The Prison Genius Next Door
In the cell next to mine lived a man named Heep, one of the strangest and most fascinating prisoners I ever met.
I would come to hear his story many times, so I may as well tell it here as he told it to me.
Heep was born in Macclesfield, near Manchester, in 1852. His family was respectable and belonged to the working class. His father died when Heep was about five, and some years later his mother married a local carpenter.
As a boy, Heep was full of energy and trouble.
“I can't remember a time when I wasn't getting into some kind of mischief,” he once told me. “Trouble came to me as naturally as water comes to a duck.”
His father had never been particularly strict with him, but his stepfather was completely different.
“He was a hard man,” Heep said. “Every little thing I did wrong earned me a beating.”
His mother did little to help matters. Before Heep was even twelve, she became so suspicious of her husband that she sent the boy to follow him and watch him visit a woman she was jealous of.
Heep was naturally intelligent. He was good-looking, polite when he chose to be, and a quick learner.
With proper guidance, he might have made something of himself.
Instead, his stubbornness and violent temper became worse as he grew older.
He soon discovered another way to get what he wanted.
“If I threatened to hurt myself, my mother usually gave in,” he explained.
But his stepfather refused to be controlled.
“Once I even cut myself badly enough to bleed,” Heep said. “I thought that would frighten him into giving me what I wanted.”
His stepfather only beat him again.
By the time Heep was fifteen, his family could no longer control him.
His father had him committed to the county asylum for the insane.
He remained there for about a year and a half.
“Heep caused so much trouble that the attendants were almost relieved when I escaped,” he told me.
He made his way to Liverpool, where he found work with a dealer in old books, antiques, and curiosities.
At first, his employer trusted him completely.
“He trusted me enough to leave the shop in my hands whenever he was away.”
That trust did not last.
Heep began stealing books and other valuable objects from the shop and selling them to customers.
He got away with it for some time.
Then one day he took an old book to a woman who owned a secondhand shop. He had sold her several things before.
“How much do you want for it?” she asked.
“One pound,” Heep replied.
The woman examined the book carefully.
She quickly realized that it was not an ordinary book. It was an ancient Greek manuscript with beautiful illustrations, worth many times what Heep was asking.
She immediately suspected that he had stolen it.
“All right,” she said calmly. “Come back tomorrow evening and I'll give you the money.”
Heep agreed and left.
The next evening, when he returned, his employer was waiting for him.
The man confronted him about the theft.
Heep's employer did not call the police. He simply told him how deeply he had betrayed his trust and dismissed him from the job.
By then, Heep had already developed several destructive habits.
The worst was drinking.
“When I was sober, I could think normally,” he said. “But once I started drinking, my common sense disappeared completely.”
Alcohol turned him into a different man.
He would become violent, reckless, and ready to fight anyone who crossed him.
Until then, he had generally stolen only when he wanted money for his bad habits.
Not long after losing his job, the police found him behaving wildly while drunk.
A magistrate decided that he was dangerous and sent him to Raynell Lunatic Asylum.
Heep quickly became a nuisance there.
He was constantly getting into trouble, playing tricks, and breaking rules.
Yet there was another side to him.
“If they gave me work I liked, I was perfectly useful,” he said.
He especially enjoyed gardening.
He also discovered a talent for painting.
He became remarkably good at copying pictures and prints. He could make them larger or smaller and reproduce them in oils or watercolors.
Before long, he was also doing decorative painting and theatrical scenery.
He even studied music and several other subjects.
Despite all this ability, Heep remained determined to escape.
Eventually he succeeded.
He hid until nightfall, but there was a problem. He was still wearing the asylum uniform.
“If anyone saw me, they'd know exactly where I'd come from.”
So he returned to the asylum.
He climbed through a window into the tailor's shop, which stood in an isolated building, and changed into one of the attendants' suits.
Now he believed he could travel without being recognized.
He set off across the countryside.
He had gone about twenty miles when he passed through a small town.
A policeman there had just received word that a patient had escaped from Raynell.
The officer looked at Heep suspiciously.
“Stop. What are you doing here?”
Heep was arrested.
The asylum sent someone to identify him, and he was taken back.
He was then prosecuted for stealing the attendant's clothes.
The clothes were still on him when he was arrested.
He was convicted and sentenced to five years of penal servitude.
He served the sentence at Chatham.
But when his prison term ended, he was not released.
Instead, guards took him straight back to the asylum.
There was a strange provision in English law at the time.
