Wall Street Before the Panic of 1907
The panic of 1903 left New York banks with enormous cash reserves. By August 1904, their surplus reserves had reached an extraordinary level. In 1905, however, speculation came roaring back. Stock prices climbed to new highs, while bank loans and deposits reached records never seen before.
The boom was not limited to Wall Street. Trade, real estate, mining, and countless other speculative ventures were expanding rapidly across the country. Bank clearings exceeded all previous records.
Foreign imports also surged to new highs, although exports did not grow at the same pace. The huge import bill was a sign of widespread prosperity. Wealthy Americans, recovering from the losses of 1903, began spending freely again.
Imports were a useful measure of the nation's economic mood. In good times, Americans bought large quantities of foreign goods, especially luxuries. In bad times, imports collapsed because people quickly cut back on expensive purchases.
By the end of 1905, banks throughout the country were reporting record deposits and loans. Earlier in the year, their main record had been the amount of cash they held. Now the picture had changed.
Money was being demanded everywhere.
Trade was expanding rapidly.
Speculation was spreading rapidly.
And businesses were borrowing heavily to keep up.
Early in 1905, heavy exports of gold had reduced the amount of money available for loans. But by December 1, the government had allowed national banks to issue another $60 million in bank notes.
That was like pouring more fuel onto a fire.
The new money did not flow mainly into Wall Street. Much of it went into the interior of the country, where people were launching new businesses and speculative ventures of every description.
Almost everyone who had enough money to make an investment seemed to believe there was a quick road to riches.
The West and South were especially active. Bank clearings in nearly every part of the country, except New York, reached record levels. Iron production also reached a new high, and foreign imports continued to climb.
The nation's gold reserves were rising as well.
Early in 1905, the Treasury held about $193 million in government-owned gold. By the end of the year, that figure had risen to more than $291 million.
Including gold held against outstanding gold certificates, the Treasury controlled more than $816 million—the largest gold reserve ever held by the United States government and, at that time, the largest held by any government or institution in the world.
The contrast with 1895 was remarkable.
In January 1895, the Treasury held only about $97 million in gold. By February, the reserve had fallen to just over $41 million as people rushed to exchange paper money for gold.
There was a real fear that the government might be forced to suspend gold payments.
President Cleveland prevented that disaster by selling government bonds for gold to the Morgan-Belmont syndicate.
But the events of 1905 could only be understood by looking back over the previous six years.
The Road from 1901 to 1906
1901 had been a year of extraordinary expansion.
New corporations were created at a furious pace. Existing companies were merged into enormous combinations. The public speculated recklessly. European money was borrowed to finance the speculation.
Then the corn crop failed, and prices of many American products fell sharply.
In 1902, Wall Street was flooded with new stock and bond offerings.
Every new corporation needed money.
Every new combination wanted bank credit.
At the same time, industrial millionaires who had recently made their fortunes began speculating heavily in stocks. They had enormous bank resources behind them and could borrow huge sums.
The general public, however, did not follow them.
That created a dangerous situation.
Banks were already carrying enormous loans to businesses. Now they were also being asked to finance the ambitious plans of wealthy speculators who wanted to control railroads, industrial companies, and other major corporations.
Meanwhile, imports were rising rapidly, agricultural exports were falling, and the prices of raw materials and labor were climbing.
Fortunately, the country had a good corn crop and generally favorable harvests.
Then came 1903.
The entire structure began to crack.
Investors became frightened by the enormous quantity of new securities being thrown onto the market. They stopped buying.
Once buyers disappeared, securities that had seemed valuable became almost impossible to sell.
Prices collapsed.
Companies, syndicates, brokerage firms, and wealthy individuals who had borrowed too heavily suddenly found themselves unable to meet their obligations. Banks began demanding repayment of loans.
The forced selling became enormous.
Even high-quality stocks and bonds had to be sold because their owners needed cash.
Wall Street was filled with what was then called "undigested securities"—securities that had been issued but could no longer be absorbed by investors or financed through bank loans.
Their owners had no choice.
They sold them for whatever they could get.
Then industrial profits collapsed.
Iron and steel prices fell sharply. Industrial companies saw their earnings shrink, and many were forced to reduce dividends.
Foreign imports also contracted dramatically as the depression spread.
It was essentially a panic among the wealthy.
There were many rich men who suddenly discovered that they were not nearly as rich as they had believed.
