← The Republic 2026 Edition
Chapter 5 · The Ideal State and the Shared Life of the Guardians

The Ideal State and the Shared Life of the Guardians

Chapter 5 of 10 · 11,338 words · Free

“This, then, is the good and true State. And the good and true man must be shaped in the same way. If our argument is correct, every other form of State and every other kind of man must be defective. The bad State is not merely badly organized on the outside. Its disorder reaches into the individual soul as well. And there are four main forms of this corruption.”

“What are they?” he asked.

“I was about to explain the order in which these four forms appear. But Polemarchus, who was sitting a little way off, just beyond Adeimantus, began whispering to him. He reached out, grabbed Adeimantus by the shoulder, and pulled him closer. Then he leaned over and whispered something in his ear. I only caught a few words.

‘Are we going to let him off, or not?’

‘Certainly not,’ Adeimantus replied loudly.

“‘Who are you refusing to let off?’ I asked.

‘You.’

‘And why am I the one who cannot be let off?’

‘Because we think you are being lazy. You are trying to skip an entire chapter of the argument, and it is one of the most important parts. You think we will not notice because you move along so casually, as if everything were already obvious. You seem to think that everyone will simply accept your statement that, when it comes to women and children, “friends have everything in common.”’

‘And was I wrong, Adeimantus?’

‘No. But even when the basic idea is correct, it still needs to be explained. There can be many different kinds of sharing. So tell us exactly what kind of community you mean. We have been waiting for you to explain how the families of our citizens will work—how children will be born, how they will be raised, and what exactly it means for women and children to be held in common.

‘We think this question is enormously important. Whether it is handled well or badly could have a huge effect on the State, either for good or for evil. And now, since you have moved on to another part of the State without settling this question, we have decided not to let you go until you explain the whole thing.’

Glaucon said, “You can count me as agreeing with that decision.”

“And without any more discussion,” Thrasymachus added, “you can count all of us as agreeing too.”

“You have no idea what you are doing by attacking me like this,” I said. “What an argument you are forcing me into! Just when I thought I had finished, I was relieved that I had finally put this difficult question to rest. I was even congratulating myself because you had accepted what I had said. And now you are asking me to go back to the very beginning and start again.

“You have no idea what kind of storm of words you are stirring up. I saw this coming, which is why I tried to avoid it.”

“Why do you think we came here?” Thrasymachus asked. “To look for gold, or to listen to an argument?”

“To listen to an argument, of course. But even arguments should have limits.”

“Yes, Socrates,” Glaucon said, “and wise men would say that the only limit to discussions like this is the whole of life. So forget about us and take courage. Answer the question in whatever way you think best.

“What kind of community of women and children is supposed to exist among our guardians? And how are we to deal with the period between birth and education, which seems to require the greatest care? Tell us how all this is supposed to work.”

“My dear Glaucon, the answer is anything but easy. There are even more difficulties here than in our earlier arguments. We can question whether such a system is actually possible. And even if it were possible, we could still question whether it would really be best.

“That is why I hesitate to approach the subject. I am afraid that what we have been imagining may turn out to be nothing more than a dream.”

“Do not be afraid,” he replied. “Your audience will not be harsh with you. We are not hostile or suspicious.”

“My friend,” I said, “I suppose you mean those words to encourage me.”

“I certainly do.”

“Then you are actually doing the opposite. Your encouragement would be useful if I believed that I knew exactly what I was talking about. When a man knows the truth about something important that he deeply values, and he is speaking among wise people who care about him, there is no reason for him to hesitate.

“But I am not in that position. I am still searching. I am uncertain myself. And arguing about something when you are not sure you have found the truth is dangerous.

“The danger is not that I might be laughed at. That would be childish to fear. The real danger is that I might lose sight of the truth precisely where I most need to stand firmly, and then drag my friends down with me.

“I pray that Nemesis will not punish me for what I am about to say. I honestly believe that accidentally causing a man's death is a smaller crime than deliberately deceiving people about what is beautiful, good, or just, especially when we are making laws for a State.

“I would rather take that risk among enemies than among friends. So you are right to encourage me.”

Glaucon laughed.

“Well then, Socrates, if your argument causes us any serious harm, we will acquit you in advance of the charge of murder. And we will not call you a deceiver either. So take courage and speak.”

“Well,” I said, “the law says that when a man is acquitted, he is free from guilt. Perhaps what applies in a court of law can also apply in an argument.”

“Then why are you still worried?”

“I suppose I must go back and say what I should probably have said earlier. We have finished discussing the men. Now it is time to discuss the women. And I am more willing to do so because you have specifically asked me to.

“My view is that if men and women are to be born and educated as citizens of the kind we have described, then the right way to think about women and children is to follow the same principle we started with when we said that the men should be guardians and watchdogs of the State.”

“Agreed.”

“Now suppose that the women are given the same kind of upbringing and education, or nearly the same. Then we can see whether the result fits the design of our State.”

“What exactly do you mean?”

“I will put it as a question. When it comes to dogs, are male dogs and female dogs separated in their duties? Do males do the hunting and guarding while females stay at home because giving birth and nursing puppies is considered enough work for them?”

“No,” he said. “They share the same duties. The only difference is that males are generally stronger and females weaker.”

“Can animals perform the same tasks unless they are raised and trained in the same way?”

“No.”

“Then if women are to perform the same duties as men, must they not receive the same upbringing and education?”

“Yes.”

“The education we gave the men consisted of music and physical training.”

“Yes.”

“Then women must also be taught music and physical training, as well as the art of war, and they must practise it just as the men do?”

“That seems to follow.”

“I imagine that many people will laugh at some of our proposals if we actually put them into practice, simply because they are unfamiliar.”

“Without doubt.”

“And the most ridiculous sight of all, according to present-day thinking, will be women exercising naked in the gymnasium alongside men, especially older women. They will certainly not look beautiful to the eyes of those who judge everything by appearances. Older men with wrinkles and ugly bodies who insist on going to the gymnasium already look ridiculous enough to such people.”

“Very true,” he said. “That is how people would see it today.”

“But once we have decided to speak honestly, we must not be afraid of jokes from clever people. They will mock women for studying music and physical training, and especially for wearing armor and riding horses.”

“Quite right.”

“Yet once we have started, we must go through the difficult parts of the law. And I would ask these gentlemen to be serious for once in their lives.

“Not so long ago, the Greeks themselves thought that seeing a naked man was ridiculous and improper. Then the Cretans and later the Spartans introduced the practice. The clever people of their time could have mocked them just as easily.”

“Certainly.”

