The True Philosopher and the Education of the Rulers
And so, Glaucon, after our argument has taken us a very long way, we have finally brought the true philosopher and the false philosopher into view.
“I do not think,” he said, “that the road could have been any shorter.”
“Probably not,” I replied. “And yet I think we might have understood them both more clearly if we had been able to focus on this one question alone. But there are many other matters still waiting for us, especially if we want to understand how the life of a just man differs from that of an unjust man.”
“What comes next?” he asked.
“The next question is obvious. If philosophers are the people who can grasp what is eternal and unchanging, while those who wander among things that are constantly changing cannot properly be called philosophers, then we must ask which of these two kinds of people should rule our State.”
“And how should we answer that?”
“Surely we should choose those who are best able to protect the laws and institutions of the State.”
“Of course.”
“Then surely there can be no doubt that a guardian who is supposed to protect something must have eyes rather than be blind.”
“Obviously.”
“And what about people who have no clear knowledge of the true nature of things? Their souls contain no clear model of truth. They cannot look, as a painter looks at an original, toward absolute truth and use it as a model. They cannot look toward the higher world and arrange our laws according to what is truly beautiful, good, and just, or preserve that order once it has been established. Are such people not, in a very real sense, blind?”
“They certainly are.”
“Then should we make such people our guardians when there are others who are just as experienced, no less virtuous, and who also understand the true nature of things?”
“There would be no reason to reject such people. If they possess the greatest quality of all, they should certainly be given the highest position, unless they fail in some other important way.”
“Then let us examine whether these qualities can exist together in the same person.”
“By all means.”
“First, as we said at the beginning, we must understand what the nature of a philosopher really is. Once we have done that, I think we shall see that all these qualities can exist together. And then we shall agree that only people in whom they are united should rule the State.”
“What do you mean?”
“Let us begin with this. A truly philosophical mind loves the kind of knowledge that reveals what is eternal and does not change with birth and decay.”
“Agreed.”
“And such a person loves all true reality. He does not reject one part of truth because it is small, ordinary, or less prestigious. He wants to understand the whole of reality.”
“That is true.”
“And if a person is truly what we have described, is there not another quality he must possess?”
“What quality?”
“Truthfulness. He will never willingly accept falsehood into his mind. He will hate lies and love truth.”
“Yes. We can certainly say that about him.”
“‘Can’ is too weak, my friend. We should say that we must say it. Anyone who truly loves something must also love everything that belongs to it or is closely related to it.”
“That is right.”
“And what is more closely related to wisdom than truth?”
“Nothing, I suppose.”
“So the same person cannot genuinely love wisdom and love falsehood.”
“No, he cannot.”
“Then the true lover of knowledge must desire truth from his earliest youth, as far as his nature allows.”
“Certainly.”
“But we know from experience that when a person's desires become very strong in one direction, they tend to become weaker in other directions. It is like a stream whose water has been diverted into another channel.”
“That is true.”
“So a person whose desires are drawn toward knowledge in all its forms will become absorbed in the pleasures of the soul and will have little interest in bodily pleasures—provided that he is a genuine philosopher rather than a pretender.”
“That must be so.”
“Such a person will also be temperate and free from greed. The motives that make other people obsessed with acquiring and spending money will have little influence over him.”
“Very true.”
“There is another quality we must look for in a philosophical nature.”
“What is it?”
“There must be no narrow-mindedness or pettiness hidden inside him. Nothing is more opposed to a generous soul than a petty concern with small things when that soul is always reaching toward the whole of reality, both divine and human.”
“Absolutely.”
“Then how could a person with such a magnificent mind, someone who has contemplated all of time and all existence, think very highly of ordinary human life?”
“He could not.”
“Could such a person regard death as something terrifying?”
“Certainly not.”
“Then cowardice and small-mindedness have no place in genuine philosophy.”
“None at all.”
“And again, can a person whose character is harmonious—someone who is not greedy, petty, boastful, or cowardly—be unjust or cruel in his dealings with others?”
“Impossible.”
“Then even when such a person is young, you will be able to see whether he is just and gentle or rude and antisocial. These are signs that distinguish a philosophical nature from one that is not philosophical.”
“That is true.”
“There is another thing we must observe.”
“What is that?”
“Whether he enjoys learning. No one loves something that causes him constant pain and gives him almost no progress in return.”
“Certainly not.”
“And if he is forgetful and cannot retain what he learns, will he not be like an empty container?”
“Of course.”
“Then after struggling without results, he will eventually hate both himself and the activity that gives him no reward.”
“Yes.”
“So a forgetful soul cannot be counted among genuine philosophers. We must require a good memory.”
“Certainly.”
“And once again, a nature that is disordered and without harmony will naturally tend toward imbalance.”
“Without question.”
“Would you say that truth belongs more naturally with harmony and proportion, or with disorder?”
“With harmony and proportion.”
“Then, besides all the other qualities, we must look for a naturally well-balanced and gracious mind, one that moves toward the true nature of everything.”
“Certainly.”
“Now, do all the qualities we have listed belong together? Are they not all necessary for a soul that is to participate fully and perfectly in true reality?”
“They are absolutely necessary.”
“And would you not say that the highest kind of education must be pursued by a person who has a good memory, learns quickly, is noble and gracious, loves truth and justice, possesses courage and self-control, and whose character is naturally related to wisdom?”
“The god of jealousy himself,” he said, “could find nothing wrong with such a person.”
“And to people like that,” I said, “once they have been perfected through years of education and experience, and to them alone, you would entrust the State.”
At this point Adeimantus interrupted.
“Socrates, no one can really argue with what you have just said. But whenever you speak this way, something strange happens to those of us listening. We feel as though we are being led astray little by little because we are not skilled enough at asking and answering questions. Each small step seems harmless, but they accumulate until, at the end, we discover that we have suffered a complete defeat and all our previous beliefs have been turned upside down.
“It is like playing draughts against someone much more skilled than yourself. Eventually every move is blocked and there is nowhere left to move. We find ourselves in the same position. We have nothing to say in this new game where words are the pieces.
“And yet, Socrates, the strange thing is that we still feel there is something right in what we believe.
