The Thief Who Stole from a Thief

Chapter 42 of 50 · 2,135 words · Free

Foster’s four years in Chicago had changed him.

He had become sharper, more confident, and much better at deceiving people. Unfortunately, his cleverness had not made him any more honest.

During the years we worked together, he told me many stories about his life. One of them showed exactly what kind of world he had entered after leaving prison.

When Foster finished his first prison sentence in England, he joined the Christian Aid Society in London.

The society’s secretary, Mr. Whitely, quickly arranged for him to be sent overseas.

In Whitely’s words, he was simply being “sent to sea.”

Thousands of former prisoners were handled in the same way.

Eventually, Foster arrived in New York.

He had no money and no real plan. But he had heard a great deal about Chicago, so he decided to go there.

He had barely arrived when he ran into an old friend.

The man’s name was Turtle.

Foster knew him from his old criminal days. Turtle had once been his partner in burglary and had also spent time in a London prison.

“What are you doing here?” Turtle asked, delighted to see him.

“I’ve just arrived,” Foster replied. “I’m completely broke.”

Turtle laughed.

“Then we’ll fix that.”

Foster soon discovered that Turtle was doing very well.

He wore an expensive diamond ring and a large diamond pin. He also carried a thick roll of banknotes.

Foster stared at him.

“You certainly seem to have done well for yourself.”

“I have,” Turtle said. “Come with me.”

He took Foster directly to a tailor.

“Get him whatever he needs,” Turtle ordered.

Within a short time, Foster had a completely new wardrobe.

Then Turtle handed him $250.

“Here. Spend this.”

Foster looked at the money in surprise.

“You’re giving me two hundred and fifty dollars just for spending money?”

“Why not?”

The next day Foster was ready to return to his old profession.

“I’m prepared to do a burglary,” he told Turtle.

Turtle immediately shook his head.

“No.”

“No?”

“We don’t do that anymore.”

Foster looked puzzled.

“Then what do you do?”

“We play the honest game.”

Foster laughed.

“Honest?”

“Yes,” Turtle said. “And it pays much better.”

Foster soon discovered what Turtle meant.

Turtle ran a private investigation office in Chicago.

Two city detectives were secretly working with him.

Whenever the police encountered a case that offered a chance to make money, the detectives brought it to Turtle.

Inside that office, schemes of every kind were planned.

Some involved criminals.

Others involved businessmen.

Some involved the police themselves.

Turtle seemed to know everyone who mattered.

He had connections with magistrates, police officers, politicians, and criminal gangs.

His influence reached deep into City Hall.

Foster soon became part of the operation.

Turtle introduced him to his associates and treated him almost like a partner.

With two corrupt detectives, Turtle, and Foster working together, they formed a remarkably effective criminal organization.

Foster later told me that Chicago had shown him a side of society that most respectable people never saw.

One story in particular stayed with me.

One day, a man from Tennessee appeared at police headquarters.

He looked frightened.

“I’ve been robbed,” he said.

“How much?” one of the detectives asked.

“Twenty thousand dollars.”

The detectives exchanged a quick glance.

Twenty thousand dollars was a lot of money.

“Where were you robbed?”

“In a crowd.”

The man showed them his coat.

“My pocket was cut open. Someone took the money.”

One of the detectives examined the coat carefully.

Something about the story seemed wrong.

The pocket had been cut from the inside.

A normal pickpocket would have cut into the pocket from the outside.

The detectives immediately suspected that the man was hiding something.

But instead of investigating him honestly, they saw an opportunity.

“If this man really has twenty thousand dollars somewhere,” one of them whispered, “we should find out where it is.”

The detectives took the man away from police headquarters.

They brought him to the Sherman House Hotel.

The man wanted to leave Chicago immediately.

But the detectives persuaded him to stay.

“We may be able to catch the people who robbed you,” they told him.

He agreed to wait.

The first day passed.

Then another.

The detectives kept asking questions.

The man insisted that the money belonged to him.

They still did not believe him.

“He’s hiding something,” they decided.

That afternoon, one of Turtle’s men secretly rented a room in the same hotel.

When nobody was watching, he entered the Tennessee man’s room.

He hid several burglar’s tools under the mattress.

Then he placed more tools inside the man’s carpetbag.

The trap was ready.

Later, the detectives took the man for a walk along Clark Street.

Turtle and one of his men appeared at exactly the right moment.

They greeted the detectives as if they were old friends.

“Are you arresting this gentleman?” Turtle asked.

“He’s a wealthy man from the South,” one detective replied.

Turtle suddenly laughed.

“Wealthy? I know this fellow. He’s an old burglar.”

The Tennessee man stared at him.

“That’s a lie!”

Turtle ignored him.

“Search his house,” he told the detectives. “You’ll find stolen property there.”

Then he added:

“Bring him to my office. I can even show you his photograph.”

The detectives suddenly became serious.

“We may have to arrest you,” one of them told the Tennessee man.

The man became nervous.

“Why? I haven’t done anything.”

“We’ll see about that.”

They arrested him.

Then they announced that they were going to search his hotel room.

The frightened man had no idea that the entire thing had been arranged in advance.

When they searched the room, they found the burglar’s tools exactly where they had planted them.

The man went pale.

“What are those doing there?”

The detectives acted shocked.

“So you really are a burglar.”

“No! Those aren't mine!”

They took him to Turtle’s office.

