Why Speculators Lose Money
There are plenty of people who enter Wall Street hoping to make money, yet end up losing it year after year. From my experience, the reasons are not mysterious.
Many simply are not suited for the game.
Some know too little. Others think they know too much. Some are too timid, while others are reckless. Some expect disaster everywhere; others are blindly optimistic. Some act too slowly, while others jump too quickly. Some trust everyone, while others trust nobody.
Any one of these weaknesses can cost a man a fortune.
But knowing yourself—and controlling yourself—can overcome many of these natural weaknesses.
There is probably no other business that demands such strict mental discipline as speculation.
A speculator cannot afford to let personal opinions, prejudices, habits, or favorite theories control his decisions. He is risking his own money on future changes in value, so he must remain as calm and impartial as a judge.
The first rule of successful speculation is simple: do not allow your personality to distort your judgment.
Once a man can control that, he may succeed despite his natural weaknesses.
Bad Information Can Be Worse Than No Information
It may sound strange, but information itself can be one of the greatest dangers in speculation.
Naturally, people want to know what they are getting into before they risk their money. The trouble is that many do not stop to ask whether the information they have is complete, reliable, or properly understood.
Sometimes the facts simply cannot be known in advance.
In that situation, a man is taking a guess. Unless experience has taught him that he is unusually good at judging uncertain situations, he would be wiser to stay out.
Many speculators lose because they do not have enough information.
Others lose because the information is false.
Still others have accurate information but do not know how to use it.
A large part of speculative losses can be traced to one of these three mistakes.
Incomplete information is especially dangerous.
Suppose a railroad reports that its gross earnings have increased.
A trader may immediately conclude that the stock should be worth two or three percent more.
But what if the increase in revenue came from some temporary circumstance? What if operating expenses are rising even faster?
The railroad may actually be in worse financial condition despite the impressive headline.
The opposite can happen too.
A financially troubled company may announce that it is going to assess its shareholders.
Investors may panic and rush to sell the stock.
But if the money raised by the assessment will greatly improve the company's facilities or reduce its fixed expenses, the company may actually become much more valuable.
Once investors understand this, the stock can suddenly rise.
Those who sold it short are then forced to buy it back at a loss.
The same thing happens in other ways.
A stock may be heavily bought in New York because London investors are buying large quantities.
Traders may assume that foreign investors have confidence in the company.
But a few days later, the actual deliveries may reveal that insiders connected with the company were quietly unloading their holdings in London because they knew the company's prospects were deteriorating.
The buyers in New York then rush to sell.
Instead of making a profit, they take a loss.
Wall Street produces new examples of this every day.
The basic mistake is always the same: people act on a small piece of fact and fill in the rest with assumptions.
They take a pound of guesswork and an ounce of evidence—and then bet their money on it.
Rumors Are Dangerous Weapons
One of the strangest features of speculation is how easily people will risk large sums based on rumors and supposedly valuable "inside points."
There are always outside traders ready to buy or sell because of some exciting rumor.
Professional operators know this.
So they keep the market supplied with rumors that can lure inexperienced traders into bad positions.
It is difficult to say who deserves more blame—the people who believe these stories without thinking, or the people who deliberately create them.
But there is a third group that also deserves criticism.
These are the people whose business is to spread false information.
Financial news agencies and the morning Wall Street newspapers play an especially important role here.
Their purpose is legitimate enough. Investors need reliable financial news.
But when people pay for information that may influence transactions worth enormous sums, those news organizations have a responsibility to gather and publish their information with extreme care.
Anything less is more than poor journalism.
It can become dishonest and dangerous.
Unfortunately, much of what is presented to the public as financial news deserves exactly that criticism.
Rumors, promotional stories, warnings, and deliberately manufactured false reports can spread rapidly through these channels.
I will not attempt to determine how much of this comes from the speed at which financial news must be gathered, how much comes from careless investigation, and how much comes from less innocent motives.
But one fact is undeniable:
False financial news can cause enormous losses.
And the problem is not limited to outright lies.
Some financial publications regularly promote particular stocks.
They give readers suggestions about what they should buy or sell.
Their editorial opinions may also carry a strong speculative bias.
To experienced Wall Street traders, this looks like a serious abuse of journalism.
Yet many ordinary investors accept such advice as if it were unquestionable truth.
They follow it straight into the hands of professional operators who are waiting to take their money.
Even so, it should be acknowledged that financial news agencies perform a valuable service for Wall Street despite these serious weaknesses.
The hope is that experience will teach them that their businesses would be even more successful if they followed a higher standard of accuracy and honesty.
Never Risk Your Entire Cash Reserve
Another major cause of loss is failing to keep enough cash available when the market moves against you.
Speculators are usually optimistic by nature.
They tend to take risks without making enough provision for bad outcomes.
An inexperienced trader will often put nearly all of his available money into the initial margin.
That is a serious mistake.
If the market moves against him, he may be forced out of the position at exactly the wrong time.
He suffers a loss he may not be able to afford.
A safer rule is to risk no more than half of one's available capital at the beginning of a transaction.
The other half should remain in reserve.
That reserve can protect the trader from being forced out of his position.
It can also allow him to make another purchase or sale at a new price, creating an average position that may eventually become profitable.
Ignoring this rule creates what might be called weak holders.
These traders have barely enough money to support their positions.
Professional room traders know this.
If they can push prices far enough against these weak holders, their margins will be damaged.
The weak holders will then have no choice but to sell.
A wave of forced selling follows, driving prices even lower.
Better margin protection would greatly reduce this danger.
