← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 36 · Young Corneel: The Vanderbilt Son Who Could Borrow from Anyone

Young Corneel: The Vanderbilt Son Who Could Borrow from Anyone

Chapter 36 of 90 · 2,623 words · Free

Cornelius Jeremiah Vanderbilt, William H. Vanderbilt’s brother, was widely known as “Young Corneel.” He was one of the strangest characters I ever met in financial circles.

“Corneel” had an unusual gift for getting himself into trouble—and an even more unusual gift for getting other people to rescue him.

He constantly relied on his father, the Commodore, to get him out of difficult situations. Sometimes the Commodore actually helped him. More often, the mere fact that he was the Commodore’s son was enough to convince people that any money they lent him would eventually be repaid.

Corneel made full use of that reputation.

He formed friendships everywhere, and once people learned who his father was, many were willing to lend him money against promises that existed mostly in Corneel’s imagination.

But relying on his father’s name was never as safe as Corneel believed.

If his entire financial strategy had depended on his father’s guarantee, he would often have discovered that he was leaning on a very weak stick.

Yet Corneel had a remarkable ability to persuade people.

He could sit down with an important man, tell a heartbreaking story about his troubles, complain about how badly his father and brother had treated him, and somehow walk away with the money he wanted.

The strange part was that the money he begged for was sometimes genuinely needed.

He might claim that he needed it to pay his room rent, settle a hotel bill, or buy necessities.

Then, once the money was in his pocket, he might walk into the nearest gambling house and lose it all.

Meanwhile, the landlord and washerwoman had to keep waiting for their money.

Two of his most devoted friends were Horace Greeley and Schuyler Colfax.

Corneel seemed to have almost complete control over both men.

Whenever he wanted money, it was remarkably difficult for either of them to say no.

He would tell them again and again about the terrible injustices he had supposedly suffered at the hands of his father and brother.

The story hardly ever changed.

But somehow Greeley and Colfax never seemed tired of hearing it.

To an ordinary businessman, Corneel could be an unbearable bore.

To Greeley and Colfax, however, he was a tragic figure who needed sympathy and assistance.

His failures with money did not destroy his credit.

They actually seemed to increase it.

The more he borrowed and failed to repay, the more sympathy he sometimes received.

His debts to Greeley eventually grew to more than $50,000.

Years after Greeley died, I was told that Corneel would sometimes sit quietly, especially when he was in serious financial trouble, with tears in his eyes.

He would sigh and say:

“When Mr. Greeley died, I lost the best friend in the world.”

To Corneel’s credit, he eventually repaid every dollar he owed Greeley, including interest, to Greeley’s daughters.

He also paid most of his other debts after reaching a settlement with William H.

The settlement gave him considerably more money than his father had originally left him.

The Commodore had deliberately provided only enough for his son to live comfortably.

He had not intended to finance Corneel’s gambling.

Corneel possessed one quality in extraordinary abundance: determination.

When he wanted something, he pursued it with every ounce of energy he had.

That was one reason people so often gave in to him.

If he had devoted the same energy to legitimate business or investing that he devoted to borrowing and gambling, he might have become as successful as his father or Jay Gould.

He also seemed to have an instinct for judging people.

He usually knew exactly whom to approach before asking for money.

In that respect, he was like a hunter who almost never missed his target.

My first meeting with Corneel came through Schuyler Colfax.

Colfax brought him to my office and introduced us.

Corneel told me that he had just returned from Hartford, Connecticut, where he had spent a week visiting with Colfax.

It was easy to imagine that Colfax’s bank account had not enjoyed the trip.

I invited both men to dinner at the Club that afternoon.

Colfax was an excellent conversationalist.

But Corneel completely overshadowed him.

For most of the dinner, Corneel talked almost without stopping.

And what did he talk about?

Colfax.

He praised him so extravagantly that anyone listening might have thought Colfax was the greatest man who had ever lived.

The remarkable thing was that none of this praise seemed to embarrass Colfax.

He accepted it as naturally as he accepted his dinner.

That told me something important.

Corneel knew exactly what kind of man Colfax was and exactly how to flatter him.

When he finally tired of praising Colfax, he turned his attention to Horace Greeley.

Corneel had plenty to say about him, too.

I later met Greeley several times and told him what a devoted friend Corneel appeared to be.

Greeley smiled knowingly.

“Yes, I think he is a good friend of mine,” he said. “I have heard that he says very nice things about me.”

