The Dix Convention
Among the political events of the past twenty-five years in which I took an active part, the Republican convention at Utica that nominated General John A. Dix for Governor of New York deserves special attention. What happened there not only changed the state election, but also had a major effect on the presidential contest that followed.
I was a delegate to the convention.
When I stepped off the train at Utica, a gentleman approached me and introduced himself as Senator Roscoe Conkling’s private secretary.
“Mr. Clews, Senator Conkling asked me to invite you to stay with him while you are in Utica.”
I accepted the invitation, and he drove me to Conkling’s magnificent home. I was the only resident guest during my stay, an honor I greatly appreciated.
That evening, several prominent men joined us for dinner, including Chester A. Arthur, A. B. Cornell, William Orton, and General Sharpe.
After dinner, Conkling brought up the subject everyone had come to Utica to discuss.
“Mr. Clews,” he asked, “why wouldn’t George Opdyke make the best candidate for Governor?”
Opdyke and Conkling had always been on good terms. Only a few weeks earlier, Opdyke had been a guest at Conkling’s home, where General Grant was also present.
It seemed clear to me that Conkling favored Opdyke and that Grant had approved of the choice. The convention appeared to be little more than a formality.
I answered carefully.
“Senator, I have great respect for Mr. Opdyke. He is an able man, and as a fellow banker I have always respected him. But our real concern is bigger than the governorship. We must think about re-electing General Grant.”
Conkling listened.
“From that point of view,” I continued, “I don't think Opdyke is our strongest man.”
“Why not?”
“You remember that he was Mayor of New York during the riots of 1863. That was one of the most dangerous moments in the country's history. It was generally believed that he failed to show the courage expected of him.”
I paused.
“I understand how frightening those riots were. Even very brave men could have been intimidated. But the Mayor was expected to stand firm regardless of the personal danger. The public did not think Opdyke had met that standard.”
Conkling remained silent.
“There is another problem,” I said.
“What is that?”
“During the war, Opdyke was a special partner in a clothing company that received a government contract to supply uniforms for Union soldiers. The government rejected the clothing because the material was so poor. It was said that this was where the word ‘shoddy’ became associated with army clothing in this country.”
Conkling looked genuinely surprised.
After a moment, he admitted that Opdyke would not do.
But he was clearly embarrassed.
“Opdyke is here,” he said. “He expects the nomination. Someone ought to tell him to withdraw.”
A. B. Cornell immediately volunteered.
“I'll handle it.”
He went to see Opdyke and soon returned.
“It's done,” Cornell reported. “He agreed to withdraw. But he was furious. He took the first train home rather than remain here for the convention.”
Before leaving, Opdyke had told William H. Robertson, another leading candidate, that he was withdrawing and that his supporters would back Robertson.
Robertson was delighted.
He suddenly found himself in a much stronger position. There seemed to be no serious candidate left who could challenge him.
He spent the entire night working to secure the nomination.
The next morning, after breakfast, I left Conkling's house and began talking with the delegates.
Everything pointed toward Robertson.
His supporters were everywhere.
The nomination seemed almost certain.
I went to General Arthur's rooms, where the Republican caucus had established its headquarters. The rooms were crowded with party leaders.
Everyone seemed convinced that Robertson would be the nominee.
Someone suggested that we should march together to Robertson's hotel, congratulate him, and assure him that the party was behind him.
I refused.
My friends were surprised.
“Why won't you come with us?” one of them asked.
“I have nothing against Judge Robertson personally,” I replied. “But the New York Times has strongly criticized his record as a state senator. I don't believe the Times would support our ticket if he were at the top of it.”
“That matters that much?”
“It matters enormously. At this time, the Times is the only major New York newspaper we can depend on to fight for us. We need a candidate it can support.”
While the others went to congratulate Robertson, I went to the telegraph office.
I sent a message to General John A. Dix at his home in New York.
“You are favored by many of the delegates for Governor. If nominated, will you accept? For the sake of the country, answer in the affirmative.”
I signed it:
“Henry Clews.”
A short time later, I received Dix's reply.
“I have telegraphed your dispatch to West Hampton, where my father now is.”
It was dated August 21, 1872.
Soon afterward, the convention opened.
Robertson's name was presented.
The campaign managers had done their work well. The hall erupted in cheers.
But I noticed something.
Many delegates seemed to be cheering simply because everyone else was cheering.
Several speakers delivered glowing speeches about Robertson. Each speech produced another burst of applause.
The managers became convinced that Robertson's popularity was unstoppable.
Robertson himself appeared equally certain.
Then other candidates were mentioned, but none seemed capable of competing with him.
The convention was ready to make Robertson the nominee.
That was when I made my move.
I put General Dix's name before the convention.
The effect was immediate.
The delegates suddenly came alive.
The excitement surrounding Robertson seemed to disappear in an instant.
After speeches by Mr. Bruce and E. Delafield Smith, I rose.
“On behalf of the bankers and business men of New York, regardless of party, I say that the nomination of John A. Dix would do more for the Republican Party in the national election than any other name that could be offered.”
I continued:
“No other candidate would command the same confidence among the great financial interests of New York.”
The reaction was extraordinary.
The entire hall rose to its feet.
