← Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin 2026 Edition
Chapter 14 · The Plan to Unite the American Colonies

The Plan to Unite the American Colonies

Chapter 14 of 19 · 816 words · Free

In 1754, war with France seemed likely again. The British government ordered the colonies to send representatives to Albany, where they would meet with the leaders of the Six Nations and discuss how to defend both their lands and the colonies.

Governor Hamilton told the Pennsylvania Assembly about the order and asked them to provide gifts for the Native American leaders. He also chose Speaker Isaac Norris and me to represent Pennsylvania, along with Thomas Penn and Secretary Peters.

The Assembly approved the appointment and supplied the gifts. Although some members disliked the idea of conducting such business outside Pennsylvania, we traveled to Albany and met the other colonial commissioners in June.

On the way there, I came up with a plan to unite all the colonies under one government, at least for defense and other matters that affected everyone.

While passing through New York, I showed my proposal to James Alexander and Kennedy, two men who knew a great deal about government and public affairs. They approved of my idea, which gave me the confidence to present it to the Albany Congress.

To my surprise, several other commissioners had already thought of similar plans.

The Congress first voted on whether the colonies should form a union at all. Everyone agreed that they should.

A committee was then formed, with one representative from each colony, to examine the different proposals and prepare a final plan.

My proposal was chosen as the best of them.

After making a few changes, the committee presented it to the Congress.

Under my plan, the colonies would have a central government led by a president-general appointed and paid by the British Crown.

There would also be a grand council, whose members would be chosen by the colonial assemblies to represent the people.

The Congress discussed the plan every day while also handling its negotiations with the Native American nations.

There were many objections and difficult questions, but eventually we resolved them all.

The commissioners unanimously approved the plan and ordered copies to be sent to the British Board of Trade and to the assemblies of the individual colonies.

But the plan met a strange fate.

The colonial assemblies rejected it because they believed it gave too much power to the Crown.

The British government rejected it for the opposite reason. Officials in England thought it gave the colonies too much democratic power.

The Board of Trade therefore refused to approve it or recommend it to the king.

Instead, the British government created another plan. Under that system, the colonial governors and some members of their councils would meet to decide how to raise troops, build forts, and handle other military needs.

The expenses would initially be paid from the British treasury. Parliament would later impose a tax on the American colonies to recover the money.

My original plan, along with the reasons I gave in its support, can be found among my published political papers.

The following winter, while I was in Boston, I had many conversations with Governor Shirley about both plans.

Some of those discussions are also recorded in my political papers.

The fact that both sides disliked my plan for completely opposite reasons made me suspect that it may actually have been the fairest solution.

I still believe that both Britain and the colonies would have benefited greatly if the plan had been accepted.

With the colonies united, they would have been strong enough to defend themselves.

There would have been no need for Britain to send troops to America.

And if Britain had not needed to pay for those troops, there would have been no excuse for Parliament to tax the colonies.

The terrible conflict that eventually followed might therefore have been avoided.

But mistakes like this are nothing new.

History is filled with governments and rulers making decisions that later prove disastrous.

As the poet wrote:

“Look round the habitable world, how few
Know their own good, or, knowing it, pursue!”

People in government usually have so many responsibilities that they do not want to spend much time examining and carrying out new ideas.

That is why the best public policies are rarely adopted simply because leaders had the wisdom to plan ahead.

More often, governments wait until a crisis forces them to act.

When the Governor of Pennsylvania sent my plan to the Assembly, he spoke highly of it.

He said it seemed to him to have been written with great clarity and sound judgment, and he strongly recommended that the Assembly give it serious and careful consideration.

Unfortunately, when the Assembly finally discussed the proposal, I happened to be away.

A certain member took advantage of my absence and pushed the Assembly to consider it without me.

I thought this was unfair.

The House then rejected the plan without giving it the serious consideration it deserved.

I was deeply disappointed by the whole affair.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!