Recent Wall Street Booms
Wall Street experienced one of its strongest booms after McKinley was elected president. What made this boom unusual was how quiet it was.
Stock prices rose sharply, and many companies were worth more than ever. Normally, a market like this would have created tremendous excitement. Newspapers would have been filled with stories, and the whole country would have been talking about Wall Street.
But that did not happen.
The reason was simple. This boom was built on real prosperity. The entire country was growing. Farmers were making money, merchants were busy, factories were expanding, miners were producing more, and workers were earning more. Wall Street was not creating the prosperity. It was simply reflecting it.
There was another important difference. No single man stood at the center of the boom.
In earlier bull markets, everyone knew who the leading operator was. One powerful man would openly push stocks higher, and the public would watch his every move.
This time, things were different.
The manipulation was quiet, organized, and difficult to see. Everyone could tell that powerful forces were moving the market, but only a handful of people knew exactly who was behind them.
The strongest force was the Standard Oil group.
They brought the same style to Wall Street that they had used in their other businesses. They did not make dramatic moves or seek publicity. They simply used enormous resources and moved steadily toward their objectives.
Compared with them, the great operators of the past looked almost like beginners.
Jay Gould had always faced the possibility of failure. Commodore Vanderbilt, powerful as he was, had sometimes been forced into desperate fights to protect his position. Every great speculator had known what it meant to take a real risk.
The Standard Oil men operated differently.
Their resources were so enormous that once they decided to concentrate on a company or a property, they had the power to shape its future.
They worked quietly.
There were no spectacular displays. No screaming headlines. No wild scenes on the exchange.
They simply bought, sold, financed, reorganized, and accumulated—slowly and steadily.
Their financial power was almost impossible to measure. Many of the strongest banks and financial institutions were available to them when they needed money or credit.
With that kind of power, they could potentially make enormous sums whether the market was rising or falling.
Fortunately for the public, their operations during this period were mainly directed toward higher prices. Combined with the country's growing prosperity, this helped many people in Wall Street make money.
There were certainly losers, but their losses were small compared with the enormous amount of money being made throughout the Street.
The previous Wall Street boom had been completely different.
That boom had centered on one man.
That man was Roswell P. Flower, the former governor of New York.
Flower was one of the most colorful characters Wall Street had ever seen.
He did not look like a Wall Street leader.
His clothes often hung loosely on him like sacks. His hat was rarely brushed. He sometimes went several days without shaving. He usually had a huge piece of chewing tobacco stuffed into one side of his mouth.
His office needed plenty of spittoons.
He had never received a college education, and his speech was blunt rather than polished.
Yet these things actually helped him.
People trusted him because he did not look or talk like a polished financier. He seemed direct and honest.
His simple way of thinking also allowed him to concentrate on business without getting lost in complicated theories.
Flower had entered Wall Street about twenty-five years earlier, when he became manager of the estate of his brother-in-law, Henry Keep.
He handled a large amount of money and increased it substantially through conservative investments.
He did not become a major speculator until after leaving the governor's office.
When he returned to Wall Street, he came back with enormous prestige.
He had another advantage.
During his years as governor, he had made friends with powerful men in both political parties. Republicans liked him. Democrats liked him. Many wealthy businessmen also had close relationships with him.
Once he returned to business, Flower selected several stocks as his specialties.
He began buying them aggressively.
The stocks rose.
Then they became stronger and more active.
The bears repeatedly attacked him, trying to force prices down.
But every time they pushed him back, Flower fought his way forward again.
Eventually, he decided to take on Brooklyn Rapid Transit.
That move created one of the wildest stock-market advances Wall Street had ever seen.
Flower began buying the stock around $6.
Before long, he had driven it above $138.
Politicians across New York suddenly appeared to be millionaires on paper.
Wall Street reporters loved Flower. Their enthusiastic newspaper stories helped make his reputation even bigger.
As Brooklyn Rapid Transit rose, other stocks began rising with it.
Soon almost everything in Wall Street was moving higher.
The bears would attack, but every attack seemed to make the stocks stronger.
Flower constantly preached confidence in America.
His message was simple: if a company was based in America and had real property behind it, investors could buy its stock with confidence.