“For example, any one of us could say this. Although we may not be able to answer you at every step of your argument, we can look at what actually happens in life. Those who devote themselves to philosophy, especially when they continue studying it into adulthood rather than treating it merely as youthful education, often become strange and useless people. Some even become thoroughly corrupt. And those who are considered the best philosophers often become useless to society precisely because of the education you praise so highly.
“Now, are people who say this wrong?”
“I cannot tell,” he replied. “But I would like to know what you think.”
“Then listen to my answer. I think they are quite right.”
“How can you then defend the claim that cities will never be free from evil until philosophers rule, when we ourselves admit that philosophers are often useless to their cities?”
“That is a question,” I said, “that can only be answered by a story.”
“Yes, Socrates. And I suppose storytelling is not usually your preferred method.”
“I can see that you are enjoying yourself enormously now that you have pushed me into such a difficult argument. But listen to the story, and perhaps you will enjoy it even more, because it will reveal how poor my imagination is.
“The way the best people are treated by their own cities is so terrible that there is almost nothing else on earth to compare with it. So if I am going to defend them, I must use an imaginary picture made from many different things, like those strange creatures artists sometimes paint by combining parts of goats and deer.
“Imagine a ship at sea.
“The captain is taller and stronger than everyone else on board. But he is somewhat deaf and has poor eyesight. His knowledge of navigation is also not much better than theirs.
“The sailors are constantly fighting with one another over who should steer the ship. Every one of them believes he has a right to take the helm, even though none of them has ever properly learned navigation. None of them can say who taught him the art, or when he learned it.
“They even insist that navigation cannot really be taught.
“And whenever someone says otherwise, they are ready to kill him.
“The sailors crowd around the captain. They beg him, flatter him, and demand that he hand over the helm.
“If they fail to persuade him, and someone else is chosen to steer, they either kill that person or throw him overboard.
“Then they drug the captain with alcohol or some other substance, overpower him, take control of the ship, and help themselves to whatever food and drink they can find.
“Of course, that is how they continue their voyage.
“The sailor who is clever enough to help them seize control of the ship, whether through force or persuasion, is praised by them as a great sailor, pilot, or skilled seaman.
“Anyone who does not help them is mocked as useless.
“Yet they have no idea that a real pilot must understand the seasons, the weather, the stars, the winds, and everything else required for navigation. They cannot even imagine that genuine knowledge of navigation must be combined with authority over the ship.
“Now imagine such a ship during a mutiny.
“How do you think the true pilot would be treated by the sailors?
“Would they not call him a useless talker, a star-gazer, someone who knows nothing practical?”
“Of course they would,” Adeimantus said.
“Then you hardly need me to explain the meaning of the story. You already understand what it represents.”
“I certainly do.”
“Then take this story to the man who is surprised that philosophers have no honour in their cities.
“Explain it to him.
“Tell him that he is right when he says that the best philosophers often appear useless to society. But tell him that he should blame the people who refuse to use them, not the philosophers themselves.
“A real pilot should not have to beg the sailors to let him steer the ship. That is not how things naturally work.
“Likewise, the wise should not have to stand outside the doors of rich men begging them for employment.
“The saying that ‘the wise should go to the doors of the rich’ is simply false.
“When a person is sick, whether he is rich or poor, he goes to a doctor.
“And when someone wants to be governed, he should go to the person who actually knows how to govern.
“A capable ruler should not have to beg his subjects to let him rule them.
“Unfortunately, the rulers of the world are often more like the rebellious sailors, while the genuine helmsmen are dismissed as useless dreamers and star-gazers.”
“Exactly,” he said.
“For this reason, philosophy—the noblest pursuit of all—is not likely to be respected by people of this kind.
“And the greatest damage done to philosophy does not come from those who openly oppose her. It often comes from those who claim to be her followers.
“These are the people you mentioned earlier: most of them are corrupt, while the best of them are useless.”
“Yes.”
“And now we have explained why the good ones become useless.”
“True.”
“Then shall we go on and show why the corruption of most philosophers is also unavoidable, and why philosophy itself should not be blamed for that either?”
“By all means.”
“Let us return to the nature of the gentle and noble person.
“You remember that truth was his guide. He followed truth everywhere. If he did not, he was merely pretending and had no real part in philosophy.”
“Yes, that is what we said.”
“And that single quality alone is already very different from the common image people have of philosophers.”
“Certainly.”
“Yet we can defend the true philosopher by saying that his whole nature is directed toward reality.
“He does not remain satisfied with the countless individual things that merely appear to be real. He continues searching.
“His desire does not weaken until he has discovered the true nature of every kind of thing.
“Using the part of his soul that is naturally related to truth, he draws close to reality itself. He comes to understand it, to live according to it, and to grow into a truly intelligent and truthful person.
“Only then does his search finally come to rest.”
“No description could be more accurate,” he said.
“And would a love of falsehood have any place in such a philosopher?”
“None. He would hate falsehood completely.”
“And if truth is leading him, can we reasonably suspect that the group following him will be evil?”
“Impossible.”
“Justice and a healthy mind will belong to that group, and self-control will follow them.”
“Certainly.”
“There is no need for me to list the philosopher's other virtues again. You remember them: courage, greatness of mind, intelligence, and memory.
“You also remember your earlier objection. You said that no one could deny these qualities in theory, but that when we looked at actual people, many who seemed to fit the description were useless, and most were thoroughly corrupt.
“That led us to ask why they were accused of these things.
“And now we have reached the question of why most of them become bad, which naturally brought us back to examining the true philosopher.”
“Exactly.”
“Then our next task is to examine the ways in which a philosophical nature becomes corrupted.
“Why are so many spoiled, while only a few escape corruption?
“I am speaking first about those who become useless but not wicked.
“After that, we will examine the imitators of philosophy—the people who enter a profession that is above their ability and beyond their worth, and who, through their contradictions and failures, bring philosophy and philosophers into universal disgrace.”
“What causes this corruption?” he asked.
“I will try to explain.
“Everyone will agree that a philosophical nature possessing all the qualities we have described is extremely rare.”
“Very rare indeed.”
“And there are countless powerful forces that can destroy such a rare nature.”