“But experience eventually showed that allowing the body to be uncovered during exercise was actually better than covering it. Once people understood the useful principle behind the practice, the ridiculous appearance disappeared.

“Then everyone could see that the real fool was not the person who exercised naked, but the person who directed his jokes at something merely because it was unfamiliar.

“The same principle applies here. We should not judge something beautiful by appearance alone. We should judge it according to whether it is good and useful.”

“That is true.”

“Then let us begin by asking seriously what a woman is capable of. Can she share fully or partly in the activities of men, or can she share in none of them? And is military training one of the activities in which she can participate? That seems the fairest way to begin.”

“That is certainly the best approach.”

“Perhaps we should first argue against ourselves. If we present the strongest case for the opposing side, then the other side will not be left without an argument.”

“Why not?”

“Let us imagine our opponents speaking to us.

“They might say:

‘Socrates and Glaucon, you do not need an opponent to defeat you. You have already defeated yourselves. At the very beginning, when you established your State, you said that every person should perform the one task for which his nature is best suited.

‘Did you not say that?’

“And we would have to admit that we did.

“Then they would continue:

‘And are not the natures of men and women very different?’

“We would answer: Of course they are.

“Then they would ask:

‘If their natures are different, should they not be given different tasks suited to those different natures?’

“We would have to agree.

“Then they would say:

‘If that is true, have you not contradicted yourselves by saying that men and women, whose natures are so different, should perform the same tasks?’

“What answer can we give to that, Glaucon?”

“That is not an easy question to answer without thinking. I ask you to make the argument for us.”

“These are the objections,” I said, “and there are many more like them. I anticipated them long ago. They were exactly what made me reluctant to discuss laws concerning women and children.”

“By Zeus,” he said, “the problem is certainly not simple.”

“No. But when a man is out of his depth, whether he has fallen into a shallow pool or into the middle of the sea, he still has to swim.”

“Very true.”

“And must we not swim and try to reach the shore? Perhaps some miraculous help will come to save us.”

“I suppose so.”

“Then let us see whether we can find a way out.

“We agreed that different natures should have different pursuits. We also agreed that men and women have different natures.

“Now what are we saying? We are saying that different natures should sometimes have the same pursuits.

“That seems inconsistent.”

“Exactly.”

“Glaucon, this shows how powerful the art of contradiction can be.”

“What do you mean?”

“I think many people become trapped in it without intending to. They believe they are reasoning when they are actually just arguing. They cannot properly define and separate the things they are discussing, so they end up fighting over words instead of examining the real issue.”

“That often happens. But how does it affect us?”

“It affects us greatly. We may accidentally fall into exactly the same trap.”

“How?”

“We insist on the verbal rule that different natures should have different pursuits. But we never stopped to ask what exactly we mean by ‘same’ and ‘different’ nature, or why some differences should determine a person's occupation while others should not.”

“No, we never considered that.”

“Let us take a simple example. Suppose we said that bald men and hairy men have different natures. If bald men happened to be shoemakers, would we then forbid hairy men from becoming shoemakers?”

“That would be ridiculous.”

“Exactly. Why is it ridiculous? Because when we designed the State, we never meant that every physical difference should determine a person's occupation. We meant only those differences that affect the particular work being done.

“For example, a doctor and another person who has the natural ability to become a doctor have the same nature with respect to medicine.”

“True.”

“While a doctor and a carpenter have different natures with respect to their occupations.”

“Certainly.”

“And if men and women differ in their natural ability to perform some particular occupation, then that occupation should be assigned to whichever sex is naturally better suited to it.

“But if the difference between them is simply that women give birth while men father children, that does not prove that women require a different education.

“Therefore we can still maintain that male and female guardians should have the same occupations.”

“Very true.”

“Now let us ask our opponent: In what respect, concerning the activities and professions of civic life, does a woman's nature differ from a man's?”

“That is a fair question.”

“He may say, as you did, that the answer is not easy to give immediately. But after some thought, perhaps it becomes much clearer.”

“Yes, perhaps.”

“Then let us invite him to continue the argument with us. We may be able to show him that there is nothing about being a woman, simply because one is a woman, that makes her incapable of participating in the government or defense of the State.”

“By all means.”

“Let us ask him:

‘When you spoke of a person being naturally gifted or ungifted, did you mean that one person can learn something easily while another struggles with it? That one person can understand a great deal after a little instruction, while another studies for a long time and still forgets what he learned? Or that one person has a body that serves his mind well, while another has a body that constantly gets in the way?

‘Would these not be the kinds of differences you mean when you speak of natural ability?’”

“No one could deny that.”

“Then can you name any human occupation in which men possess all these abilities to a greater degree than women?

“I do not even need to waste time talking about weaving, cooking, or preserving food, where women often excel, and where it would be absurd for a man to defeat a woman.”

“You are right,” he replied, “that women are generally weaker than men, although many women are better than many men at particular things.”

“Exactly. And if that is true, then there is no special ability to govern a State that belongs to women merely because they are women, or to men merely because they are men.

“The natural abilities required for different occupations are found among both sexes.

“Women can perform the same kinds of work as men, although generally they are weaker than men in physical strength.”

“Very true.”

“Then should we make laws that apply to men but not to women?”

“Certainly not.”

“One woman may be naturally gifted at medicine while another is not. One may be musical while another has no musical ability.”

“True.”

“One may have a natural talent for physical training and military exercises, while another may hate exercise and have no interest in war.”

“Certainly.”

“One may love philosophy while another may dislike it. One may have courage and spirit while another may be timid.”

“That is also true.”

“Then one woman may possess the qualities required of a guardian, while another may not. Wasn't this the same principle we used when selecting male guardians?”

“Yes.”

“Then men and women both possess the qualities required of a guardian. The difference is only that men are generally stronger and women generally weaker.”

“Obviously.”

“So the women who possess the qualities needed for guardianship should be selected as companions and colleagues of the men who possess similar abilities and character.”

“Very true.”

“And should not people with the same natural abilities be given the same pursuits?”

“They should.”

“Then, as we said before, there is nothing unnatural about assigning music and physical training to the wives of our guardians.”

“Certainly not.”

“Then the law we proposed is in accordance with nature. It is possible, and it is not merely an unrealistic dream. The real violation of nature is the practice that exists now.”

“That seems correct.”

“We said we had to consider two things: first, whether our proposal was possible; and second, whether it would be beneficial.”

“Yes.”

“We have established that it is possible.”

“Yes.”

“Then we must establish that it is highly beneficial.”

“Agreed.”

“You will admit that the same education that produces a good male guardian can also produce a good female guardian, because their natural abilities are essentially the same?”

“Yes.”

“I have another question.”

