← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 20 · The Real Story of Black Friday

The Real Story of Black Friday

Chapter 20 of 90 · 3,690 words · Free

In 1869, America had produced far more crops than it needed. Business leaders believed the surplus should be exported, especially grain and cotton.

The problem was gold.

The government had been selling gold from the Treasury, which kept its price relatively low. Many bankers and merchants argued that the government should stop selling gold. If gold became more expensive, American crops would become cheaper to foreign buyers, encouraging exports.

The Treasury eventually agreed to suspend gold sales.

Jay Gould and his associates immediately saw an opportunity.

They began buying gold in large quantities.

Of course, they did it for the most patriotic reason imaginable.

At least, that was the story.

For several months, Gould accumulated gold at prices between 135 and 140. This became the foundation of what would later explode into the infamous Black Friday panic.

But the man who turned the situation into a frenzy was James Fisk Jr.

Fisk jumped into the operation on Thursday, the day before the crash.

He became obsessed with driving gold higher.

Early Friday morning, he ordered his brokers, William Belden and Albert Speyer, to buy huge amounts.

Gold began shooting upward.

The original group behind the operation included Jay Gould, Arthur Kimber of Stern Brothers in London, and W. S. Woodward, who had previously been involved in a famous stock corner.

Kimber and Woodward eventually sold their interests to Gould.

From then on, Gould controlled the operation.

Their headquarters were on Broad Street, where the Drexel Building would later stand.

As the excitement in Wall Street grew, I sent a telegram to Secretary Boutwell and another to President Grant.

I told them exactly what was happening and urged the government to sell gold immediately.

I also persuaded General Butterfield, the New York Sub-Treasurer, and Moses H. Grinnell, the Collector of the Port, to send similar warnings.

The government acted.

An order was issued to sell $5 million in gold.

The psychological effect was immediate.

People who had been holding gold became terrified.

They rushed to sell.

The price collapsed from 160 to 132 in less than two hours.

The panic on the way down was every bit as wild as the excitement on the way up.

Meanwhile, Fisk had given Albert Speyer an extraordinary verbal order.

Buy.

Buy a million dollars at a time.

Buy everything you can get at 160.

Speyer obeyed.

He kept bidding 160 for million-dollar lots even while gold was being sold elsewhere at 140, 145, 147, and 150.

Then the price fell to 135.

Speyer was still bidding 160.

It was one of the strangest spectacles Wall Street had ever seen.

Fisk later denied giving Speyer those orders.

Because the instructions had been given verbally, there was little legal evidence against him.

Speyer & Belden collapsed under the enormous losses.

One famous firm sold Speyer several million-dollar lots and immediately bought them back at 140.

They were happy with a 20 percent profit.

But as soon as they finished buying, gold dropped to 132.

Then Speyer failed.

That firm failed too.

Before the day was over, roughly half the members of the Gold Room were in serious trouble.

The situation became so complicated that the Gold Bank could no longer clear the transactions.

The governing committee of the Gold Room met urgently.

They decided to suspend gold trading for a week.

The idea was to give everyone time to settle their private disputes and figure out who owed what.

The Gold Bank suspended business as well.

While Speyer continued buying at 160, the clique was selling everything it could at prices roughly ten points lower.

At the same time, they were secretly negotiating settlements with traders who had been betting on falling prices.

The entire market had become a giant paper game.

The major speculators suffered enormous losses on paper, but they found ways to avoid carrying much of the damage themselves.

Gould's losses were estimated at more than $4 million.

Fisk's losses were about the same.

But Fisk simply refused to honor many of the contracts made in his name.

Other people were left carrying the losses he should have paid.

Importing merchants suffered particularly badly.

Many had to buy gold at extremely high prices to cover their obligations.

The suspension of the Gold Board caused a wave of failures.

For the next sixty days, people negotiated private settlements, often accepting only a portion of what they were originally owed.

When Fisk heard that Boutwell had ordered the government to sell gold, he reportedly exclaimed:

“This will knock the spots out of phantom gold and send me and the others where the woodbine twineth.”

Once the Gold Board and Gold Bank suspended operations and the failures began pouring in, Wall Street seemed to descend into complete chaos.

Nobody knew exactly where he stood.

Nobody knew who would pay.

Nobody knew who would fail.

Nobody could even calculate his final profit or loss.

The Gold Room was packed almost beyond breathing room.

The scene looked like a madhouse.

Late that afternoon, an angry crowd gathered outside the offices of Smith, Gould & Martin.

People shouted threats against the men inside.

The police had to be called in to protect them.

The gold boom had also attracted many Jewish traders to Wall Street.

One of them had taken a huge position in gold.

When the price collapsed from 160 to 140, he fainted.

Someone brought water and tried to revive him.

