The Net Closes In
Mac and George were completely unprepared for what happened next.
They had only to look at the crowd gathering outside the bank and see people rushing in and out in a state of excitement to realize that something serious had happened.
They both knew at once that Noyes must be in terrible danger.
Mac hurried into the bank, hoping he might warn Noyes or somehow help him.
Inside, everything was in chaos.
Without attracting attention, Mac slipped into the parlor. What he saw there made his heart stop.
Noyes was standing in the middle of the room, surrounded by a group of angry officials.
Mac forced himself to remain calm. He pushed his way through the crowd until he was close enough for Noyes to see him.
Their eyes met.
Noyes immediately understood why Mac was there. If there was even the slightest chance to escape, Mac would help him.
But there was no chance.
The officials were watching him too closely.
When they began taking Noyes toward Newgate Prison, Mac slipped outside and found George.
"Noyes has been arrested," he told him.
George stared at him.
"Arrested?"
"Yes. They're taking him to Newgate."
They quickly discussed whether there was any possible way to rescue him.
They waited near the entrance, and before long Noyes appeared, surrounded by his guards.
He saw Mac and George.
They joined the crowd and stayed within a few feet of him all the way to Newgate. But the streets were packed with people. There was barely room to move.
A rescue attempt would have been hopeless.
When they reached Newgate, Mac was so desperate that he started to follow the guards inside.
George grabbed his arm.
"Come on, Mac. There's nothing we can do now."
Mac finally allowed himself to be pulled away.
As they escaped the crowd, they heard newspaper boys shouting in the street:
"Great Bank of England forgery by an American! Ten million pounds obtained!"
The news spread through London like wildfire.
That afternoon, Lionel Rothschild, chairman of the bank's board, went to Newgate to see Noyes.
He made him an extraordinary offer.
"Tell us everything you know," Rothschild said. "If you do, you will be released, and you will receive a thousand pounds."
But Noyes did not break.
He simply replied:
"A gentleman whom I had never seen before hired me as a clerk and messenger. That's all I know. I know nothing about Mr. Warren or his business."
No threat or promise could shake him.
Meanwhile, the $150,000 that had been withdrawn that morning was still sitting in a heavy bag behind the counter at Garraway's.
The barmaids working there had no idea that a fortune was lying almost at their feet.
When Mac returned to collect the money, one of the barmaids casually asked him:
"Have you heard about the great bank robbery?"
Mac kept his composure.
He took the money and drove back to St. James' Place.
George soon joined him.
Once again, the two men looked at each other in stunned silence.
The same question was in both their minds.
Why hadn't they been satisfied with what they had already made?
Why had they allowed Noyes to go back for that miserable £5,000?
And why had they failed to understand what all the excitement around the bank meant?
In Rio, they had only raised suspicion.
Now things were completely different.
Their companion was sitting in Newgate Prison.
Only an hour earlier, Noyes had been free, standing with them at Garraway's while they celebrated their success.
Now everything had suddenly become dangerous.
After thinking it over carefully, Mac and George reached two conclusions.
First, Noyes would never betray them. They trusted him to keep his mouth shut no matter what pressure was put on him.
Second, they believed Noyes could never actually be convicted of the forgery.
He might spend a few uncomfortable weeks in Newgate, but eventually, they thought, everything would work itself out.
So for the moment they decided to remain in London and wait.
That night, the news was carried around the world by cable.
The reports emphasized one detail above all others:
The suspected forger was an American.
The next morning, London newspapers were filled with the story.
Almost every important paper published an editorial about the crime. Later, the weekly and monthly publications joined in.
Looking back on those articles, we found them almost amusing.
The writers were shocked and indignant. Most of them believed Noyes was merely an innocent man who had been used by someone else.
They also wondered whether the mysterious Mr. F. A. Warren would ever return to England to prove Noyes's story.
Of course, they had no idea that Warren was much closer than they imagined.
Day after day, Mac and George remained in London, following every newspaper report and reading every account of Noyes's appearances before the Lord Mayor.
