Commodore Vanderbilt: How He Built His Vast Fortune
The most powerful figure I knew on Wall Street in my early days as a speculator was Commodore Cornelius Vanderbilt.
I will not go into every detail of his early life. For this story, it is enough to know that he began with a small rowboat, carrying passengers between Staten Island, Governor’s Island, and New York. He did the rowing himself.
Over time, that little business grew into a fleet of steam-powered boats.
While working as a ferryman, Vanderbilt also became the owner of a hotel in New Brunswick, New Jersey. The venture was not very profitable. Whatever his talents may have been, running a hotel was apparently not one of them.
The hotel still stood near the railroad station and was, then as now, little more than a railroad tavern.
My first strong memory of Vanderbilt as a Wall Street operator came from his dealings with the Nicaragua Transit Company.
The company had more than $4 million in capital. Vanderbilt became its president and soon took control of the entire operation.
The directors, stockholders, and practically everyone else connected with the company were gradually pushed aside until they had almost no power at all.
Once Vanderbilt had complete control, he grew larger and more powerful while the Nicaragua Company itself seemed to shrink in importance.
Eventually, the angry stockholders fought back.
The matter went to court and was investigated, but I never heard of the company recovering anything. I assume their claims were eventually written off as permanent losses.
After that, Vanderbilt started a steamship line to compete with the Pacific Mail fleet.
He kept his ships running until the Pacific Mail people finally paid him to withdraw from the competition.
Around this time, a story occurred that perfectly illustrates Vanderbilt's character.
His son-in-law, James M. Cross, had decided to enter the wholesale leather business in New York's "Swamp" district.
An experienced businessman had persuaded Cross to become his partner.
They had found a store and arranged everything for the new business except the money.
Cross was supposed to provide $50,000.
Since Vanderbilt was already wealthy and successful, Cross naturally assumed that borrowing $50,000 from his father-in-law would be easy.
He went to Vanderbilt, explained the business carefully, and asked for the money.
Vanderbilt listened.
Then he asked, "James, if I let you have this $50,000 for the leather business, how much do you think you can make for yourself from the profits?"
Cross knew he was dealing with a very hard-headed businessman.
So instead of making extravagant promises, he deliberately kept his estimate modest.
After thinking for a moment, he replied, "I believe I can almost certainly make $5,000 a year."
Vanderbilt answered immediately.
"James, I can do better than that myself with $50,000. So I'll give you $5,000 a year from now on, and you can consider yourself in my employ."
There was not much Cross could say after that.
He accepted the arrangement as gracefully as he could, whatever he may have felt inside.
Vanderbilt immediately sent him to San Francisco to manage his steamship business there.
But he soon discovered that Cross was not aggressive enough to deal with the hard-driving men of the Pacific Coast.
So Cross was recalled.
Vanderbilt then began looking for someone who could handle the rough and competitive world of the West.
He eventually met Commodore C. K. Garrison, who was then running a Mississippi steamboat.
Garrison had a reputation as the best euchre player on the river.
He was also known as a fearless and aggressive man.
In many ways, he resembled Jim Bludso, the famous fictional steamboat hero, except that Garrison had little of Bludso's self-sacrificing spirit.
Those were dangerous days on the Mississippi.
A large part of the passenger trade involved professional gamblers, many of whom were experts with bowie knives and revolvers.
A steamboat captain needed courage as well as business ability.
Vanderbilt interviewed Garrison.
The meeting ended with Garrison taking the job.
He went to San Francisco as Vanderbilt's agent.
It did not take long to discover that Garrison was exactly the kind of man needed on the Pacific Coast.
He also quickly realized how valuable he was to Vanderbilt.
So he repeatedly demanded higher pay.
Each time, Vanderbilt had little choice but to meet his price.
Garrison's salary kept rising until it reached the astonishing sum of $60,000 a year.
Stories of Garrison's enormous success on the Pacific Coast soon reached New York.
His reputation grew so quickly that people began talking about him more than they talked about Vanderbilt himself.
This eventually irritated the Commodore.
Vanderbilt began to realize something humiliating.
He was supposed to be Garrison's employer, but Garrison was becoming the real boss.
