Samuel J. Tilden: How Opportunity Made Him Famous
William H. Havemeyer had been closely associated with Samuel J. Tilden for years in the business of breaking up troubled railroads and reorganizing them. Both men made a great deal of money through these operations.
When Havemeyer later invited Tilden to become one of the three lawyers representing the Committee of Seventy, Tilden immediately understood what the offer could mean for his future.
He knew how to recognize an opportunity.
He did not wait for the tide to turn. He caught it at its strongest point, like a skilled sailor who knows exactly when to raise his sails.
The reform movement was gathering tremendous momentum, and Tilden stepped aboard at precisely the right moment.
At first, this appointment brought him more fame than money.
But it gave him something far more valuable—the platform from which he would eventually build a national political career.
Before this, Tilden was relatively unknown to the public. His work with the Committee of Seventy gave him the opportunity to step into the political spotlight.
Tilden had one outstanding quality, both in politics and in finance.
He put a value on everything.
If he opened his political "barrel," he did not scatter the money everywhere. He spent it where he believed it would produce the greatest return.
I will leave it to the reader to decide exactly what Tilden considered a worthwhile investment.
The important point is that his position as counsel for the Committee of Seventy gave him a path upward.
He could move from being a successful railroad operator to becoming Governor of New York.
And from there, he came remarkably close to becoming President of the United States.
For a man who had previously been little known outside financial and political circles, the change was extraordinary.
One can only wonder what would have happened to Tilden if Havemeyer had not recognized his ability at exactly the right moment.
Perhaps he would have remained largely forgotten.
But Havemeyer found him when the opportunity was there and gave him the chance to step forward.
Tilden, for his part, made the most of it.
He showed remarkable judgment and proved that Havemeyer had chosen the right man.
The old saying that opportunity comes only once seemed especially appropriate in his case.
Tilden struck while the iron was hot.
He never reached the highest office he wanted, but his career showed just how far an obscure man could rise when ability, opportunity, good fortune, and the right connections came together.
Whether his success came mainly from luck, genius, wise guidance, or some combination of all three, I will not attempt to decide.
I can only describe what I saw and what I learned from following his career.
When the Committee of Seventy began its work, it passed a resolution allowing its chairman to appoint a subcommittee to select three lawyers to represent the organization in any legal proceedings arising from its investigations.
Havemeyer was a member of that subcommittee.
Through his influence, Samuel J. Tilden became one of the three lawyers.
The power of the Committee of Seventy at that time was enormous.
One of its recommendations helped make Abraham Lawrence a judge of the Supreme Court.
The third lawyer, W. H. Peckham, could probably have obtained almost any judgeship he wanted.
These are matters of public record.
They show just how much influence the committee possessed.
Judge Lawrence continued to serve on the bench with an excellent reputation, while Peckham later became an important lawyer in many of the major cases that became part of New York's history.
Tilden saw what the committee could accomplish.
He understood that it was not merely an investigative organization. It was a powerful force for political reform.
And he saw another opportunity.
If the committee stood for reform, then he could stand beside it as a reformer.
He built his new public identity on that foundation.
And this time, the foundation was solid.
Tilden used the opportunity with great skill.
Whatever his political enemies may have said about him, the man later known as the Sage of Greystone had to be judged by what he ultimately accomplished.
He became one of the most prominent and respected citizens in the country.
If age and certain physical problems had not stood in his way, he might have made a very capable President.
His record as Governor certainly suggested that possibility.
I have no personal hostility toward Tilden.
My purpose is not to attack him.
I simply want to show how quickly a man's entire destiny can change when he recognizes an opportunity at exactly the right moment.
In that respect, what I have said about Tilden is actually more favorable than unfavorable.
A man who rises so far through his own intelligence and hard work deserves respect.
I know something about the struggle involved in rising above the crowd. There are always people below who resent anyone who climbs too high, and there are others who will do everything they can to pull him back down.
Tilden not only earned success.
He commanded respect.
That deserves recognition.
I can therefore count myself among those who admired much of his career, while recognizing that human beings are never perfect.
Almost every successful man has some shadow hanging over his reputation.
Tilden was no exception.
Still, the way he eventually distributed most of his fortune deserves considerable praise.
Even strict moralists who disliked the way he had made his money would have found it difficult to ignore the enormous public benefit that came from his generosity.
There were probably few churches or charitable institutions in the country that would have refused a share of his fortune, regardless of what their members or ministers thought about his railroad dealings.
The lesson of Tilden's career is simple.
A man's destiny can change almost overnight.
But opportunity alone is not enough.
A man must have the intelligence to recognize it and the ability to turn it into something valuable.
Tilden had both.
That is why I have devoted these pages to his career.
His involvement with railroads places him naturally among the major Wall Street speculators, investors, and operators of his time.
His story therefore belongs in a book about Wall Street.
There was another remarkable episode after his death.
Tilden's will contained a very unusual provision.
He ordered that if any beneficiary challenged the will, that person would lose the inheritance.
Despite this warning, George H. Tilden and Samuel J. Tilden, the sons of Henry A. Tilden and nephews of the testator, challenged the will.
They did not claim that Tilden had lacked mental capacity or had been improperly influenced.
Their argument concerned the legal construction of the will.
Their lawyers were Henry L. Clinton and Aaron Vanderpoel.
There was something ironic about the situation.
Tilden had been deeply knowledgeable about the law.
Yet after his death, the legal validity of the very document he had carefully prepared became the subject of a major dispute.
The central issue concerned the creation of the Tilden Trust.
Tilden's will instructed his trustees to ask the New York Legislature to create an institution called the Tilden Trust.
The institution was supposed to establish and maintain a free library and reading room in New York City and to support scientific and educational work.
Once the corporation had been created, the trustees were supposed to transfer the remaining estate to it.
The contestants argued that this arrangement was legally defective.
Their position was that Tilden had effectively given his trustees the power to choose the ultimate public beneficiary of his estate.
According to recent decisions by the highest courts, a testator could not leave that power to someone else.
Only the person making the will could name the beneficiary.
Tilden apparently had a different legal theory in mind.
He seems to have relied upon an English rule that permitted this kind of arrangement.
His will stated that his executors and trustees should obtain an act of incorporation for an institution called the Tilden Trust.
The institution was to have at least five trustees.
Those trustees would have the power to fill vacancies.
If the corporation was legally established during the required period, Tilden authorized his executors and trustees to organize it, appoint its first trustees, and transfer to it the remainder of his estate.
The estate would first have to satisfy the special trusts created for particular individuals.
But if the Tilden Trust could not be incorporated, or if the executors considered another arrangement more appropriate, Tilden gave them another option.
They could use the remaining estate for charitable, educational, and scientific purposes.
Their goal was to make the fortune as broadly and substantially beneficial to mankind as possible.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!