“What forces?”
“First, strangely enough, its own virtues.
“Courage, self-control, and the other admirable qualities we have praised can themselves pull a person away from philosophy and destroy the philosophical direction of his soul.”
“That is certainly strange.”
“Then there are the ordinary advantages of life: physical beauty, wealth, strength, social status, powerful friends, and influence in the State.
“You understand the sort of things I mean.”
“I do, but I would like you to explain more precisely.”
“Think of the whole matter in the right way, and you will understand.
“We know that every seed, whether belonging to a plant or an animal, becomes especially vulnerable when it does not receive the food, climate, or soil appropriate to its nature.
“The stronger the seed, the greater the damage caused by an unsuitable environment.
“Bad conditions are a greater enemy to something good than to something mediocre.”
“That is true.”
“So the finest natures can suffer more damage under bad conditions than inferior ones, because the contrast is greater.”
“Certainly.”
“And may we not say, Adeimantus, that the most gifted minds, when badly educated, can become exceptionally bad?
“Do not the greatest crimes and the most destructive forms of evil often come from a powerful nature that has been ruined by bad education, rather than from a weak nature?
“A weak nature is rarely capable of producing either extraordinary good or extraordinary evil.”
“I think you are right.”
“The philosopher is the same.
“He is like a plant that, if properly nourished, naturally grows into great virtue.
“But if he is planted in the wrong soil, he can become the most destructive weed of all, unless some divine power protects him.
“Do you really think, as people often claim, that young people are corrupted mainly by professional Sophists or private teachers?
“Are the public who make this accusation not themselves the greatest Sophists of all?
“Do they not educate everyone—young and old, men and women alike—and shape them according to their own desires?”
“When does this happen?” he asked.
“When they gather together.
“When the whole population sits together in an assembly, a court of law, a theatre, a military camp, or any other public gathering.
“There is a tremendous uproar.
“They praise some things that are said or done and condemn others.
“They exaggerate both their praise and their criticism.
“They shout, clap, and create such a noise that the very place echoes their approval or disapproval.
“Now, do you think a young person's heart can remain unaffected by such a flood of public opinion?
“Can any private teacher prepare him to stand firm against it?
“Or will he simply be swept away?
“Will he not eventually adopt the public's ideas of good and evil?
“Will he not behave as the crowd behaves and become like them?”
“Yes, Socrates. He will have little choice.”
“And there is an even stronger force that we have not yet mentioned.”
“What is it?”
“The threat of confiscation, imprisonment, or death.
“These are the punishments that the public can use when persuasion fails.
“And the public's new Sophists and educators are perfectly willing to use them.”
“They certainly are.”
“Then what other Sophist or private teacher could possibly overcome such an unequal force?”
“None.”
“Exactly.
“Anyone who even attempts such a struggle would be acting foolishly.
“There never has been, and there probably never will be, a human character whose education in virtue comes entirely from private instruction while remaining untouched by public opinion.
“I am speaking only of ordinary human virtue.
“As for anything beyond ordinary human virtue, as the proverb says, that belongs to another level.
“In the present corrupt condition of governments, whatever good survives often survives only through divine power.”
“I agree,” he said.
“Then let me ask you to agree to one more point.
“All those paid teachers whom the public calls Sophists, and whom they imagine are their opponents, actually teach nothing except the opinions of the public.
“They study the opinions of the crowds in their assemblies and then call this knowledge.
“They are like a man who raises a powerful animal.
“He studies its moods and desires.
“He learns when it is dangerous and when it is calm.
“He learns what different sounds it makes and what those sounds mean.
“He learns which noises will soothe it and which will make it angry.
“After observing it for a long time, he becomes extremely skilled at handling it.
“Then he calls this skill ‘wisdom’ and turns it into a system that he teaches to others.
“Yet he has no real understanding of the animal's nature or of why it behaves as it does.
“He simply labels whatever the animal likes ‘good’ and whatever it dislikes ‘bad.’
“He calls one thing honourable and another dishonourable, one thing just and another unjust, entirely according to the animal's preferences.
“He has no deeper explanation.
“He has never understood what justice or nobility truly are, or how greatly they differ from mere public opinion.
“Would you call such a man an impressive educator?”
“Certainly.”
“And how is a person who thinks wisdom consists in understanding the tastes and moods of the crowd any different?
“It makes no difference whether he does this in painting, music, or politics.
“When someone presents his poem, artwork, or political achievement to the public and allows them to judge it, he is forced to give them whatever they praise.
“He must obey what the crowd likes.
“And the explanations they give for their judgments are often ridiculous.
“Have you ever heard them offer a genuinely sound explanation of why something is beautiful or good?”
“No, and I doubt I ever will.”
“Then you see the truth of what I am saying.
“Now consider this.
“Will the crowd ever be persuaded to believe in absolute beauty rather than merely many beautiful things?
“Will they believe that there is one absolute reality behind all the many things that share the same name?”
“Certainly not.”
“Then the crowd cannot possibly be philosophical.”
“Impossible.”
“And therefore philosophers will inevitably be criticized by the crowd.”
“They will.”
“And also by individuals who spend their lives trying to please the crowd.”
“Obviously.”
“Then do you see any way in which the philosopher can remain faithful to his calling throughout his life?
“Remember what we said about him.
“He must be intelligent, have a good memory, possess courage and greatness of mind.”
“Yes.”
“Such a person will probably stand out from childhood.
“If his body is as strong and impressive as his mind, he will be first among his peers in almost everything.”
“Certainly.”
“And as he grows older, his friends and fellow citizens will want to use him for their own purposes.”
“No doubt.”
“They will fall at his feet, ask him for favours, honour him, and flatter him because they want to control the power they know he will eventually possess.”
“That often happens.”
“And what is such a young man likely to do?
“Especially if he comes from a great city, is wealthy and well connected, and is physically impressive?
“Will he not develop enormous ambitions?
“Will he not imagine that he can manage the affairs of Greeks and foreigners alike?
“Will he not fill his head with grand ideas about his own importance and become inflated with pride?”
“Of course he will.”
“Now imagine that, while he is in this condition, someone approaches him gently and tells him that he is foolish, that he lacks understanding, and that genuine understanding can only be acquired through years of hard work.
