I found something very important.

“There were two sets of footprints.

“One belonged to a man wearing boots.

“The other belonged to someone who was barefoot.

“I immediately thought of Arthur because you had told me he was barefoot when you saw him.

“The booted man had walked both ways.

“The barefoot man had run.

“His footprints sometimes crossed over the boot prints, proving that he had followed the other man.

“I followed the tracks to the hall window.

“The booted man had stood there for a long time.

“Then I followed the tracks in the opposite direction.

“About a hundred yards away, the booted man had turned around.

“The snow showed signs of a struggle.

“There were also several drops of blood.

“That proved someone had been injured.

“The booted man then ran away.

“More blood appeared farther along the lane.

“He was the injured man.

“Eventually he reached the main road, where the snow had been cleared.

“So the trail ended there.

“I then examined the hall window.

“With my magnifying glass I found evidence that someone had climbed through it.

“I could even see the outline of a wet foot on the frame.

“By then I had almost reconstructed the whole event.

“A man waited outside.

“Someone inside brought him the coronet.

“Arthur saw what was happening.

“He chased the thief.

“They struggled over the coronet.

“The force of both men caused damage that neither could have caused alone.

“Arthur returned with most of the coronet.

“The thief escaped with the broken piece containing the three missing stones.

“The remaining question was simple.

“Who was the man outside?

“And who had given him the coronet?”

Holmes leaned back.

“I have an old rule.

“When every impossible explanation has been eliminated, whatever remains, no matter how unlikely, must be the truth.

“I knew you had not given Mary the coronet.

“So the only possibilities were Mary and the maids.

“But if one of the maids had done it, why would Arthur allow himself to be accused instead?

“There was no reason.

“However, Arthur loved Mary.

“That gave him every reason to protect her.

“Especially because the truth would destroy her reputation.

“Then I remembered that you had seen Mary at the window.

“I remembered how she fainted when she saw the damaged coronet.

“Those details made my suspicion certain.

“The person outside had to be someone she loved.

“Who else could persuade her to betray you?

“You rarely went out.

“Your circle of friends was small.

“But Sir George Burnwell was among them.

“I already knew of his terrible reputation with women.

“So I concluded that he was the man outside.

“He had worn the boots.

“He had received the three missing stones.

“Even after Arthur discovered him, Sir George could feel safe.

“He knew Arthur could not reveal the truth without exposing his own family.”

Holder slowly nodded.

“What did you do next?”

“I disguised myself as a beggar and went to Sir George's house.

“I became friendly with his servant.

“I learned that Sir George had injured his head the previous night.

“That confirmed my suspicion.

“Then, for six shillings, I bought a pair of his old shoes.

“I took them to Streatham.

“They matched the footprints exactly.”

“I saw a badly dressed man in the lane yesterday,” Holder said.

“That was me.

“Once I knew I had the right man, I returned home and changed.

“Then I had to deal with Sir George.

“A police investigation would have created an enormous scandal.

“I also knew a clever criminal like him would understand that your family could not openly accuse him without exposing Mary.

“So I went to him myself.

“At first he denied everything.

“Then I described every detail I had discovered.

“He became aggressive and reached for a heavy weapon on the wall.

“I drew my pistol and pointed it at him before he could attack.

“That made him more cooperative.

“I told him I would buy the three stones for £1,000 each.

“He immediately complained.

“‘Damn it!’ he said. ‘I already sold all three for six hundred pounds!’

“He eventually gave me the address of the man who had bought them.

“I promised that no prosecution would follow.

“I went there, negotiated with the man, and bought the three stones for £3,000.

“Then I visited Arthur and told him everything was under control.

“After that, I finally went to bed around two in the morning.”

Holder stood.

“A day of work that saved England from a terrible scandal.

“I don't know how to thank you.

“Your skill is even greater than I had heard.

“I must go to my son immediately and apologize for what I did to him.

“As for Mary, what you have told me breaks my heart.

“Can you tell me where she is now?”

Holmes gave him a grave look.

“I think we can safely assume that she is wherever Sir George Burnwell is.

“And whatever consequences await her, I doubt she will escape them for long.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!