Wall Street Men and Personal Honor
There is probably no place in the world where people trust one another more than they do on Wall Street—not even in the Church.
Wall Street runs on mutual confidence. Every day, men have opportunities to take control of millions of dollars belonging to other people and simply disappear with it. They could cross the border and begin a new life as fugitives.
Yet considering how much money passes through Wall Street and how many transactions take place there, such betrayals are surprisingly uncommon.
That is why Wall Street men have earned a reputation around the world for straightforward and honest dealing. They have become leading figures in the speculative business, not only in America but throughout the world.
Wherever people have developed an interest in speculation, the name Wall Street is known. Even people who know almost nothing about the business recognize the name.
An English clergyman who had recently visited Liverpool once asked a friend of mine:
“What exactly is Wall Street?”
Then he added:
“What a strange place for Mr. Talmage to have his tabernacle!”
He had apparently heard only a few scattered reports about the fierce attacks on Wall Street made by the famous Brooklyn preacher.
He actually thought Talmage was preaching among the bulls and bears of Wall Street, as though he had boldly entered their dangerous den to confront them face-to-face.
Of course, Wall Street's reputation is sometimes damaged by dishonest men who take advantage of the Street and its money.
But these people are usually outsiders. They come into Wall Street pretending to be legitimate businessmen, only to use the confidence they gain there for fraudulent purposes.
No place offers a confidence man a richer opportunity than Wall Street if he can establish a relationship of trust and use it to steal large sums of money.
But Wall Street itself is no more responsible for these people than the Church is responsible for swindlers who use its respectable name and surroundings for their own purposes.
The Street is their victim, not their sponsor.
Imagine a financier declaring:
“The Church is a refuge for swindlers. They come out of the Church and commit crimes against society.”
Everyone with common sense would reject such a statement.
Yet there is about as much truth in that accusation as there is in many of the dramatic attacks against Wall Street delivered from pulpits every Sunday.
In fact, there are few places where thieves receive less sympathy than Wall Street—perhaps only the offices of the Pinkerton and Byrnes detective agencies would be less welcoming to them.
There is another common misunderstanding about people who fail on Wall Street.
Their failures are often blamed on the experienced men of the Street, as though older Wall Street operators had cheated them.
But speculation is a specialized business. A man cannot simply arrive with a few hundred dollars, start trading stocks, and expect to become rich.
Most people who fail in Wall Street are men who spent their early years doing something else. Their habits and ways of thinking were formed in completely different environments.
Wall Street requires years of serious training in financial affairs.
A person needs time to develop the mental flexibility required to understand the many complicated situations that arise in speculation.
The earlier that training begins, the better.
Many of the most successful Wall Street men received their training from a young age.
There are certainly successful people who entered the business late in life. But such men usually possess an unusual natural talent for it.
Exceptional genius can overcome many disadvantages.
For ordinary people, however, early training is usually essential to financial success.
And there is another important point.
A man who has been properly trained in business from an early age rarely becomes deliberately dishonest.
Ferdinand Ward might appear to be an exception.
But Ward was an extraordinary case. He seemed to possess a natural talent for wrongdoing. He had every opportunity to become an honorable man, yet his character was so deeply corrupt that nothing short of prison walls could restrain him.
He was a rare criminal genius.
Society must always protect itself against such people.
But exceptional cases do not destroy the general rule. They actually make the rule clearer: in finance, perhaps more than in any other profession, early training is enormously important.
When a properly trained businessman fails, disgrace does not necessarily follow.
He may suffer every kind of financial disaster.
He may lose everything.
He may even end up in poverty because of excessive drinking, despair after a long series of bad investments, or unfortunate partnerships with dishonest people.
But even after falling that far, he can still rebuild his life.
He may be morally weakened in many ways, but he will not necessarily become a swindler.
A great business cannot be built on dishonesty.
A dishonest enterprise may prosper for a while, but sooner or later it will collapse.
The enormous size of Wall Street itself is evidence of this.
Large numbers of people cannot conduct major business with one another unless there is some basic understanding of fairness and honest dealing.
A conspiracy to cheat can survive only among a small group.
The most successful Wall Street men I have personally known were people who entered the business when they were young and learned through hard experience.
They were tested severely.
They took some very painful lessons.
Those experiences hardened and strengthened them, much as repeated blows transform iron into steel.
These are some of the basic requirements for a successful career in finance.
There is another mistake people often make in every area of life.
A man succeeds at one thing and then assumes he can succeed at everything.
Usually, reality eventually teaches him otherwise.
A few failures are often enough to remind a man that his abilities are limited.
But when that lesson comes in Wall Street, the price can be much higher.
The result may be financial ruin and lasting disgrace.
The panic of 1884 provided several striking examples.
Some of the men involved had been great military commanders during the Civil War.
They had fought to preserve the Union when victory seemed almost impossible.
Their reputations as generals were enormous.
They had planned and carried out military operations on which the future of a great nation—and perhaps the future of other nations—had depended.
Yet when they turned their attention to banks, railroads, and financial enterprises, they became completely entangled.
General Grant was one of the most remarkable examples.
The man who had commanded armies and helped save the Union could be almost helpless when Ferdinand Ward and James D. Fish turned their financial schemes against him.
Grant had been able to understand an enormous battlefield almost instantly at Vicksburg, Richmond, and Appomattox.
Yet he could not see through the complicated financial schemes of the man known as the “Young Napoleon of Finance.”
Grant was not simply a victim because he was honest, trusting, and unsuspecting.
His real weakness was that he had never received the kind of early training in financial business that would have taught him how necessary caution was when dealing with aggressive businessmen of questionable morals.
Generals Winslow and Porter made a similar mistake in connection with the West Shore Railroad.
Their lack of financial experience nearly caused serious damage to the railroad interests of the country.
General Wilson of the New York and New England Railroad and General Gordon also suffered from similar mistakes.
These were honorable men who had given enormous service to the country.
But they shared the same weakness: they were highly trained in their own professions and poorly trained in practical financial business.
That weakness contributed to the broader financial disorder that Treasurer Jordan bitterly described when criticizing railroad practices.
From time to time, those practices caused serious damage to some of the country's best securities.
So I have one piece of advice for parents whose sons are going into business.
Give them early, practical training in the particular business for which they seem best suited.
Do not be afraid to let practical experience take priority over some of their formal school and college education.
Real business is the greatest school a future businessman can attend.
It is where he learns judgment, discipline, responsibility, and the consequences of his decisions.
In many cases, practical experience is the best college a young businessman can possibly graduate from.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!