Eventually he opened his eyes.

His first question was:

“What ish the prish now?”

He was told the price had fallen even further.

He closed his eyes and fainted again.

He was eventually carried out of the Gold Room.

He left Wall Street sick, ruined, and considerably wiser.

He later went into the old-clothes business on the East Side.

That is the short version of Black Friday.

But the real story behind the conspiracy is even more remarkable.

The plot to force gold prices higher was carefully planned.

The conspirators understood that the government might ruin their scheme simply by selling gold.

So they needed to control the people who controlled the Treasury.

And, above all, they needed to influence President Grant.

James Fisk became the public face of the operation.

He had started life as a peddler in New England, following the same trade as his father.

A few years before the gold conspiracy, he appeared in Wall Street as one of Daniel Drew's trusted men.

Fisk soon proved to be too clever for some of the people around Drew.

He was politely encouraged to leave.

Fisk then opened his own office with William Belden.

The firm was called Fisk & Belden.

It did not last long.

They could not find bankers willing to provide the financing they needed, so the firm eventually closed.

But Fisk's career was far from over.

He remained useful to Daniel Drew, who continued to support him.

Soon afterward, Fisk was elected to the board of the Erie Railroad.

Ironically, Drew, who had helped him get there, was left outside.

It was an early example of Fisk's ability to use his friends to advance himself.

After Fisk joined the Erie board, forty thousand new shares were issued.

The same machinery was soon used in attempts to take control of other railroads.

Fisk quickly acquired a reputation as a financial genius.

People began calling him the “Prince of Erie.”

When he first arrived on Wall Street, he had almost no money.

Yet after the Erie stock issue, his apparent wealth grew rapidly.

People joked that he owned railroads, steamboats, an opera house, a bench full of judges, an army of lawyers, and a whole company of ballet dancers.

But Fisk was not really the mastermind.

That role belonged to Jay Gould.

Gould was the man behind the curtain.

He controlled the Erie operation and the gold operation alike.

Fisk was the colorful public performer.

Gould pulled the strings.

He knew how to use lawyers, judges, courts, politicians, and legislators.

Fisk received much of the public credit.

Gould quietly handled the machinery behind the scenes.

Erie was particularly valuable because it could be turned into cash whenever Gould needed money.

If he needed funds to buy another railroad, influence a legislature, or win a legal battle, he could issue hundreds of thousands of convertible bonds and turn them into Erie shares.

That gave him an almost unlimited source of financing.

And he intended to use that financial power to support the gold corner.

At the time, New York held no more than about $25 million in gold.

The federal government held less than $100 million.

About one-quarter of the government's gold was tied up in special deposits represented by gold certificates.

Some of those certificates were held by banks.

Others circulated throughout the country.

The Treasury had been selling about $1 million in gold each month.

That policy naturally kept the price from rising too far.

But the bankers and merchants were now arguing that the policy was hurting American exports.

They wanted the government to stop selling gold.

Gould and his associates wanted something more.

They wanted to make absolutely certain that the government would not change its mind.

President Grant was cautious.

So the conspirators decided they needed to persuade him that stopping gold sales was essential to the nation's economic survival.

Their plan was simple.

Convince Grant that selling gold would destroy American business.

Get him to order Boutwell not to sell gold without his approval.

Then make sure Grant could not easily reverse himself.

From a patriotic standpoint, the scheme was almost unbelievable.

The conspirators wanted to use the President's authority to help create a private corner in gold.

They needed Grant out of the way at the critical moment.

Fortunately, they managed to accomplish this without physical violence.

Their first major opportunity came during a trip to Boston.

Jim Fisk arranged for Grant to join a party traveling to Patrick Sarsfield Gilmore's great Peace Jubilee.

There was a champagne dinner aboard the Boston boat.

Several men with strong opinions about finance were present.

Soon the conversation turned to American exports and the government's gold policy.

Grant listened carefully.

He had not yet decided that stopping gold sales was the right thing to do.

Gould noticed his uncertainty.

According to Gould's later testimony, Grant essentially said that there was something artificial about the country's prosperity and that the bubble might eventually have to be punctured.

Then Grant asked Gould what he thought.

Gould immediately delivered the argument the conspirators wanted Grant to hear.

He claimed that selling gold would create terrible economic distress.

Factories would close.

Workers would strike.

Businesses would fail.

The country might even approach civil war.

Instead, Gould argued, the government should allow gold to find its “commercial level.”

He even suggested that the government should encourage gold to rise during the fall.

That was quite a statement from the man secretly trying to push gold toward 200.

Gould presented his private speculation as a patriotic economic policy.

It was a remarkably effective performance.

Around this time, H. H. Van Dyck, the Assistant Secretary of the Treasury in New York, resigned.