They had contacted Noyes through his solicitor.
His message to them was simple:
"Leave England immediately."
They were already sending money away.
They were so confident that the police would never connect their names with the crime that, except in two cases, they sent money and bonds to America under their real names.
Meanwhile, the Bank of England took a much wiser step.
Its legal representative in New York, Clarence A. Seward, received a cable asking him to put the American detectives on alert.
Seward understood exactly what kind of police administration he was dealing with in New York.
He immediately called Robert A. Pinkerton and gave him full responsibility for the American side of the investigation.
Pinkerton eventually uncovered the entire scheme.
He found the evidence that helped convict us and recovered a large portion of the stolen money.
His first move was particularly clever.
He wanted the police at headquarters to believe they were running the investigation themselves.
So Pinkerton arranged for the Bank of England's representative in New York to visit police headquarters every day.
The man pretended to consult James Irving about the case.
Irving had no idea that he was being manipulated.
After our return from the European trip to London, we had sent Irving $3,000 in greenbacks by registered mail.
But this time we took an extra precaution.
We wanted to make certain that our three friends at headquarters could never betray us without risking trouble themselves.
So we placed the money in the envelope in front of a magistrate. His clerk registered the letter and entered the transaction into the official court record.
The envelope was simply addressed:
"James Irving, Esq., 300 Mulberry Street, New York."
The London authorities naturally assumed it was just a private address.
Later, after we returned from Rio, we sent another $3,000.
This time it was $1,000 each for Irving, Stanley, and White.
Again, we took the same precautions.
Then the real flood of money began arriving in London.
Mac sent Irving another $15,000 in a registered letter.
This time we took no special legal precautions.
Irving and his friends had no idea what game we were playing.
They were simply delighted with the money they had already received and expected to receive in the future.
Then they began reading the newspaper reports about the Bank of England forgery.
Their excitement became almost ridiculous.
Each man imagined himself wearing a magnificent diamond ring and a huge diamond pin, racing through Harlem in an expensive carriage behind a pair of fast horses.
At night, their dreams became even grander.
They imagined themselves sitting in fashionable establishments, ordering bottle after bottle, or riding through New York at night and spending money as though a hundred dollars a minute meant nothing.
And, in their fantasies, the British bank was paying for everything.
But while Irving and his companions were dreaming of riches, the lawyers and Pinkerton detectives were quietly making fools of them.
Almost every day, one of the lawyers visited Mulberry Street.
Pinkerton had carefully instructed him what to say.
He fed Irving information that sounded convincing but was designed to keep him completely confused.
Irving and his two friends never suspected that the entire performance was a trap.
But I have gone ahead of the story.
Let us return to London.
Noyes was brought before the Lord Mayor almost every day for questioning.
His lawyer had instructed him to say as little as possible.
So Noyes remained completely noncommittal.
The detectives and officials were convinced that he knew everything.
They tried threats.
They tried promises.
They tried every method they could think of to make him talk.
Baron Rothschild and other bank directors visited him again.
But Noyes remained as silent as ever.
Nothing they said could make him betray us.
Eventually, two Pinkerton detectives arrived in London.
They began following clue after clue, and gradually the investigation started to make progress.
The English police had searched Noyes and discovered that his clothes had been made by a particular London tailor who operated several shops.
They brought the managers and salesmen from those shops to identify him.
None of them recognized Noyes.
But the Pinkerton detectives decided to check the shops themselves.
They discovered that the English police had missed one branch.
That was the very shop Noyes had used.
The employees remembered him.
But he had not given his real name.
When he ordered his clothes, he had called himself Bedford.
That was another serious problem for him.
The American detectives were eager to make him talk. If they had been allowed to use the rough methods sometimes employed by American investigators, they might have had better luck.
Then one salesman remembered something else.
"I think I saw him in Mayfair one day," he said. "He was walking with another American gentleman."
"Can you describe the man?"
