← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 35 · William H. Vanderbilt: The Railroad Builder Who Inherited a Fortune

William H. Vanderbilt: The Railroad Builder Who Inherited a Fortune

Chapter 35 of 90 · 3,016 words · Free

William H. Vanderbilt was very different from his father, Cornelius Vanderbilt.

He was not a Wall Street gambler in the usual sense. He preferred long-term investments, and his financial moves generally strengthened rather than damaged the value of the properties he controlled.

He also understood the danger of becoming too powerful in the eyes of the public.

One of the clearest examples came in 1879, when he sold a controlling block of New York Central stock.

Vanderbilt believed that one man owning such a huge share of a major railroad was not good for either himself or the company. He wanted ownership spread among many investors.

The sale involved 300,000 shares out of his 400,000 shares. He sold them for about $35 million, at prices below the market.

The stock was eventually distributed among thousands of investors. The number of shareholders grew from roughly 3,000 to about 14,000.

But Vanderbilt's success in the railroad business had begun much earlier.

His first real test came with the Staten Island Railroad.

The railroad was only thirteen miles long, but it had been badly managed and was deeply in debt. Eventually, it went bankrupt.

Vanderbilt and his father already had a large interest in the company, so William was appointed receiver.

The appointment was apparently arranged secretly by his father.

The Commodore wanted to know whether his son actually had the ability to run a railroad.

William passed the test brilliantly.

Within two years, he had paid off the railroad's entire debt.

The company's stock, which had once been practically worthless, climbed to 175.

William was then elected president of the railroad.

His father began to change his opinion of his son's abilities.

William, for his part, worked hard to satisfy his demanding father. Even when the Commodore criticized or abused him, William rarely complained.

When Cornelius Vanderbilt took control of the Harlem Railroad, he made William its vice president.

Again, William proved himself.

The Harlem Railroad had been almost worthless, with its stock selling around eight or nine dollars.

Under William's management, the railroad was rebuilt and improved.

It was double-tracked, its operations were upgraded, and the value of its stock eventually rose far above par.

His father was so impressed that William was given additional responsibilities.

He became vice president of the Hudson River Railroad and later took a leading role in the combined New York Central and Hudson River system.

At every stage, William demonstrated remarkable executive ability.

Once he became vice president of the great Vanderbilt railroad system, he worked almost without rest.

He wanted to understand everything personally.

He examined bills, checks, and vouchers.

He inspected locomotives.

He read mountains of correspondence.

He answered many letters himself instead of leaving them to secretaries.

Even with his enormous fortune, he worked with an intensity that many ordinary businessmen would have found exhausting.

That habit of constant work probably contributed to the decline of his health.

When his father died in January 1887, William was fifty-six years old and inherited a fortune estimated at between $75 million and $90 million, while the remaining bequests amounted to another $15 million.

Now the entire Vanderbilt railroad empire depended heavily on him.

One of his greatest tests came during the railroad strike of 1877.

The strike threatened to shut down transportation and create widespread social disorder.

About 12,000 men worked for the New York Central and Harlem railroads.

Their wages had been cut by ten percent.

The workers were angry and had even threatened to destroy the Grand Central Depot.

In Pennsylvania, authorities had called out the militia.

William Vanderbilt chose another path.

From Saratoga, he telegraphed his senior managers.

"Distribute $100,000 among the striking workers."

He also promised that the ten-percent wage reduction would be restored as soon as business improved enough to justify it.

The decision worked.

More than 11,500 workers returned to their jobs.

While Pittsburgh was suffering from violence and bloodshed, New York's railroad system remained comparatively peaceful.

Vanderbilt's approach to management was fundamentally different from his father's.

Cornelius had loved competition, confrontation, and conquest.

William preferred negotiation.

He believed disagreements could usually be settled through reason and arbitration.

Yet he was extremely careful with money.

He could notice a tiny unnecessary charge on his lunch bill and have it removed.

