← The Republic 2026 Edition
Chapter 3 · Courage, Education, and the Character of the Guardians

Courage, Education, and the Character of the Guardians

Chapter 3 of 10 · 11,418 words · Free

“Such, then,” I said, “are our principles concerning stories about the gods. Some stories should be told to our young students, while others must never be told to them. If we want them to respect the gods and their parents, and to value friendship with one another, we must be careful about what they hear from childhood.”

“Yes,” he said. “I think those principles are sound.”

“But if we want them to become courageous, must they not learn something more? They must learn lessons that free them from the fear of death. Can anyone truly be courageous while remaining terrified of death?”

“Certainly not.”

“And can a man who believes that the world below is a terrible and frightening place remain fearless of death? Would he choose death in battle rather than defeat and slavery?”

“Impossible.”

“Then we must control the poets who tell stories about the world below just as carefully as we control the other storytellers. We must ask them not to describe the underworld as something terrible, but rather to speak of it with approval. They must understand that frightening descriptions of the afterlife are false and harmful to the courage of our future warriors.”

“That is certainly our duty.”

“Then we will have to remove many passages from their poems. For example, we must remove the lines:

‘I would rather be a poor man’s servant, with no property of my own, than rule over all the dead who are no more.’

“And we must remove the passage describing how Pluto fears that the terrible and gloomy halls of the dead might become visible to gods and men.

“And this passage too:

‘O heavens! In the house of Hades there is only a soul and a shadowy form, but no mind at all.’

“And the description of Tiresias:

‘Even after death, Persephone allowed him to keep his understanding, while the other souls moved about like empty shadows.’

“And this:

‘Her soul left her body and went down to Hades, mourning her fate and leaving behind the strength and beauty of youth.’

“And this:

‘The soul slipped beneath the earth with a shrill cry, like smoke.’

“And this description:

‘Like bats squealing and clinging together in a mysterious cave when one falls from the rock, so the souls gathered together with shrill cries as they moved.’

“We must ask Homer and the other poets not to be offended when we remove passages like these. We are not rejecting them because they are poor poetry. Quite the opposite. Their poetry is so powerful and attractive that it makes such stories especially dangerous for young people who are supposed to grow up as free men and who should fear slavery more than death.”

“Absolutely,” he said.

“We must also reject all those terrifying names used to describe the underworld—Cocytus, Styx, ghosts beneath the earth, lifeless shadows, and all those other words that make the listener shudder from the depths of his soul.

“I am not saying that such stories can never serve any purpose. But there is a danger that they will make our guardians nervous, weak, and overly sensitive.”

“That danger is real,” he said.

“Then we must remove such stories.”

“I agree.”

“We must compose and sing stories of a different and nobler kind.”

“Clearly.”

“And what about the crying and lamentations of famous men? Shall we remove those too?”

“They should go as well.”

“Let us think carefully. Our principle is that a good man should not regard death as something terrible when it happens to another good man who is his friend.”

“Yes, that is our principle.”

“Therefore, he will not mourn his dead friend as though something terrible has happened to him.”

“No, he will not.”

“We also say that a good man is sufficient for himself and his own happiness. Therefore, he is less dependent on others.”

“That is true.”

“And so the loss of a son or brother, or even the loss of wealth, should be less terrifying to him than to anyone else.”

“Certainly.”

“And therefore he will be less likely to lament. He will endure such misfortune with greater calm.”

“Yes, he will feel it less deeply than another man would.”

“Then we are right to remove the lamentations of famous men from our poetry and leave them to women—and not even to respectable women—or to men of a lower character. Those who are being trained to defend their country should be ashamed to behave in such a way.”

“That is entirely right.”

“Then once again we must ask Homer and the other poets not to portray Achilles, the son of a goddess, throwing himself first on his side, then on his back, then on his face; rising suddenly and wandering madly along the barren shore; grabbing handfuls of black ashes and pouring them over his head; or crying and lamenting in all the ways Homer describes.

“And they should not portray Priam, a man related to the gods, begging and pleading in the dirt, calling every man by name.

“Even more strongly, we must object when poets make the gods themselves cry and lament:

‘Alas for me! What misery! Why did I ever give birth to the greatest of heroes?’

“If the gods must appear in stories, they certainly must not be portrayed as saying things like:

‘O heavens! I see a dear friend of mine being driven around the city, and my heart is filled with sorrow.’

“Or:

‘What misery! I am destined to see Sarpedon, the man dearest to me, defeated by Patroclus, son of Menoetius.’