If someone escaped from a lunatic asylum and remained free for fourteen days, the authorities could no longer arrest him unless he committed another obvious act of insanity.
Heep knew this.
So he escaped again.
This time he found work on a farm and managed to stay there for thirteen days.
“I was counting the hours,” he said. “One more day, and they couldn't legally take me back.”
Then, just when he thought he had finally won, two asylum attendants appeared.
They seized him and carried him back.
That broke whatever patience he had left.
He felt that the whole system was treating him with terrible injustice, and he became more desperate and violent.
The doctor ordered that his head be shaved and blistered as punishment.
They had already tried a straitjacket and other restraints, but none of them had controlled him.
The night watchman was ordered to keep a close eye on him.
Unfortunately for the watchman, Heep was keeping an even closer eye on him.
One night, Heep saw that the guard had fallen asleep.
He quietly went to a small closet window that he had previously weakened.
He pushed his way through it and climbed over a low wall.
Suddenly he was free again.
But he was in terrible condition.
It was a cold November night. Rain was pouring down, and Heep was completely naked. His head had been shaved, and his skin was covered with the blisters caused by the doctor's treatment.
Still, he was free.
He walked through the night, soaked and freezing.
Just before daylight, he came to a cemetery.
“I thought the living had treated me so badly that perhaps the dead would give me shelter.”
Under the church entrance was a passage leading down to some family burial vaults.
He crept inside and found a place where he could escape the rain.
He was cold enough to shake uncontrollably.
Then, while feeling around in the darkness, his hand touched something soft.
He grabbed it.
It was an old coat, probably left there by the gravedigger and forgotten.
“I can't describe how happy I was,” Heep said. “That old coat felt like a fortune.”
He stayed hidden throughout the day.
That night, he continued walking across the fields.
Along the way, he came across a scarecrow.
He looked at the scarecrow, then at himself.
He took the scarecrow's old hat and trousers.
“For the first time in days, I looked almost human again.”
He was still desperately hungry, but being dressed made him feel strangely happy.
After walking several more miles, he approached a laborer's cottage.
He knocked on the door.
“Could you spare me something to eat?”
The people inside gave him food.
They also gave him a pair of old boots.
Nobody asked many questions.
In England, poorly dressed travelers and wandering laborers were common enough that his appearance did not immediately arouse suspicion.
For the first time in years, Heep felt truly free.
He found odd jobs on farms and worked whenever he could.
He was never accused of being lazy.
Eventually he earned enough money to buy decent clothes.
Then he applied for work with a house painter.
He had never actually worked as a painter before.
The master looked at him and decided to give him a chance.
But after half a day, the man saw how little Heep knew.
“You don't know the first thing about painting.”
Heep was dismissed and paid for half a day's work.
But he had learned something from the experience.
He tried another job.
Then another.
After being dismissed from about six different places, he had learned enough to become a competent painter.
Once he had the skill, he could usually keep a job as long as two things did not interfere: alcohol and his temper.
The moment a boss criticized him, Heep could explode.
And if he suspected that the employer had somehow discovered his prison record, he would leave immediately.
One day he was working with another painter inside the home of a wealthy gentleman near Bradford.
During the work, his companion made a remark that caused Heep to think the man knew about his past.
Heep immediately became suspicious.
He stopped working and went to a nearby public house.
He spent the rest of the day drinking.
By midnight, he was extremely drunk.
As he walked back toward his lodging, another thought entered his mind.
He remembered all the valuable things he had seen inside the gentleman's house.
“If I went back, I could take some of them,” he thought.
Once the idea entered his head, he acted on it.
He returned to the house.
He managed to get inside and began collecting valuables.
But he had drunk so much that he could barely think straight.
After gathering a few things, he simply lay down beside them and fell asleep.
The servants discovered him the next morning.
The police were called.
Heep was arrested, tried, and convicted of burglary.
The sentence was seven years of penal servitude.
His earlier five-year prison term had taught him a great deal about prison life.
Heep now considered himself an expert.
“I knew all the tricks,” he said. “I intended to make those seven years as easy as possible.”
Because he had previously been confined in an asylum, he knew another trick.
If he could convince the prison authorities that he was insane, he might be transferred to the prison's section for mentally ill convicts.
He believed life there would be easier.
So he began pretending to be insane.
When that was not enough, he began cutting his arms and legs with a piece of glass.
He cut himself deeply enough to bleed badly.
Eventually the authorities transferred him to the convict lunatic ward.
There, he again made himself useful through work.
But his temper caused problems.
