Andrew Johnson’s Political Disaster and Impeachment
When I later blamed some of my own losses—and those of other Northern investors—in Southern securities on President Andrew Johnson, I had to explain how his strange political behavior helped damage Northern investments in the South.
Like several other Wall Street men, I believed that the President might be influenced by the goodwill and social pressure of Northern businessmen. We thought that if we approached him properly, we might persuade him to take a more reasonable position toward the South and Congress.
In 1866, we heard that President Johnson had been invited to Chicago to attend the ceremony for laying the cornerstone of a monument to Stephen A. Douglas.
I prepared a letter signed by several Wall Street men and other prominent citizens.
We urged the President to accept the invitation and asked him to stop in New York on his way West.
He accepted our invitation graciously.
We immediately began preparing a grand reception.
Our hope was simple: if we showed the President how warmly the business community of the North regarded him, perhaps he would soften his hostility toward Congress.
We also hoped he would use his influence in the South to encourage former Confederates to put politics aside, rebuild their businesses, and develop economic relations with the North.
The country desperately needed that kind of cooperation.
President Johnson left Washington near the end of August.
General Grant, Admiral Farragut, Secretary of the Navy Gideon Welles, Postmaster General Randall, and several other officials traveled with him.
When the party reached New York, Secretary of State William H. Seward joined them.
The reception was enormous by the standards of the time.
Crowds filled the streets to welcome the President.
A grand procession escorted him to City Hall, where city and state officials formally received him.
From there, the procession continued to Delmonico’s at Fourteenth Street and Fifth Avenue.
A magnificent dinner had been prepared.
Every detail was designed to show the President the highest possible respect.
A prominent citizen delivered a welcoming address.
President Johnson replied with a speech that was widely praised.
For a time, it looked like one of his finest performances.
He could be remarkably forceful when he spoke.
His speeches and official papers were often sharp, energetic, and persuasive.
There had probably never been a President who produced stronger or more forcefully argued political documents than Andrew Johnson.
The guests at Delmonico’s were delighted.
The dinner was a complete success.
Everything seemed to suggest that the President’s visit might help open a new era of peace and cooperation between North and South.
Then the party reached Albany.
There, everything changed.
It soon became clear that Johnson had not really come on a goodwill tour.
He intended to turn the journey into a political campaign.
He wanted to attack his enemies publicly and defend his Reconstruction policies against Congress.
A huge crowd gathered when he arrived in Albany.
At first, most people seemed willing to welcome him warmly.
The President was asked to speak.
Instead of giving a dignified presidential address, he launched into fierce attacks on the people who opposed him.
He had lowered himself from the position of President of the United States to that of an angry political campaigner.
Naturally, people in the crowd began to answer him.
Some challenged his arguments.
Others simply made jokes.
Several people amused themselves by joking about the Tennessee tailor who had somehow risen to the highest office in the country.
Johnson did not take the jokes lightly.
His temper exploded.
He began arguing with people in the crowd and trading insults with them.
Then someone displayed a small black flag.
The sight seemed to affect Johnson like a red flag waved in front of a bull.
He became furious.
Pointing toward the man holding it, he shouted:
“Who is that man who dares to hoist that black flag? Let him come up here and I will tell him what I think of him.”
The crowd was disgusted.
The President of the United States had just reduced himself to the level of an ordinary stump speaker.
People began jeering and shouting at him.
The entire meeting turned into a spectacle.
Johnson, who should have been the dignified central figure, became the main character in a political farce.
The less educated part of the crowd loved it.
The men who had arranged the President’s visit were humiliated.
His own friends were furious.
My business associates and I deeply regretted having anything to do with the trip.
It seemed that Johnson had lost control of himself after suddenly acquiring so much power.
The tour continued westward through Cleveland.
At Cleveland, Johnson made similar angry speeches.
By the time he reached Chicago, he had become a national joke.
He repeatedly spoke of “my policy.”
Soon the phrase became a sarcastic slogan.
Even boys on the streets shouted “my policy” at one another to mock him.
The whole journey became known as “Swinging Around the Circle.”
When Johnson finally returned to Washington, he had lost much of the public’s respect.