Gould wanted to control his replacement.

The right man could give him influence inside the Treasury at exactly the moment he needed it.

Abel R. Corbin became useful to him.

Corbin was experienced in business and politics.

He had worked as a Washington lobbyist.

He understood finance and politics and was an excellent speaker.

More importantly, Corbin's wife was the sister of President Grant's wife.

That gave Corbin unusually easy access to the President.

Gould and Corbin approached Robert B. Catherwood, who was married to Corbin's stepdaughter.

They encouraged him to accept the Assistant-Treasury position.

They told him he could make a great deal of money legally once he had the job.

Catherwood later testified that his idea of “legitimate” business was different from theirs.

He refused.

The position eventually went to General Daniel Butterfield.

Butterfield accepted the appointment.

Gould considered this another important piece of his plan.

Corbin now had a Treasury official he believed he could influence.

And Corbin had a direct connection to Grant.

Gould later described Corbin as a clever man who immediately understood the economic argument.

Corbin believed the government should do everything it could to encourage exports and help American farmers.

He also wanted Gould to explain his views directly to Grant.

Corbin eventually obtained an assurance from Grant that Boutwell was not to sell gold without consulting him.

At one meeting in Grant's house, Grant even said that when Boutwell had once ordered gold sold, he had heard about it and countermanded the order.

Only after hearing this directly from Grant did Gould believe his plan was secure.

The bankers and merchants were on his side.

The Sub-Treasury appeared to be under control.

And the President had apparently restricted Boutwell's freedom to sell gold.

But Gould still had one problem.

Grant was not actually part of the conspiracy.

If circumstances changed, he might change his mind.

So the conspirators needed to keep him away from Washington.

After the Boston Peace Jubilee, they spent the summer developing the next stage of the plan.

In August, Fisk went to Newport, where Grant was staying.

Fisk brought a letter from Gould.

The letter described hundreds of ships carrying grain toward Liverpool.

Fisk argued that if gold remained at its current price, American farmers would have trouble exporting their crops.

He tried to convince Grant that selling gold would destroy the country.

Grant agreed to meet with Boutwell to discuss the matter.

The conspirators then surrounded the President with people who repeated the same economic arguments.

Again and again, Grant heard that America desperately needed higher gold prices and greater exports.

Eventually, he began to believe that almost everyone agreed with this position.

By early September, Gould thought the President had been persuaded.

He bought $1.5 million in gold for Corbin at 132½.

Gould was still nervous.

He had heard that some traders who were betting against gold were planning to give Boutwell a dinner.

Then Corbin assured him that Grant had instructed Boutwell not to sell gold without consulting him.

Gould felt ready.

Almost everything was in place.

There was only one final problem.

Grant had to be physically removed from the scene.

The conspirators persuaded him to visit a small Pennsylvania town called Little Washington.

They appealed to his feelings by arranging the trip around a visit to an old friend.

The town had little telegraphic communication.

Transportation was inconvenient.

It was the perfect place to keep the President isolated for several days.

Around the time Grant left for Little Washington, Fisk bought seven or eight million dollars' worth of gold.

Gould told him:

“Everything is fixed. Butterfield is all right. Corbin has Butterfield all right. Corbin has Grant fixed all right.”

Then Gould went even further.

He suggested that everyone was financially involved in the scheme.

It was an astonishing accusation.

The men were using Grant's name and influence to build a gold corner, and then implying that Grant himself was secretly involved.

They also tried to involve members of Grant's family.

Through Corbin, Gould and Fisk claimed that Mrs. Grant had an interest in the gold operation.

They also claimed that $500,000 of gold had been purchased for her and another $500,000 for Grant's private secretary, General Horace Porter.

Fisk later described a conversation with Corbin in which Corbin claimed that he had sent $25,000 to Washington connected with Mrs. Grant's supposed profits.

Fisk wanted proof.

Corbin could not produce it.

But he repeatedly assured Fisk that everything was legitimate.

Fisk believed him.

Later, investigators tried to determine whether a package containing $25,000 had actually been sent to Mrs. Grant through Adams Express.

The evidence could not settle the question.

The written amount might have been $25,000.

It might have been only $250.

But the purpose of the conspiracy was clear.

The conspirators wanted to create some connection between the President's family and the gold operation.

If they could do that, they could use the President's influence more effectively.

But the plan ultimately failed.

As the Garfield Investigating Committee later concluded, the attempt to compromise President Grant and his family failed completely.

Fisk's own impatience helped destroy it.

He was so anxious to make sure that Grant would not interfere that he pushed Corbin to write the President a letter telling him to stand firm and never allow the Treasury to sell gold.

The letter was delivered to Grant by a special messenger who rode twenty-eight miles on horseback from Pittsburgh.