People in San Francisco treated Garrison as the important man and Vanderbilt as little more than his Eastern representative.
That was more than Vanderbilt could tolerate.
The partnership ended.
Not long afterward, Vanderbilt sold his steamship interests to Pacific Mail.
The monopoly was restored, and Vanderbilt, having lost the battle, had to look for another field.
From the moment he began working with his little rowboat on New York Harbor, Vanderbilt had enjoyed almost uninterrupted success.
His defeat by Pacific Mail was the first major setback he had experienced.
His break with Garrison also seemed, for a while, to threaten his future.
But Vanderbilt recovered.
He simply began moving toward a different kind of business.
His last great ship was the famous Vanderbilt, one of the finest vessels in the world at the time.
During the Civil War, he gave the ship to the United States government—or, according to another account, lent it to the government and never got it back.
At one point, Vanderbilt owned a fleet of about sixty ships.
But he was beginning to see that railroads offered something ships could not.
Transportation by water had limits.
Railroads did not.
Vanderbilt became convinced that the railroad business offered a much larger field and much greater profits.
So he turned his back on the sea and put his enormous energy into railroads.
His first major railroad campaign involved the Harlem Railroad.
He quietly began buying Harlem stock until he could control the company.
This led to the famous Harlem corner.
The railroad had asked the New York Legislature for certain advantages.
The request had been rejected, for reasons known best to the politicians involved.
Meanwhile, Harlem stock had fallen to a very low price.
Vanderbilt quietly bought it.
Then he went back to the Legislature and pushed for the bill he wanted.
Many legislators thought they had Vanderbilt trapped.
They brought their friends into the speculation and tried to use the situation to make money from him.
For a while, they appeared ready to pass the bill.
The market believed them.
Harlem stock rose.
The legislators sold the stock short.
Then they refused to pass the legislation.
They expected the stock to collapse.
And it did fall.
But Vanderbilt had been waiting for exactly that opportunity.
He bought more.
Instead of being crushed, he cornered the market.
The legislators were suddenly the ones in trouble.
They had to go to Vanderbilt's office and settle their positions on his terms.
Vanderbilt then arranged for the legislation he wanted to pass as part of the settlement.
It was a brilliant piece of financial and political maneuvering.
His next great move involved the New York Central Railroad.
After defeating the politicians in the Harlem affair, Vanderbilt was ready to play for much higher stakes.
Once he gained control of the New York Central, the railroad seemed to change overnight.
It was almost as if someone had touched it with the magic wand of King Midas.
Before Vanderbilt arrived, the railroad had struggled under the management of Dean Richmond, Samuel Sloan, and Henry Keep.
There had been little evidence of real prosperity.
Then Vanderbilt took control.
Suddenly the railroad began to move forward.
Its fortunes improved rapidly.
From that point on, the enterprise continued to prosper.
This demonstrated Vanderbilt's extraordinary ability to organize and manage enormous businesses.
But his manipulation of the railroad's stock was another story altogether.
On one occasion, he drove the stock up 20 percent between Saturday and Monday.
The move stunned some of the most experienced operators on the Stock Exchange.
He repeatedly pushed the stock up and down, drawing speculators into the market and then taking their money.
He kept the promise of a huge dividend shining before them.
Everyone wanted to own the stock when the dividend arrived.
But Vanderbilt managed the market so skillfully that by the time the famous 80 percent dividend was declared, many of those same speculators were too poor to hold any shares.
They had been "milked" dry.
As far as I knew, only one man managed to benefit from that dividend.
He was an old friend of Vanderbilt who had suffered severe losses in the Erie battles during the period when Jay Gould was skillfully controlling that railroad.
The man had been ruined in Erie.
His condition apparently awakened a rare moment of sympathy in Vanderbilt.
The Commodore quietly gave him a tip the day before the dividend was announced.
The friend then found another man to buy enough stock to make $700,000.
The profits were divided between them.
That was the only case I knew of in which Vanderbilt did not take the entire prize for himself.
The story of Vanderbilt's life provides extraordinary evidence of what tremendous business ability can accomplish in a relatively short time.
Vanderbilt and his son, William H. Vanderbilt, accumulated what was then the greatest private fortune in the world, except for the combined wealth of the Rothschild family.