Then he added:

“It is a great pity that he is so often short of money. If he had more money, he would be a very good fellow.”

That was Corneel’s method.

He would praise Greeley to someone else.

That person would repeat the compliments to Greeley.

Then Corneel would appear a few days later and ask Greeley for money.

By then, the ground had already been prepared.

Corneel understood perfectly how to use friendship, sympathy, family connections, and flattery to achieve his purpose.

The next day after our first meeting, he returned to my office.

He told me Colfax had left early that morning for Washington and had urged him to come along.

Corneel said he had some business to finish first and would leave on the night train.

Then he casually asked:

“By the way, you know Jay Cooke very well, don’t you?”

“Yes,” I replied.

“I have some business to attend to involving the Treasury Department,” he said. “I think Mr. Cooke might be able to help me. Would you give me a letter of introduction?”

Then, with an innocent businesslike air, he added:

“I may never need it, but I would like to have it just in case.”

I wrote him a short and completely noncommittal letter.

It simply introduced him as the Commodore’s son and said that I was making the introduction at Corneel’s request.

There was nothing in the letter that could reasonably have been considered a financial guarantee.

But Corneel knew how to turn even such a harmless introduction into something useful.

A few days later, drafts from Jay Cooke began arriving at my office.

They came one after another.

None was particularly large.

But together they amounted to a substantial sum.

And they kept coming.

Had I not sent Mr. Cooke a telegram telling him to stop sending money, there was no telling how large the total might have become.

The last time I saw Young Corneel was at Long Branch.

We took a drive together on a beautiful, warm afternoon.

That day he spoke very differently from the young man I had known before.

He talked sadly about the life he had wasted.

He spoke with gratitude about the friends who had repeatedly rescued him from trouble.

Then he told me that he had only one purpose left in life.

He wanted to live long enough to repay his debts.

After that, he said, he could see no reason to continue living.

He eventually accomplished what he had set out to do.

But afterward, in deep despair, he took his own life.

His final years were tragic.

Whatever faults he had, there was clearly a troubled and unhappy man beneath the eccentric behavior.

It is better, therefore, to look with compassion upon the tragic scene at the Glenham Hotel and hope that Corneel finally found the peace that had escaped him throughout his life.

The Commodore’s will showed exactly how little confidence he had in his son’s ability to manage money.

He set aside $200,000 in bonds for Cornelius J. Vanderbilt.

The income was to be used for Corneel’s support during his lifetime.

But the trustees were given complete control over the payments.

They could give him all the interest, part of it, or none of it whenever they thought necessary.

More importantly, Corneel could not assign the income to his creditors.

If he tried to transfer, borrow against, or otherwise pledge his future income, the payments would stop entirely.

After his death, the $200,000 would pass to the residuary legatee.

The arrangement may seem severe, but the Commodore knew his son.

He was trying to prevent Corneel from using his future income to finance his gambling.

Even if Corneel needed money badly, the Commodore did not want him borrowing against his future allowance.

The will made one thing very clear.

The Commodore still regarded his son as someone who needed supervision.

Corneel hated that.

He believed he was intellectually superior to William H., and he deeply resented the idea that his brother should have any authority over him.

Almost nobody shared that opinion.

Perhaps Greeley and Colfax did.

Corneel complained constantly about his father’s hardness and stinginess.

Yet at the same time, he admired the Commodore enormously.

He knew his father’s achievements in great detail and never tired of talking about them.

He could insult the Commodore himself, but if anyone else criticized him, Corneel became furious.

He was also obsessed with his hatred of Jay Gould.

He believed that Gould and Jim Fisk had actually plotted to assassinate the Commodore during the Erie railroad struggle.

There was no evidence whatsoever for such a belief.

But Corneel had convinced himself that it was true.

Once, when a friend tried to explain how unlikely it was that Gould would have planned a murder, Corneel became so agitated that he suffered an epileptic seizure.

His resentment toward his father went back many years.

During the gold rush, when he was only eighteen, he had run away to California and worked as a sailor.

He soon returned.

He had neither the ability nor the endurance to compete in the brutal struggle for wealth on the Pacific coast.

When he came home, his father had him arrested and sent to Bloomingdale.

It was soon determined that he was not insane.

He was released.

But the experience deeply affected him.

He never forgave his father.

From then on, he became increasingly bitter and dissatisfied.

