← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 66 · The Wild Ups and Downs of Wall Street

The Wild Ups and Downs of Wall Street

Chapter 66 of 90 · 3,852 words · Free

Wall Street has always been a place of dramatic reversals. Men who seemed unbeatable one year could be ruined the next. The best way to understand this is to look at the lives of the men who once dominated the market.

One of the earliest great names was Jacob Little.

Little had been trained in the office of Jacob Barker, the first major leader of Wall Street. In 1835, he began trading stocks for himself.

The Panic of 1837 made him famous and wealthy. He naturally expected prices to fall, so he had sold large amounts of stock short.

When the panic swept across the country, prices collapsed.

Little made a fortune.

From 1835 to 1846, he was at the height of his power. Nobody seriously challenged his position in Wall Street.

Then he suffered a major setback.

He joined a Boston group trying to control Norwich & Worcester Railroad stock. Little personally agreed not to sell his shares below $90.

He tried to push the stock higher.

But the stock refused to cooperate.

Little had to pay the penalty and sell his shares at whatever price he could get. He lost about a million dollars, an enormous fortune for that time.

It was the only major bull operation of his career, and it only made him more convinced that betting on falling prices was the safer game.

Not long afterward, he made an even more spectacular comeback.

He was heavily short of Erie stock when another group tried to corner the market. The group bought almost every available share and pushed the price higher and higher.

Everyone expected Little to panic.

He refused to buy back his short positions.

Wall Street watched him closely.

The common belief was that he would eventually be forced to cover at a huge loss and would probably be ruined.

But Little had a secret.

When the time came for him to deliver the shares, he calmly produced a large supply of new Erie certificates.

The cornerers were stunned.

Little had obtained the shares by exchanging the company's convertible bonds for stock. The existence of the conversion arrangement had been kept from the men who were trying to corner the market.

The corner collapsed.

The men who had engineered it were devastated, while Little walked away with a huge profit and an even greater reputation.

Yet Little went through several more failures on the bear side.

Each time, however, he eventually paid his debts from later profits.

He was also remarkably generous to people who owed him money. Instead of crushing them, he often accepted easy settlements and gave them time to recover.

That made him widely respected despite his aggressive style.

Little was a true-born speculator.

He loved the game itself.

He once explained his attitude simply:

“I care more for the game than the results. Winning or losing, I like to be in it.”

That passion kept him in Wall Street even after his money, influence, and health were largely gone.

By then he was little more than a famous name. He had no serious debts, but he had very little money.

Still, he continued trading small positions because he could not stay away from the market.

One morning he collapsed in the board room at Lord's Court.

He died not long afterward.

“I die poor,” he said.

But after his death, his family discovered that about $150,000 could still be collected from forgotten assets and unsettled accounts.

Little had never been interested in saving money for its own sake.

He valued money mainly because it allowed him to speculate.

His career was finally brought to an end by a much younger man, Anthony W. Morse.

While Little was betting on falling prices, Morse entered Wall Street as an aggressive bull.

Morse believed that the enormous amount of paper money being issued during the Civil War would drive stock prices much higher.

He was right.

And he acted with extraordinary confidence.

Morse had come to New York as a poor country boy.

He became a clerk in a brokerage office and later married a woman who had some money. She allowed him to speculate with part of it.

He did well enough to buy a seat on the Stock Exchange.

The seat cost only $500 at the time.

That was in 1862.

Until then, almost nobody in Wall Street had heard of him.

Then everything changed.

Morse began bidding aggressively for railroad stocks.

The old traders were shocked.

He first drove Cleveland & Pittsburgh higher.

Then he attacked Ohio & Mississippi, Rock Island, Erie, and Fort Wayne.

He moved Fort Wayne from 118 to 152 in a single day.

He pushed Pittsburgh from 65 to 108.

The market kept rewarding him.

Soon the entire Street was following him.

By early 1863, Morse was believed to have made at least $1.25 million.

His success lasted roughly two years.

Whenever he formed a pool, investors rushed to join it.

