The Money Kept Coming Until Everything Fell Apart
I will condense the events in London into one continuous story, beginning with my departure and ending several months later, when our entire scheme collapsed and Noyes was arrested.
We had already spent an enormous amount of money.
So we agreed that our first batch of forged bills would be limited to roughly the amount we had spent since leaving Rio.
I left for Paris on Monday.
On Wednesday, Noyes went to the Bank of England and withdrew almost everything in my account, leaving only three hundred pounds behind.
That same day, he went to Birmingham and mailed the first batch of forged bills.
The total was £8,000.
The next twenty-four hours were extremely tense for George and Mac.
The bills should reach the bank with the early Thursday mail.
If everything worked as planned, the bank would discount them before noon, put the money into my account, and lock the bills away in its vault until they became due months later.
George and Mac waited nervously.
Two o'clock came.
Still nothing.
They had already packed their bags and were ready to disappear at the first sign of trouble.
Finally, they left Mac's lodging and headed toward the bank.
They were carrying two checks.
One was for £2,300, payable to Warren.
The other was for £4 10s., payable to the bearer.
Noyes walked ahead.
George and Mac followed at a distance.
Near the bank, Noyes stopped outside a hotel on a quiet side street.
He watched the people passing by until he spotted a uniformed messenger who looked suitable.
He approached him.
"Would you do a small job for me?"
The messenger looked at him.
"What kind of job?"
"Take this check to the Bank of England. Bring the cash back here, and I'll pay you for your trouble."
The messenger agreed.
Noyes handed him the £4 10s. check.
As soon as the man turned the corner, Noyes disappeared in the opposite direction and went to the place they had agreed upon.
Mac followed the messenger.
He watched him enter the bank.
A few minutes later, the teller handed over the money without asking a single question.
Mac gave the agreed signal to George.
George immediately went to find Noyes.
When the messenger returned with the cash, Noyes was already waiting for him, looking completely calm.
He paid the man.
Then the three men walked toward the bank together.
On the way, Mac handed Noyes the £2,300 check.
Noyes entered the bank and presented it.
"Good afternoon," he said to the cashier.
Then he added, "I'd like £2,000 in gold and the rest in notes."
The cashier handed him the money without hesitation.
That evening, three extremely happy men sat down to dinner.
The test had worked.
The Bank of England was not nearly as secure as we had believed it was.
The next morning, Noyes went to Jay Cooke & Co.
"I'd like to buy seventy-five thousand dollars' worth of United States bonds."
He handed over a check drawn on the Bank of England.
That afternoon, he returned to Birmingham and mailed another batch of forged bills.
This time the total was £15,000.
Later that day, he went back to the bank and withdrew another £2,000 in gold.
On Monday, he returned to Jay Cooke & Co.
The $75,000 worth of bonds was handed to him without a single question.
From then on, the process became routine.
The amounts simply grew larger.
Some days the bank received forged bills worth $100,000.
Sometimes the amount was higher.
Sometimes it was lower.
November passed.
Then December.
Week after week, the Bank of England continued accepting our worthless paper and giving us real money in return.
The bank was filling its vaults with our forged bills.
We were filling our pockets with its gold.
But why didn't we stop?
That is the question a sensible person would ask.
The answer is simple.
When someone wants something badly enough, he can always invent a hundred reasons for continuing.
And we wanted more money.
As Christmas approached, Mac began thinking seriously about going home.
He had already paid his father back every penny of the money he owed him.
They had also reconciled through letters.
Every ship brought more letters from his parents and sisters.
They were full of happiness.
They believed Mac was finally coming home.
His father, who had once been deeply disappointed in him, had become proud again.
He believed his eldest son had finally abandoned the foolishness of his youth and was making up for his past mistakes.
The family had no idea what was really happening.
Soon the newspapers would be filled with stories about Mac's arrest and imprisonment for taking part in one of the biggest financial frauds anyone had ever seen.
The news would destroy the family.
When the cable finally arrived announcing that their son had been sentenced to life imprisonment in a foreign prison, their happiness disappeared.
Their reputation had been ruined.
Their hope was gone.
One by one, members of that family eventually passed away, unable to recover from the shock and shame.
Meanwhile, in London, Mac and George discussed spending Christmas at home.
They almost decided to leave.
Then they looked at the money.
"Why should we run away now?" one of them said.
"The money is coming in so easily."
Another argument seemed even more convincing.
"If we collect enough, we can put a huge amount somewhere safe."
"Then the bank might be willing to settle."
"Exactly. If we gave them a million or two, perhaps they would be happy to get their money back and forget the rest."
So they stayed.
They spent Christmas in London.
It was a happy Christmas.
And an extremely expensive one.
By February, however, they finally decided it was time to leave.