The salesman gave them a fairly good description.
The detectives immediately took him with them and began going from house to house.
Their first stop was No. 1 Mayfair.
It happened to be the home of a famous London doctor, Payson Hewett.
Mac had once been his patient.
Dr. Hewett knew very little about him.
"His name was Mac," the doctor told them. "He gave me an address at the Westminster Palace Hotel."
The detectives were thrilled.
They hurried to the hotel.
But Mac had never stayed there.
They found nothing.
Even so, they were encouraged.
They now had several suspicious facts.
Noyes had used a false name when dealing with his tailor.
He had been seen with a well-dressed American.
That American had apparently given a false address to his doctor.
The detectives were becoming convinced that the two men were connected.
Dr. Hewett also told them something interesting.
"He told me he was a medical graduate from an American university," the doctor said. "From the way he talked about medicine, I believe he was telling the truth."
The detectives sent all this information to America.
They instructed the New York authorities to investigate Mac and his friends.
They had followed many false leads before reaching this point, but at last they believed they were getting close.
Meanwhile, George and Mac decided that it was time to return to America.
Before leaving his rooms at St. James' Place, Mac gathered $254,000 worth of United States bonds.
He divided them into three bundles.
Then he wrapped them in an old nightshirt of mine that had somehow ended up in his luggage.
He packed the bonds into a trunk and sent the trunk by express to Major George Mathews in New York.
Afterward, Mac bought a ticket to Paris.
He sent his baggage ahead and stayed in London for another day or two before following it.
George chose a different route.
He decided to go to Ireland.
He went there, and later I will let him tell in his own words about the exciting events that took place in Ireland and Scotland before he was finally arrested in Edinburgh several weeks later.
Before Mac sent his baggage away, he had intended to sail from Liverpool on the Cunard liner Java.
He even cabled Irving at police headquarters:
"Meet me when the ship arrives."
Then Mac changed his plans.
He went to Paris and checked into the Hotel Richmond on the Rue du Helder.
He used his real name.
He never imagined for a moment that he was being hunted.
But the Pinkerton detectives were already searching London.
They went from one fashionable lodging house to another, asking whether an American named Mac had stayed there.
In a city as enormous as London, the job was almost impossible.
But the detectives kept moving.
Eventually, one of them went to St. James' Place and asked a landlady whether an American gentleman had ever lodged there.
She answered:
"Yes. He lived here, but he left a few days ago."
That was exactly the information they needed.
The detectives rushed back to St. James' Place.
The landlady turned out to be a devoted friend of Mac.
When the detectives explained why they wanted to question her, she became furious.
"You have no right to accuse that man!" she said.
She ordered them out of the house.
The detectives had to bring the bank's solicitors and other important officials before she finally agreed to answer their questions.
Once she began talking, however, her information proved extremely valuable.
She knew little about George.
But she had seen me often.
She had never known my name, yet her description was enough for the detectives to understand that she was describing the man they were looking for—the mysterious F. A. Warren.
Finding him would bring the detectives fame and a fortune.
Mac's rooms had been empty since his departure.
The detectives searched them carefully.
At first they found nothing.
Then someone asked:
"Where is the waste-paper basket?"
The landlady brought it to them.
It was actually a small bag.
They emptied it.
Among the scraps were several pieces of blotting paper.
The detectives knew that writing pressed onto blotting paper could sometimes be read by holding the paper against a mirror.
They held the final piece up to the glass.
What appeared there made them stare in excitement:
"Ten Thousand Pounds Sterling.
F. A. WARREN."
They compared the writing with a canceled check belonging to me that was already in the bank's possession.
The handwriting matched perfectly.
At last they had something substantial.
If they could connect that piece of evidence to Mac, they believed they would have a case strong enough to hold him.
Pinkerton and his fellow detective immediately left for Paris.
They went to the American banking house where newly arrived Americans commonly registered.
There they found Mac's name.
He had registered with Andrews & Co. and had given the Hotel Richmond as his address.
