The Prisoner’s Road to America

Chapter 40 of 50 · 1,126 words · Free

Once a man was convicted of a crime in England, starting an honest life again was extremely difficult unless he had money, friends, or a useful trade.

Most large employers demanded references covering several years of a man's past. They were especially interested in knowing about his most recent employer.

For a former prisoner, that was often the end of the road.

With nowhere to go and no respectable employer willing to take a chance on him, many discharged prisoners began looking toward America.

“America is our only chance,” they would say.

A considerable number of prisoners were not hardened criminals. Some had broken the law because of terrible temptation or because they had been drunk. Once punished, they genuinely wanted to live honestly.

Such men were not necessarily dangerous citizens.

But there was another kind of prisoner—the professional criminal.

The prisons were full of them.

And outside the prisons, the slums and drinking houses of England were producing thousands more.

The system seemed to keep creating criminals faster than it could imprison them.

Society helped create the conditions that produced crime, then built an enormous police system to control the people caught in that system.

Eventually, some prisoners became experienced enough to understand that they had no future in England.

Then they left.

They crossed the Atlantic carrying years of bitterness, bad habits, and criminal experience with them.

America received many of them.

To me, this constant stream of former criminals arriving on American shores was like a river of moral waste that never stopped flowing.

“Our government has protested against this,” I said.

But the English authorities always denied it.

“They say the British government has nothing to do with sending criminals to America.”

I knew better.

I had spent twenty years in Chatham Prison, and during that time thousands of prisoners asked me about America.

Again and again I heard the same promise.

“When I get out, I'm joining the society and going to America.”

They imagined America as a land of opportunity—a promised land where a poor man could begin again.

And the prisoners were not alone in thinking this way. Poor people throughout Europe dreamed of America in much the same way.

Every English prison displayed brightly colored posters advertising different prisoners' aid societies.

The message was always essentially the same:

“Join us.”

But every prisoner understood what those words really meant.

“Join us, and we'll take you across the Jordan. Leave this miserable land behind and we'll carry you to the land of opportunity on the other side.”

These organizations called themselves prisoners' aid societies.

In my opinion, many of them were little more than elaborate frauds.

Elizabeth Fry had helped make prison assistance fashionable in England, and after that, prisoners' aid societies appeared everywhere.

They grew rapidly because they had two things working in their favor: plenty of money from the public and strong support from the government.

They were rooted in England, but their branches stretched across the Atlantic, and much of their human cargo eventually landed in America.

For a prisoner, the question began almost as soon as he became accustomed to prison life.

“Which society should I join?”

It was easy to predict the answer.

Most would eventually join the Royal Prisoners' Aid Society of London.

The society proudly listed the Queen and numerous famous lords and ladies among its governors.

But what did those distinguished names actually do for discharged prisoners?

As far as I could see, very little.

The real beneficiaries seemed to be the society's officials.

Several clergymen who were related to deans or bishops held highly paid positions as secretaries.

Every year they appeared before fashionable audiences at Exeter Hall and delivered impressive reports about their work.

Their names appeared in church newspapers and society journals alongside the names of royalty and other important people.

The system looked respectable.

But behind the respectable appearance was another purpose.

The British government had found a clever way to remove unwanted prisoners from England without openly admitting that it was doing so.

The Home Secretary controlled the prisons throughout the United Kingdom.

His authority reached into almost every part of the prison system.

He also officially recognized and registered the prisoners' aid societies operating throughout England, Scotland, and Wales.

Then the government offered them a powerful financial incentive.

A prisoner who agreed to join one of these societies upon release received an additional £3 from the government.

Naturally, almost everyone joined.

England was small, and its police system was closely connected.

The Home Secretary stood at the top of that system.

If a former prisoner was later arrested and convicted again, the authorities could easily identify him.

The Home Secretary would then inform the society that had taken responsibility for him when he was released.

This was extremely embarrassing for the society.

The organizations desperately wanted to show that they were reforming prisoners.

At their annual meetings, they wanted impressive statistics.

“Look how many men we have saved!”

“Look how many of them have become honest!”

But they could only count the men they heard nothing bad about.

If a man disappeared and was never reported as a repeat offender, they could proudly list him as a success.

And what better way could a society guarantee that a man would disappear?

Send him out of England.

The societies collected subscriptions from the public, but most of that money went toward salaries and office expenses.

The actual help given to a discharged prisoner was very limited.

The society received the government's extra £3, and that was essentially the financial assistance attached to the prisoner.

The London societies had also made arrangements with the Netherlands Line and the Wilson Line of steamships.

For £2 10s., these companies would take the “workingmen” whom the societies sent to them.

I spoke with thousands of prisoners who had joined these societies.

Most told me the same thing.

“I'm going to America.”

I also met dozens of men who had joined but never managed to leave England.

Some were arrested again and sent back to Chatham.

During my twenty years there, I spoke with several thousand men who joined the societies and announced that they were going to America.

Many disappeared from England afterward.

I never heard of them again.

I also knew scores of men who passed through the hands of the society agents, only to be arrested and convicted again later.

So I had seen the system from both sides.

I had watched men disappear across the Atlantic under the protection of these organizations.

I had also watched others return to prison.

For that reason, I believed I knew exactly what was happening.

England was quietly getting rid of many of its discharged criminals.

And America was receiving them.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!