“Do you think he will listen easily?”
“Not at all.”
“And even if a person of naturally good character or sound judgment has his eyes opened and becomes humbled, allowing philosophy to capture his heart, what will his friends do?
“If they believe they are about to lose the benefits they expected from having such a man as their friend, will they not do everything they can to stop him from following his better nature?
“Will they not use private conspiracies and public accusations to make his teacher powerless?”
“Without a doubt.”
“Then how could such a person ever become a philosopher?”
“He could not.”
“Were we not therefore right when we said that even the very qualities that make someone suited to philosophy can, if he is badly educated, pull him away from philosophy?
“Just as wealth, social position, and the other so-called goods of life can do the same.”
“We were completely right.”
“So this is how the destruction and failure of the people best suited to philosophy comes about.
“They are rare by nature.
“And from such powerful natures come both the greatest harm and the greatest good to cities and individuals, depending on which direction their character is pushed.
“A weak person never accomplishes anything truly great, whether for an individual or for a State.”
“That is certainly true.”
“And so philosophy is left abandoned.
“Her own true children have turned away from her.
“Others who are unworthy of her enter in and dishonour her.
“They then attach to philosophy the accusations people make against her.
“Some philosophers are useless, they say, while most deserve severe punishment.”
“That is certainly what people say.”
“And what else would you expect?
“Imagine weak little people seeing philosophy standing before them like an open sanctuary filled with glorious names and impressive titles.
“They rush into it as prisoners escaping from a jail.
“They are often clever people in their own small trades, but they suddenly abandon those trades and take up philosophy.
“Even though philosophy is in such a miserable condition, she still possesses a dignity that ordinary crafts do not.
“So many imperfect people are attracted to her.
“Their souls are already damaged and distorted by their petty ambitions, just as their bodies may have been distorted by the physical work they perform.”
“Is that not inevitable?”
“Exactly.
“They are like a bald little mechanic who has just escaped from prison and suddenly inherited a fortune.
“He takes a bath, puts on expensive clothes, and dresses himself as a bridegroom preparing to marry his former master's daughter, who has been left poor and abandoned.
“What kind of marriage would come from such a union?”
“Nothing good could come of it.”
“Exactly.
“It would produce something false and illegitimate.
“And when people who are unworthy of education approach philosophy and form a relationship with something far above them, what kind of ideas are likely to come from the union?
“Nothing genuine.
“Only clever arguments designed to sound impressive, but without any real connection to wisdom.”
“Certainly.”
“Then, Adeimantus, the genuine disciples of philosophy will always be few.
“Perhaps one will be a noble and well-educated person who has been driven into exile and therefore remains devoted to philosophy because he is protected from corrupting influences.
“Perhaps another will possess a great soul but be born in a small city whose politics he despises and therefore avoids.
“Perhaps another will be gifted and will leave behind some profession that he has rightly recognized as inferior.
“Perhaps a few are restrained by what our friend Theages called his ‘bridle.’
“Almost everything in Theages' life seemed to push him toward politics, but his poor health kept him away from it.
“And as for my own inner sign, there is hardly any point in mentioning it, because very few people, if any, have ever had such a guide.
“Those few people have tasted how sweet and blessed philosophy can be.
“They have also seen the madness of the crowd.
“They know that politicians are rarely honest, and that there is no reliable champion of justice beside whom they can stand and be saved.
“Such a person is like someone who has fallen among wild animals.
“He refuses to join them in their wickedness.
“But he cannot fight all of them alone.
“So he sees that he would accomplish nothing for the State or his friends.
“He realizes that throwing away his life would achieve nothing.
“Therefore he keeps quiet and goes his own way.
“He is like a man who, during a violent storm of dust and freezing rain, takes shelter behind a wall.
“He sees the rest of humanity behaving wickedly, and he is satisfied if he can live his own life without becoming unjust.
“He wants to leave this world peacefully, with a clear conscience and good hopes.”
“Yes,” he said. “And he will have accomplished something important before he dies.”
“Something important, certainly.
“But not the greatest thing.
“Unless he finds a State suited to his nature.
“In a State suited to him, he would develop much more fully and become a saviour of his country as well as of himself.”
“We have now explained why philosophy has such a bad reputation.
“We have shown that the accusations against her are unjust.
“Is there anything more you want to say on this subject?”
“Nothing more,” he replied. “But I want to know which of the governments that exist today you think is suitable for philosophy.”
“None of them,” I said.
“And that is precisely the accusation I make against them.
“Not one is worthy of a philosophical nature.
“That is why such a nature becomes distorted and alienated.
“Just as a seed planted in foreign soil can lose its natural character because the new environment overwhelms it, philosophy, when placed in the wrong political environment, degenerates into something else.
“But if philosophy ever finds a State that possesses the perfection she herself represents, then everyone will see that philosophy is truly divine, while other political institutions and human characters are merely human.
“And now I know what you are about to ask.
“You are going to ask what such a State would be.”
“No,” he said. “You are mistaken.
“I was going to ask whether it is the State that we ourselves have founded in our discussion, or some other State.”
“Yes,” I replied, “ours in most respects.
“But you may remember that I said earlier that the State would always require a living authority who holds the same conception of the constitution that guided us when we were creating its laws.”
“Yes, you said that.”
“But you did not say it in a very satisfactory way.
“You frightened us with objections that showed how long and difficult the discussion would be.
“And what remains is even more difficult.”
“What remains?”
“We must determine how philosophy can be taught and organized so that it does not destroy the State.
“Every great undertaking involves danger.
“As people say, ‘What is good is difficult.’”
“Still,” he said, “if you clear up this point, the investigation will be complete.”
“I will not be stopped by lack of willingness.
“If I fail, it will be because I lack ability.
“My enthusiasm is obvious enough.
“And listen carefully to what I am about to say.
“I will boldly and openly declare that States must pursue philosophy—but not in the way they do now.
“They must approach it in a completely different spirit.”
“How?”
“At present, philosophy is studied by people who are barely out of childhood.
“They devote only whatever time remains after making money and managing their households.