The other prisoners disliked him because he was aggressive, bossy, and constantly looking for arguments.
Eventually he completed his sentence.
He was released on an eighteen-month ticket of leave with only $2.50 to begin his new life.
He went to Liverpool and found work aboard a freight steamer bound for America.
He paid for his passage by working as a painter.
When he arrived in New York, he traveled to Norfolk, Virginia, and found another painting job.
As usual, his temper soon cost him the position.
After drifting around for several months, he suddenly decided to return to England.
“It was probably the worst place I could have chosen,” he later admitted. “A man who has been in prison has little reason to go back there.”
But back in England, he found painting work without much difficulty.
The problem was that he never stayed anywhere very long.
And, as usual, much of what he earned disappeared in public houses.
Eventually Heep decided to visit his old home in Macclesfield.
He quit his job and arrived at the railway station an hour before his train.
To pass the time, he went into a pub.
He drank several glasses of ale.
Soon the alcohol took control of him.
When he finally boarded the train, the compartment was empty.
As the train sped along, Heep became convinced that someone aboard the train intended to murder him.
He panicked.
Then he did something extraordinary.
He jumped out of the moving train.
The train was traveling at nearly forty miles an hour.
Yet somehow he survived.
The train was stopped, and Heep was taken back aboard.
He was not seriously injured, but the railway authorities left him at Wrexham in Denbighshire.
From there, he was sent to the Denbigh Insane Asylum.
Heep disliked the Welsh asylum.
“This place isn't anything like Raynell,” he complained. “There was much more freedom at Raynell.”
So he decided to behave himself.
He became quiet and cooperative.
He caused no trouble.
After watching him for some time, the doctor concluded that Heep had recovered.
He was released.
Not long afterward, Heep found work near Manchester painting a row of new houses.
Plumbers were working there at the same time, installing gas and water pipes.
One Saturday, Heep finished work at noon.
Outside, he met a young plumber who was unemployed.
“I know where we can make a sovereign,” the plumber said. “But I need some tools.”
“What kind of job?”
“A small plumbing job in a butcher's shop. If you help me, we'll split the money.”
Heep agreed.
They needed a few plumbing tools.
Heep went back to the houses where he had been working.
It was Saturday afternoon, so the master plumber and his men had already gone home.
Heep took the tools they needed.
He and the young plumber went to the butcher's shop and finished the job by seven that evening.
Instead of returning the tools immediately, they went to a public house.
They drank and celebrated until midnight.
Then they separated.
Heep took the tools back to his boarding house.
Early Monday morning, he set out to return them before the other workers arrived.
As he approached the building site, he passed a policeman who walked with a slight limp.
Heep glanced back.
The policeman happened to glance back too.
Their eyes met.
The officer became suspicious.
He walked over.
“What have you got in those two baskets?”
“Plumbing tools,” Heep replied.
“Where did you get them?”
Heep explained what had happened.
He even showed the policeman the key to the building where he had taken the tools.
“Come with me,” Heep said. “I'll put everything back. You can wait there until the master arrives.”
The policeman followed him inside.
Heep returned the tools to their proper place.
“There. You can see exactly where I got them. Just stay here for half an hour until the master comes.”
“No,” the policeman replied. “You're coming with me to the station.”
Heep's temper exploded.
“You bloody fool! I've just returned the things!”
The policeman walked toward the door.
Another officer happened to be passing outside.
The first policeman waved him over.
Together, they took Heep to the station.
The young plumber was brought in.
The police persuaded him to make a formal complaint against Heep.
They valued the stolen tools at ten shillings.
Heep immediately realized what was happening.
“They're going to make a criminal case out of this,” he thought.
In a sudden rage, he grabbed the plumber's knife.
Before anyone could stop him, he slashed the man's throat and severed his windpipe.
A doctor was called.
Heep was taken to the prison hospital.
After two or three weeks, he had recovered enough to appear before the magistrate.
But because of the injury to his throat, he could not speak.
He was ordered to stand trial.
Meanwhile, the police discovered his previous prison record.
They learned that he had already served two terms of penal servitude.
That history was used against him.
He was convicted and sentenced to ten years of penal servitude.
When the trial took place, Heep still could not speak.
He also had no lawyer to defend him.
In those days, unlike today, the government did not provide legal representation for prisoners who could not afford a lawyer.
As the magistrate prepared to pronounce sentence, he looked at Heep.
“You've escaped from ordinary asylums before,” he said. “This time, I'll send you somewhere you won't be able to escape.”
He meant prison.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!