Everything seemed to be going perfectly.
The gold and bonds we had accumulated represented enormous fortunes for all of us.
I was far away in the tropics, enjoying an easy life with my young bride among palm and coconut trees.
George and Mac had never appeared in any of the transactions.
Almost nobody knew that Noyes was even in Europe.
Only a handful of people had seen him, and they knew him only as a representative of Warren.
As far as we could tell, the operation was finished.
The three men in London would leave England carrying their money.
The Bank of England would continue holding the forged bills for several weeks or months before they became due.
By then, we would be safely gone.
There seemed to be no way to trace the money back to us.
So they decided to stop.
The final batch of forged bills had already been mailed.
One more day.
Then everything would be over.
That day, Noyes bought more bonds and withdrew cash totaling more than $150,000.
At three o'clock, the three men sat down for their final lunch in London.
Afterward, they went straight to Mac's apartment in St. James's Place.
All the materials used to make the forged bills were there.
It was time to destroy the evidence.
Anything that could be burned would go into the fireplace.
Anything that could not be burned would be reduced to useless scraps and thrown into the Thames.
The three men looked at one another.
They were happy.
They believed they had accomplished something extraordinary.
They had challenged society.
They had cheated one of the greatest banks in the world.
And they had won.
Mac, who had done most of the actual writing, opened a box containing the unused bills.
He moved it beside the fireplace.
One by one, he began throwing the papers into the flames.
Occasionally, however, he tossed a more elaborate bill onto the floor beside his chair.
Eventually, he finished.
He bent down and picked up the papers lying on the floor.
He looked at them.
Then he began to crush them in his hand.
He was about to throw them into the fire when he stopped.
He smoothed them out again.
"Boys," he said, "these are beautiful pieces of work."
He smiled.
"It seems a shame to destroy them."
He was right.
From our point of view, it seemed almost wasteful.
All we had to do was put them in the mail.
They could make us thousands of pounds.
George looked at him.
"Why don't we send them?"
There was a pause.
Then the others agreed.
"All right."
That decision sealed our fate.
There were nineteen bills in the batch.
Together, they represented £26,000.
But one of them contained a fatal mistake.
A date was missing.
None of us noticed it.
We had everything else under control.
But that tiny omission would destroy us.
It was not really an accident.
Call it fate.
Call it Nemesis.
Call it whatever you like.
But something had finally caught up with us.
We prepared the final letter.
The nineteen bills were placed inside with a memorandum.
The envelope was addressed and stamped.
Then the three of them traveled to Birmingham.
They mailed the letter.
And afterward, they laughed.
They believed they had beaten the system.
They believed they had discovered a secret path to wealth that no one else could see.
They were wrong.
There is no safe shortcut to fortune through crime.
The bills were mailed on Monday.
The moment that letter disappeared into the mailbox, the final act of our disaster began.
By the end of it, we would be standing in court and then walking down into the cold cells of Newgate.
The next morning, Tuesday, the letter arrived at the Bank of England.
The bills went through the normal discounting process.
The bank accepted them and credited my account.
I already had £20,000 there.
The new bills increased the balance to £46,000.
Then something almost unbelievable happened.
One of the bills was accepted by Blydenstein & Co., a major London banking firm.
The discount clerk noticed that the acceptance date was missing.
But he assumed it was nothing more than a clerical mistake.
He thought someone at Blydenstein's had simply forgotten to write the date.
He did not report it.
The bill was discounted along with the other eighteen.
Those eighteen were put into the vault.
The questionable one was placed aside.
The clerk planned to deal with it the next day.
On Wednesday morning, at half past ten, he handed the bill to a bank messenger.
"Take this to Blydenstein & Co. when you're making your rounds," he instructed.
"Ask them to correct the missing date."
At two o'clock on Tuesday afternoon, Noyes had gone to Jay Cooke & Co.
He ordered another $100,000 worth of United States bonds.
He paid with a Bank of England check.
He was told to return the following day after the check had passed through the clearing system.
Wednesday morning came.
Noyes wanted to make one final test.
He sent a messenger to the bank with a small check.
The money was handed over immediately.
No questions.
No suspicion.
Nothing.
To Noyes, it was perfect proof that everything was still safe.
But he did not know that within half an hour, the bank messenger would leave with the forged bill and take it to Blydenstein's.
By then, the forged bills had been inside the Bank of England for twenty-five hours.
They had already been discounted.
The money had been credited to my account for a full day.
How could anyone have imagined the chain of events that was about to unfold?
First, three supposedly clever men had made such a basic mistake.
Second, the Bank of England, considered almost impossible to deceive, had accepted a bill with an incomplete date.
Third, the bank had held that bill for more than a day without discovering the problem.
And finally, the company whose name appeared on the bill was less than a hundred yards away.