“For, my dear Adeimantus, if our young people seriously listen to such disgraceful descriptions of the gods, rather than laughing at them as they should, how could they possibly believe that being dishonoured in the same way would be shameful for an ordinary human being?

“They would have no reason to control themselves. They would simply imitate these examples, whining and complaining whenever anything unpleasant happened to them.”

“Yes,” he said. “That is absolutely true.”

“And yet,” I replied, “the argument we have just established shows that this must not happen. We must hold firmly to our principle unless someone can give us a better argument.”

“Certainly.”

“Our guardians must not be constantly laughing either. Excessive laughter usually produces an equally violent reaction afterward.”

“I agree.”

“Then respectable men, even ordinary mortal men, should not be portrayed as being overcome by laughter. And certainly the gods must never be portrayed that way.”

“Certainly not.”

“Then we cannot accept Homer’s description of the gods laughing uncontrollably when they see Hephaestus struggling around the divine palace.”

“According to your principles, we must reject it.”

“According to my principles, if you want to put it that way. But whether you attribute them to me or not, we certainly must reject it.”

“Another principle is that truth should be highly valued. We said earlier that lying is useless to the gods and useful to human beings only as a kind of medicine. If it is a medicine, then only physicians should administer it. Ordinary people have no business using it.”

“Clearly not.”

“Therefore, if anyone in the State is ever allowed to lie, it should be the rulers. They may lie to enemies or even to their own citizens when doing so serves the good of the whole State.

“But everyone else must stay away from lying. And if a private citizen lies to the rulers, that should be considered a more serious offense than when a patient lies to a doctor about his illness, or a student lies to his trainer about his physical condition, or a sailor lies to the captain about what is happening aboard the ship, either to himself or to the other sailors.”

“That is absolutely true.”

“So if a ruler catches anyone else in the State lying—whether he is a craftsman, priest, doctor, carpenter, or anyone else—he should punish him for introducing a practice that could damage the State just as surely as it could damage a ship.”

“Certainly, if our State is ever established.”

“Next, our young people must learn self-control.”

“Of course.”

“Generally speaking, are not the main elements of self-control obedience to one's commanders and control over one's physical desires?”

“Yes.”

“Then we should approve of words like those of Diomedes in Homer:

‘Friend, sit quietly and obey my command.’

“And we should approve the description of the Greeks marching bravely and silently respecting their leaders, along with other sentiments of the same kind.”

“We certainly should.”

“What about the line:

‘Drunk with wine, with the eyes of a dog and the heart of a deer,’

“and the insults that follow? Would you say that such language, or similar insults that private individuals are supposed to address to their rulers in poetry or prose, is good or bad?”

“Bad.”

“They may provide some amusement, but they do nothing to develop self-control. So they are likely to harm young people. Would you agree?”

“Yes.”

“And what about making the wisest of men say that nothing is more wonderful than sitting at a table piled high with bread and meat while wine is constantly being poured into one's cup?

“Is that appropriate for a young man to hear if we want him to learn self-control?

“Or consider the line:

‘The worst fate of all is to die and meet one's destiny through hunger.’

“What do you think of that?

“And what about the story of Zeus? While all the other gods and human beings were asleep, Zeus alone stayed awake making plans. But then he became so overcome by lust when he saw Hera that he forgot everything he had been planning. He could not even wait to reach a private place. He wanted to lie with her right there, saying that he had never felt such desire, not even when they first met secretly without their parents knowing.

“And then there is the story of Hephaestus binding Ares and Aphrodite in chains because of their sexual misconduct.”

“I strongly agree,” he said. “Young people should never hear such stories.”

“But stories about famous men enduring hardship should certainly be shown and told to them. For example:

‘He struck his chest and said to his heart, “Endure, my heart. You have suffered worse than this.”’”

“Certainly,” he said.

“Next, we must not teach them to accept gifts or to love money.”

“Certainly not.”

“Nor should we sing to them that gifts can persuade gods or even respected kings.

“And Phoenix, the tutor of Achilles, should not be praised for telling Achilles to accept gifts from the Greeks and then help them, but to remain angry if no gift was offered.

“Nor should we accept the idea that Achilles himself was so greedy that he accepted Agamemnon's gifts, or that he agreed to return Hector's body only after being paid, while refusing to do so without payment.”

“Those are certainly not ideas we can approve,” he said.

“I love Homer too much to accuse him lightly. But when he attributes such feelings to Achilles, I cannot help thinking that the story is deeply wrong.

“Nor can I believe the story of Achilles insulting Apollo:

‘You have wronged me, most hateful of gods. If I had the power, I would repay you.’