People crowded outside his office on William Street simply to hear what he was buying.

If Morse recommended a stock, many people bought it immediately.

They believed he could not be wrong.

Even other brokers followed him like ordinary customers.

The entire country seemed caught up in the speculation.

Morse was riding at the very top of the wave.

One evening, Morse bid 112 for 10,000 shares of Erie.

Daniel Drew sold them to him.

Morse then bid 112 for another 20,000 shares.

Drew sold those too.

A few days later, Drew had to buy the stock back at a heavy loss.

When Morse turned his attention to Ohio & Mississippi, he pushed it from 49 to 69 in only a few days.

Money was everywhere.

The wartime expansion of the currency made borrowing cheap and easy.

Stock speculation exploded.

Some brokerage firms even kept clerks working through the night.

Gold speculation became just as wild.

New mining and oil companies appeared everywhere.

Their stocks were traded at rapidly rising prices.

Even old, nearly worthless companies were brought back to life and promoted as exciting investments.

Clergymen bought stocks.

Women bought stocks.

Almost anyone could be drawn into the fever.

If a stock had the word “gold” in its name, people wanted it.

Morse was at the center of it all.

He pushed Rock Island from 106 to 149 and, in the process, bought virtually the entire 56,000-share capital stock.

But the end was approaching.

Treasury Secretary Salmon P. Chase decided to fight the enormous inflation and speculation in gold.

The government sold gold for currency and then locked much of that currency away in the Treasury.

Money suddenly became scarce.

Interest rates rose.

Banks began calling in loans.

Speculators who had borrowed heavily were forced to sell.

Unfortunately for Morse, this happened when he was carrying more stock than ever before.

He was already exhausted and in poor health.

When he tried to sell, his followers panicked.

They began selling too.

Prices collapsed.

On Monday, April 18, 1864, Fort Wayne plunged from 153 to 119 during the morning session.

Reading fell 19 percent.

Pittsburgh fell 17 percent.

Hudson River fell 23 percent.

Almost every active stock suffered a similar collapse.

Morse finally left the exchange.

He went back to his office and looked at his partner.

“The game is up,” he said.

A few minutes later, he sent word to the Exchange that Morse & Co. had suspended operations.

The great Wall Street leader was finished.

Thousands of customers were ruined because they had trusted him so completely.

Many of them rushed to his office and angrily blamed him for their losses.

That night, the Evening Exchange was filled with chaos.

A furious crowd gathered there and spilled into the Fifth Avenue Hotel.

Women were among those who had lost fortunes.

Across New York, families faced a night of fear and despair.

Morse disappeared from Wall Street for a year.

When he returned, he looked even more exhausted.

He died poor not long afterward.

Yet no one seriously accused him of dishonesty.

Because he had not been regarded as a cheat, he retained considerable sympathy.

Few Wall Street leaders had ever had more loyal friends.

Another major speculator of the period was John M. Tobin.

Tobin had once worked as a gatekeeper for Commodore Vanderbilt's ferry on Staten Island.

During the Morse boom, he became an important trader in both gold and stocks.

After Morse's collapse in 1864, Tobin became even more prominent.

He was known as Vanderbilt's agent in the famous Harlem corner.

The Harlem operation became one of the great episodes in Wall Street history.

During the winter of 1863–64, Harlem stock traded around 60.

Vanderbilt was a director and major shareholder, and he believed the railroad could become extremely valuable.

At the time, many people dismissed Harlem as little more than a railroad for carrying milk.

Vanderbilt wanted to change that.

He pushed the stock to 117 while seeking permission from New York City's Common Council to improve the railroad.

The councilmen appeared to support him.

Then they betrayed him.

They sold the stock short and withdrew their favorable resolution.

Harlem collapsed to 72.

The politicians had made money at Vanderbilt's expense.

Vanderbilt then took his case to Albany.

The state legislature appeared ready to approve a franchise allowing Harlem to lay tracks along Broadway.

The stock jumped to 150.

The legislators and their friends began selling it short.

They believed they had found an easy way to make money.