Fortunately, grain harvests remained strong. The cotton crop, however, was extremely small.
That shortage pushed cotton prices to unusually high levels, and American exporters shipped more cotton to Europe that autumn than ever before.
In 1904, the effects of the previous year's depression became obvious.
New York banks accumulated unusually large surplus reserves. For roughly eight months, call money could often be borrowed at rates as low as one percent.
Only four times in the past had the banks held more surplus cash.
Then came another extraordinary event: the United States exported more gold than ever before.
By June, the stock market began recovering.
Investors returned.
Speculators began betting heavily on higher prices.
But the professionals became too aggressive.
They pushed stock prices far beyond reasonable levels, and in December the market collapsed again.
Trade itself was slowly recovering, but the cotton industry was suffering badly because cotton prices had become extremely high.
The shortage and resulting bull speculation made cotton so expensive that many textile mills in the United States and England were forced to close.
Then nature produced an unexpected reversal.
The high price of cotton had encouraged farmers throughout the South to plant more cotton, producing the largest cotton crop the country had ever seen.
Cotton prices then collapsed.
The leading cotton bull failed.
The grain harvests were also disappointing. They were the smallest since 1900, pushing grain prices to their highest levels since 1898.
American grain exports to Europe fell to their lowest level since 1872.
Yet the presidential election passed without disturbing Wall Street.
Gold, Money, and the Speculative Boom
By 1905, the world had entered an extraordinary period of monetary expansion.
Gold production was increasing rapidly.
At first glance, one might expect more gold to make money cheaper.
But that was not what happened.
The additional gold encouraged banks to issue more paper money. More money encouraged more speculation.
And speculation created still more demand for money.
The result was higher prices for stocks, commodities, labor, and almost everything else money could buy.
In other words, the growing supply of gold did not satisfy speculation.
It stimulated it.
Demand for money grew faster than the supply.
Interest rates therefore rose even while the amount of gold in circulation was increasing.
The prosperity of 1905 was supported by extraordinary harvests. The corn crop was the largest ever recorded, and the wheat crop was the second largest.
Trade expanded.
Railroads earned more.
Industrial production reached new highs.
Iron and steel production in particular was operating at an extraordinary level.
Dividends rose.
Corporate reserves increased.
Even Russia's disastrous war did not disturb Wall Street.
In fact, Russia's poor wheat harvest helped American farmers because Europe had to buy more American wheat.
Sometimes, as the saying goes, one country's misfortune becomes another country's opportunity.
The Equitable Life Scandal
1905 also brought a major scandal in the insurance industry.
A bitter personal conflict erupted between the president of the Equitable Life Assurance Society, Alexander, and its vice president, Hyde.
Their feud eventually exposed widespread waste, extravagant spending, corruption, and questionable practices in the life-insurance business.
A New York legislative investigation revealed how badly some insurance companies had been managed.
The public lost confidence.
New insurance business declined.
For Wall Street, the most important consequence was that insurance companies stopped buying bonds as aggressively as before.
The bond market then entered a prolonged period of stagnation.
The scandal was damaging, but the exposure was necessary.
Abuses that had been tolerated for years were finally brought into the open.
Powerful men were removed, and the insurance industry was forced to clean up many of its practices.
America Becomes an Industrial Power
American prosperity was also transforming the country's position in world trade.
During the ten years ending in June 1906, exports of American-made goods more than doubled.
In 1906, exports of raw cotton, food products, and iron and steel alone exceeded $300 million.
Cotton remained the country's largest export.
Food products ranked second.
Iron and steel had risen to third place.
Copper products had climbed from eleventh to fourth.
Other traditional exports were losing ground. Refined petroleum fell from third to eleventh, while flour dropped from fourth to seventh and wheat from seventh to thirteenth.
Agricultural machinery was another success story.
Exports of farm machinery in 1906 were five times larger than they had been in 1896.
Cotton textiles also expanded dramatically, rising from about $17 million in exports to roughly $53 million.
And the potential was even greater.
China, the Philippines, and South America represented enormous future markets for American manufactured goods.
America was no longer simply an agricultural nation.
It had become a major manufacturing and mining power as well.
A lower tariff on raw materials, the author believed, would make American exports even more competitive.
But politics stood in the way.
The Great Bull Market of 1906
The huge bull market that had begun in 1904 continued into 1906.
Two men dominated the railroad world and, increasingly, Wall Street itself:
Edward H. Harriman and James J. Hill.