Grant read it.

His suspicions immediately awakened.

He simply told the messenger:

“It is satisfactory. There is no answer.”

Grant had begun to understand what was happening.

He asked Mrs. Grant to write to Mrs. Corbin.

She told her to make Corbin withdraw immediately from the men who were trying to manipulate the President.

Corbin obeyed.

He was frightened and deeply embarrassed.

But even then, his greed remained strong.

As he prepared to break with Gould, he asked Gould for his share of the profits.

Gould agreed to give him $100,000 immediately and promised to settle the rest later.

That was the end of the attempt to control Grant.

The President quickly returned to Washington.

Meanwhile, Wall Street was approaching the final act.

The conspirators had tried to keep their influence over Assistant Secretary Butterfield as secret as possible.

But Butterfield did not have as much power over events as they had hoped.

Fisk later boasted that they did not need to tap the government's telegraph wires.

“All we had to do was tap Butterfield.”

It was probably more boast than fact.

By Wednesday, September 22, two days before Black Friday, the clique controlled several million dollars more gold than existed in New York outside the Sub-Treasury.

Belden bought about $8 million.

Smith, Gould, Martin & Co. were also buying heavily.

The conspirators held a secret meeting at William Heath & Co.'s office on Broad Street.

They believed they had enough gold to push the price to 200.

Their plan was to refuse to lend out the gold and force traders who had bet on falling prices to buy at whatever price they demanded.

But there was a serious problem.

They were holding enormous contracts.

At some point, all those contracts would have to be settled.

On Thursday morning, another secret meeting took place at Belden & Co.'s Broadway office.

Gould, Fisk, Henry N. Smith, and William Belden attended.

The details remained secret.

But afterward, Belden ordered his clerk to keep gold at 144.

That day alone, Belden bought roughly $20 million in gold.

The price opened around 141½ and closed around 143½.

That evening, the leaders met again.

Their biggest problem was now obvious.

They had contracts involving more than $100 million in gold.

Fisk estimated that the short interest was around $250 million.

Yet the entire city held only about $25 million in physical gold.

The difference was enormous.

If they actually completed the corner, they could be trapped by their own success.

Fisk proposed revealing the situation publicly and offering to settle with the short sellers at 150.

The others rejected his idea.

Then came Friday.

Black Friday.

Early that morning, Belden and William Heath had breakfast together at the Fifth Avenue Hotel.

They immediately went to their offices.

Belden confidently announced:

“Gold is going to 200.”

Then he added:

“This will be the last day of the Gold Room.”

His words terrified traders who were betting against gold.

Thousands rushed to cover their positions.

Henry N. Smith later described it simply:

“They came on with a rush to settle.”

Smith was settling contracts at 150, then 145.

At the same time, Albert Speyer, acting for Fisk and Gould, was still bidding 160 for gold in million-dollar lots.

Then the price began to collapse.

By the time gold reached 133, Speyer finally understood the absurdity of what was happening.

Since morning, he had bought $26 million worth of gold at 160.

The market was now nearly thirty points lower.

Around noon, the demand for additional margins became overwhelming.

The entire operation began to break apart.

At Heath's office, the scene was frantic.

An eyewitness later described what happened.

Belden entered the office while people waited outside.

Deputy sheriffs and men who appeared to be deputies arrived and guarded the doors.

After a long wait, Jay Gould suddenly slipped out through a rear door.

He looked around carefully before disappearing through a private passage.

Then Fisk came running out.

He was sweating and shouting.

He initially went in the wrong direction.

Then he realized his mistake and followed Gould through the passage.

Belden came next.

His hair was disheveled.

His eyes were red, as though he had been crying.

He shouted:

“Which way did they go?”

Then he ran after them.

The passage led to Wall Street.

The three men jumped into a carriage and disappeared from the immediate scene.

But they did not escape Wall Street.

They went to the Broad Street office of Smith, Gould & Martin.

An angry crowd had gathered there.

Many people were furious enough that the situation could easily have turned violent.

If Gould, Fisk, or the others had stepped outside, they might have been attacked or even killed.

A small police force surrounded the building.

The men stayed inside until the early hours of the morning.

They spent the night trying to determine how badly they had been hurt.

The more they calculated, the less certain they became.

They could not tell whether they were standing on their heads or their feet.

The Black Friday gold corner was a temporary financial disaster.

But it also taught Wall Street a lasting lesson.

A market can be manipulated for a while.

A corner can create enormous paper profits.

But when the time comes to settle the contracts, the same machinery that created the fortune can turn against the people who built it.

Black Friday showed just how dangerous speculation becomes when enormous borrowed positions, political influence, and artificial scarcity are combined.

The gold corner collapsed.

But the lesson remained.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!