“What is it?”

“Would you say that all men are equally excellent, or are some better than others?”

“Some are better than others.”

“In the State we are creating, would the guardians trained according to our system be better citizens than the cobblers who have been trained only in cobbling?”

“What a ridiculous question.”

“You have answered it for me,” I said. “Then may we not say that our guardians are the best of our citizens?”

“By far.”

“And their wives will be the best women?”

“Yes, by far.”

“Can anything be better for the interests of the State than having the best possible men and women?”

“Nothing.”

“And this is what music and physical training, properly taught, will accomplish?”

“Certainly.”

“Then our law is not only possible but extremely beneficial to the State.”

“True.”

“Then let the wives of the guardians train without hiding their bodies out of shame. Their virtue will be their clothing. Let them share in military duties and in the defense of the State.

“The lighter duties should generally be assigned to women because they are physically weaker. But in every other respect, their duties should be the same as those of men.

“And if anyone laughs at women exercising naked for the sake of their physical and moral excellence, then his laughter only shows his ignorance. He does not understand what he is laughing at.

“The best principle remains this: what is useful is honorable, and what is harmful is shameful.”

“Very true.”

“So we have escaped one difficulty in our law concerning women. The first wave did not drown us.

“We have shown that it is possible and useful for male and female guardians to share the same pursuits.”

“Yes.”

“But now comes a much greater wave. You will barely remember the first once you see the second.”

“Go on. Let me hear it.”

“The next law follows naturally from everything we have said:

“The wives of the guardians are to be held in common, and their children are to be held in common. No parent is to know his own child, and no child is to know his own parent.”

“That is certainly a much bigger wave. The possibility of such a law is even more questionable, and its usefulness is also much harder to establish.”

“I do not think there can be much argument about the usefulness of having wives and children in common. The possibility is another matter entirely, and there will be plenty of disagreement about it.”

“I think both questions can be challenged.”

“You are suggesting that we must deal with both at once. I was hoping you would simply accept the usefulness first. That would have allowed me to escape one difficulty, leaving only the question of possibility.”

“I caught your little trick. So now you must defend both.”

“Well, I accept my fate. But give me one small favor.

“Let me enjoy the idea as a daydreamer enjoys his dreams when he walks alone. Before a daydreamer knows how to make his wishes possible, he does not worry about practicality. He simply assumes that his wishes have already come true and enjoys imagining what he will do afterward.

“I am beginning to lose courage myself. So, if you permit me, let us postpone the question of whether this system is possible.

“Let us assume for the moment that it is possible. Then I will explain how the rulers would put it into practice, and I will show that, if carried out, the system would be enormously beneficial to the State.

“After that, we can return to the question of whether it is actually possible.”

“I have no objection. Go ahead.”

“First, if our rulers and their assistants are truly worthy of those names, then some must be willing to obey while others have the authority to command. The guardians must obey the laws themselves, and in all the details entrusted to them, they must preserve the spirit of those laws.”

“That is right.”

“You, as the lawgiver, will now select the women just as you selected the men. You will match women with men who are as similar as possible in natural ability and character.

“They will live together in common houses and eat together at common meals. None will possess a private household or private property.

“They will be raised together, trained together, and exercise together.

“And because men and women are naturally attracted to one another, they will inevitably have sexual relationships. ‘Necessity’ is not too strong a word, is it?”

“Yes,” he said. “Necessity is the right word—not mathematical necessity, but the kind of necessity that lovers understand and that has an even stronger hold over ordinary people.”

“Exactly. But even this must be organized properly. In our ideal city, uncontrolled sexual behavior would be considered shameful. The rulers must prevent it.”

“Yes. It should not be permitted.”

“Then marriage must be treated as something sacred. And whatever benefits the State most should be considered sacred.”

“Exactly.”

“Now how can marriages be arranged in the most beneficial way? I ask you because I have noticed the hunting dogs and fine birds in your household.

“Have you ever paid attention to how they are bred?”

“In what way?”

“First, although they are all good animals, aren't some better than others?”

“Of course.”

“Do you breed all of them indiscriminately, or do you select the best?”

“Only the best.”

“And do you choose the oldest and youngest, or those in their prime?”

“Those in their prime.”

“And if you were careless about breeding them, would your dogs and birds gradually become worse?”

“Certainly.”

“And the same applies to horses and other animals?”

“Without question.”

“Good heavens, my friend! If the same principle applies to human beings, our rulers will need extraordinary skill.”

“Why should that require special skill?”

“Because our rulers will sometimes have to use what we might call medicine on the State itself.

“You know that when patients are basically healthy and only need a proper diet, even an ordinary doctor can manage them. But when real medicine is necessary, you need a more skilled physician.”

“That is true. But what are you getting at?”

“I mean that our rulers may sometimes need to use deception and falsehood for the good of the citizens.

“We have already agreed that certain falsehoods can be used like medicine when they benefit the people.”

“Yes, we did.”

“And this may be especially necessary when arranging marriages and births.”

“How so?”

“We have already established the principle that the best men should be paired with the best women as often as possible, and the less capable should be paired with one another as rarely as possible.

“If we want the guardian class to remain strong, the children of the better unions should be raised, while the children of inferior unions should not.

“But these arrangements must remain a secret known only to the rulers. Otherwise the guardians themselves might rebel.”

“That is true.”

“Perhaps we should establish certain public festivals where brides and bridegrooms are brought together, sacrifices are offered, and our poets compose suitable wedding songs.

“The rulers will secretly determine how many marriages take place, always trying to keep the population at the right level.

“They will also consider wars, diseases, and other circumstances, so that the population does not become too large or too small.”

“Certainly.”

“We will also have to invent some clever system of drawing lots. The less worthy will then blame their bad luck rather than the rulers when they are paired with one another.”

“Of course.”

“And our bravest and best young people should receive greater opportunities for sexual relationships as part of their rewards and honors. Their courage gives them a reason to have more children than others.”

“Agreed.”

“Then the proper officials—men, women, or both—will oversee the children.

“They will take the children of the better parents to a nursery or common enclosure and place them under the care of nurses living in a separate area.

“The children of inferior parents, and any children of the better parents who happen to be seriously deformed, will be taken away to some hidden and unknown place.”

“Yes,” he said. “That must be done if the guardian class is to remain pure.”

“The officials will care for the children and bring the mothers there when they have milk.

“But they will take the greatest care that no mother knows which child is hers. Other wet nurses can be brought in if necessary.

“The mothers will not be allowed to spend their nights caring for their own children. Nurses and attendants will take care of that.”

“You are giving the wives of the guardians a very easy life when they have children.”