“Nor can I believe that Achilles would attack the river god as though the god were merely an ordinary enemy.

“Nor can I believe that he would cut off his hair and offer it to the dead Patroclus when that hair had already been dedicated to the river god Spercheius.

“Nor can I believe that he dragged Hector's body around Patroclus's tomb and slaughtered captives at Patroclus's funeral pyre.

“I cannot accept any of these stories. Nor can I believe that Achilles—the student of the wise centaur Chiron, the son of a goddess and of Peleus, one of the gentlest of men and a descendant of Zeus—could have been so mentally confused that he was simultaneously ruled by greed and contempt for both gods and men.”

“You are right,” he said.

“And we should equally reject the stories about Theseus, son of Poseidon, and Peirithous, son of Zeus, going out to commit terrible acts of sexual violence, or any other stories in which heroes or sons of gods are described as committing such wicked and impious acts.

“We must force the poets to say either that these things never happened, or that the men who did them were not the sons of gods. They cannot have it both ways.

“We will not allow poets to teach our young people that the gods are responsible for evil or that heroes are no better than ordinary criminals. Such stories are neither pious nor true, because we have already established that evil cannot come from the gods.”

“Certainly not.”

“And such stories will also harm those who hear them. Once people believe that the relatives of the gods and descendants of Zeus regularly commit wicked acts, everyone will use the same stories to excuse his own behavior.

“They will say, ‘If the descendants of the gods can behave like this, why should I be ashamed?’

“So let us put an end to such stories before they corrupt the morals of the young.”

“Absolutely,” he said.

“Now that we have decided what subjects may and may not be spoken about, let us see whether we have left anything out.

“We have already discussed how stories should portray gods, demigods, heroes, and the world of the dead.”

“Very true.”

“Then what remains is human beings.”

“Clearly.”

“But we are not yet able to answer that question, my friend.”

“Why not?”

“Because, unless I am mistaken, we shall have to say that poets and storytellers make some of their worst mistakes when they tell us that wicked people are often happy while good people are miserable; that injustice is profitable when it remains hidden; and that justice harms the person who practices it while benefiting someone else.

“We shall forbid them to say such things and command them to say the opposite.”

“Certainly,” he replied.

“If you agree that I am right about this, then you have already accepted the principle we have been arguing for all along.”

“I agree.”

“But we cannot decide exactly what should or should not be said about human beings until we have discovered what justice actually is, and whether justice naturally benefits the person who possesses it, whether or not other people recognize him as just.”

“That is certainly true.”

“Then we have finished discussing the subjects of poetry. Let us now turn to its style. Once we have examined style, both the subject matter and the manner of poetry will have been dealt with.”

“I do not understand what you mean,” Adeimantus said.

“Then I must explain it. Perhaps it will be clearer if I put it this way.

“You know that all poetry and mythology is a narration of events. These events may have happened in the past, may be happening now, or may happen in the future.”

“Certainly.”

“And narration can take three forms. It can be simple narration, imitation, or a mixture of the two.”

“I am not sure I understand.”

“Then I must be a poor teacher if I cannot make myself clear. Like a bad speaker, I will not explain everything at once. I will take one small example.

“You know the opening of the Iliad. The poet tells us that Chryses came to Agamemnon and begged him to release his daughter. Agamemnon became angry with him. Chryses failed to achieve his purpose and then prayed to the god to punish the Greeks.

“Up to the point where the poet says:

‘And he prayed to all the Greeks, especially the two sons of Atreus, the leaders of the people,’

“Homer speaks in his own voice. He never makes us think he is anyone else.

“But after that, he takes on the character of Chryses. He does everything possible to make us believe that the person speaking is not Homer but the old priest himself.

“This same technique runs throughout his stories of Troy, Ithaca, and the events of the Odyssey.”

“Yes.”

“And the whole thing is still narration, whether the poet is speaking through direct speeches or describing what happens between those speeches.”

“Exactly.”

“But when the poet speaks in the character of someone else, does he not adapt his style to sound like the person he claims is speaking?”

“Certainly.”

“And this adaptation—using voice, gesture, or manner to imitate the person whose character he has assumed—is imitation.”

“Of course.”

“So when the poet narrates events in this way, his narration is based on imitation.”

“Exactly.”

“But if the poet always speaks in his own voice and never pretends to be anyone else, then the imitation disappears and the poetry becomes simple narration.