At the same time, he could be extraordinarily generous.

His brother, known as Young Corneel, had been left only the income from $200,000 under the Commodore's will.

William eventually settled the dispute by giving him the income from $1 million instead.

He also gave each of his sisters $500,000 in United States bonds from his own fortune.

One evening, William personally delivered the bonds to his sisters in his carriage.

One of his brothers-in-law looked at the day's bond prices and said:

"William, these bonds are worth $150 less than $500,000 at today's closing price."

Vanderbilt calmly replied:

"All right. I'll give you a check for the difference."

He immediately wrote the check.

Another brother-in-law followed him toward the door.

"If there's going to be anything more like this," he said, "I hope we won't be forgotten."

Instead of becoming angry, Vanderbilt apparently laughed at the man's shamelessness.

He understood human weakness and found the whole episode amusing.

Vanderbilt's greatest personal extravagance was his magnificent mansion on Fifth Avenue.

He filled it with paintings by some of the greatest artists of Europe and America.

His interest in art was another area where the public badly underestimated him.

Many people assumed that Vanderbilt knew nothing about painting.

The artists who knew him personally thought otherwise.

He did not pretend to be an art expert.

When someone showed him a beautiful painting, he would simply say:

"It may be a very fine picture, but until I can appreciate its beauty, I won't buy it."

His judgment was practical rather than pretentious.

Once, he visited a French dealer to look at a painting by Troyon.

The picture showed a team of oxen turning away from a plowed field.

Some art experts had criticized the way the animals were moving.

Vanderbilt looked at the painting and said:

"I don't know as much about the artistic quality of the picture as I do about whether the cattle are behaving naturally. I've seen oxen do that hundreds of times."

The artists accepted his judgment.

He knew the behavior of horses and cattle from personal experience.

In France, he visited the famous painter Rosa Bonheur and commissioned two paintings from her.

He also commissioned the celebrated artist Meissonier to paint his portrait.

He eventually paid nearly $200,000 for seven of Meissonier's works.

He even bought one of the artist's masterpieces from Germany for $40,000.

The purchase delighted Meissonier, who had not seen the painting for years.

Vanderbilt also loved music, especially opera.

But nothing excited him quite as much as horses.

Normally quiet and reserved, he could become remarkably talkative whenever someone mentioned fast horses.

He loved speed and became one of America's most famous drivers of fast teams.

With Small Hopes and Lady Mac, he established a remarkable mile time of 2:23¼.

His chief rival was Frank Work.

Work kept challenging him, so Vanderbilt bought faster horses.

With Aldine and Early Rose, he reduced the time to 2:16½.

Work soon beat that record.

Vanderbilt responded by buying the famous Maud S. in Kentucky for $21,000.

With Maud S. and Aldine, he drove a mile at Fleetwood Park in 2:15½.

Later, he brought the time down to 2:08¾.

No rival could come close.

Eventually he sold Maud S. to Robert Bonner for $40,000, with one important condition: she could never again be raced for money.

Bonner might otherwise have paid more than $100,000 for her.

Vanderbilt's generosity extended beyond his family.

He added $300,000 to the million dollars his father had given to Nashville University.

He gave $500,000 to the College of Physicians and Surgeons, while his sister added another $250,000.

He also spent more than $100,000 helping move Cleopatra's Needle from Egypt to Central Park.

He once offered to cancel a $150,000 check he had given General Grant to help him through the Ward-Fish financial disaster.

He also made a famous gift to waiter students working in the White Mountains.

Despite his enormous wealth, Vanderbilt was not a man who frightened easily.

He received countless threatening letters from cranks, socialists, and other people who wanted to intimidate him.

He simply ignored them.

He never changed his schedule because of threats.

If he was expected somewhere, he went.

If he had business to conduct, he conducted it.

Yet he was surprisingly sensitive to public opinion.

He cared deeply about how people viewed his wealth and power.

That was one reason he sold his controlling interest in New York Central.