Yet nobody had noticed.
So when Mac saw the small check paid without hesitation that Wednesday morning, he felt completely reassured.
He believed the last batch of forged bills was safely locked away in the bank's vault.
"We're finished," he probably thought.
Noyes immediately went to Jay Cooke & Co.
The Bank of England had honored the check.
So Jay Cooke & Co. handed him the $100,000 worth of bonds.
Mac and George were waiting outside.
George took the bonds.
Then he handed Noyes another check, this one for £10,000.
Noyes returned to the bank.
He walked up to the counter.
The cashier paid him.
Noyes walked out feeling lighter than ever.
The danger seemed to be over.
The money was secured.
The operation was finished.
He would never have to visit the bank again.
The three men had arranged to meet at Garraway's Coffee House in Exchange Alley.
Garraway's was an old and famous meeting place.
It had once been closely associated with the South Sea Bubble and had remained known as a traditional London coffeehouse.
By 1873, its days as a center of financial speculation were long gone, but its reputation remained.
That morning, the three men sat around a small table there.
They were delighted.
It was only 10:35.
They had just made another $150,000.
And this was only one of many successful days.
They believed all danger had passed.
They imagined themselves back in America.
They would become wealthy men.
They would move among the richest people in society.
They knew the money had been obtained illegally, but they comforted themselves with the thought that they had not ruined ordinary families.
No poor widow or orphan had been left destitute because of them.
That made the whole thing easier for them to accept.
Noyes leaned back happily.
"I am never going back to that bank again."
He laughed.
"Come on, boys. Shake hands on it."
The three men shook hands.
Then they shook hands again.
They were celebrating what they thought was their victory.
They had no idea what was happening only a short distance away.
At that very moment, a terrified bank employee was rushing through the building.
His face was pale.
He was carrying terrible news.
The bill was a forgery.
The bank erupted into chaos.
Telegrams were sent immediately to the police detectives.
Within minutes, officers were being dispatched from Bow Street and Scotland Yard.
Rumors spread through London at incredible speed.
People began saying that enormous frauds had been committed.
Some rumors claimed that almost every bank in London had been robbed.
Within ten minutes, the story reached the Stock Exchange.
Panic followed.
But at Garraway's, the three men continued sitting quietly at their table.
They knew nothing.
As far as they were concerned, everything was going perfectly.
At the bank, the frightened officials could give the detectives only one useful description.
A tall young American.
His name was Warren.
That was almost useless.
Thousands of men in London could fit that description.
Had my friends known what was happening, they could probably have stayed in the coffeehouse all day.
They might even have sat there drinking porter from old pewter mugs while the police searched the city.
Mac and George had never appeared at the bank.
Noyes was almost unknown in Europe.
And I—the man the bank believed was F. A. Warren—was thousands of miles away, living quietly with my young wife on a beautiful tropical island.
It seemed that the three men still had nothing to fear.
They had the money.
There was no obvious connection between them and the crime.
The police had no clear idea who they were.
The world seemed to be open to them.
Wealth, they believed, could buy almost anything.
But fate had other plans.
Something drove them to make one final, foolish decision.
Mac casually mentioned that there was still a large balance in Warren's account.
"We've still got about $75,000 sitting there," he said.
Noyes thought about it.
"That's too much money to leave behind."
George looked at him.
"What do you suggest?"
"Write me a check for £5,000."
He smiled.
"I'll go over and get the cash. It will be useful spending money."
It was a ridiculous idea.
But by then, success had made them careless.
"All right," they agreed.
They wrote the £5,000 check.
Noyes picked it up and walked toward the bank.
He had no idea what was waiting for him.
The moment he entered the bank, he walked straight into a trap.
Twenty-five detectives were already inside or surrounding the building.
Special messengers had summoned the bank's directors.
The main banking room was packed.
Directors and shareholders were demanding answers.
Everyone was talking at once.
The manager and clerks were being questioned.
The atmosphere was close to panic.
Then Noyes walked in.
The detectives recognized him as the man who had been making the withdrawals.
They seized him immediately.
Several hands grabbed him at once.
He was dragged into the crowded room.
The men surrounding him looked furious.
Noyes, however, did not lose his nerve.
He remained calm.
"A gentleman hired me as his clerk," he said.
"That's all I know."
"Where is this gentleman?"
"I left him near the Stock Exchange."
"What's his name?"
"I don't know anything else."
He tried to sound convincing.
"If you let me go, I'll find him and bring him here."
Nobody believed him.
The bank officials were angry.
The detectives were suspicious.
Noyes had walked into the middle of a storm.
He was held tightly and taken away.
A group of furious Englishmen escorted him toward Newgate.
Only then did our seemingly perfect plan finally begin to collapse.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!