Stock prices kept rising.
So did the cost of borrowing money.
Call and time rates frequently moved above six percent. In August, some loans reached extraordinary levels, and early in September certain borrowers effectively paid rates equivalent to thirty percent once commissions were included.
This was happening just before the normal seasonal movement of money toward the West and South to finance the harvest.
Wall Street was deeply worried.
The Treasury Department eventually stepped in.
Treasury Secretary Leslie M. Shaw offered to deposit gold with national banks, provided the banks supplied government bonds as security. The banks could use the gold while arranging imports from Europe and then return it when the imported gold arrived.
This prevented banks from losing interest while the gold was in transit.
Gold began flowing into the country.
But the great speculators were not frightened.
They kept buying.
Harriman and Hill stocks continued to rise.
Then came the great shock of August 1906.
On Friday, August 17, Harriman announced that Union Pacific would dramatically increase its dividend.
The semiannual dividend was raised to five percent, putting the railroad on a ten-percent annual dividend rate.
At the same time, Southern Pacific declared its first dividend, equal to five percent annually.
Wall Street was stunned.
The directors had approved the decisions on Wednesday and Thursday, but the information was not released until Friday.
The timing created enormous excitement.
Union Pacific jumped about sixteen percent in a single day.
Southern Pacific rose about five percent.
The entire market suddenly became more bullish.
Short sellers rushed to cover their positions.
Outside investors poured into the market.
The bull leaders took advantage of the buying wave and pushed prices even higher.
Investors began wondering whether other major railroads and industrial companies would follow Union Pacific's example.
Would they raise dividends because earnings justified it?
Or were they simply trying to push their stock prices higher?
The controversy surrounding Harriman and his associates became intense.
Critics accused them of using the dividend announcements to manipulate the market.
Harriman was reportedly able to add about $10 million to his personal fortune from the rise in Union Pacific and Southern Pacific shares surrounding the dividend announcements.
Edward Harriman's Extraordinary Rise
Harriman's rise was one of the most remarkable stories in Wall Street history.
He was the son of a quiet country clergyman.
Yet he entered Wall Street and rose with astonishing speed to enormous wealth and power.
The railroad system he controlled represented billions of dollars of other people's property and employed tens of thousands of people.
His influence extended far beyond Union Pacific and Southern Pacific.
He was connected with numerous banks and corporations, including Wells Fargo.
In this respect, Harriman's power exceeded that of Russell Sage.
Sage had accumulated an enormous fortune, but his power came mainly from his money.
Harriman controlled vast business organizations and other people's capital.
His great struggle with James J. Hill for control of Northern Pacific in 1901 had already become one of the legendary battles in Wall Street history.
The Death of Russell Sage
Russell Sage died in July 1906, only days before his ninetieth birthday.
He left a fortune approaching $100 million.
His will revealed the same careful financial thinking that had characterized his entire life.
With only a few minor exceptions, he left his entire fortune to his wife.
There was a financial reason for this decision.
New York's inheritance tax was only one percent on property left to a spouse.
Had he left the money directly to other relatives, the tax would have been five percent.
Sage therefore saved millions in taxes even in death.
It was a final example of the principle that had guided his life.
He knew perfectly well that his wife had no practical need for such an enormous fortune.
Nevertheless, leaving it to her was both a tribute to their marriage and a way to reduce the government's share.
The task of distributing such a fortune would eventually fall to Mrs. Sage.
Russell Sage's life remained an example of extreme frugality.
He had lived simply even after becoming extraordinarily wealthy.
His plain habits, great age, and enormous fortune made him a natural target for cartoonists and comedians.
But beneath the caricatures was a remarkable story.
He had started in poverty and built his fortune himself.
Wealth had not changed his basic way of life.
His entire career demonstrated what a determined and financially disciplined person could accomplish in Wall Street.
By 1906, membership in the New York Stock Exchange had become so valuable that a seat was approaching $100,000.
That price reflected the growing importance of the institution.
The Market Begins to Break
The year 1906 was extraordinarily prosperous for American business.
Prices were high and rising.
Industrial companies were making large profits.
The grain harvest was the largest in American history.
Railroads and industrial corporations were announcing enormous new securities issues.
But the boom had created a serious problem.
Everyone needed money.
Corporations needed money for expansion.
Railroad companies needed money for new projects.