Pinkerton hurried to the Rue du Helder.
But Mac had already left.
He learned that Mac had gone to Brest the night before.
Pinkerton rushed to the Paris office of the steamship company.
There he discovered that Mac had bought a ticket to New York aboard the Thuringia.
The ship was scheduled to leave Brest that very hour.
Pinkerton hurried to the telegraph office.
He sent an urgent message ordering the authorities to arrest Mac.
The reply came quickly.
The Thuringia had sailed half an hour before the telegram arrived.
Pinkerton may not have been entirely disappointed.
Mac was now on his way to New York, where he could be watched more easily.
And there was another advantage.
The longer the investigation continued in America, the more of the bank's money would pass through New York.
Pinkerton immediately sent the details of Mac's departure to his New York office.
Then he turned his attention to another question.
Who was F. A. Warren?
Mac had already cabled Irving to tell him that he was coming aboard the Thuringia.
Pinkerton decided there was no longer any reason to keep Mac's movements secret.
He gave the information to the newspapers.
Irving soon discovered, to his horror, that the whole world now knew where Mac was.
His problem was obvious.
If he wanted to preserve his reputation, he had to make a genuine arrest.
He could no longer behave like Mac's friend.
But Irving had another idea.
Perhaps Mac could be secretly taken off the ship before the official police boat arrived.
He discussed the plan with Stanley and White.
They decided to ask their friend Johnny Dobbs to help.
Dobbs was a well-known burglar and a close friend of Irving.
His job was to get Mac off the ship.
But Dobbs made a serious mistake.
Instead of arranging two boats so that one could replace the other, he hired only one.
For several days, he and his companions went out to meet incoming steamers.
Then, one morning, they went ashore on Staten Island to rest.
That was the morning the Thuringia entered the harbor.
One of the men in Dobbs's boat knew Mac.
The plan was simple.
They would approach the ship.
Mac was expected to be on deck watching for Irving.
When he saw the small boat, the man would call out to him:
"Jump overboard! We'll pick you up!"
They would then take Mac ashore and hide him.
But the plan never had a chance.
By the time the Thuringia entered the harbor, Irving had already kept the police boat waiting for more than an hour.
He assumed his friend had safely escaped.
So he finally boarded the ship.
Five United States Marshals were waiting on the police tug.
Bank lawyers and private investigators were with them.
Irving, accompanied by White and Stanley, climbed aboard the huge liner.
Before leaving the tug, he ordered its captain:
"Don't let anyone off the ship until I give you permission."
Mac saw the tug.
Then he recognized Irving, White, and Stanley.
At first, he was not alarmed.
Irving shook his hand and hurriedly explained the situation.
Mac took the three men to his cabin.
Then he handed them $150,000 in bonds.
He also gave them $10,000 in greenbacks that he had bought from brokers in London.
There were English banknotes and several valuable diamonds as well.
Finally, he brought out several bags filled with gold sovereigns.
"Now, boys," he said, "help yourselves. Take as much as you can and keep it away from the enemy."
It would have been a remarkable sight to see those three men loading themselves with gold.
They knew the marshals and detectives were trapped aboard the tug outside.
They were also convinced that Irving and his friends had managed to get to Mac first.
But they could not simply walk off the ship with their pockets bulging with gold.
If they were caught, the consequences would be disastrous.
They wanted every coin.
Their fingers practically itched to take more.
But they had to restrain themselves.
Then Irving noticed the enormous diamond ring on Mac's finger.
He stared at it greedily.
"My God, Mac," he said, "I wish I'd brought a fake diamond with me. You could keep wearing that ring and give me the real one in exchange."
The ring had already been seen by too many people, so Irving was afraid to take it.
His disappointment must have stayed with him for a long time.
It was remarkable how much our supposedly honest detectives loved diamonds.
One might reasonably ask where they expected to get them.
Meanwhile, tempers were rising on the tug.
The rival officials had finally realized that they had been tricked.