But Tobin kept buying Harlem for Vanderbilt.

On March 25, 1864, the legislature suddenly voted against the bill.

Harlem crashed to 101.

The short sellers celebrated.

They thought Vanderbilt had finally been defeated.

But Tobin continued buying.

The stock quickly recovered.

Within ten days, it was back at 150.

A week later, it reached 185.

For the next ten days, it moved between 175 and 200.

Daniel Drew sold calls on 30,000 shares because he believed the price could not remain so high.

Other professional traders also sold short.

Then the Morse panic struck in April.

Harlem fell with the rest of the market.

But it refused to collapse.

Tobin kept buying.

By May, Harlem had reached 300.

When 15,000 shares became due for delivery, the settlement price was 285.

Drew was forced to settle his short position by paying Tobin $1 million.

His total liability was said to have been $1.7 million.

Tobin's share of the profits was around $2 million.

That made him worth roughly $3 million.

Vanderbilt had won his revenge.

He eventually leased Harlem to the New York Central & Hudson at an 8 percent return on the stock.

The railroad became one of Vanderbilt's most valuable properties and remained a major asset of his descendants.

But Tobin's luck did not last.

After the Harlem corner, he made a huge bet on gold.

Even as Union victories suggested that the Civil War was nearing its end, Tobin pushed gold from 198 to 211.

Then gold collapsed.

Tobin lost more than $1.5 million.

After that came a series of disasters in the stock market.

Eventually he lost everything.

He even owed money to his brokers.

He withdrew from Wall Street and went to live with his sister on a farm on Staten Island.

He never returned to the Street.

His rise and fall had been extraordinary.

Addison G. Jerome experienced an equally dramatic career, although his time at the top was much shorter.

Jerome entered Wall Street in early 1863 after working in the dry-goods business.

Before the year was over, traders were calling him “the Napoleon of the public board.”

He was bold, active, and extremely successful.

He was also a friend and broker of John Tobin.

The two men worked together during the Harlem operation.

Jerome made a fortune from the rise from 60 to 117 and then made even more during Vanderbilt's battle with the Albany legislators.

For a time, almost everything Jerome touched seemed to turn into money.

Then he made one fatal mistake.

He began buying Michigan Southern Railroad stock with a group of associates.

He gained control of the stock and pushed the price higher.

Jerome thought he had the situation completely under control.

But Henry Keep, the company's treasurer, knew something Jerome did not.

The company's charter allowed its directors to increase the number of shares.

Keep secretly arranged for the board to issue 14,000 new shares.

He then sold the stock short against those new shares.

Jerome assumed Keep was simply another large short seller.

So Jerome and his group bought even more stock and pushed the price higher.

Keep kept selling.

Finally, Jerome demanded that the short sellers return the stock.

He expected them to be forced to buy at high prices.

Instead, Keep delivered the newly issued 14,000 shares.

The sudden supply crushed the market.

Michigan Southern fell 20 percent in a single day.

Jerome lost almost all of the roughly $3 million he had made.

His career as a Wall Street leader was over.

He was still respected as an honest man, but the loss devastated him.

He became ill and died the following year.

Fortunately, during his nine months of extraordinary success, he had put enough money in his wife's hands to protect her from poverty.

His rise and fall were astonishingly fast, even by Wall Street standards.

Jerome's younger brother, Leonard W. Jerome, also became a major Wall Street figure.

Leonard was prominent not only in finance but also in New York society.

In 1863, he owned a large amount of Hudson River Railroad stock.

The bears had pushed the stock down to 107.

Jerome formed a powerful group and began buying.

Eventually he controlled almost the entire capital stock.

Then he slowly pushed the price to 175.

The stock became so scarce that Jerome could lend shares to short sellers at five percent interest per day.

The shorts had no choice.

They had to buy back their positions at enormous losses.

Jerome reportedly made several million dollars from the squeeze.

His wealth and reputation grew together.

He soon became a major figure in both Wall Street and New York society.

Then he turned to Pacific Mail.