He did not want to be seen as a single individual controlling one of the nation's most important corporations.

It was also the reason his famous remark about "the public" has been misunderstood for generations.

A Chicago reporter once asked him why he planned to discontinue a fast mail train to Chicago.

"Why are you going to stop the fast mail train?" the reporter asked.

"Because it doesn't pay," Vanderbilt replied. "I can't run a train permanently at a loss."

"But the public finds it useful," the reporter argued. "You ought to accommodate them."

"The public?" Vanderbilt replied. "How do you know they want it? If they want it, why don't they patronize it and make it pay? That's the only test I have."

The reporter continued:

"Are you working for the public or for your stockholders?"

Vanderbilt lost patience.

"The public be damned! I'm working for my stockholders. If the public wants the train, why don't they support it?"

The sentence became famous.

Newspapers presented it as proof that Vanderbilt despised the public.

But the context was much simpler.

He was saying that a private railroad company could not be expected to operate an unprofitable train merely because a reporter claimed that the public liked it.

The wording was certainly harsh.

But the business argument behind it was straightforward.

Vanderbilt was responsible to the owners of the railroad, not to every person who demanded a service without paying enough to support it.

Another great project of his was the Vanderbilt family mausoleum at New Dorp on Staten Island.

Architect Richard M. Hunt designed it.

Vanderbilt wanted something massive and dignified rather than decorative.

The structure stood forty feet high, sixty feet wide, and about 150 feet deep.

It was built on a hill overlooking the bay.

The mausoleum and the twenty-one acres surrounding it cost nearly half a million dollars.

Once the grounds were completed, the total cost was expected to approach $1 million.

The family took extraordinary precautions against grave robbers.

Guards watched the tomb day and night.

Every fifteen minutes, each guard had to wind a clock to prove that he was still awake and performing his duty.

The record was then sent to the Grand Central Depot every morning.

By May 1883, Vanderbilt's health had deteriorated enough that he resigned the presidencies of his railroads and went to Europe.

James H. Rutter became president of the Central.

After Rutter's death, Chauncey M. Depew took over.

Vanderbilt had already begun to show signs that his health was failing.

One of the clearest signs was his decision to stop driving his fast teams.

For a man who loved horses and driving more than almost anything else, giving up the reins must have been painful.

He had suffered a mild stroke that caused a twitch in his lower lip.

Later, he lost the sight in one eye.

Very few people knew how serious his condition had become.

Then, on December 8, 1885, the end came suddenly.

That morning, Vanderbilt rose early.

He appeared no worse than he had been for some time.

He went to the studio of the sculptor J. Q. A. Ward to sit for a bronze bust.

At one o'clock, Chauncey Depew came to visit him.

But Robert Garrett, president of the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, was already there.

Garrett was discussing his plan for bringing his railroad into New York through Staten Island and across the Arthur Kill.

Vanderbilt listened from a large armchair.

Garrett sat across from him.

Everything seemed normal.

Then Vanderbilt's voice began to weaken.

Garrett noticed a strange twitching around his mouth.

Suddenly Vanderbilt stopped speaking.

His body went into a spasm.

He leaned forward and would have fallen to the floor, but Garrett caught him.

Garrett gently lowered him onto the rug and placed a pillow beneath his head.

Within moments, William H. Vanderbilt was dead.

His family doctor, Dr. McLean, arrived shortly afterward.

He believed that a blood vessel had burst in Vanderbilt's brain.

Death had been instantaneous.

For Wall Street, the news was shocking.

Vanderbilt had been one of the most powerful forces in the American securities market.

Many feared that his death would trigger a financial panic.

A group of wealthy operators quickly formed a $12 million pool to protect the market.

But the disaster never came.

The market fell a few points the next morning, then recovered before the day's close.

Vanderbilt's railroad holdings had already been distributed widely enough that his death could not by itself destroy the market.

The day after his death, I sent my customers a letter explaining what his loss meant for Wall Street.