“To make this completely clear, imagine that Homer had described the beginning of the Iliad like this:

‘The priest came carrying the ransom for his daughter and begged the Greeks, especially their kings, to return her. He prayed to the gods that the Greeks might capture Troy and return safely home. He asked them to accept the ransom, respect the god, and return his daughter. The Greeks respected the priest and agreed with him.

“But Agamemnon became angry and ordered him to leave and never return. He warned that the god's staff and sacred wreath would not protect him. His daughter would remain in Argos and grow old there. Agamemnon ordered him to leave immediately if he wanted to return home safely.

“The old man left the camp in fear and silence. When he was far away, he prayed to Apollo, calling him by all his names and reminding him of the temples he had built and the sacrifices he had offered. He asked the god to repay his devotion and punish the Greeks for his tears.’

“And so on.

“If Homer had told the story entirely in that way, without speaking as Chryses, it would be simple narration.”

“I understand,” he said.

“Or imagine the opposite. Suppose the ordinary narrative passages were removed and only the dialogue remained.”

“I understand that too,” he said. “You mean something like tragedy.”

“Exactly. Now you understand what I was trying to explain.

“Poetry and mythology sometimes consist almost entirely of imitation, as in tragedy and comedy. Sometimes the poet is the only speaker, as in the dithyramb. And sometimes the two forms are mixed, as in epic poetry and other kinds of poetry.”

“Yes,” he said. “I understand now.”

“Remember what I said at the beginning: we had finished discussing the subject matter and were going to discuss style.”

“I remember.”

“What I meant was that we now have to decide what to do about imitation.

“Should poets be allowed to imitate characters when telling their stories? If so, should they imitate everything, or only certain things? Or should imitation be completely forbidden?”

“I suppose you are asking whether tragedy and comedy should be allowed in our State.”

“Yes. But the question may be broader than that. I do not yet know exactly where the argument will take us. Wherever it leads, we will follow.”

“And I will follow with you,” he said.

“Then tell me, Adeimantus: should our guardians be imitators?

“Or has that question already been answered by our principle that one person should devote himself to one task? A person cannot do many things equally well. If he tries to do too many, he will fail to become excellent at any of them.”

“Certainly.”

“And the same applies to imitation. No one can imitate many different things as well as he can imitate one.”

“He cannot.”

“Then the same person cannot both live a serious life and become a skilled imitator of many different characters.

“Even in closely related forms of imitation, the same people cannot succeed at both. For example, tragedy and comedy are both forms of imitation, yet the same writers cannot excel equally at both.”

“That is true.”

“Nor can someone be both a rhapsode and an actor.”

“True.”

“Nor are comic actors and tragic actors usually the same people. Yet all these activities are forms of imitation.”

“They are.”

“And human nature seems to be divided into smaller and smaller parts. A person is no better at imitating many things than he is at performing many different kinds of real work.”

“That is certainly true.”

“Then let us return to our original principle.

“Our guardians must devote themselves entirely to protecting the freedom of the State. That is their profession. They should not practice or imitate anything unrelated to that purpose.

“If they imitate anything, they should begin from childhood by imitating only the qualities appropriate to their profession: courage, self-control, holiness, freedom, and similar virtues.

“They should not imitate cowardice, slavery, vulgarity, or any other base quality. Otherwise, by repeatedly imitating such behavior, they may gradually become like the characters they imitate.

“Have you never noticed that imitation, when practiced from childhood and continued for many years, eventually becomes a habit and almost a second nature? It affects the body, the voice, and even the mind.”

“Yes, certainly,” he said.

“Then we must not allow those whom we are training to become good men to imitate a woman—young or old—arguing with her husband, boasting against the gods because she thinks herself happy, or crying and grieving in misfortune.

“They must certainly not imitate women who are sick, in love, or giving birth.”

“Quite right.”

“Nor should they imitate male or female slaves performing the work of slaves.”

“Certainly not.”

“Nor should they imitate bad men—cowards, drunkards, people who insult and mock one another, or people who behave disgracefully toward themselves and others.

“They should not be trained to imitate mad or vicious people either. We need to understand madness and vice, but we must never practice or imitate them.”

“Very true.”

“Nor should they imitate blacksmiths, craftsmen, rowers, sailors, or people in similar occupations.”

“How could they,” he said, “when they are not even supposed to devote themselves to those occupations?”

“Nor should they imitate the sounds of horses, bulls, rivers, the sea, thunder, or anything of that sort.”

“But if madness itself is forbidden,” he said, “then they certainly should not imitate the behavior of madmen.”

“You understand me correctly.

“There is one kind of narrative style that a genuinely good man may use, and another used by someone of the opposite character.”