They threatened the captain until he agreed to bring the tug alongside the Thuringia.
Then they rushed aboard.
There they found Irving, White, and Stanley waiting with Mac.
The marshals went straight to Mac's cabin.
They found about £4,000 or £5,000 in gold sovereigns.
But when they searched Mac himself, they found almost nothing.
All he had on him was $20 in greenbacks.
He was taken into custody and brought ashore.
He was placed in Ludlow Street Jail while arrangements were made for a hearing before a United States Commissioner and, ultimately, his extradition to England.
The Pinkertons soon discovered the $254,000 in bonds hidden inside the old clothing in Mac's trunk at the European Express Office at 44 Broadway.
They also sent warnings to banks and trust companies throughout the country.
The message was simple:
"Hold any funds deposited by members of this party."
Pinkerton's men recovered large amounts of money from various places.
The most damaging evidence, however, was the piece of blotting paper.
It was produced in New York along with a long list of other evidence.
After a hard legal battle, Mac was finally ordered to be surrendered to the British Government to stand trial for his part in the great bank forgery.
The proceedings before the commissioner lasted three months.
Lawyers on both sides fought the case with extraordinary skill.
They dug through legal history, searching for precedents and arguments.
The case became one of the most closely watched extradition battles of the time.
Commissioner Gutman eventually ruled that Mac should be surrendered to the British authorities.
Mac's lawyers appealed.
The case went to the United States Circuit Court before Judge Woodruff.
Then it went higher still.
Mac was brought before the Supreme Court under writs of habeas corpus.
But the earlier decision was upheld.
He was sent to Fort Columbus for safekeeping while his lawyers continued filing new petitions.
They argued over habeas corpus and certiorari, hoping to delay his surrender.
But before they could achieve anything, Mac's custodians suddenly moved him.
He barely had time to say goodbye to his lawyers.
A United States officer hurried him into a carriage on Chambers Street.
Chief Deputy Marshal Kennedy and Deputies Robinson and Crowley surrounded him.
The carriage raced down Broadway toward the Battery.
A large crowd had gathered, hoping to watch Mac's departure from New York.
But he was moved so quickly that the spectators had little time to see him.
At the Battery, he was transferred to a tug and taken across to Governor's Island.
There the deputy marshals handed him over to Major J. P. Roy, who had him escorted to Fort Columbus.
The following morning, United States Marshal Fiske arrived with Deputies Crowley and Purvis.
Peter Williams, solicitor for the Bank of England, was there as well, along with Sergeant Edward Hancock, a London detective, Deputy Marshal Colfax, and several others.
They boarded the steam tug P. C. Schultze at the Battery and crossed to Governor's Island.
At 10:30 that morning, Captain J. W. Bean received the order to surrender Mac.
Captain Bean formally handed him over to Marshal Fiske.
Mac walked down from the fort with a deputy on either side.
They passed through the tiled paths and shaded avenues toward the wharf on the opposite side of the island.
The Schultze was waiting there.
A large crowd had gathered.
Soldiers and civilians lined the wharf, all eager to see the famous prisoner leave.
Yet Mac seemed strangely cheerful.
He walked slowly.
He smoked a cigarette.
He laughed and joked as though nothing serious were happening.
There was no sign of fear.
It was nearly eleven o'clock when the Schultze finally left Governor's Island.
The tug steamed down the bay, heading toward the Minnesota, which was waiting near Pier 46 on the North River.
The Minnesota remained at anchor throughout the morning and was not scheduled to sail until shortly after noon.
The Schultze waited in the lower bay until the great ship was ready to leave.
At last the tug approached the Minnesota.
Mac was taken aboard by Marshal Fiske and Deputies Robinson, Crowley, and Colfax.
He was then handed over to the English detectives, Sergeants Webb and Hancock.
They formally acknowledged receipt of the prisoner.
And so Mac began the journey that would take him across the Atlantic.
For now, I leave him on that ship, sailing eastward toward England and the terrible fate that awaited him.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!