“Even those who are considered especially philosophical often abandon the subject as soon as they encounter its greatest difficulty—dialectic.
“Later in life, if someone invites them to a philosophical lecture, they may go and listen.
“They make a great fuss about it, as though philosophy were some interesting hobby.
“But they do not consider it their true work.
“Finally, when they become old, most of them disappear from philosophy more completely than Heraclitus' sun, because they never rise again.”
“Then what should they do?”
“Exactly the opposite.
“When they are children and young people, their studies should suit their age.
“While they are growing toward adulthood, their main attention should be given to developing their bodies so that they will later be strong enough to serve philosophy.
“As they grow older and their minds mature, they should devote increasing attention to the education of the soul.
“And when their physical strength begins to decline and they are no longer suited for military or civic duties, they should be free to devote themselves entirely to philosophy.
“They should live happily in this life and, when it ends, crown it with the hope of an equally happy existence beyond it.”
“You are certainly serious about all this, Socrates,” he said.
“I am sure of it.
“But I suspect that most of your listeners will be even more determined to oppose you.
“Thrasymachus most of all.”
“Do not try to start another quarrel between Thrasymachus and me.
“We have recently become friends.
“Indeed, we were never really enemies.
“I will continue trying as hard as I can either to persuade him and others, or at least to do something that may benefit them when they live again and we have this conversation in another world.”
“That sounds like a very distant future.”
“Compared with eternity,” I replied, “it is not distant at all.
“Still, I am not surprised that most people refuse to believe us.
“They have never seen what we are talking about actually exist.
“They have only seen a superficial imitation of philosophy—people arranging words cleverly without any real unity behind them.
“They have never seen a human being whose words and actions are perfectly shaped, as far as human beings can be, according to virtue.
“And they have never seen a city ruled by such a person.
“Do you think they have ever seen such a thing, whether once or many times?”
“No, certainly not.”
“And they have rarely, if ever, heard the kind of free and noble speech we are discussing.
“The kind of speech spoken by people who sincerely pursue truth because they want knowledge itself, while caring very little for clever arguments whose real purpose is merely to win disputes in courts or social gatherings.”
“They are complete strangers to such language,” he said.
“And this is precisely what we predicted.
“It is why we were forced, reluctantly and with some fear, to admit that cities, States, and individuals will never become perfect until one of two things happens.
“Either the small group of philosophers whom we called useless but not corrupt are compelled by circumstances to take responsibility for the State, whether they want to or not, and the State is likewise compelled to obey them.
“Or kings—or, if not kings, their sons and heirs—are inspired by something divine to develop a genuine love of genuine philosophy.
“I see no reason to say that either possibility is impossible.
“If both were truly impossible, then we would deserve to be mocked as dreamers and visionaries.
“Am I not right?”
“Quite right.”
“If, then, at some point in the countless ages of the past, or somewhere in a distant foreign land beyond our knowledge, or at some future time, a perfected philosopher has been or will be compelled by a higher power to take charge of a State, then we are prepared to defend our constitution to the death.
“We can say that it has existed, does exist, and will exist whenever philosophy becomes the ruling power.
“There is nothing impossible about it.
“We admit only that it is extremely difficult.”
“I agree,” he said.
“But you do not think the crowd will agree with us?”
“I doubt it.”
“My friend, do not attack the crowd.
“They may change their minds if you approach them gently rather than aggressively.
“Show them philosophers as they really are.
“Describe their character and profession as we have just described them.
“Then people will see that the philosopher we are talking about is not the person they imagined.
“And once they see him in this new light, their opinion may change.
“Who can hate someone who genuinely loves them?
“And who would envy a person who himself has no envy?
“I will even say this for you: a few people may have that harsh attitude, but the majority do not.”
“I agree.”
“And do you also agree with me that much of the hostility people feel toward philosophy comes from pretenders?
“These people rush into philosophy without being invited.
“They constantly insult the public and criticize everyone.
“They talk about people rather than ideas.
“And nothing is more inappropriate for a philosopher than that.”
“That is certainly true.”
“Adeimantus, a person whose mind is fixed on true reality has no time to look down on ordinary human affairs or fill himself with hatred and envy.
“His attention is always directed toward what is stable and unchanging.
“He sees that these realities do not injure one another and are not injured by one another.
“They exist in an ordered relationship according to reason.
“The philosopher imitates that order.
“As far as possible, he shapes himself according to it.”
“Of course.”
“Can a person avoid becoming like what he constantly studies with respect and admiration?”
“Impossible.”
“So a philosopher who spends his life contemplating the divine order becomes orderly and divine himself, as far as human nature allows.
“Of course, like everyone else, he will still be vulnerable to criticism and slander.”
“Certainly.”
“But suppose he is required to shape not only himself but also human beings in general, whether in individuals or in States, according to the order he has contemplated.
“Do you think he would be an incompetent creator of justice, self-control, and every other civic virtue?”
“Quite the opposite.”
“And if people understood that this is what the philosopher is really like, would they still be angry with philosophy?
“Would they refuse to believe us when we say that no State can be happy unless its lawmakers are artists who imitate the heavenly model?”
“They would not be angry if they understood it,” he said.
“Then how would they create the plan we are talking about?”
“They would begin with the State and the character of its people.
“They would erase the existing picture completely, just as an artist wipes a tablet clean before beginning a new painting.
“That would not be easy.
“But whether easy or difficult, this would be the difference between them and every other lawgiver.
“They would refuse to write laws for either individuals or the State until they had either found or created a clean surface.”
“That would certainly be the right approach.”
“Once they had done that, they would begin drawing the outline of the constitution.”
“Certainly.”
“And when they began filling in the picture, they would constantly look both upward and downward.
“First they would look toward absolute justice, beauty, and self-control.
“Then they would look at human beings and compare them with those ideals.
“They would combine and balance the different elements of human life until they had created the image of a good human being.
“They would shape that person according to the higher model—the image that Homer called the form and likeness of God.”
“Very true.”
“They would erase one feature and add another until human life, as far as possible, resembled the divine order.”
“They could hardly create a more beautiful picture,” he said.
“And now,” I said, “are we beginning to persuade the people who were attacking us so fiercely?