“What are they?” he asked.

“Suppose a good and just man is telling a story and comes to something said or done by another good man. He will probably be willing to imitate him. He will not be ashamed of doing so.

“He will especially enjoy imitating the good man when he is behaving with courage and wisdom.

“But if the good man becomes sick, falls in love, gets drunk, or suffers some other misfortune, he will be less eager to imitate him.

“When he comes across a character who is beneath him, he will not spend much time imitating that person. At most, he may imitate him briefly if the character happens to do something good.

“Otherwise, he will be ashamed to act like someone he has never trained himself to become. He will not want to shape himself after inferior models. He will consider such imitation beneath him unless he is doing it as a joke.”

“That is what I would expect,” he said.

“Then his style will resemble the method we saw in Homer. It will contain both imitation and narration, but very little imitation and much more narration.”

“Certainly.”

“But there is another kind of person who will imitate anything.

“The worse he is, the less ashamed he will be. Nothing will seem beneath him. He will imitate anything seriously, not merely as a joke, and he will perform before a large audience.

“He will imitate thunder, wind, hail, wheels, pulleys, flutes, pipes, trumpets, and every kind of instrument. He will bark like a dog, bleat like a sheep, or crow like a rooster.

“His whole art will consist of imitating voices and gestures, while almost no narration remains.”

“That would indeed be his style,” he said.

“So there are two basic styles?”

“Yes.”

“One is simple, with only a few changes. If the harmony and rhythm are also simple, then the speaker's style remains fairly consistent. He uses almost one kind of harmony and one kind of rhythm.”

“That is true.”

“The other style requires many different harmonies and rhythms, because it contains many different changes in character.”

“That is also true.”

“And these two styles—or a mixture of them—cover all poetry and every form of spoken expression. Nothing can be said except through one of them or through a mixture of both.”

“They cover everything,” he said.

“Then should we admit all three styles into our State? Or only one of the two pure styles? Or perhaps the mixed style?”

“I would prefer to admit only the pure imitation of virtue.”

“Yes, Adeimantus. But the mixed style is very attractive. In fact, the highly imitative style you have rejected is extremely popular with children, their teachers, and the general public.”

“I cannot deny that.”

“But you would agree that it is unsuitable for our State. Our State is founded on the principle that human beings should not try to play many different roles. Each person should have one proper occupation.”

“Yes. It would be unsuitable.”

“And that is why, in our State, a shoemaker will be a shoemaker, not a pilot as well; a farmer will be a farmer, not a judge; a soldier will be a soldier, not a merchant; and so on.”

“Exactly.”

“Therefore, if one of these highly skilled performers comes to us and says that he can imitate anything and wants to perform his poetry for us, we will admire him as a remarkable and almost sacred person.

“But we will also tell him that such people cannot live in our State. Our laws do not allow it.

“We will pour perfume over him, place a woolen crown on his head, and send him away to another city.

“Our own State needs a stricter kind of poet and storyteller—one who imitates virtue and follows the models we established when we began educating our soldiers.”

“Certainly,” he said, “if we have the power.”

“Then, my friend, we can consider the part of education dealing with stories and mythology complete. We have discussed both what should be said and how it should be said.”

“I agree.”

“Next comes melody and song.”

“Obviously.”

“Everyone can already see what our principles require here, if we remain consistent.”

Glaucon laughed.

“I am afraid,” he said, “that ‘everyone’ does not include me. I cannot say at this moment exactly what the answer should be, although I can make a guess.”

“At least you know that every song has three elements: words, melody, and rhythm.”

“Yes, I know that much.”

“And the rules governing the words are the same whether the words are sung or spoken. We have already established those rules.”

“Yes.”

“And the melody and rhythm must fit the words.”

“Certainly.”

“We said earlier that our poetry has no place for mourning and lamentation.”

“That is true.”

“Then which musical harmonies express sorrow? You are the musician here. Tell me.”

“The mixed and deep Lydian harmonies, and the full-toned or low Lydian, and similar forms.”

“Then these must be banished.

“They are not even useful for women who are supposed to be respectable, much less for men.”

“Certainly.”

“Next, drunkenness, softness, and laziness are completely inappropriate for our guardians.”

“Completely.”

“And which harmonies are associated with softness and drinking?”

“The Ionian and Lydian,” he replied. “They are called relaxed harmonies.”

“Are they useful for soldiers?”

“Quite the opposite.”

“Then we have only the Dorian and Phrygian left.”

“I suppose so.”

“I know nothing about the technical details of musical harmonies,” I said, “but I want one that expresses the voice of a brave man facing danger and making a firm decision.