The great Wall Street speculators needed money to keep buying stocks.
The banks were being stretched to their limits.
Money-market shortages became increasingly frequent.
The stock market continued to climb, but underneath the surface it was becoming more fragile.
By the end of 1906, the market had reached extraordinary heights.
Yet it was gradually becoming weaker and more unstable.
The great bull campaign finally met its Waterloo in the spring of 1907.
The wealthy speculators who had pushed prices higher suddenly discovered that there were not enough buyers willing to take their stocks.
They had no choice.
They had to sell.
It became another panic among the rich.
The decline turned into a bear market.
Bears became increasingly confident as prices fell.
Then came March 14, 1907.
Prices collapsed between ten and twenty-five percent under relentless selling.
Stop-loss orders were triggered.
Weak margin accounts were liquidated.
Investors who could no longer tolerate their losses rushed to sell.
The market was overwhelmed by an avalanche of stock.
The collapse was enormous.
But it was not the end.
Many stocks continued falling even after the market staged a sharp rebound.
March ended in gloom.
April and May brought little recovery.
Then, in June, something changed.
The liquidation appeared to have run its course.
The bad news had already been reflected in prices.
Although the market was still dominated almost entirely by professional traders, stocks began to turn upward.
The public remained largely uninterested.
Grain and cotton prices were rising because an unusually cold spring had damaged crops.
The United States also shipped $15 million in gold to France in June.
Yet the market continued to improve.
The Speculators Are Forced Out
The great liquidation had mainly been carried out by Wall Street's largest speculative operators.
Their losses were enormous.
They had entered the decline overloaded with stocks purchased during the previous boom.
The banks began calling their loans.
Some speculators could not repay them.
Others were required to provide additional margin as stock prices fell.
Their cash reserves were disappearing rapidly.
At the same time, interest rates were abnormally high.
Five times during the spring, autumn, and winter of 1906, New York banks found their reserves below the legally required level.
Money was becoming extremely difficult to obtain.
The great speculators had borrowed so heavily that they had effectively consumed much of the banking system's available credit.
Meanwhile, ordinary Americans were putting their money elsewhere.
The public was busy speculating in land, mines, construction projects, and new businesses throughout the country.
That boom stretched from Maine to California.
It absorbed huge amounts of capital.
Very little of that money reached Wall Street.
The result was disastrous for the stock-market bulls.
They had assumed that the public would eventually come in and buy their stocks at still higher prices.
But the public never came.
By the spring of 1907, the great speculators were trapped.
They had pushed prices too high, borrowed too much money, and discovered that there was no large group of new buyers waiting behind them.
Wall Street had become the only seriously troubled area in an otherwise prosperous United States.
The Gold Imports
To support the money market, the major Wall Street interests—except J. P. Morgan & Co.—imported $40 million of gold from Europe in the spring of 1906 and another $45 million in the autumn.
The second operation caused serious problems in Britain.
The Bank of England raised its minimum discount rate from three percent to four percent, then to five, and finally to six percent.
It was the highest rate since the Boer War.
British officials warned that the rate might have reached seven percent if America had continued taking large amounts of gold.
The United States was able to import so much gold partly because Secretary Shaw effectively advanced the money.
He lent gold to American banks against collateral, with the understanding that the banks would return the gold once the imported metal arrived.
The spring gold imports came shortly after the great San Francisco earthquake and fire of April 18, 1906.
The disaster caused an estimated $250 million in losses.
Fortunately, much of the insurance burden fell on British, German, and other foreign insurance companies.
That prevented the disaster from becoming an even greater financial drain on the United States.
New York nevertheless sent more than $50 million in gold to San Francisco to strengthen the city's banks.
The Market Tries to Recover
By May 1907, the stock market had been beaten into submission.
The weakest companies and the most heavily leveraged investors had been forced out.
After such a brutal decline, a recovery was almost inevitable.
The spring weather finally improved.
The crops looked better.
Stocks began rising.
The foundation for a future bull market had been laid by the enormous liquidation that had just taken place.
Wall Street was once again following its familiar cycle.
After a violent decline comes recovery.
After darkness comes dawn.
The stock market never truly disappears.
It simply moves from one extreme to another.
By July, the recovery had become obvious, particularly in the Harriman stocks.
A new bull campaign appeared to be developing.
The Standard Oil and Harriman interests were leading it, with Union Pacific at the center.
But there was still one major problem.