“They deserve it,” I said.

“Now let us continue. We said that parents should be in the prime of life.”

“Correct.”

“What is the prime of life? Could we define it as about twenty years of a woman's life and thirty years of a man's?”

“What ages do you mean?”

“A woman may begin bearing children for the State at twenty and continue until forty.

“A man may begin at twenty-five, after the period of his greatest physical energy, and continue fathering children until fifty-five.”

“That seems reasonable. Those are the years when both men and women are at their physical and intellectual peak.”

“Anyone above or below these ages who takes part in the public marriages will be said to have acted unlawfully and without religious sanction.

“If a child is born from such a union, it will have been conceived outside the sacrifices and prayers that accompany approved marriages. Those prayers are meant to ensure that the new generation will be better and more useful than its parents.

“Such a child, by contrast, will have been conceived secretly and without proper approval.”

“Very true.”

“The same rule applies to anyone within the permitted age who forms a relationship with a woman of the proper age without the approval of the rulers.

“Such a man will be said to have produced an unauthorized child for the State.”

“Very true.”

“After a man and woman have passed the prescribed childbearing ages, however, we will allow them considerable freedom, except that they must not marry their children or grandchildren, nor their parents or grandparents.

“The same restrictions will apply to women in the opposite direction.

“And we will order them to prevent any child conceived from such relationships from being born. If one somehow survives until birth, the parents must understand that the State cannot raise it.”

“That seems reasonable. But how will people know who their fathers and daughters are if everyone is supposed to be unaware of their actual family relationships?”

“They will not know.

“The system will work like this. From the date of an approved marriage, every male child born during the seventh or tenth month afterward will be called the husband's son, and every female child will be called his daughter. The children will call him father.

“The children of those children will be called grandchildren.

“The older generation will be called grandparents.

“All children born at the same time that their supposed parents were having their approved marriages will be treated as brothers and sisters. Therefore they will not be allowed to marry one another.

“However, this does not absolutely forbid marriage between brothers and sisters. If the official lottery allows it and the Pythian oracle approves, such a marriage will be permitted.”

“That is correct.”

“That, Glaucon, is the system by which the guardians of our State will share wives and families.

“Now you want the argument to show that this arrangement is consistent with everything else we have established, and that nothing could be better for the State. Is that what you want?”

“Yes, certainly.”

“Then let us begin by asking what the chief aim of a lawgiver should be when making laws and organizing a State.

“What is the greatest good? And what is the greatest evil?

“Then we can examine whether our earlier description belongs to the side of good or evil.”

“By all means.”

“Can there be a greater evil than division, disagreement, and fragmentation where there should be unity?

“And can there be a greater good than unity?”

“Nothing greater.”

“There is unity when people share pleasures and pains—when citizens rejoice together at the same things and suffer together at the same things.”

“Certainly.”

“But when people have only private feelings and no common feelings, the State becomes disorganized.

“One part of the population celebrates while another suffers because of the same event. One group thinks something belongs to ‘us,’ while another thinks it belongs to ‘them.’”

“Exactly.”

“And such divisions often begin with disagreements over the words ‘mine’ and ‘not mine,’ ‘his’ and ‘not his.’”

“Exactly.”

“Then the best-organized State would be the one in which the greatest number of people use the words ‘mine’ and ‘not mine’ in the same way about the same things.”

“That is true.”

“Or think about the human body.

“If one of us injures a finger, the entire body responds. The whole body, united under the direction of the soul, feels the pain of that one small part.

“We say, ‘My finger hurts.’

“And when the pain disappears, the whole body shares in the relief.”

“Very true.”

“The best-organized State should come as close as possible to that kind of shared feeling.”

“I agree.”

“Then whenever one citizen experiences good or evil, the whole State should feel it as if it were its own, rejoicing with him or suffering with him.”

“Yes. That is what would happen in a well-ordered State.”

“Then it is time to return to our State and see whether it has this character more than any other.”

“Very well.”

“Our State, like every other, has rulers and subjects.”

“True.”

“And all of them will call one another citizens?”

“Of course.”

“But in other States, what names are normally given to rulers?”

“They are often called masters. In democratic States they are simply called rulers.”

“And in our State, what other name will the people give their rulers?”

“Saviors and helpers.”

“And what will the rulers call the people?”

“Their supporters and foster-fathers.”

“And what are ordinary people called in other States?”

“Slaves.”

“And what do rulers call one another elsewhere?”

“Fellow rulers.”

“And what will ours call one another?”

“Fellow guardians.”

“Have you ever known another State where one ruler could describe one colleague as his friend and another as a stranger?”

“Yes, many times.”

“And the friend is someone in whom he has an interest, while the stranger is someone he considers unrelated to his interests?”

“Exactly.”

“But would any of our guardians think of another guardian as a stranger?”

“Certainly not. Everyone they meet will be regarded as a brother or sister, father or mother, son or daughter, or as the child or parent of someone who has one of those relationships.”

“Excellent.

“But let me ask one more question. Will they merely use these family names, or will their behavior actually match the names?

“For example, if they call someone ‘father,’ will they also treat him with the care, respect, obedience, and duty that the law requires toward a father?

“Would someone who violated those duties be regarded as an impious and unjust person who would receive little good from either gods or men?

“Would all citizens teach children these attitudes toward the people they are told are their parents and relatives?”

“Yes,” he said. “Nothing else would make sense. What could be more absurd than using family words with your lips while refusing to behave as a family?”

“Then our city will hear the language of harmony and agreement more often than any other city.

“As I said before, whenever someone is well or ill, the common expression will be, ‘It is well with me’ or ‘It is bad with me.’”

“Exactly.”

“And because they think this way, they will share their pleasures and pains.”

“Yes.”

“They will also share the same interests. They will call the same things ‘mine,’ and because they have the same interests, they will naturally share the same feelings.”

“Much more than people in other States.”

“And the main reason for this, apart from the general structure of the State, is that the guardians share wives and children.”

“That is the main reason.”

“And we already agreed that this unity of feeling is the greatest good, just as we compared the well-ordered State to a human body whose parts all share the same pain and pleasure.”

“We did, and rightly.”

“Then the community of wives and children among our citizens is clearly one of the greatest sources of good for the State.”

“Certainly.”

“And this agrees with another principle we established earlier: the guardians should possess no private houses, land, or other property.

“They receive food from the other citizens as their pay and have no private expenses, because we want them to remain true guardians.”

“Right.”

“So both the sharing of property and the sharing of families will make them more completely guardians.

“They will not tear the city apart by arguing about what belongs to ‘me’ and what belongs to ‘you.’

“No guardian will drag his private possessions into a private household and separate himself from the others.