“I want the harmony of a man who is wounded, dying, or suffering some other disaster, yet stands firm and endures whatever happens to him.

“And I want another harmony for peaceful times, when a man is free from immediate danger and is trying to persuade a god through prayer, or a human being through teaching and advice.

“It should also express a man who is willing to listen to persuasion, to accept advice, or to yield to someone's request.

“And when he succeeds through his own good judgment, it should show a man who remains moderate and sensible rather than becoming proud or carried away by success.

“These are the two harmonies I want us to keep: the harmony of necessity and the harmony of freedom; the harmony of hardship and the harmony of good fortune; the harmony of courage and the harmony of self-control.”

“And those,” he replied, “are the Dorian and Phrygian harmonies I mentioned.”

“Then if we use only those two, we will not need a great variety of notes or a scale containing every possible harmony.”

“I suppose not.”

“Then we will not support lyre-makers who create complicated instruments with many corners and elaborate scales, or makers of other instruments with many strings and complex harmonies.”

“Certainly not.”

“What about flute-makers and flute-players? Would we admit them?

“When you consider that the flute, because it can produce so many different harmonies, is even more complicated than all the stringed instruments put together, should we allow it?”

“Clearly not.”

“Then the only instruments we need in the city are the lyre and the harp. Shepherds in the countryside may have their simple pipes.”

“That certainly follows from our argument.”

“There is nothing strange, then, about choosing Apollo and his instruments rather than Marsyas and his.”

“Not at all.”

“And so,” I said, “without even realizing it, we have been purifying the State we once called luxurious.”

“And wisely so,” he replied.

“Then let us complete the purification.

“After harmonies come rhythms. They must follow the same principles. We should not seek complicated metres or every possible rhythmic pattern. Instead, we must discover which rhythms express courage and order in life.

“Once we find them, we should adapt the rhythm and melody to words that express the same character. We must never force the words to fit the rhythm and melody.

“You must tell me what those rhythms are, just as you told me about the harmonies.”

“I cannot,” he said. “I only know that there are about three basic principles from which rhythmic patterns are formed, just as musical harmonies are built from a limited number of notes. But I cannot say what kinds of life those rhythms imitate.”

“Then we should consult Damon. He can tell us which rhythms express vulgarity, arrogance, anger, and other bad qualities, and which express their opposites.

“I vaguely remember him mentioning a complicated Cretan rhythm, a dactylic or heroic rhythm, and perhaps an iambic and a trochaic rhythm.

“But I do not fully understand his technical explanation. We should leave these questions to Damon.”

“That would probably be best,” he said.

“But there is no difficulty in seeing that grace comes from good rhythm and lack of grace from bad rhythm.”

“None at all.”

“And good rhythm naturally follows good style, while bad rhythm follows bad style. The same is true of harmony and discord.

“Our principle is that rhythm and harmony must follow the words, not the words follow them.”

“Exactly.”

“And the words and style depend on the character of the soul.”

“Yes.”

“And everything else depends on style.”

“Yes.”

“Then beauty of style, harmony, grace, and good rhythm all depend on simplicity.

“Not the kind of simplicity that is merely another word for stupidity, but the genuine simplicity of a mind and character that are properly ordered and noble.”

“Very true.”

“And if our young people are going to live good lives, should they not pursue these qualities constantly?”

“They certainly should.”

“The same qualities appear in painting and every other creative art—in weaving, embroidery, architecture, craftsmanship, and even in nature, in animals and plants.

“Everything can possess grace or lack grace.

“Ugliness, disorder, and disharmony are closely related to bad language and bad character. Grace and harmony are closely related to goodness and virtue.”

“That is completely true.”

“Then should our supervision stop with poetry? Should we require poets to represent goodness in their works, while allowing other artists to represent vice, self-indulgence, vulgarity, and indecency?

“Should we allow sculptors, architects, and other artists to display such things?

“Or should anyone who cannot follow our rule be prevented from practicing his art in our State, so that our citizens' taste is not corrupted?

“We do not want our guardians growing up surrounded by images of moral ugliness, as though they were grazing in a poisonous field, slowly eating one harmful plant after another until corruption fills their souls without their even noticing it.

“Instead, our artists should be people who understand the true nature of beauty and grace.

“Then our young people will grow up surrounded by beautiful sights and sounds. They will live in an environment that is healthy for the soul.

“Beauty will enter through their eyes and ears like a fresh, healthy breeze from a pure land. From their earliest years, it will quietly lead their souls toward harmony with reason.”