The more his friends tried to help him, the more difficult he often became.

Yet anyone who wanted to remain his friend had to humor him.

That was almost impossible.

Even Dr. Swazy found his patience severely tested while trying to care for him.

Corneel was extraordinarily careful with money in ordinary life.

He could hold on to a penny more tightly than most people would hold on to a ten-dollar bill.

But the moment he entered a gambling house, his attitude changed completely.

Ten dollars or a hundred dollars seemed almost worthless.

Faro and keno had an extraordinary hold over him.

He had even been known to suffer an epileptic seizure while gambling.

Afterward, he would fall into a deep sleep and look almost like a corpse.

Then he would wake up and return to the game.

The gambling table seemed to possess a power over him that he could not resist.

Eventually, the Commodore heard that Greeley had been lending Corneel hundreds and sometimes thousands of dollars.

The Commodore went straight to the offices of the Tribune.

He entered Greeley’s office without ceremony.

Greeley was sitting at his high desk, working on one of his political or social articles.

The Commodore confronted him.

“Greeley, I hear yer lendin’ Corneel money.”

Greeley looked up over his glasses.

“Yes,” he replied calmly. “I have let him have some.”

The Commodore warned him:

“I give you fair warning. You need not look to me. I won’t pay you.”

Greeley immediately shot back:

“Who the devil asked you?”

Then he added:

“Have I?”

That ended the conversation.

The Commodore walked back down the old stairs toward Spruce Street.

Greeley returned to his writing.

As far as I know, neither man ever brought up the subject again.

After Greeley died, however, the Commodore sent $10,000 to each of his two daughters.

The Commodore was pleased when Corneel married Miss Williams of Hartford, Connecticut.

He hoped marriage would finally persuade his son to change his life.

Unfortunately, he was disappointed.

There is a particularly revealing story about the Commodore’s conversation with his future daughter-in-law’s father.

Mr. Williams visited the Commodore at his office on Fourth Street near Broadway.

He explained that Cornelius Jeremiah had asked to marry his daughter, and that she was willing to marry him if the Commodore had no objection.

The Commodore asked:

“Has your daughter plenty of silk dresses?”

Mr. Williams was surprised.

“My daughter is not wealthy,” he replied. “She has a few dresses, like other young women in her position, but her wardrobe is not large or expensive.”

The Commodore continued:

“Has your daughter plenty of jewelry?”

“No, sir,” Williams replied, now becoming irritated. “I have already explained that I am a man of modest means. My daughter cannot afford much jewelry.”

The Commodore finally explained why he was asking.

“The reason I ask is that if she owned valuable things, my son would take them, pawn or sell them, and gamble away the money. So I want you and your daughter to understand that I cannot take responsibility for that.”

The marriage went ahead anyway.

Afterward, Corneel asked his father for money to build a house.

The Commodore refused.

“No, Corneel. You have to prove that you can be trusted before I trust you.”

His wife had better luck.

She went to her father-in-law and asked for help.

The Commodore gave her a check for $10,000.

Several months later, she returned.

The Commodore greeted her warmly but immediately assumed she had come to ask for more money.

He was already preparing himself to say no.

The Commodore could be almost impossible to move on most matters.

But around women, he had a weakness.

He looked at his daughter-in-law and smiled.

“Well, what can I do for you now?”

She answered pleasantly:

“Well, Papa, we didn’t need all the money, so I brought you back $1,500.”

The Commodore could hardly believe what he was hearing.

For a moment, he probably wondered whether he had somehow wandered into one of the spiritual séances he had become interested in attending.

But the money was real.

She put it in his hands.

From that moment, the Commodore developed a deep affection for his daughter-in-law.

Their friendship lasted until her premature death, about ten years before Corneel himself died.

Much of the sympathy shown toward Young Corneel was as excessive and misguided as many of his own complaints.

He received $200 a week from his father while publicly complaining that he was being kept in poverty and that the Commodore was miserly.

Two hundred dollars a week was more than enough to provide him with a comfortable life if he had managed it sensibly.

But no amount of money could have satisfied him while gambling controlled his life.

Even if his father had given him the income from the entire Vanderbilt fortune, he probably would not have been better off.

He would simply have lost more money at the gaming tables.

The Commodore understood his son better than Corneel understood himself.

By limiting him to $200 a week, the old man was not merely being harsh.

He was protecting his son from himself.

And, in the end, that strictness probably protected society as well.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!