The Rothschild fortune had been built over several generations through financial operations across Europe, supported by immense political and economic resources.
Yet the Vanderbilt fortune eventually reached roughly two-thirds of the combined Rothschild wealth.
That comparison shows just how extraordinary the result was.
Vanderbilt had risen from a boy rowing a small boat on New York Harbor to the owner of a fleet of dozens of steamships and, later, a vast railroad empire.
But his son's achievement was even more remarkable.
In seventy years, Vanderbilt rose from having almost nothing to possessing about $90 million.
William H. Vanderbilt inherited approximately $75 million of that fortune.
Then he nearly tripled it in only a fraction of the time.
His father had spent seventy years building his fortune.
William H. made three times as much as his father had made in only seven years.
In other words, during every two and a half years of his son's career, William H. accumulated about as much wealth as his father had accumulated during his entire seventy-year career.
If anyone had predicted such a thing to the old Commodore, he would probably have thought the man completely insane.
Even Vanderbilt himself could hardly have imagined what his fortune would become after his death.
If the dead could look down upon the world, one can imagine the old Commodore's ghost wandering through the magnificent Vanderbilt homes on Fifth Avenue or looking down from the roof of Grand Central Terminal and seeing how far his empire had grown beyond anything he had ever imagined.
Some people might argue that creating the first $90 million required greater ability than preserving and expanding the fortune afterward.
But there is little historical evidence to support that argument.
Few fortunes have ever grown so dramatically in such a short period.
Most wealthy families built their fortunes slowly over generations.
In many European families, fortunes actually declined as they were passed from one generation to another.
Only a few families, such as the Rothschilds and the Astors, managed to preserve and expand their wealth successfully.
In America, where estates were divided among heirs, the challenge was even greater.
William H. Vanderbilt had once been regarded as a man of only moderate ability.
Yet he proved himself to be one of the greatest financiers in history.
Jay Gould had enormous resources at his disposal.
He had access to newspapers, politicians, lawyers, judges, and courts.
Beginning in 1878, he had a financial position at least as strong as William H. Vanderbilt's.
Yet Gould eventually fell far behind Vanderbilt in the race for wealth.
William H. Vanderbilt achieved what may have been the greatest individual accumulation of wealth ever seen.
There is an old saying that anyone can make money, but it takes wisdom to keep it.
William H. Vanderbilt proved that he possessed both the ability to make money and the judgment to preserve it.
He not only protected the enormous fortune his father left him.
He added nearly three times as much to it.
His father therefore made a wise choice when he selected William H. to carry the Vanderbilt name and fortune into the future.
Yet this enormous fortune had one serious effect from the public's point of view.
When newspapers announced the size of William H. Vanderbilt's estate after his death, many wealthy people suddenly felt poor.
I do not blame the Vanderbilt family for this.
Every American has the opportunity to follow the path of the two great Vanderbilts—provided he has the ability.
But it would be foolish for everyone to try.
Most would simply lose everything.
The distribution of the Vanderbilt fortune also created dissatisfaction in many homes that had previously been perfectly happy.
That was almost inevitable.
Human nature is ambitious, especially in a highly competitive commercial society.
People who had always considered themselves rich and socially important because they had a million dollars or more suddenly felt insignificant.
Compared with the Vanderbilt fortune, their wealth seemed almost worthless.
The figures revealed in the Surrogate's Court were so enormous that they sounded like fiction.
They resembled the old story of Sinbad and the Valley of Diamonds.
But there was nothing fictional about them.
The numbers were real.
And that is precisely what made the comparison so painful.
It was a level of wealth that few people of that generation could ever hope to reproduce.
The possibility existed, of course.
But expecting every ambitious man to become another Vanderbilt was about as realistic as expecting every ordinary soldier in Napoleon's army to become a marshal simply because every soldier was said to carry a marshal's baton in his knapsack.
As the Reverend Robert Collyer once observed, every blacksmith might become a preacher, but it would be a disaster if all of them actually did.
The basic details of the Vanderbilt wills, which caused such a sensation throughout the country, are given elsewhere in this book.
They should remain fascinating reading for generations to come.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!