The public remained completely uninterested.
The new advance was almost entirely professional speculation.
At the same time, investors were becoming increasingly nervous about the money market.
America unexpectedly had to ship gold to Europe, much of it to the Bank of France.
Europe itself was suffering financial difficulties.
Heavy liquidation disturbed both London and Berlin.
Even British Consols were falling steadily.
They eventually reached 81, their lowest price since 1848.
The Southern Railway Fight
Then another problem appeared.
North Carolina and Alabama became involved in a bitter legal conflict with the Southern Railway.
Other Southern states and railroads were also drawn into the dispute.
The central issue was state laws limiting railroad passenger fares to roughly two and a quarter or two and a half cents per mile.
The conflict between the states and the federal courts became so serious that Alabama revoked the Southern Railway's license to operate within the state.
For a time, the situation looked extremely dangerous.
Eventually, however, the two sides reached a temporary truce.
Southern Railway agreed to obey the state law while allowing the United States Supreme Court to decide whether the law was constitutional.
But another shock was already approaching.
The Standard Oil Bombshell
On Saturday, August 3, Judge Kenesaw Mountain Landis of the United States District Court in Chicago imposed a staggering $29.24 million fine on the Standard Oil Company of Indiana.
The decision hit Wall Street like a thunderbolt.
To many investors, the fine looked almost like confiscation.
The great speculative interests immediately became frightened.
They had been supporting the stock market, but now they withdrew their buying orders.
For their own protection, they began selling heavily.
They understood what the decision could mean.
If the government could impose such severe penalties on Standard Oil, investors began wondering what might happen next to other major corporations.
The railroad disputes in the South added to the fear.
Then a threatening report from the Bureau of Corporations made matters even worse.
On Monday, August 5, the market opened under enormous pressure.
For twelve consecutive business days, prices fell heavily.
Railroad and industrial stocks both suffered.
The strongest and most expensive stocks were hit particularly hard.
Many fell ten to twenty-five percent.
As prices dropped, fear increased.
As fear increased, more investors sold.
The market became almost completely demoralized.
Many stocks fell below their March panic lows.
Once again, it was largely a panic among wealthy investors.
They feared that government action, legal disputes, and declining confidence could destroy the value of their stocks and reduce future dividends.
As always, however, ordinary investors suffered alongside the people who had created the speculative excesses.
Eventually the storm passed.
Rumors of major Wall Street and industrial failures spread everywhere.
But only one important industrial company failed, along with one relatively minor Wall Street suspension.
Confidence slowly returned.
The stock market began recovering.
Southern Railway reduced its preferred dividend from two and a half percent to one and a half percent.
Erie reduced the cash payments on its first and second preferred stocks, replacing them with four-percent scrip warrants.
Then, near the end of August, Secretary Shaw announced that the Treasury would continue making weekly deposits in national banks until October 15.
The additional money immediately eased pressure on the banking system.
Confidence improved.
But the crisis was not over.
The Copper Collapse
Early in September, the market suffered another setback.
Copper became the new source of trouble.
The copper industry had entered a period of stagnation and then outright weakness in both America and Europe.
The selling agency of Amalgamated Copper cut the price of copper from 25 cents a pound to 18 cents.
Not long afterward, it fell again to 15 cents.
Copper companies began cutting dividends.
Calumet and Hecla, Quincy, and others reduced their payments because demand for copper had fallen sharply.
Amalgamated Copper stock collapsed to 57½, compared with 121 in January.
Boston's copper stocks suffered an equally brutal decline.
Railroad stocks weakened as well, although they did not fall as violently as the copper shares.
Industrial companies such as American Smelting and U.S. Steel were hit particularly hard.
Eventually, however, the copper crisis began losing its grip on the railroad market.
A major piece of good news then appeared.
New York City issued $40 million of 4½-percent bonds.
The offering was so successful that investors submitted orders for five times the amount available.
That was an encouraging sign.
It showed that enormous amounts of money were still sitting on the sidelines, waiting for safe and attractive investments.
But the stock market remained nervous.
Some railroad and industrial shares continued making new lows.
Southern Railway common and preferred were among them.
The market moved violently from day to day.
The bulls had become cautious.
The bears had become aggressive.
And beneath the surface, investors were increasingly worried about the future of American business.
The great boom had already begun to unravel.
Wall Street was heading toward the most serious financial crisis it had seen in years.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!