Instead of strengthening his position, the tour had turned him into an object of national ridicule.
Most people had lost confidence in him.
Another event also intensified the hostility against Johnson.
That was his attitude toward the New Orleans massacre, which had taken place only about a month before his political tour.
In 1864, a convention had created a new free constitution for Louisiana.
Its president later ordered the convention to meet again.
Former Confederate sympathizers, encouraged by Johnson’s policies, were determined to prevent the Republican convention from meeting.
They claimed that the convention intended to impose Black voting rights on Louisiana.
Violence followed.
A terrible riot and massacre took place.
More than a hundred people were killed, and several hundred were wounded.
The municipal authorities of New Orleans supported the rioters.
A congressional committee later investigated what had happened.
Its report stated that President Johnson knew violence was expected.
He knew what military orders were already in effect.
Yet, without the approval of the Secretary of War or the commanding General of the Army, he sent orders by telegraph that, if carried out, would have forced federal soldiers to assist the rebels against loyal citizens in New Orleans.
Those orders would also have helped people who were determined to prevent the convention from meeting.
The convention had been called with the approval of the governor and under the authority of a Louisiana Supreme Court judge who claimed to be acting as its president.
According to the congressional investigation, Johnson's actions encouraged those who intended to stop the convention.
His opposition to the Reconstruction Bill made him even more unpopular.
Congress passed the bill by large majorities in both the House and Senate.
Johnson's proposal concerning the national debt was also deeply unpopular.
In his December 1868 message to Congress, he argued that bondholders had already received more money in interest than their original investments were worth when measured in gold.
He therefore proposed that the government's six percent interest payments be applied directly to reducing the principal of the national debt.
He claimed that, under this plan, the entire debt could be paid off in sixteen years and eight months.
Congress rejected the idea almost unanimously.
But the most dramatic episode of Johnson's presidency was still ahead: his impeachment trial.
The trial lasted from March 5 to May 26, 1868.
Johnson was brought before the United States Senate.
Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase presided over the proceedings.
The President's legal team included Attorney General Henry Stanbery, who resigned his office so that he could defend Johnson, former Judge Benjamin R. Curtis, William S. Groesbeck, who replaced Judge Jeremiah Black, and William M. Evarts.
General Benjamin F. Butler delivered the opening argument against the President.
He accused Johnson of committing high crimes and misdemeanors.
William Lawrence of Ohio helped explain the legal case for impeachment.
The central charge involved Johnson's removal of Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton.
Congress claimed that Johnson had violated the Tenure of Office Act.
Under that law, Stanton was entitled to remain in office during the term of the President who had appointed him and for one additional month.
Stanton had been appointed by President Abraham Lincoln.
The constitutional question was therefore crucial.
Was Johnson merely completing Lincoln's unfinished presidential term?
Or, as Judge Curtis argued, was Johnson serving as President in his own right?
Curtis took the second position.
If Johnson was President in his own right, he argued, Stanton's original term of office had already expired.
As the trial came to an end, General John A. Logan and Representative George S. Boutwell spoke against Johnson.
Thaddeus Stevens wanted to deliver a speech himself, but he was too weak to read it.
He handed his manuscript to General Butler, who read it for him.
The speech received little response.
Thomas Williams of Pennsylvania then delivered a strong argument in favor of impeachment.
It was well received.
John A. Bingham gave the final major argument for the Senate.
He presented the charges against Johnson in the strongest possible terms.
He argued that a President could not excuse a violation of the law by claiming that he had the right to interpret the Constitution for himself.
If an ordinary citizen could not use such an excuse in court, Bingham argued, neither could the President.
The Constitution, he insisted, did not give the President judicial power.
His conclusion was devastating: if the Senate accepted Johnson's defense, it would effectively approve the violation of the Constitution and laws of a free people.
William M. Evarts then delivered what many considered the finest speech of his career.
His defense of Johnson was brilliant.
It probably played an important part in saving the President.
When the final vote was taken, Andrew Johnson escaped conviction by only one vote.
That deciding vote was cast by Senator Edmund G. Ross of Kansas.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!