For a while, almost everyone believed him.
Then something happened that probably saved Wall Street from a much worse disaster.
Roswell P. Flower suddenly died.
He had gone to the country for a short rest.
He ate a heavy meal of ham and radishes and drank a large amount of ice water.
A few hours later, he died from acute indigestion.
If Flower had lived another month, the boom might have ended in a devastating panic.
His death stopped the machine before it could completely destroy itself.
Rockefeller, Vanderbilt, and other wealthy men immediately stepped into the market.
They poured millions of dollars into stocks and tried to keep prices from collapsing.
They argued that Flower's death should not change the value of good companies.
Newspapers repeated this argument, and it helped calm the market.
Instead of a complete collapse, Wall Street experienced a serious but manageable decline.
The small speculators were not so lucky.
Most of them had bought stocks on margin and were wiped out.
Many politicians and smaller operators who had expected to leave the market with comfortable fortunes lost everything instead.
It may be the only example in Wall Street history where the death of a major operator prevented a much larger financial disaster.
There was another strange force behind Flower's boom.
It involved young Joseph Leiter.
Leiter had tried to corner the wheat market and had eventually gone broke.
But before he failed, he had driven wheat from around sixty cents a bushel to well above one dollar.
That made a huge difference to American farmers.
Thousands of wheat growers were suddenly able to sell their crops at much higher prices.
They used the money to pay off hundreds of millions of dollars in farm mortgages.
Most of those mortgages were held by Eastern investors.
As farmers paid them off, enormous amounts of Eastern capital became available for new investments.
Then Flower's Wall Street boom provided a perfect place for that money to go.
The result was another powerful force pushing stock prices higher.
Around the same period, J. Pierpont Morgan was becoming one of the most important financial figures in America.
Morgan had started his career as a clerk at the famous banking house of Duncan, Sherman & Co.
Later he became associated with Anthony J. Drexel, one of the richest bankers in America.
Their partnership eventually produced Drexel, Morgan & Co., with Morgan running the New York operation.
After Drexel died, Morgan took control of the business.
When his father later died, Morgan also became head of the London banking house of J. S. Morgan & Co.
He was now in an extraordinary position.
Morgan soon demonstrated his power through railroad reorganizations.
One of his first major successes came when he reorganized the bankrupt Richmond and West Point Terminal Railway and Warehouse Company.
He renamed it the Southern Railway.
He then brought several smaller railroads into the system.
Many of these companies were nearly bankrupt and badly managed.
Morgan combined them into a single organization under centralized management.
He next turned his attention to the Reading and Erie railroads.
Both were in serious trouble.
Morgan imposed order on their chaotic finances, and the improvement helped create a new boom in railroad stocks.
Not everyone welcomed his methods.
Some major shareholders fought him because they believed his restructuring plans were too severe.
But investors who followed Morgan generally made money.
Another remarkable Wall Street operation had been carried out by S. V. White, better known as Deacon White because he was a deacon at Plymouth Church.
White was one of the oldest and most colorful operators in the Street.
He had made several great fortunes through speculation—and lost them again.
Even after turning seventy, he continued to trade actively every day.
But one of the strangest deals of all involved Joseph Bannigan, president of the Rubber Trust.
Bannigan had started life as an uneducated Irish immigrant.
He began working in a New England rubber factory for $1.50 a day.
Through intelligence, hard work, and careful saving, he eventually became worth about $5 million.
By the time the Rubber Trust was formed, he controlled one of the largest rubber factories in Providence.
His knowledge of the business was so valuable that he was made president of the trust.
He owned about 40,000 shares.
Eventually, Bannigan became convinced that the other powerful men in the trust were treating him unfairly.
He decided to sell everything.
He put all 40,000 shares into a bag, took the night boat from Providence to New York, and went straight to a stockbroker.
He told the broker exactly what he wanted.
“I want to sell everything,” Bannigan said. “All 40,000 shares. Here they are. Put them on the market.”
The broker shook his head.
“You can't do that.”
“Why not?”
“If you dump 40,000 shares on the market, you'll destroy the price. You won't get anything close to their real value.”
Bannigan frowned.