“They were angry because we entrusted the State to the philosopher.
“Perhaps they are becoming a little calmer now.”
“Much calmer, if they have any sense.”
“Where could they still find an objection?
“Would they deny that the philosopher loves truth and reality?”
“They would have to be unreasonable to deny it.”
“Would they deny that a nature like the one we have described is related to the highest good?”
“They could hardly deny that either.”
“Would they claim that such a nature, if placed in favourable circumstances, could not become perfectly good and wise?”
“Surely they would not prefer the people we rejected.”
“Then would they still be angry when we say that until philosophers rule, States and individuals will never be free from evil, and that our ideal State will never become real?”
“I think they would be much less angry.”
“Let us suppose, then, that they have become completely calm.
“Let us suppose they have been persuaded and, if only out of embarrassment, are now willing to compromise with us.”
“Very well.”
“Then would anyone deny that there could be sons of kings or princes who are naturally philosophical?”
“Certainly not.”
“And when such people appear, will anyone say that they must inevitably be destroyed?
“We do not deny that it may be extremely difficult for them to survive.
“But who would dare claim that throughout all of history not even one could escape corruption?”
“No one could reasonably say that.”
“One is enough,” I said.
“If even one man possessed a city willing to obey him, he could establish the ideal political system that everyone else finds so unbelievable.”
“Yes, one would be enough.”
“If such a ruler established the laws and institutions we have described, and the citizens were willing to obey them, would that not be possible?”
“Certainly.”
“And if other people came to approve of what we approve, that would hardly be a miracle.”
“No, I think not.”
“Then we have shown enough to establish that if our constitution is possible, it would certainly be for the best.”
“We have.”
“And now we can say not only that our laws would be best if they could be established, but also that establishing them, though extremely difficult, is not impossible.”
“Very good.”
“So, with considerable effort, we have finally finished one part of our discussion.
“But there is still more.
“We must determine how the future saviours of the constitution are to be created.
“What studies and activities should they undertake?
“And at what ages should they undertake them?”
“Certainly.”
“I deliberately postponed the troublesome questions about women, children, and the appointment of rulers.
“I knew that our perfect State would attract suspicion and would be difficult enough to establish.
“I hoped that avoiding those questions for a while would save me some trouble.
“But it did not help much.
“We have dealt with women and children.
“Now we must return to the rulers and examine their selection from the beginning.
“You remember that we said they must love their country.
“They must be tested through pleasures and pains.
“They must remain loyal in hardship, danger, and every other crisis.
“Anyone who failed the test would be rejected.
“But anyone who always emerged pure, like gold tested in a furnace, would become a ruler and receive honours and rewards both during life and after death.
“That was the argument we were making.
“Then the discussion turned away and hid itself, as though it were afraid to face the question that has now returned.”
“I remember perfectly,” he said.
“Yes, my friend.
“At that time I was afraid to say something too bold.
“But now I will dare to say it.
“The perfect guardian must be a philosopher.”
“Yes,” he said. “Let us say that openly.”
“But do not imagine that there will be many of them.
“The qualities we have said are essential rarely appear together.
“Most people possess them only in fragments.”
“What do you mean?”
“You know that quick intelligence, good memory, sound judgment, cleverness, and similar qualities rarely occur together.
“And people who possess these qualities and are also energetic and ambitious are often not naturally calm or orderly.
“They are driven by their impulses in every direction, and eventually they lose all firm principles.”
“That is true.”
“On the other hand, people with steady, dependable characters, who are fearless and immovable in battle, are often equally immovable when it comes to learning.
“They tend to be slow and sluggish.
“They yawn and fall asleep when faced with intellectual work.”
“That is also true.”
“And yet we said that both kinds of qualities are necessary for people who are to receive the highest education and eventually hold important offices.”
“Certainly.”
“Then such a combination must be extremely rare.”
“Very rare indeed.”
“Therefore the future guardian must not only be tested through the hardships, dangers, and pleasures we discussed earlier.
“He must also be tested through many different kinds of knowledge.
“We must see whether his soul can endure the highest forms of study or whether it collapses under intellectual pressure just as some bodies collapse under physical training.”
“Yes. That is a sensible test.
“But what do you mean by the highest form of knowledge?”
“Do you remember that we divided the soul into three parts and distinguished justice, self-control, courage, and wisdom?”
“Of course. If I had forgotten, I would not deserve to hear anything more.”
“And do you remember the warning I gave before we began discussing those qualities?”
“What warning?”
“We said that anyone who wanted to see these virtues in their perfect form would have to take a longer and more difficult path.
“Only at the end of that path would their true nature become visible.
“But we could give a simpler account of them that would be adequate for the discussion we had been having.
“You said that such an explanation would satisfy you.
“So we continued, although I knew the treatment was far from exact.
“Whether you were satisfied or not is for you to say.”
“Yes,” he said. “I thought, and so did the others, that you had given us enough truth.”
“But my friend, an incomplete measure of something is not a fair measure.
“Nothing imperfect can serve as the proper standard for something perfect.
“Yet people are often lazy.
“They are satisfied with a partial answer and decide that there is no need to search further.”
“That happens often.”
“And there can be no worse weakness in a guardian of the State and its laws.”
“Certainly not.”
“Then the guardian must take the longer road.
“He must work hard at learning as well as at physical training.
“Otherwise he will never reach the highest form of knowledge, which we have said is his proper goal.”
“What knowledge could be higher than justice and the other virtues?”
“There is such a knowledge.”
“And we must not be satisfied with merely outlining the virtues.
“We must see them in their complete and perfect form.
“If people spend endless effort making tiny details of ordinary things appear beautiful and precise, how ridiculous would it be to say that the highest truths do not deserve the greatest possible accuracy?”
“That is a noble idea.
“But do you really think we will let you escape without asking what this highest knowledge is?”
“Ask, if you wish.
“But I am certain you have heard the answer many times.
“Perhaps you do not understand me.
“Or perhaps you are simply trying to force me into saying more.
“You have often heard me say that the knowledge of the good is the highest knowledge.
“And everything else becomes useful only because of its relationship to the good.
“You cannot possibly have forgotten that this is what I was about to discuss.