There, they threatened him with a long prison sentence.

“You could get ten years for possessing those tools,” one of them told him.

The man was terrified.

They searched his clothes.

They found no cash.

But one detective discovered something else.

It was a receipt for a registered letter.

The letter had been mailed from Nashville to St. Paul.

Turtle immediately understood that this might be where the missing twenty thousand dollars was hidden.

That night, the Tennessee man was kept under guard.

Turtle caught the first train to St. Paul.

He carried the postal receipt with him.

The next morning, Turtle arrived in St. Paul.

He presented the receipt and collected the registered letter.

It was surprisingly large.

He opened it.

Inside were United States government bonds and cash.

The total value was exactly twenty thousand dollars.

Turtle smiled.

He had found the money.

The four men divided almost all of it among themselves.

They kept only one thousand dollars for their victim.

Back in Chicago, the Tennessee man was taken before a friendly magistrate.

He was charged with possessing burglar’s tools and sent to jail.

He had no idea what had really happened.

The next day, a man came to see him.

“You have two choices,” the man said.

The prisoner looked at him nervously.

“You can take one thousand dollars and leave Chicago on the first train.”

“And the other choice?”

“Stay here and face a sentence of ten years for possessing burglar’s tools.”

The man trembled.

He knew he was trapped.

He accepted the thousand dollars.

Within an hour, the necessary papers had been arranged.

That evening, he was on a train heading west.

He never returned to his hometown.

But the strange part of the story was that the man really had committed a crime.

He simply had not been the innocent victim he claimed to be.

So where had the twenty thousand dollars come from?

The answer went back to Tennessee.

There was a widow living in a small Tennessee town.

Her husband had been killed while serving in the Confederate army.

After the war, she was left with almost nothing and had several children to support.

But she was courageous and intelligent.

She opened a small hotel in Nashville.

The business succeeded.

Over the years, she saved money and invested it in new businesses around the city.

Her investments grew.

Eventually, she became financially comfortable.

At about forty years old, she decided to retire from the hotel business and return to the place where she had been born.

The man who later stole her money had been her neighbor.

He had also fought beside her husband during the war.

She trusted him.

One day, she asked him for financial advice.

At first, he made another proposal.

“I want you to marry me,” he told her.

She refused.

After that, he changed his approach.

“You should sell your investments in Nashville,” he told her.

“Why?”

“You could make more money by investing in Knoxville.”

She eventually agreed.

She trusted him enough to appoint him as her agent.

He went to Nashville and sold most of her property.

He received twenty thousand dollars on her behalf.

But once he had the money in his hands, greed took control of him.

He decided to keep it.

It was a cowardly betrayal of a woman who trusted him.

He wrote to her and claimed that he was going to Chicago for a short visit.

He took the twenty thousand dollars with him.

Then he created an elaborate story.

He went to police headquarters and claimed that he had been robbed.

He showed them his coat.

The pocket had been cut open.

But the money was never really stolen.

He had mailed it to himself in a registered letter.

Then he made sure the story appeared in the newspaper.

He sent the newspaper to the widow.

He also wrote her a carefully prepared letter.

He claimed that he was devastated by the loss of her money.

“I’m too ashamed to face you,” he wrote.

“I won’t come back until I can repay everything.”

He claimed he was going to California to work.

“Someday, when I have earned enough money, I’ll return.”

But he never intended to repay her.

He had stolen her money and invented a fake robbery to cover his crime.

Unfortunately for him, he had chosen the wrong city to play such a game.

He had been trying to deceive criminals who were even more experienced than he was.

In the end, the thieves robbed the thief.

Strangely enough, the disaster eventually became a blessing for the widow.

The loss forced her to return to her hotel business.

She rebuilt her life.

Later, she married a man who was known as one of the bravest and finest men in Tennessee.

Years afterward, I became curious about what had happened to her.

When I visited Nashville in 1893, I tried to find her.

I spoke with several people who knew the story.

They confirmed what Foster had told me and explained how her life had turned out.

Meanwhile, Foster continued to prosper in Chicago.

He remained there for four years.

He and Turtle became increasingly powerful.

They developed political connections and formed alliances with corrupt aldermen and magistrates.

Together, they helped rob the city and its citizens while protecting one another from the law.

Foster seemed to believe that he had finally made it.

Then he made one serious mistake.

He decided to return to England.

He wanted to visit his old friends and former criminal associates.

More than anything, he wanted them to see how successful he had become.

He arrived in London pretending to be a wealthy American.

He wore expensive clothes.

He displayed his diamonds.

He carried plenty of money.

But the police recognized him.

They remembered him.

An old charge was brought against him.

He was arrested.

He was put on trial.

He was convicted.

The sentence was ten years in prison.

By then, Foster had accumulated considerable property.

But none of it could save him.

He was sent to Chatham, where he worked under prison conditions that made him feel like a slave.

If he survived his sentence, he would probably leave prison a broken man.

And yet I could almost predict what would happen next.

The moment Foster was released, some prisoner-aid society would probably “send him to sea.”

He would be shipped overseas once again.

And sooner or later, there was a good chance he would find his way back to Chicago.

Perhaps he would return with the same old ambition.

Perhaps he would once again become a powerful man in the city.

And who knows?

He might even end up sitting in City Hall as an alderman.

After all, in a city where corruption had become so deeply rooted, men far worse than Foster had already managed to put “Alderman” after their names.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!