Villard’s Big Railroad Gamble
When Henry Villard returned to Wall Street after two years in Germany, people immediately became interested in him again. He had been one of the boldest speculators of his time.
His career from 1879 to 1884 showed just how far a clever operator could go in building a financial empire out of very little real capital.
The most spectacular episode was his famous “blind pool” and his attempt to take control of Northern Pacific.
Villard followed many of the same tactics that had made Cornelius Vanderbilt so successful. There was one crucial difference, however.
Vanderbilt usually finished his campaigns as the winner.
Villard did not.
Villard had played a leading role in creating the Oregon Railway and Navigation Company. The new company was designed to combine the Oregon Steam Navigation Company with the Oregon Steamship Company and to buy, build, and operate railroads.
Its lines ran west from Portland to Wallula Junction.
But Northern Pacific posed a serious threat. The company planned to extend its railroad westward and establish a terminal at Tacoma.
Villard offered Northern Pacific a deal. He suggested that Northern Pacific use the Oregon Railway and Navigation lines to reach the Pacific Coast.
Northern Pacific president Frederick Billings rejected the proposal.
That was when Villard decided to use the old Vanderbilt strategy.
If he could not cooperate with Northern Pacific, he would try to control it.
Villard organized a secret buying pool, known as a “blind pool.” Among the original members were Woerishoffer, Pullman, Endicott, and many other wealthy investors.
They initially subscribed $8 million to buy Northern Pacific stock.
Throughout the spring of 1881, the pool quietly bought shares.
They kept buying through the summer.
But by the middle of the year, something had gone badly wrong.
The pool had nearly spent all its money, yet it still did not control Northern Pacific.
Villard called a meeting of the investors.
“We have not reached our goal yet,” he told them. “But the opportunity is far greater than we originally expected.”
He proposed expanding the pool and bringing in more members.
Then he explained the enormous profits that could be made if they succeeded.
His argument worked.
The investors put up another $12 million.
With that additional money, Villard finally gained control of Northern Pacific.
In September 1881, he was elected president of the railroad.
Almost overnight, Villard went from being a daring speculator to one of the most powerful railroad magnates in America.
To the public, his rise seemed almost miraculous.
Northern Pacific stock shot upward.
Villard and his associates appeared to be making millions at an astonishing rate.
For a while, he seemed to have achieved the financial dreams of Monte Cristo.
He was rapidly becoming a serious rival to Gould, Vanderbilt, and Huntington.
Villard pushed ahead with the construction of Northern Pacific.
Two years after he gained control, the railroad was completed.
His extraordinary success encouraged him to expand into other investments.
His personal spending also changed dramatically.
The man who had once lived very carefully now spent money freely.
He even built a magnificent mansion on Madison Avenue at Fiftieth Street.
Everything seemed to be going his way.
Then the whole picture suddenly changed.
Villard became financially embarrassed.
When the accounts for completing Northern Pacific were finally examined, there was a huge hole in the finances.
The railroad was about $20 million short.
Villard had an explanation.
“Our engineers estimated that the railroad would cost $20 million to complete,” he said.
“But the actual cost turned out to be $40 million.”
The investors in the blind pool had put up $20 million in all.
In return, they received stock in the Oregon & Transcontinental Company.
That company had been created to build branch lines connecting with Northern Pacific, because Northern Pacific’s charter did not allow it to build those lines itself.
That was the short version of Villard’s spectacular rise and collapse.
But his earlier railroad dealings were just as remarkable.
Before Northern Pacific, Villard had already shown extraordinary skill at creating the appearance of wealth where very little real wealth existed.
In the art of “watering” railroad stock, he had few equals.
George I. Seney was perhaps the only man who could match him.
Villard’s takeover of the Oregon Steam Navigation Company and the Oregon Steamship Company provides a good example.
When Villard first proposed buying the two companies, he had virtually no money.
What he did have was enormous confidence in his own ability.
He approached both companies with an unusual proposal.
“Give me an option to run your businesses for one year,” he said. “I will pay you $100,000.”
They agreed.
Villard then approached a group of wealthy investors.
Together, they organized the Oregon Railway & Navigation Company.
The name sounded impressive.
The company itself was another matter.
It had virtually no assets.
And at that moment, there was little reason to believe it could acquire any.
The organizers included Henry Villard, James H. Fry, Artemus H. Holmes, Christian Bors, W. H. Starbuck, and Charles E. Brotherton of New York, along with W. H. Corbett, C. N. Lewis, J. N. Dolph, Paul Schulze, and N. Thielson of Portland, Oregon.
The company declared a capital stock of $6 million, divided into 60,000 shares.
This arrangement was completed in June 1879.
But one major problem remained.
How was this new company going to get the money it needed to operate?
Villard and his directors quickly found an answer.
A few days after the company was organized, the directors met in Portland.
They arranged a mortgage with the Farmers’ Loan and Trust Company of New York.
Against that mortgage, they issued 6,000 bonds, each with a face value of $1,000.
The bonds were due thirty years later and paid 6 percent interest.
Villard then paid the $100,000 promised to the two original companies.
In exchange, he received his options, stock, and bonds.
He took the securities east and began looking for investors.
According to the story, Villard first showed them to Jay Gould.
Gould refused.
He apparently believed the new enterprise was too weak to be worth the trouble.
He also understood that the project would bring Villard into conflict with Northern Pacific.
Gould wanted no part of that fight.
Villard had better luck elsewhere.
Mr. Endicott of Boston, George Pullman, and several other wealthy investors became interested.
The actual property of the two companies was not purchased by the new company until March of the following year.
By then, the financial structure was already extraordinary.
The Oregon Railway and Navigation Company had visible assets of no more than $3.5 million.
Yet its total liabilities had reached $21 million.
The figures were roughly these:
Original stock: $6 million.
Watered stock: $3 million.
Additional watered stock: $6 million.
Mortgage bonds: $6 million.
In other words, the company carried about seven dollars of liabilities for every dollar of actual assets.
Its stock had no real positive value.
By the author's calculation, its intrinsic value was actually 20 percent below zero.
Yet Villard managed to get the stock listed on the Stock Exchange.
Then he produced a carefully prepared report showing spectacular earnings.
The market responded.
The stock was pushed all the way up to 200.
Only after the price had reached that extraordinary level did Villard release another $9 million of watered stock into the market.
This was the first major demonstration of Villard's method.
He would build up the appearance of enormous value and then issue still more paper securities against it.
That was the preparation for his much larger manipulation of Northern Pacific.
Villard's methods were even more aggressive than those of George I. Seney.
Seney had poured large amounts of watered stock into his companies during the reorganization, before the stocks were listed on the Stock Exchange.
Villard took the idea one step further.
He used Seney's method at the beginning.
Then, after the stock had already been pushed to extremely high levels, he continued issuing large quantities of additional stock.
It was an extraordinary way to manufacture the appearance of wealth.
Few examples in railroad history show a man presenting such a convincing picture of solid financial strength when so little genuine capital actually existed.
Villard had started with almost nothing in 1879.
Within a year, through a series of clever financial maneuvers, he had acquired control of railroad securities backed by about $3.5 million in assets.
Then he used that small foundation to build an enormous empire.
Within five years, he had temporarily gained control of railroad properties with a combined value of more than $1 billion.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!