“We know very little about the good.
“And without knowledge of it, no other knowledge or possession can truly benefit us.
“What value is there in possessing everything else if we do not possess the good?
“What value is there in knowing everything else if we do not know what is beautiful and good?”
“None,” he said.
“You also know that most people say pleasure is the good.
“More sophisticated thinkers say that knowledge is the good.”
“Yes.”
“And you know that these thinkers cannot explain what they mean by knowledge.
“They eventually have to say that they mean knowledge of the good.”
“That is ridiculous.”
“Exactly.
“They begin by criticizing us for not knowing what the good is, and then define the good as ‘knowledge of the good,’ as though that explained anything.
“It is like using the word to define itself.”
“Very true.”
“And those who say pleasure is the good are equally confused.
“They have to admit that some pleasures are bad.”
“Certainly.”
“So they must admit that good and bad pleasures exist.”
“Yes.”
“And that creates just as many difficulties.”
“Without question.”
“Moreover, we see that many people are willing to do what is just and honourable, or at least appear to be just and honourable, without actually being so.
“But no one is satisfied merely with appearing to have the good.
“Everyone wants the real thing.
“When it comes to goodness, appearance alone is not enough.”
“That is certainly true.”
“Then every human soul pursues the good.
“Everyone acts with some sense that there is a final goal worth reaching.
“But people hesitate because they do not understand what the good really is.
“They do not possess the same certainty about it that they possess about other things.
“And because they lack this understanding, they fail to benefit fully from everything else they possess.
“Can we really allow the best people in our State, the people to whom everything is entrusted, to remain ignorant of such a fundamental principle?”
“Certainly not.”
“I am sure,” I said, “that anyone who does not understand why beauty and justice are also good will make a poor guardian of them.
“And I suspect that no one who does not understand the good can truly understand justice and beauty either.”
“That is a reasonable suspicion.”
“And if our guardians possess this knowledge, our State will be perfectly ordered.”
“Of course.
“But I want to know whether you think this highest principle—the good—is knowledge, pleasure, or something different from both.”
“Ah,” I said, “I knew that someone as demanding as you would not be satisfied with other people's opinions on the subject.”
“That is true.
“Socrates, someone who has spent his whole life studying philosophy should not always repeat what others have said.
“Surely he should sometimes tell us what he himself thinks.”
“But can anyone claim with certainty to know something he does not actually know?”
“No,” he said. “Not with certainty.
“But he can give his opinion.”
“And do you not know that mere opinions are unreliable, and that even the best opinions are blind?
“You would not deny that people who possess a true belief without understanding are like blind people feeling their way along a road.”
“Very true.”
“Then do you really want to see something blind, crooked, and ugly when others could show you what is bright and beautiful?”
“I beg you, Socrates,” said Glaucon, “do not turn away just when you are reaching the goal.
“If you would only explain the good as clearly as you explained justice, self-control, and the other virtues, we would be satisfied.”
“Yes, my friend, and I would be just as satisfied.
“But I am afraid I will fail.
“My enthusiasm may carry me too far and make me ridiculous.
“No, gentlemen, let us not try to discover the actual nature of the good itself just yet.
“To reach the idea that is now in my mind would require more strength than I possess.
“But I can speak about what is born from the good and most closely resembles it.
“If you want to hear that, I will explain it.”
“Of course,” he said. “Tell us about the child, and you will still owe us an account of the parent.”
“I wish I could give you the account of the parent,” I replied, “and let you receive it.
“But since I cannot, take this account of the child as interest.
“And please be careful that I do not give you a false account, even though I have no intention of deceiving you.”
“We will do our best. Go on.”
“Then first I need you to agree with something we have discussed many times.
“We have said that there are many beautiful things and many good things, and similarly many things of other kinds.
“We call all of them ‘many.’”
“True.”
“But we also say that there is absolute beauty and absolute goodness.
“And for every other group of things we call ‘many,’ there is also an absolute reality behind them.
“All the individual things can be understood under one single idea, which is the true essence of that kind of thing.”
“Exactly.”
“The many individual things can be seen, but they cannot truly be known.
“The ideas themselves can be known, but they cannot be seen with the physical eyes.”
“Exactly.”
“And what is the organ through which we see visible things?”
“Sight.”
“And with hearing we hear, while with our other senses we perceive their respective objects.”
“Correct.”
“But have you ever noticed how much more complicated sight is than the other senses?”
“No, I have not.”
“Think about it.
“Does the ear or the voice need some third thing in order for hearing to take place?
“Does the ear need something additional in order to hear, or the voice something additional in order to be heard?”
“No.”
“And the same seems to be true of most, perhaps all, of the other senses.”
“Certainly.”
“But sight is different.
“Without something additional, there can be no seeing and no being seen.”
“What do you mean?”
“The power of sight is located in the eyes.
“And someone may possess perfectly good eyes and be looking directly at an object.
“Yet unless a third thing is present, he will not see it.
“The object may have colour, and the eye may be functioning perfectly, but without this third thing, the colours remain invisible.”
“What third thing do you mean?”
“Light.”
“Yes, of course.”
“Then there is a remarkable bond between sight and the visible world.
“Light connects them.
“And light is certainly no insignificant thing.”
“Quite the opposite.”
“And which god in heaven would you say is the master of this power?
“Whose light allows the eye to see clearly and makes visible things visible?”
“You mean the sun, as everyone says.”
“Then would you describe the relationship between sight and the sun like this?”
“How?”
“Sight itself is not the sun.
“The eye in which sight exists is not the sun either.”
“No.”
“Yet among all the organs of sense, the eye is the one most like the sun.”
“By far.”
“And the power of sight that the eye possesses is, in a sense, something that comes from the sun.”
“Exactly.”
“So the sun is not sight itself.
“Rather, the sun is the source that makes sight possible and is recognized by sight.”
“True.”
“And this,” I said, “is what I call the child of the good.
“The good produced the sun in its own likeness.
“In the visible world, the sun stands in relation to sight and visible things in much the same way that the good stands in the intellectual world in relation to the mind and things that can be understood.”
“Can you explain that more clearly?” he asked.