“There could be no better education,” he said.

“And that is why,” I said, “musical education is more powerful than almost anything else.

“Rhythm and harmony penetrate deep into the soul. They establish themselves there and give the soul grace.

“A properly educated soul becomes graceful; an improperly educated one becomes ugly and disordered.

“A person who has received true inner education becomes able to notice what is missing or wrong in art and nature. His judgment becomes refined.

“He praises and welcomes what is good and beautiful, takes it into his soul, and gradually becomes noble and good.

“He rejects and hates what is ugly and bad, even while he is still young and cannot yet explain why.

“Later, when reason develops, he will recognize goodness as an old friend, because his education has already taught him to love it.”

“Yes,” he said. “I completely agree that our young people should be educated through music for these reasons.”

“It is like learning to read.

“When we learn the alphabet, there are only a few letters, but we must learn to recognize every one of them wherever it appears, whether large or small, whether written alone or combined with others.

“We do not say, ‘This letter is too small to matter,’ or ‘That one looks different, so it must be something else.’

“We keep practicing until we can recognize the letters wherever they appear.”

“Exactly.”

“And once we know the letters themselves, we can recognize them even when we see their reflections in water or a mirror.

“The same knowledge allows us to recognize the letters in both places.”

“Exactly.”

“In the same way, neither we nor our guardians can truly become musical until we learn to recognize the essential qualities of self-control, courage, generosity, magnificence, and their related virtues—and also their opposites—in every combination.

“We must be able to recognize them wherever they appear, whether in great matters or small ones.

“We must understand that all of them belong to the same field of knowledge.”

“Certainly.”

“And when a beautiful soul is united with a beautiful body, so that the two are perfectly harmonious, would that not be the most beautiful sight for anyone capable of seeing it?”

“The most beautiful indeed.”

“And the most beautiful is also the most lovable?”

“That seems obvious.”

“And a person who loves harmony will naturally love what is beautiful. But he will not love someone whose soul is disordered and ugly.”

“That is true,” he said, “provided the defect is in the soul. If the other person's body happens to have some physical defect, however, I would still be patient with him and love him.”

“I see that you have had some experience with this,” I said.

“But I agree with you.

“Now let me ask another question. Can excessive pleasure have anything to do with self-control?”

“How could it?” he replied. “Pleasure can weaken a person's judgment just as much as pain can.”

“Can excessive pleasure have anything to do with virtue?”

“Not at all.”

“What about recklessness and lack of self-control?”

“Yes, very strongly.”

“And is there any pleasure greater or more intense than sexual pleasure?”

“No, and none more likely to drive a person mad.”

“True love, however, is love of beauty and order. It is controlled and harmonious.”

“Exactly.”

“Then madness and lack of self-control should never be allowed to approach true love.”

“Certainly not.”

“So uncontrolled sexual pleasure must never come between the lover and the beloved. If their love is genuine, neither of them should take part in it.”

“Absolutely not.”

“Then in the city we are founding, you would make a law saying that a lover must show no greater physical familiarity with his beloved than a father would show his son, and only for a noble purpose.

“He must first have the other person's consent, and this rule must govern all their interactions.

“He must never be seen going beyond these limits. If he does, he should be regarded as vulgar and lacking in good taste.”

“I completely agree,” he said.

“That completes our discussion of music.

“And what better conclusion could music have than love of beauty?”

“I agree.”

“After music comes physical training, where our young people must next be educated.”

“Certainly.”

“Physical training, like music, should begin in childhood. It should be carefully supervised and continue throughout life.

“My own belief—and I would like you to confirm it—is that a good body does not make the soul better through its physical excellence.

“Rather, a good soul improves the body as much as possible through its own excellence.

“What do you think?”

“I agree.”

“Then once the mind has been properly trained, we can leave the detailed care of the body to it.

“To avoid unnecessary detail, we will discuss physical training only in broad terms.”

“Very good.”

“We have already said that guardians must avoid drunkenness. Of all people, a guardian should be the last person to become drunk and not even know where he is.”

“Yes,” he said. “It would be absurd for a guardian to need another guardian to look after him.”

“Now what shall we say about their food? They are preparing for the greatest contest of all, are they not?”

“Yes.”

“Would the training diet of ordinary athletes be suitable for them?”

“Why not?”

“I am afraid that the bodies of ordinary athletes are trained in a way that makes them sleepy and unhealthy.

“Do you not see that these athletes spend much of their lives sleeping, and that if they depart even slightly from their usual diet and routine, they can become seriously ill?”