“Then what am I supposed to do?”
“Buy.”
“Buy? I already own more stock than I want.”
“That doesn't matter. You have to buy more first. That will create a market. Then you can sell your original holdings later.”
“How much do I have to buy?”
“About $250,000 worth.”
“I don't have $250,000.”
“You can borrow it. A man in your position won't have trouble borrowing that much.”
Bannigan hated the idea, but eventually agreed.
About two weeks later, the broker contacted him again.
“You need to buy another $200,000 worth.”
Bannigan was furious.
But once again, he borrowed the money and followed the broker's instructions.
The strategy worked.
The broker quietly began buying and selling Rubber Trust stock.
Some days he bought heavily.
Other days he sold.
His goal was to keep the stock active and make it look as though strong investors were interested.
Soon the insiders noticed the buying.
They did not know that Bannigan was behind it.
They assumed a powerful investor was secretly accumulating the stock.
Then the insiders noticed something else.
The broker had begun borrowing large quantities of Rubber Trust shares.
That suggested there was a large short position somewhere.
The insiders decided to attack the shorts.
They joined together and began forcing the price higher.
The stock eventually reached $61.
By then, Bannigan had quietly sold all his original shares.
He was now sitting on a huge amount of cash.
The insiders, meanwhile, were holding the shares they had bought from him.
They did not realize what had happened until it was too late.
They thought they were buying shares from short sellers.
Instead, they had been buying Bannigan's stock.
Then the market collapsed.
Rubber fell from $61 to $16.
Bannigan had escaped with his fortune.
The insiders were left holding the stock.
It was almost a perfect Wall Street comedy.
But deals like this were rare.
Most newcomers who entered Wall Street and enjoyed a spectacular rise eventually gave much of it back.
A. B. Stockwell was a perfect example.
At one time, Stockwell was worth many millions.
He had started life as a purser on a Lake Erie steamboat. His father was reportedly a livery-stable owner in Cleveland.
During one of his trips, Stockwell met Elias Howe, the inventor associated with the sewing machine.
Howe was traveling with his daughter.
Stockwell paid close attention to both of them.
He eventually won the daughter's affection and married her.
When Elias Howe died, Mrs. Stockwell inherited his fortune.
That money gave Stockwell the capital he needed to enter Wall Street.
He quickly became one of the most talked-about men in the financial district.
He invested his wife's entire fortune in Pacific Mail.
Then he gained control of the company and made himself president.
At first he was simply Stockwell.
Then people began calling him Mr. Stockwell.
After he took control of Pacific Mail, he became known as Commodore Stockwell.
Everyone wanted to be his friend.
Stockwell bought Pacific Mail around $40 and drove it to $107.
At that point, his paper fortune exceeded $15 million.
But there was one problem.
Pacific Mail was not really worth $107.
When Stockwell finally tried to sell, he discovered that there were not enough buyers.
The market simply disappeared beneath him.
Then his lenders began demanding repayment of his loans.
He had no choice but to sell.
His forced selling pushed the stock lower and lower.
The decline became a vicious circle.
Eventually Pacific Mail fell all the way back to the price where Stockwell had originally started buying.
His paper profits disappeared.
So did his wife's inheritance.
He lost everything.
It became the most famous Pacific Mail boom of its time, even though Leonard Jerome had previously produced several spectacular rises and collapses in the same stock.
Leonard Jerome and his brother Addison had repeatedly made fortunes trading Pacific Mail.
Then they suffered the same fate as Stockwell.
The two brothers went from being among Wall Street's richest and most glamorous operators to being practically ruined.
Leonard Jerome was the father of Lady Randolph Churchill.
When he died, there was little left for his daughter except an interest in the house later occupied by the Manhattan Club on Madison Avenue.
That property produced about $15,000 a year, of which Lady Churchill received $10,000.
These were only a few of the great booms that had shaken Wall Street over the years.
There had also been the Keene boom, the Gould boom, the Vanderbilt boom, and many others.
They all followed the same basic pattern.
Fortunes were made quickly.
Confidence grew.
Prices seemed capable of rising forever.
Then the market turned.
And when it did, the paper fortunes of yesterday could disappear almost overnight.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!