The delegates shouted and cheered.
The men managing the convention were stunned.
Robertson must have wondered what had happened to his supposedly certain victory.
The next morning, the New York Herald described the scene.
The newspaper reported that the enthusiasm created by my intervention swept the convention toward Dix. Delegates began shouting their support from every corner of the hall.
One delegation after another joined the movement.
St. Lawrence declared for Dix.
Then came Kings, Jefferson, Cayuga, and others.
The excitement became impossible to control.
Soon delegates were demanding that Dix be nominated by acclamation rather than by ballot.
The chairman, William A. Wheeler, objected.
“That motion is not in order. There are still other candidates before the convention.”
But the objection could not stop what was happening.
The movement for Dix had become a political storm.
Then something even more remarkable happened.
The man who had originally nominated Robertson stood up.
He announced that Robertson's name was being withdrawn.
The hall exploded with applause.
One after another, the other candidates were withdrawn as well.
Once again the delegates demanded that Dix be nominated by acclamation.
The vote was taken.
It was unanimous.
John A. Dix was the Republican candidate for Governor of New York.
The New York Times strongly endorsed the choice.
It declared that the convention had selected two of the strongest names available and described Dix as a Democrat whose character was beyond reproach.
The Times praised his service to the Union during the Civil War, his support for reform, his integrity, and his ability.
The paper concluded that Dix was the best man the convention could possibly have chosen.
Democrats who valued the Union could support him.
Republicans could support him without hesitation.
I was delighted.
At the close of the convention, I sent Dix another telegram.
“I took the responsibility of putting your name forward as a candidate for Governor, and now rejoice in informing you that the Convention has nominated you by acclamation.”
But when I returned to New York, I received a shocking reply.
“West Hampton, Aug. 22, 1872.
Henry Clews:
I have been compelled to decline.
John A. Dix.”
I was deeply disappointed.
That afternoon, I went to Long Branch to see General Grant.
We spent the evening together.
I showed him Dix's telegram.
“General,” I said, “we have to persuade Dix to reconsider. It is extremely important that he accept.”
Grant understood immediately.
“Why do you think his acceptance is so important?” he asked.
“Dix is a War Democrat,” I explained. “He can serve as a bridge between the Republicans and thousands of War Democrats who still hesitate to join us. That is exactly why I put his name before the convention.”
Grant agreed.
“You must write to him,” I said. “Urge him to accept.”
Grant agreed to do so.
Within a few days, he wrote to Dix.
The veteran general was deeply moved by a letter from his old comrade-in-arms. Yet he still hesitated.
He feared that accepting the Republican nomination after initially refusing it might make him appear inconsistent.
There was, however, one more person whose opinion mattered greatly.
His wife.
Dix decided that he would wait until Mrs. Dix returned from Europe before giving his final answer.
Grant's letter to Dix was dated August 24, 1872.
“My dear General,
I congratulate you on the unanimity and enthusiasm with which the Utica Convention nominated you for the honorable and responsible office of Governor of New York.
More than that, I congratulate the people of New York, almost regardless of party, because of your nomination.
I believe the great majority of the best people in the State will actively support you. Thousands more may secretly sympathize with you even though party loyalties force them to vote for your opponent.
To doubt your election would be to doubt the intelligence and patriotism of the people of New York.
With your election, reform in the State will naturally follow. Everyone agrees that reform has been needed for many years.
The abuses in New York politics cannot fairly be blamed on one party alone. Members of both parties have shared responsibility.
When I read the proceedings of the Utica Convention and saw the extraordinary unity surrounding you and the rest of the Republican ticket, I felt that victory had already been achieved and that reform had already begun.
I congratulate you not simply because you may become Governor, but because you have been given the opportunity to serve your State.
It is a fortunate day when a political convention searches for a candidate instead of candidates searching for a nomination.
That is exactly what happened at Utica.
Your obedient servant,
U. S. Grant.”
Dix replied on August 28.
“My dear General,
I am very grateful for your kind letter.
You know, of course, that I had declined the nomination before the convention met.
I am deeply conscious of the honor that has been offered to me, especially because of the extraordinary manner in which it was offered.
But my objections to accepting the nomination are very strong.
The only reason I continue to consider it is the importance of the election and the great public interests involved.
Mrs. Dix is expected to return from Europe on September 2 or 3.
As soon as I have had an opportunity to speak with her, I will answer the letter informing me of my nomination.
Very sincerely yours,
John A. Dix.”
The correspondence makes the situation clear.
The letter from Grant, which I take some credit for inspiring, strengthened Dix's resolve to reconsider.
Then Mrs. Dix's good judgment helped complete the decision.
The War Democrat who had initially refused the Republican nomination finally accepted it.
The result was exactly what I had hoped.
Dix was elected Governor.
His election helped guarantee Grant's re-election as President.
The Republican Party had brought a respected War Democrat into its ranks, and thousands of other War Democrats followed him.
They voted for Grant in the presidential election.
The Dix nomination was one of the greatest blows suffered by Horace Greeley during the campaign.
Greeley himself later acknowledged, even on his deathbed, that the Dix nomination, together with the great Grant meetings at Cooper Institute, had helped seal his political defeat.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!