Vanderbilt had been one of the largest holders of American securities in the world.

Thousands of investors followed his lead.

When he bought, they bought.

When he sold, they sold.

He was not merely a wealthy investor.

He was a leader.

His followers trusted his judgment, much as soldiers trusted the general of an army.

His death therefore created uncertainty.

Yet the market had changed.

Wall Street was no longer a one-man market.

Too many investors and too much capital were now involved for the death of a single financier to cause permanent destruction.

Vanderbilt had been an unusually strong operator.

He knew how to support a stock when necessary and had the courage to stand his ground.

His absence would certainly be felt.

But the market itself had grown beyond the control of any single man.

In England, even William E. Gladstone had once been concerned about the enormous size of Vanderbilt's fortune.

Chauncey Depew recalled a dinner in London where he sat beside Gladstone.

The two men discussed American and British railroad finance.

Gladstone said:

"I understand that you have a man in America worth £20 million, or about $100 million, and that his fortune is held in property which he can turn into cash whenever he wishes."

Gladstone thought such concentrated financial power was dangerous.

"If he converted it all into money and locked it away," he said, "he could create a panic in America that might spread across the world."

Depew admitted that the man was Vanderbilt.

Then he replied:

"But you have a man in England with an equally large fortune."

Gladstone assumed he meant the Duke of Westminster.

But Gladstone explained that the duke's fortune was different.

Most of it consisted of inherited land and property that could not simply be converted into cash and withdrawn from the financial system.

Depew's answer was simple:

"Unlike you in England, we in America do not consider a fortune dangerous."

Vanderbilt's own financial record supported that argument.

During the seven years he controlled his father's estate, he more than tripled its value.

His biggest mistake was probably the purchase of the Nickel Plate Railroad.

The problem was not necessarily the railroad itself.

It was the timing.

Vanderbilt bought it about a month too early.

Had he waited, the railroad probably would have gone into bankruptcy, allowing him to acquire it on far better terms.

The West Shore Railroad might have followed the same path.

Instead, Vanderbilt paid heavily for the Nickel Plate.

The people who built the railroad had wanted to sell it to either Jay Gould or Vanderbilt.

They had even encouraged rumors that Gould was interested in buying it.

When Gould traveled west, the syndicate arranged for him to return over the Nickel Plate.

They made sure the news reached Vanderbilt.

He believed Gould was inspecting the railroad because he intended to buy it.

Vanderbilt feared being beaten to the deal.

That was exactly what the syndicate wanted him to believe.

The trap worked.

Vanderbilt bought the railroad at a high price.

The purchase was intended to protect the interests of the Lake Shore system because the Nickel Plate ran parallel to it.

Eventually, the road was turned over to the Lake Shore Company.

The sellers had built the railroad cheaply and succeeded in selling it to Vanderbilt for as much as possible.

Vanderbilt later realized that he had made a serious mistake.

The mistake troubled him deeply.

By then, his health was already failing, and the mental strain only made matters worse.

He had always wanted his transactions to be clean and successful.

The Nickel Plate deal was the rare case in which he felt he had been outmaneuvered.

That failure weighed heavily on him during his final years.

Yet his greatest financial achievement remained the fortune he inherited and multiplied.

When he died, the estate was worth about $200 million.

Few fortunes in American history had ever reached such a size.

But Vanderbilt did not simply leave the money untouched.

His will distributed the fortune among his children and other beneficiaries with considerable care.

He had spent his life building, organizing, and expanding a vast financial empire.

In the end, he left behind not only an enormous fortune but also a transformed American railroad system.

His death marked the end of one of Wall Street's most powerful eras.

The Commodore had built the empire through aggression and relentless conquest.

William H. Vanderbilt expanded it through management, organization, investment, and patience.

He was not as flamboyant as his father.

He was quieter, more cautious, and more willing to compromise.

But his ability to turn an inherited fortune into an even greater one made him one of the most important financiers of nineteenth-century America.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!