Pacific Mail had enormous earnings during the Civil War period.

A group of investors had acquired most of its shares and selected Leonard Jerome to push the stock higher.

He did exactly that.

The stock rose to 160 within thirteen months.

A large short interest developed.

Jerome pushed it to 200 and held it there until the short sellers finally settled.

By 1865, Pacific Mail had increased its capital from $4 million to $10 million.

Yet the stock traded at 240 and paid a 20 percent annual dividend.

The following year, the capital was doubled again to $20 million.

The stock still traded around 180.

Jerome remained confident.

But in 1867, Pacific Mail became his Waterloo.

The company's earnings fell sharply.

Its reported assets dropped from $34 million to $22 million.

Government money was being withdrawn from circulation.

The enormous expansion of the company's stock was beginning to hurt.

Jerome had also agreed to buy shares from the old five-year combination at 160.

Then the general stock market weakened.

Pacific Mail collapsed under heavy selling.

In only a few days, it plunged from 163 to 115.

Jerome was overwhelmed.

He lost almost everything except some real estate.

After that, he no longer had any influence in Wall Street.

He soon left the market entirely.

He eventually died poor at the London home of his daughter, Lady Randolph Churchill.

Pacific Mail had destroyed the fortune and influence he had spent years building.

Another man who rose and fell through Pacific Mail was Alden B. Stockwell.

By 1871, Pacific Mail had become a badly damaged company.

Its stock had fallen into the 40s.

The existing directors had little stock themselves, so they decided to step aside.

A new board took control in November 1871, with Stockwell becoming president.

At that time, almost nobody in Wall Street knew him.

He had once worked as a steamboat clerk on Lake Erie.

Later, he married the daughter of Elias Howe, the famous sewing-machine inventor, and gained considerable wealth.

Stockwell came to Wall Street to see what he could accomplish.

When he saw Pacific Mail trading in the 40s, he began buying aggressively.

Then people discovered that he had quietly acquired enough shares and voting proxies to choose his own directors.

He elected himself and his chosen board with 118,000 votes.

Almost overnight, he became “Commodore Stockwell.”

His fellow directors followed his wishes so closely that critics jokingly called them a dummy board.

Stockwell also gained control of the Panama Railway.

Then he began promoting Pacific Mail again.

He made glowing predictions about the company's future.

Even while the company's ships were suffering repeated disasters, Stockwell claimed that Pacific Mail had greatly expanded its property and was earning more than 11 percent a year above its government subsidy.

He predicted that the company would soon be able to pay a 12 percent dividend.

The market believed him.

Pacific Mail climbed from around 40 to roughly 107.

Stockwell became the sensation of Wall Street.

He was now a wealthy social celebrity.

He owned a huge house on Madison Avenue and one of the city's finest carriages.

Yet he had been a Wall Street “commodore” for less than a year.

Stockwell expanded his operations.

He took an interest in Boston, Hartford & Erie.

He also bought 30,000 shares of Atlantic & Pacific preferred stock at 25, even though there were serious questions about whether the stock had been legally issued.

For a while, the stock traded actively at prices far above what Stockwell had paid.

Then confidence disappeared.

Boston, Hartford & Erie collapsed.

Atlantic & Pacific collapsed.

Pacific Mail suffered further losses and declining earnings.

Bears attacked all three stocks at once.

Stockwell could no longer support them.

His profits vanished.

He became entangled in a dispute involving 27,000 shares of Pacific Mail treasury stock.

A settlement followed.

Stockwell reportedly gave the company a $1.14 million note backed by the Howe Sewing Machine Company.

At the next election, he lost the presidency.

He also lost his positions with the Panama Railroad and Atlantic & Pacific.

His money and prestige were gone.

Nobody cared about him anymore.

He survived for a time as a small-scale speculator and eventually failed for a relatively small amount as a member of the Consolidated Exchange.

Stockwell later joked about how quickly Wall Street had changed its opinion of him.

“When I first came into Wall Street,” he said, “people asked, ‘Who is that man Stockwell?’”