“Instead, they will share the same pleasures and pains because they all agree about what matters to them, and therefore they will all move toward the same goal.”

“Certainly.”

“And because they have almost nothing they can call their own, they will have no lawsuits and no private complaints arising from money, children, or family relationships.”

“Of course.”

“They will also have little reason for lawsuits over assault or insult.

“We will say that when equals defend themselves against equals, that is honorable and necessary. But personal violence will be prevented.”

“That is good.”

“There is another advantage.

“If one guardian has a dispute with another, he can settle his anger immediately instead of allowing it to grow into something more dangerous.”

“Certainly.”

“The older citizens will be responsible for ruling and correcting the younger.”

“Clearly.”

“And there is no reason to fear that a younger person will strike or insult an older one unless the authorities specifically order it.

“There are two powerful guardians preventing such behavior: shame and fear.

“Shame prevents a person from attacking someone who stands to him in the place of a parent.

“And fear reminds him that the injured person will be supported by all the others who are his brothers, sons, or fathers.”

“That is true.”

“So in every way our laws will help citizens live peacefully with one another.”

“Yes. There will be no shortage of peace.”

“And since the guardians will not quarrel among themselves, there will be little danger of the rest of the city being divided against them or against one another.”

“None at all.”

“I hardly even want to mention the petty problems they will escape because those problems are beneath serious discussion.

“For example, the poor will not have to flatter the rich.

“They will not suffer the worries of raising a private family or finding money for household necessities.

“They will not have to borrow money and then avoid repaying it.

“They will not have to struggle to earn money and then hand it over to wives or slaves to manage.

“All these problems are obvious enough and not worth discussing.”

“Yes,” he said. “You do not even need eyes to see them.”

“And by escaping all these troubles, the guardians will live a blessed life—perhaps even more blessed than that of Olympic champions.”

“How so?”

“An Olympic champion is considered fortunate because he receives a small share of the happiness available to our citizens.

“Our guardians have won a far more important victory and receive complete support from the State.

“Their victory is the salvation of the whole State.

“The crown placed upon their heads, and upon the heads of their children, represents everything necessary for a good life.

“They receive rewards from their country during their lifetime, and after death they receive honorable burial.”

“Yes,” he said. “Those are magnificent rewards.”

“Do you remember that earlier, someone—let us not name him—accused us of making our guardians miserable?

“He said they had nothing, while other citizens could possess everything.

“We answered that perhaps we would discuss this later. But we said that, as things stood, our purpose was to make the guardians truly guardians and to build the State for the greatest happiness of the whole community, not for the happiness of one class.”

“Yes, I remember.”

“Now that we have shown the life of the guardians to be far better and nobler than that of Olympic champions, can the life of shoemakers, craftsmen, or farmers compare with it?”

“Certainly not.”

“But I should repeat something I said earlier.

“If one of our guardians tries to become happy in a way that makes him stop being a guardian—if he is dissatisfied with this safe, harmonious life, which we believe is the best of all lives, and becomes obsessed with the idea of taking the entire State for himself—then he will learn how wise Hesiod was when he said that half is better than the whole.”

“If he asked my advice,” I added, “I would tell him to stay exactly where he is when he has been offered such a life.”

“So you agree,” I said, “that men and women should share the kind of life we have described?

“They should share education and children.

“They should watch over the citizens together, whether inside the city or outside it.

“They should fight together and hunt together like dogs.

“In every way possible, women should share the duties of men.

“And by doing so, they will do what is best. They will not violate the natural relationship between the sexes but preserve it.”

“I agree,” he replied.

“Then we still have to ask whether such a community is actually possible among human beings, just as it is among animals.

“And if it is possible, how could it be achieved?”

“You have anticipated exactly what I was about to ask.”

“There is no great difficulty in seeing how they would fight wars together.”

“How?”

“They would go on military expeditions together.

“They would take their children with them if the children were strong enough.

“The children would watch their parents at work, just as the children of craftsmen watch and help their parents long before they are old enough to practise the craft themselves.

“They would not merely watch. They would help wherever they could.”

“Have you ever seen how potters' children watch their fathers and even help them before they are old enough to work the wheel?”

“Yes.”

“Then would potters be more careful to educate their children and give them experience of their future duties than our guardians would be?”

“That would be ridiculous.”

“There is also another effect. Like other animals, parents will be especially brave when their children are present.”

“That is true.

“But if they are defeated in battle,” he said, “there could be terrible consequences. The children could be killed along with their parents, and the State might never recover.”

“That is possible. But would you forbid them from ever taking risks?”

“I am not saying that.”

“If they must take risks, shouldn't they sometimes take them when surviving the danger would make them stronger and better?”

“Clearly.”

“And whether future soldiers see war while they are young is important enough that some reasonable risk may be justified.”

“Yes, very important.”

“Then our first step should be to let the children observe war.

“But we must also make every effort to protect them from danger. If we can do both, the result should be good.”

“True.”

“The parents should not be blind to the dangers. They should use whatever human foresight is available to distinguish safer expeditions from dangerous ones.”

“That seems reasonable.”

“And they should take the children on the safer expeditions while avoiding unnecessary risks.”

“Agreed.”

“They should also place the children under the command of experienced soldiers who can serve as both leaders and teachers.”

“Certainly.”

“Still, no one can predict every danger in war. There is always an element of chance.”

“True.”

“Then we must give the children a way to escape if things suddenly go wrong.”

“What do you mean?”

“I mean that they should learn to ride horses from a very young age.

“Then they can accompany the army on horseback and watch what will eventually become their own work.

“The horses should not be wild or aggressive. They should be calm, manageable, and fast.

“That way the children can see the fighting from a safe distance, and if danger comes, they can follow their experienced leaders and escape.”

“That seems sensible.”

“Now, regarding war, how should our soldiers treat one another and their enemies?

“I would suggest that a soldier who abandons his position, throws away his weapons, or commits some other act of cowardice should be removed from the guardian class and reduced to the rank of a farmer or craftsman.

“What do you think?”

“Absolutely.”

“And if a soldier allows himself to be captured, perhaps he should simply be handed over to the enemy. He has given himself to them, so they can do with him whatever they wish.”

“Certainly.”

“But what should we do with the hero who distinguishes himself in battle?”

“First,” I said, “he should receive honors from the younger soldiers. Each of them should crown him.”

“I approve.”

“And what about giving him the right hand of friendship?”

“I approve that too.”

“But you may not agree with my next suggestion.”

“What is it?”

“That he should be allowed to kiss and be kissed by them.”

“Certainly not!”