“You know that when the eyes look toward objects that are not illuminated by sunlight but only by the moon and stars, they see poorly.
“Their vision is weak and unclear, almost as if they were blind.”
“Certainly.”
“But when they look toward objects illuminated by the sun, they see clearly.”
“Of course.”
“The soul works in a similar way.
“When the soul turns toward what is illuminated by truth and reality, it understands and knows.
“It becomes intelligent and clear.
“But when it turns toward the changing world of becoming and decay, it has only opinion.
“It becomes confused.
“It shifts from one opinion to another and seems to possess no real understanding.”
“Exactly.”
“Now what gives truth to the things we know, and gives the mind the power to know them, is what I want you to call the idea of the good.
“The good is the cause of knowledge and truth insofar as truth can be known.
“Knowledge and truth are beautiful, but the good itself is even more beautiful.
“Just as light and sight resemble the sun without being the sun, knowledge and truth resemble the good without being the good.
“The good holds a higher place than either.”
“What an extraordinary beauty that must be,” he said.
“To be the source of knowledge and truth, yet surpass them both in beauty.
“You surely cannot mean that pleasure is the good?”
“Absolutely not.
“But let us look at the image from another angle.”
“What angle?”
“You would agree that the sun is not only responsible for making things visible.
“It is also responsible for their generation, nourishment, and growth, even though the sun itself is not generation.”
“Certainly.”
“In the same way, the good is not only the source of knowledge for the things that can be known.
“It is also the source of their being and essence.
“Yet the good itself is not essence.
“It stands beyond essence in dignity and power.”
Glaucon responded with exaggerated seriousness.
“By heaven, Socrates, that is an astonishing claim!”
“Yes,” I said. “And if it sounds exaggerated, you may blame yourself.
“You are the one who forced me to say all this.”
“Then please continue.
“At least let us hear whether there is anything more to say about the likeness of the sun.”
“There is a great deal more.”
“Then leave nothing out, however small.”
“I will do my best.
“But I suspect there will still be much that must be left unsaid.”
“I hope not.”
“Then imagine two ruling powers.
“One governs the intellectual world.
“The other governs the visible world.
“I do not want to call the first one heaven, because you might think I am merely playing with words.
“But do you understand the distinction between the visible and the intelligible?”
“I do.”
“Then imagine a straight line divided into two unequal sections.
“Now divide each section again in the same proportion.
“The first major section represents the visible world.
“The second represents the intelligible world.
“Then compare the smaller sections according to how clear or unclear they are.
“The first part of the visible world will consist of images.
“By images I mean shadows first, and then reflections in water, mirrors, polished surfaces, and things of that kind.
“Do you understand?”
“Yes.”
“Now imagine the other part of the visible world.
“It consists of the actual animals we see, along with plants and everything else that grows or is manufactured.”
“Very good.”
“Would you agree that these two sections have different degrees of truth?
“The relationship between a copy and an original is similar to the relationship between opinion and knowledge.”
“Certainly.”
“Now let us consider how the intelligible world itself should be divided.”
“How?”
“There are two sections.
“In the lower section, the soul uses the things from the visible world as images.
“It begins from assumptions or hypotheses and does not rise above them.
“Instead, it moves downward from those assumptions toward its conclusions.
“In the higher section, however, the soul moves beyond hypotheses.
“It rises toward a first principle that stands above them.
“It does not use images in the same way.
“It reasons directly through ideas themselves.”
“I do not completely understand that.”
“Then let me explain it another way.
“You know that students of geometry, arithmetic, and related sciences begin by assuming things such as odd and even numbers, shapes, three kinds of angles, and other basic principles.
“These are their hypotheses.
“They assume everyone understands them, so they do not stop to explain or justify them.
“They simply begin from them and continue reasoning until they eventually reach their conclusions.”
“Yes, I understand.”
“And you know that although they use visible diagrams and figures in their reasoning, they are not really thinking about those particular drawings.
“They are thinking about the ideal forms that the drawings represent.
“They are not thinking about this particular square they have drawn.
“They are thinking about the absolute square.
“They are not thinking about this particular diameter.
“They are thinking about the absolute concept of a diameter.
“The physical diagrams they draw have shadows and reflections of their own.
“But these physical figures are merely images.
“What they are really trying to understand are the ideal realities themselves.
“And those realities can only be seen with the eye of the mind.”
“That is true.”
“That is what I mean by the intelligible realm.
“But when the soul investigates it, it is still forced to begin with hypotheses.
“It cannot yet rise above them to the first principle.
“So it uses the objects whose shadows appear below as images.
“These objects are clearer than the shadows and reflections, and therefore have a higher degree of reality.”
“I understand.
“You are talking about geometry and the related sciences.”
“And when I speak of the higher division of the intelligible world, I am talking about another kind of knowledge—the kind reached by reason through dialectic.
“Here the soul does not treat hypotheses as final principles.
“It treats them as temporary steps.
“They are starting points that allow reason to rise toward a principle above all hypotheses.
“Once reason reaches that first principle, it holds onto it and then follows the chain of ideas that depends upon it.
“Finally, it moves back down through ideas, without relying on anything perceived by the senses.
“It proceeds through ideas and ends in ideas.”
“I think I understand you,” he replied.
“Not perfectly, because what you are describing sounds extremely difficult.
“But I understand that you are saying something like this:
“The knowledge of being and reality that dialectic investigates is clearer than the knowledge produced by the mathematical and related sciences.
“Those sciences also use the intellect rather than the senses.
“But because they begin from hypotheses and never rise beyond them to a first principle, they do not exercise the highest form of reason.
“If a first principle is added, however, then they become objects of higher reason.
“So I suppose you would call the kind of thinking used in geometry and related sciences ‘understanding’ rather than full reason, because it stands between opinion and reason.”
“You have understood me exactly,” I said.
“Then, corresponding to these four divisions, let us imagine four corresponding powers of the soul.
“The highest is reason.
“The second is understanding.
“The third is faith or conviction.
“And the fourth is the perception of shadows and appearances.
“Let us arrange them in a scale.
“And let us say that each power is as clear as the truth of the objects it deals with.”
“I understand,” he replied.
“And I agree with your arrangement.”
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!