“After I made money bulling Pacific Mail, I became ‘Mr. Stockwell.’”

“When I became president of Pacific Mail, I was ‘Commodore Stockwell’ and a great Wall Street leader.”

“But when Pacific Mail broke and broke me, I became ‘that red-headed cuss Stockwell.’”

That was Wall Street in a nutshell.

But no story better illustrates the extreme rise and fall of a Wall Street speculator than Daniel Drew.

Drew enjoyed enormous success for many years.

Then he lost everything and died bankrupt.

His early success was remarkable because he was barely educated.

He had been a cattle drover and later ran the Bull's Head Tavern at the New York cattle yards.

He knew nothing about banking or the Stock Exchange.

He did not even read newspapers.

Yet he began making money almost immediately.

He invested in Hudson River steamboats and eventually owned large interests in them.

Although he knew little about running steamships, his investments were highly profitable.

His natural shrewdness also made him a successful stock speculator.

Eventually he became a partner in a Stock Exchange firm called Drew & Robinson.

For years, the firm prospered.

At the height of his career, Drew was believed to be worth $20 million.

He once corrected that estimate.

“I guess sixteen will cover it,” he said.

But his judgment gradually deteriorated.

He suffered one bad loss after another.

At the same time, he became increasingly generous to Methodist institutions, including Drew Theological Seminary.

Unfortunately, he often made his donations with promissory notes instead of cash.

He paid interest on those notes.

When his fortune finally disappeared, the notes became worthless.

Drew eventually became bankrupt.

He had no assets and depended on his son for a home.

When he died, almost nobody in Wall Street noticed.

Once his money was gone, he had largely disappeared from people's minds.

Few men ever traveled as far upward or downward in Wall Street as Daniel Drew.

Charles F. Woerishoffer also made a large fortune from stock speculation.

He eventually lost most of it because he remained aggressively bearish for too long after the Panic of 1884.

James R. Keene arrived in New York with several million dollars earned from California mining stocks during the great Bonanza discoveries.

But he later lost his fortune by overextending himself in stocks and grain.

He eventually found another opportunity.

Large financial interests hired him to manipulate stocks for them.

After several more reversals, he became wealthy again.

Henry N. Smith, once a partner of Jay Gould, made five or six million dollars in Wall Street.

He eventually lost it all and died poor.

Ferdinand Ward also became famous.

He persuaded General Ulysses S. Grant to join him in the firm of Grant & Ward.

Ward rose rapidly.

Then his entire operation collapsed.

He eventually ended up in Sing Sing Prison.

Fish, president of the Marine Bank, suffered a similar fate after years of being respected.

There were also men such as the Vanderbilts, Jay Gould, Russell Sage, Henry Keep, Henry Villard, and William E. Travers.

Their careers had serious setbacks, but none experienced quite the total collapse seen in some of these other cases.

John F. Tracy, president of the Rock Island Railroad during the 1860s, was different.

He had once been worth more than $5 million.

Stock speculation destroyed his fortune.

He had to give up his railroad presidency and eventually died in poverty.

Cyrus W. Field also lost nearly all of his fortune after taking on too much Manhattan Railway stock.

Addison Cammack, one of the great bears of Wall Street, died with only a small fraction of the wealth he had once possessed.

Wall Street's violent reversals can also be seen in the great market disasters themselves.

The Black Friday gold conspiracy of September 24, 1869, caused enormous losses and forced the Stock Exchange, the Gold Clearing House, and the Gold Exchange Bank to close.

The Northern Pacific panic of May 9, 1901, caused another devastating collapse.

The Panic of 1873 caused damage that lasted for years.

The failure of Jay Cooke & Co. at the beginning of that panic became as memorable as the collapse of the Ohio Life and Trust Company, which had helped trigger the Panic of 1857.

All these stories teach the same lesson.

Making money in Wall Street can sometimes seem easy.

Losing it is even easier.

A successful speculator needs courage, but courage without caution can be fatal.

In the pursuit of money, boldness must always be balanced by restraint.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!