“I would go further,” I said. “No one whom the hero wishes to kiss should be allowed to refuse him while the campaign continues.

“If he has a lover among the soldiers, whether a young man or a young woman, this honor may make him even more eager to win the prize of courage.”

“Excellent,” I said. “We have already decided that brave men should have greater opportunities to father children.

“They should also have the first choice in such matters, so that they can have as many children as possible.”

“Agreed.”

“Homer gives us another example of how brave young soldiers should be honored.

“He tells us that Ajax, after distinguishing himself in battle, was rewarded with long portions of meat.

“That is an honor suitable to a young hero—not only a public reward, but also something that strengthens the body.”

“Very true.”

“Then Homer can be our teacher here.

“At sacrifices and other public occasions, we will honor brave men and women according to their courage.

“We will praise them with songs and give them the other honors we discussed, including places of honor, generous portions of food, and full cups.”

“That is excellent.”

“And when a man dies gloriously in battle, shall we not say that he belonged to the golden race?”

“Certainly.”

“Hesiod gives us authority for saying that after death such people become sacred spirits on earth, doing good, protecting people from evil, and watching over humanity.”

“Yes, we accept his authority.”

“Then we must ask the gods how the burial of such heroic and almost divine people should be arranged, and what special honors should be given to them.”

“Certainly.”

“In future generations, we will honor them and kneel at their tombs as we do at the graves of heroes.

“And not only those who die in battle. Anyone who is judged exceptionally good, whether he dies of old age or in some other way, will receive similar honors.”

“That is right.”

“Now how should our soldiers treat their enemies?”

“What aspect do you mean?”

“First, slavery.

“Do you think Greeks should enslave other Greeks, or allow other Greeks to enslave them if they can prevent it?

“Shouldn't they spare one another, especially because there is a danger that the entire Greek race could someday fall under the control of barbarians?”

“To spare them would certainly be better.”

“Then no Greek should be kept as a slave by another Greek.

“And our citizens should follow this rule and encourage other Greeks to do the same.”

“Certainly. In that way they would unite against the barbarians and stop fighting among themselves.”

“Now consider the dead.

“Should victorious soldiers take anything from the enemy except his weapons?

“Doesn't the habit of stripping the dead encourage soldiers to avoid the real fighting? Cowards hide around dead bodies pretending to be performing some useful task, and many armies have been ruined because soldiers cared more about plunder than victory.”

“Very true.”

“Isn't there something greedy and dishonorable about robbing a corpse?

“And isn't there something almost childish about attacking a dead body after the real enemy has already escaped?

“It is like a dog that cannot reach the man who threw a stone at it, so it turns around and attacks the stone.”

“Very much like a dog.”

“Then our soldiers must not strip the dead or prevent them from being buried.”

“Certainly not.”

“Nor should they dedicate the weapons of Greek enemies in the temples of the gods.

“Above all, they should not dedicate weapons taken from Greeks if they want to preserve good relations among Greeks.

“Indeed, we should fear that dedicating such trophies could be a kind of pollution unless the god himself commanded it.”

“Very true.”

“What about destroying Greek farmland or burning Greek houses?”

“What is your opinion?”

“Neither should be allowed.

“I would permit the taking of the year's harvest, but nothing more.”

“Why?”

“Because there is a difference between what we call ‘discord’ and what we call ‘war.’

“Discord is internal conflict within a people or community.

“War is conflict with foreigners.”

“That is a proper distinction.”

“And we can also say that the Greeks are connected to one another by blood and friendship, while the barbarians are foreign and different from us.”

“Very good.”

“Therefore, when Greeks fight barbarians, or barbarians fight Greeks, we will call it war.

“They are natural enemies.

“But when Greeks fight Greeks, we will say that Greece has fallen into disorder and internal conflict.

“Greeks are naturally friends, so this kind of hostility should be called discord.”

“I agree.”

“Now consider what happens when a city is divided by internal conflict.

“If both sides destroy one another's land and burn one another's houses, how wicked does the conflict become?

“No true patriot would want to tear apart the land that raised him, like a child attacking his own mother.

“The victorious side may perhaps take the defeated side's harvest, but even then they should think about peace and understand that the conflict should not continue forever.”

“Yes,” he said. “That is much more civilized.”

“And will not the city we are creating be a Greek city?”

“It should be.”

“And will its citizens be civilized and decent?”

“Certainly.”

“And will they love Greece and regard Greece as their own land, sharing its temples?”

“Absolutely.”

“Then when disagreements arise among them, they should regard them as internal discord, a quarrel among friends—not as war.”

“Certainly not war.”

“They will quarrel with the expectation that one day they will reconcile.”

“Exactly.”

“They will correct one another as friends do, but they will not enslave or destroy one another.

“They will act as correctors, not enemies.”

“Exactly.”

“And because they are Greeks themselves, they will not destroy Greek land or burn Greek houses.

“They will never regard an entire population—men, women, and children—as their enemies.

“They will understand that guilt belongs to the few who caused the conflict, while the majority remain their friends.

“For all these reasons, they will not want to destroy the land or houses of other Greeks.

“Their hostility will last only until the innocent majority has forced the guilty few to make amends.”

“I agree that our citizens should treat Greek enemies this way.

“And they should treat barbarians the way Greeks currently treat one another.”

“Then let us add this law to our constitution:

“Our guardians must never destroy Greek farmland or burn Greek houses.”

“Agreed. And we can also agree that this law, like the others, is a good one.”

“But Socrates,” he said, “if you continue like this, you are going to forget the question you pushed aside at the beginning.

“Is such a State actually possible? And if it is, how could it be brought into existence?

“I am willing to admit that if your State could actually exist, it would produce all kinds of benefits.

“I will even add something you have not mentioned.

“Your citizens would probably be the bravest warriors imaginable because every soldier would know the others personally. Each would call another father, brother, or son.

“And if the women joined the army, whether in the same ranks or behind them as support, or even simply as a threat to the enemy, I can imagine them becoming almost impossible to defeat.

“There are also many domestic advantages I could mention, and I accept all of them.

“But if this State could actually exist, then we need say no more about its benefits.

“Let us now return to the question of possibility and the practical means of creating it.”

“If I hesitate for even a moment,” I said, “you immediately attack me again.

“You have no mercy.

“I have barely escaped the first two waves, and now you are bringing the third upon me—the largest and most dangerous of all.

“Once you hear it, I think you will understand why I was afraid and hesitant to propose something so extraordinary.”

“The more you warn us,” he replied, “the more determined we are to hear it. So tell us immediately how such a State could possibly exist.”

“Let me begin by reminding you why we started this entire investigation.

“We were searching for justice and injustice.”