It would weaken the power of bears and market wreckers and eliminate a large part of the losses suffered by outside traders.
Do Not Always Bet on the Same Side
Another group of traders is constantly exposed to loss because they always take the same side of the market.
Wall Street has permanent optimists and permanent pessimists.
Some people are naturally bullish.
Others are naturally bearish.
They remain bullish or bearish regardless of what is actually happening.
Those who follow their temperament instead of the market's conditions will eventually pay a heavy price.
That does not mean a trader can never remain on one side of the market.
When conditions clearly favor rising prices, a skilled bear may still find opportunities by selling into an excessive rise.
Likewise, when conditions clearly favor falling prices, a skilled bull may find opportunities when prices have dropped too far.
But anyone who consistently trades against the general current must be an exceptional operator.
He must be highly experienced, emotionally controlled, and capable of suppressing his natural instincts.
Most importantly, he must have enough money to withstand the pressure and, if necessary, influence the market through sheer financial strength.
Nine out of ten people who try this have none of these advantages.
Consider the gloomy man who sees disaster everywhere.
While the entire country is enjoying prosperity, he is convinced that everything is going to collapse.
Everyone else is buying stocks.
He keeps selling them.
He does not realize that he is looking at the world through his own dark temperament.
He is destroying his fortune without understanding why.
The opposite man is just as dangerous.
He is permanently intoxicated by optimism.
Even when the country has clearly reached the peak of a prosperous period and a general decline in business and asset values is approaching, he continues buying and holding.
Such people do not remain in Wall Street for long.
Their money soon disappears.
Then they leave the market and have plenty of time to think about the foolishness of refusing to recognize the direction in which economic conditions are moving.
Sometimes the Best Trade Is No Trade
There is another, less obvious cause of loss.
Sometimes the market is simply not offering any real opportunity.
The forces pushing prices higher and the forces pushing them lower may be almost perfectly balanced.
Prices barely move.
A trader becomes frustrated.
He keeps changing his positions from one day to the next, accomplishing nothing except generating profits for his broker.
At the end of the month, his statement is full of interest charges and commissions, while his profit column remains empty.
These periods of inactivity can last for weeks or even months.
During such times, the wise speculator stays out.
He keeps his money available and waits until something important happens.
There is no shame in doing nothing.
Sometimes doing nothing is the smartest position a trader can take.
Watch Everything That Can Move the Market
To avoid unnecessary losses, a trader must constantly watch the forces that control prices.
These forces fall into two broad groups.
The first group comes from inside the market itself.
The trader must watch the mood of the market, the position and intentions of powerful groups, the actions of large operators, and whether stocks are heavily borrowed or heavily shorted.
He must also watch unusually active stocks and consider whether their movements could influence the rest of the market.
He should pay attention to stop orders, weakened margins, large groups unloading their holdings, and major short sellers covering their positions.
These internal forces can control the market for a surprisingly long time, even when economic conditions seem to point in the opposite direction.
But understanding them is extremely difficult.
They are hidden, constantly changing, and often revealed only through vague signals.
It takes years of experience and unusual intelligence to understand what these forces are really saying.
A few exceptional traders seem to have an almost instinctive ability to read such signals.
They can weigh tiny changes in market behavior and reach remarkably accurate conclusions.
These traders often pay little attention to outside economic conditions unless those conditions are likely to affect prices immediately.
Their trades are usually short-lived.
They move quickly with the market and change direction as soon as the market changes.
These are among the most intelligent and successful speculators.
But their ability is partly a natural gift.
It cannot simply be copied by someone else.
The World Outside Wall Street Matters Too
The second group of influences comes from outside the market.
And this group is enormous.
Almost anything that affects the country's economic health can eventually affect stock prices.
A serious speculator must watch the crops.
He must understand the condition of manufacturing.
He must follow trade and transportation earnings.
He must watch imports and exports.
He must know how foreign investors are treating American securities.
He must follow the movement of gold and other precious metals.
He must understand the condition of the London and European money markets.
He must watch the New York banks and movements in the currency supply.
He must pay attention to what Congress, state legislatures, and the courts are doing when their decisions could affect investments.
He must watch labor unions, strikes, labor disputes, and political and social developments.
That may seem like an overwhelming list.
But any one of these things can suddenly become the force that controls the stock market.
A serious speculator therefore has to be a close observer of the world around him.
Few people have such a broad range of knowledge.
Most people simply wait for an event to happen and then try to find out what it means.
By that time, someone better informed may already have acted.
It is certainly true that many people speculate successfully without understanding all these forces.
So such knowledge is not absolutely necessary for making money.
But it is enormously valuable.
The person who understands these conditions can act with greater intelligence, confidence, and speed than the person who does not.
For anyone who wants to anticipate changes rather than merely react to them, a broad understanding of the forces that create and destroy value is essential.
But even that is not enough.
Knowing the facts is one thing.
Knowing what those facts mean is another.
Knowing how to turn that understanding into a profitable trade is something else again.
A trader can fail at any one of these stages—and any one failure can be enough to destroy him.
What Makes a Great Speculator?
So what does it take to become a truly complete speculator?
The answer is demanding.
A great speculator must possess exceptional abilities.
He must constantly observe what is happening in the world.
He must understand the signals coming from the stock market.
His judgment must be sound not only about present conditions but also about the direction in which those conditions are likely to move.
And when the unexpected happens, he must have the courage and self-control to face it without panic.
A man who possesses all these qualities in the highest degree deserves to be called the King of Speculators.
Everyone else must be judged by how closely he comes to that standard.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!