“True. But what does that have to do with this?”

“I want to ask whether, after discovering justice, we must demand that the perfectly just man exist in every detail, or whether it is enough to approximate perfect justice and make him more just than other people.”

“An approximation will be enough.”

“We were investigating perfect justice and the perfectly just man, and also perfect injustice and the perfectly unjust man, because we wanted an ideal.

“We could then use those ideals as standards for judging happiness and unhappiness according to how closely we resemble them.

“We were never trying to prove that such perfect examples must actually exist.”

“True.”

“Would a painter be a worse painter because, after creating a beautiful image of a perfectly beautiful man, he could not prove that such a man had ever existed?”

“Certainly not.”

“And weren't we doing the same thing when we created an ideal State?”

“Of course.”

“Then is our theory any worse simply because we cannot prove that such a State can actually exist?”

“Certainly not.”

“That is the truth.

“But if you insist that I try to show how such a State might be possible, and under what conditions it would be most likely to exist, then I need you to repeat something you already admitted.”

“What?”

“I want to know whether ideals can ever be perfectly expressed in words.

“Doesn't language often describe something more perfectly than reality can ever become?

“And doesn't reality, whatever we may imagine, always fall short of the ideal?”

“I agree.”

“Then you must not demand that I prove that an actual State will exactly match the ideal State in every detail.

“If I can show how a real city could be governed in something close to the way we described, you must accept that as enough to establish possibility.

“I would be satisfied with that. Will you be satisfied?”

“Yes.”

“Then I will try to show what flaw in existing States causes their bad government, and what smallest possible change could transform them into a better form.

“If possible, I want to identify only one change.

“If that is impossible, then perhaps two.

“In any case, I want the fewest and smallest changes possible.”

“Certainly.”

“I believe,” I said, “that there is one change that could reform the State.

“It is not small or easy, but it is possible.”

“What change?”

“Now I must face the greatest wave of all.

“I am going to say it even though it may overwhelm me with laughter and disgrace.

“Listen carefully.”

“Go on.”

“Until philosophers become kings, or the kings and rulers of this world genuinely embrace philosophy and possess its wisdom, and until political power and philosophy come together in the same people, while those who pursue one without the other are forced to step aside, there will be no end to the troubles of States—or of humanity.

“Only then will our State have any real chance of coming into existence and seeing the light of day.

“That is what I have wanted to say, my dear Glaucon, but I hesitated because it sounds so extraordinary.

“It is difficult to believe that happiness, either for individuals or for the public, can exist in any State unless this condition is met.”

“Socrates, what exactly do you mean?

“You should realize what you have just said.

“A great many people—and some of them highly respected—will react as though they had suddenly thrown off their clothes, grabbed the nearest weapon, and charged at you before you even know what is happening.

“If you cannot answer their objections quickly, they will tear your argument apart with their cleverness.”

“You got me into this situation,” I said.

“And I was right to do so. But now I will do everything I can to help you escape.

“I can offer you goodwill and advice. Perhaps I can also help you answer their questions better than anyone else.

“Now that you have such an ally, you must do your best to show the doubters that you are right.”

“I will certainly try,” I said, “especially since you are offering such valuable help.

“And I think that if we are going to have any chance of escaping this difficulty, we must first explain exactly whom we mean when we say that philosophers should rule.

“Then we can defend ourselves.

“We will discover that some people are naturally suited to philosophy and leadership, while others are not born to be philosophers and are better suited to following than leading.”

“Then define these people for me.”

“Follow me,” I said. “I hope I can explain it clearly enough.”

“Go ahead.”

“I am sure you remember that a true lover does not love only one part of the thing he loves. He loves the whole thing.”

“I do not understand. You will have to remind me.”

“Someone else might fairly say that. But a man who enjoys love as much as you do should understand.

“Anyone who has ever been young and in love knows that every attractive young person can awaken some kind of affection.

“One has a snub nose, and you call it charming.

“Another has a hooked nose, and you say it gives him a noble appearance.

“One has neither, and you praise the perfect balance of his features.

“A dark complexion looks strong and masculine.

“A fair complexion looks divine and youthful.

“And when someone has that soft golden complexion lovers call ‘honey-colored,’ what lover would complain about it?

“In short, a true lover will find an excuse to admire every kind of youthful beauty because he does not want to lose any of the flowers of youth.”

“If you want to treat me as an expert in love for the sake of the argument,” Glaucon said, “I accept.”

“And what about wine lovers?

“Don't they do the same thing? They find pleasure in almost any wine because they simply want wine.”

“Very true.”

“Ambitious men behave similarly.

“If they cannot command an army, they are happy to command a small group.

“If they cannot receive honors from great and important people, they will accept honors from less important people.

“But they must have honor of some kind.”

“Exactly.”

“Then let me ask again.

“When someone desires a particular class of things, does he desire the whole class or only a part?”

“The whole class.”

“Then we can say that a philosopher is not a lover of one small part of wisdom, but a lover of wisdom as a whole.”

“Yes.”

“And someone who dislikes learning, especially when young and therefore unable to judge what is genuinely good, cannot be called a philosopher or lover of knowledge.

“He is like someone who refuses food even when hungry. We would say that he has a poor appetite rather than a healthy one.”

“Very true.”

“But someone who enjoys every kind of knowledge, is curious about everything, and is never satisfied with learning—can we not properly call such a person a philosopher?”

Glaucon replied:

“If curiosity is enough to make someone a philosopher, then many strange people will qualify.

“All the people who love watching things enjoy learning and would have to be philosophers.

“Music lovers would also qualify, although they are often the last people who want to participate in serious philosophical discussion.

“Yet they rush to every musical festival, whether in the city or countryside, eager to hear every chorus.

“Are we really going to call all these people philosophers, along with people who practise minor arts?”

“Certainly not,” I replied. “They are only imitations of philosophers.”

“Then who are the true philosophers?”

“Those who love the sight of truth.”

“That sounds right. But what exactly do you mean?”

“To someone else, I might have difficulty explaining it. But I am sure you will accept what I am about to say.”

“What is it?”

“Beauty is the opposite of ugliness, so these are two different things.”

“Certainly.”

“And because they are two, each is one thing in itself.”

“True.”

“The same is true of justice and injustice, good and evil, and every other category.

“Each thing is one in itself.

“But when these things combine with actions, objects, and one another, they can appear in many different forms.”

“Very true.”

“And this is how I distinguish between people who love beautiful sights and practical activities and the people I call true philosophers.”

“How do you distinguish them?”

“Those who love sounds and sights enjoy beautiful tones, colors, shapes, and all the things artists create from them.

“But their minds cannot see or love beauty itself—the absolute beauty behind all beautiful things.”

“True.”

“Very few people are capable of seeing that.”

“Very true.”

“And if someone can recognize beautiful objects but cannot recognize absolute beauty itself—or cannot follow someone who leads him toward it—what should we call him?

“Is he awake or dreaming?

“Think carefully.

“Isn't a dreamer someone who confuses one thing with another, treating an image as though it were the real thing?”

“I would certainly call such a person a dreamer.”

“Now consider another person.

“He recognizes that absolute beauty exists. He can distinguish the idea of beauty itself from the particular objects that participate in it.

“He does not confuse the objects with the idea, or the idea with the objects.

“Is this person dreaming, or is he awake?”

“He is fully awake.”

“Then we can say that the mind of the person who truly knows possesses knowledge, while the mind of the person who merely believes possesses opinion.”

“Certainly.”

“Now suppose the second person argues against us.

“Can we give him some gentle advice without telling him that there is something seriously confused about his thinking?”

“We should certainly try to help him.”

“Then let us think of something to say.

“We can begin by welcoming whatever knowledge he actually possesses and congratulating him for having it.

“But then we should ask him a question:

‘When someone has knowledge, does he know something or nothing?’

“You must answer for him.”

“I will answer. He knows something.”

“Something that exists or something that does not exist?”

“Something that exists. How could anyone know what does not exist?”

“Exactly.

“After examining the question from every angle, can we say that what absolutely exists can be known with certainty, while what absolutely does not exist cannot be known at all?”

“Nothing could be more certain.”

“Good.

“But what if there is something that both exists and does not exist in some respect?

“Wouldn't that fall somewhere between pure existence and absolute non-existence?”

“Yes, between them.”

“And if knowledge corresponds to existence while ignorance corresponds to non-existence, then shouldn't there be some intermediate faculty between knowledge and ignorance for whatever lies between existence and non-existence?”

“Certainly.”

“Do we admit that such a faculty exists?”

“Of course.”

“Is it the same as knowledge, or is it different?”

“It is different.”

“Then knowledge and opinion must deal with different kinds of things, just as they are different faculties.”

“Yes.”

“Knowledge deals with what exists and knows the nature of what exists.”

“Yes.”

“Opinion is what we use when we merely form an opinion.”

“Yes.”

“And does opinion deal with the same subject matter as knowledge?”

“No. We have already ruled that out.

“If opinion and knowledge are different faculties, then their objects must also be different.”

“Exactly.”

“Then if existence is the object of knowledge, what is the object of opinion?”

“Something else.”

“Could it be non-existence?

“Or rather, can anyone have an opinion about nothing at all?

“When a person has an opinion, isn't it always an opinion about something?”

“Of course.”

“Then someone who has an opinion has an opinion about some particular thing.”

“Yes.”

“But non-existence is not a thing. Properly speaking, it is nothing.”

“True.”

“We said that ignorance corresponds to non-existence and knowledge corresponds to existence.”

“True.”

“Then opinion is concerned with neither existence nor non-existence.”

“That seems right.”

“Then opinion can be neither knowledge nor ignorance.”

“Apparently not.”

“Does that mean opinion is something outside both knowledge and ignorance, perhaps clearer than knowledge or darker than ignorance?”

“Neither.”

“Then perhaps opinion is darker than knowledge but clearer than ignorance.”

“Both, and by a considerable amount.”

“And therefore it lies between them?”

“Yes.”

“Then opinion is an intermediate faculty.”

“Certainly.”

“Earlier we said that if something both is and is not, it must lie between pure existence and absolute non-existence.

“And the faculty corresponding to that intermediate reality would have to lie between knowledge and ignorance.”

“True.”

“And now we have discovered that faculty. We call it opinion.”

“Exactly.”

“Then what remains is to identify the kind of object that is partly like existence and partly like non-existence.

“It cannot properly be called either one or the other in absolute terms.

“Once we discover it, we can call it the object of opinion.

“Then we can assign the extremes to the extreme faculties and the middle to the intermediate faculty.”

“Agreed.”

“Now let us return to the man who insists that there is no absolute or unchanging idea of beauty.

“He thinks beauty is simply a collection of many different beautiful things.

“He is the kind of person who loves beautiful sights but refuses to accept that beauty itself is one thing, just as justice itself is one thing.

“Let us ask him:

‘Can you name one beautiful thing that will never appear ugly from any point of view?

“Can you name one just thing that will never appear unjust in some respect?

“Can you name one holy thing that will never appear unholy from another perspective?’”

“No,” he would answer. “A beautiful thing can appear ugly in some respect, and the same is true of everything else.”

“And can't things that are called doubles also be halves?

“A thing can be double relative to one thing and half relative to another.”

“Certainly.”

“And things described as large or small, heavy or light, can also be called by their opposite names depending on what they are compared with.”

“True. Both the name and its opposite may apply.”

“Then can any of these many things be firmly said to be one thing rather than its opposite?”

“They are like those riddles people ask at banquets.

“Like the old puzzle about the eunuch throwing a stone at a bat: What did he hit it with, and what was the bat sitting on?

“These objects are similar riddles. They seem to have two meanings.

“You cannot firmly say that they are, or are not, or both, or neither.”

“Then what can we say about them?

“Where else can they belong except somewhere between existence and non-existence?

“They are clearly no darker or less real than non-existence, but they are also not as clear or as fully real as existence.”

“That is true.”

“Then we seem to have discovered that the many opinions people hold about beauty and other things exist somewhere between pure existence and pure non-existence.”

“Yes.”

“And earlier we agreed that anything of this kind belongs to opinion rather than knowledge.

“It is something that shifts between the two and is grasped by the intermediate faculty.”

“Exactly.”

“Then those who see many beautiful things but cannot see absolute beauty, and who cannot follow someone who points toward it; those who see many just things but cannot see justice itself, and so on—such people possess opinions, but not knowledge.”

“That is certain.”

“But those who can see what is absolute, eternal, and unchanging possess knowledge rather than mere opinion.”

“That cannot be denied.”

“Then one group loves and embraces the objects of knowledge, while the other loves the objects of opinion.

“The second group, as you may remember, are the people who enjoy beautiful sounds and colors but refuse to accept that absolute beauty exists.”

“Yes, I remember.”

“Then would it be wrong to call them lovers of opinion rather than lovers of wisdom?”

“Would they be angry with us for saying so?”

“I would tell them not to be angry. No one should be angry when someone tells the truth.”

“And those who love the truth itself in every subject should be called lovers of wisdom, not lovers of opinion.”

“Absolutely.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!