“Yes, I have noticed that.”

“Our warrior-athletes need a better kind of training.

“They must be like alert dogs, able to see and hear with exceptional sharpness.

“On campaign they will have to endure changes in water and food, extreme summer heat, winter cold, and many other hardships. Their health must not collapse under such conditions.”

“I agree.”

“The best kind of physical training is the twin sister of the simple musical training we just described.”

“How so?”

“I believe there is a kind of physical training that is simple and healthy, just as our music is simple and healthy.

“Military training is the clearest example.”

“What do you mean?”

“Homer gives us an example.

“When his heroes are campaigning, they eat simple soldiers' food. They are near the Hellespont, yet they do not eat fish. They are given roast meat rather than elaborate boiled dishes, because roasting requires only a fire and does not require soldiers to carry pots and cooking equipment.”

“True.”

“And Homer hardly ever mentions sweet sauces.

“He is not alone in avoiding them. Professional athletes know very well that anyone who wants to remain fit should avoid such things.”

“Yes, and they are right.”

“Then you would not approve of elaborate Syracusan meals or the rich cooking of Sicily.”

“I think not.”

“Nor would you approve of a Corinthian girl kept as a man's expensive companion if he is supposed to remain physically fit.”

“Certainly not.”

“Nor would you approve of the luxurious Athenian desserts people praise so highly.”

“Certainly not.”

“All such elaborate eating and living can be compared to music with every possible harmony and rhythm.

“Complexity there encourages disorder, while complexity here encourages disease.

“Simple music produces self-control in the soul, while simple physical training produces health in the body.”

“That is very true.”

“But when luxury and disease spread through a State, courts and medical practices multiply.

“Doctors and lawyers become important because not only slaves and ordinary people but also supposedly educated citizens become obsessed with them.”

“Of course.”

“And what greater evidence could there be of poor education and a disgraceful way of life?

“It is bad enough when craftsmen and ordinary workers constantly need skilled doctors and judges.

“But when people who claim to have received a liberal education cannot manage their own lives without constantly needing lawyers and doctors, is that not shameful?

“They have to go elsewhere to obtain legal and medical help because they have no ability to manage these matters themselves. Then they place themselves under the authority of other people whom they make their judges and masters.”

“That is certainly disgraceful.”

“Would you call that the worst stage of the problem?

“Imagine a man who spends his entire life in court, constantly suing or being sued.

“He becomes proud of his ability to manipulate the law. He thinks he is clever because he knows every dishonest trick, every crooked path, every way of bending around justice.

“And what is all this cleverness for?

“To win tiny disputes that are barely worth anything.

“He does not understand that the truly noble achievement is to live one's life so well that one never needs to depend on a judge.”

“That is even more disgraceful,” he said.

“And what about the excessive use of medicine?

“Not when a person has a serious wound or is caught in an epidemic, but when his laziness and unhealthy lifestyle fill his body with fluids and gases, forcing doctors to invent ever more complicated names for diseases.

“Is that not also disgraceful?”

“Yes,” he said. “Doctors certainly do invent some very strange names.”

“And I do not think such diseases existed in the time of Asclepius.

“I infer this from a story in Homer.

“Eurypylus is wounded and is given a drink made from Pramnian wine mixed with barley meal and grated cheese—exactly the kind of thing that would make inflammation worse.

“Yet the sons of Asclepius, who were serving in the Trojan War, do not criticize the woman who gives it to him or Patroclus for treating him in that way.”

“That certainly seems like a strange drink for an injured man.”

“Not so strange if you remember that, as people commonly say, before the time of Herodicus, the medical guild of Asclepius did not practice the kind of medicine that spends its time managing chronic illness.

“Herodicus was a trainer with a weak constitution.

“He combined athletic training with medicine and discovered a way of tormenting himself first and everyone else afterward.”

“How?”

“By inventing a kind of slow death.

“He had a disease from which he could never fully recover, so he spent his entire life monitoring his health.

“He could do almost nothing except take care of himself.

“Whenever he departed from his routine, he suffered terribly.

“So, by constantly treating himself, he managed to survive into old age.”

“That is a strange reward for his medical skill.”

“Yes,” I said. “But perhaps it was exactly what he deserved.

“He never understood why Asclepius did not teach his descendants this kind of medicine.

“It was not because Asclepius lacked the knowledge.

“He understood that in a well-ordered State, every person has work to perform and cannot spend his entire life being sick.

“This principle is obvious when we talk about ordinary workers, yet strangely we refuse to apply it to wealthy people.”

“What do you mean?”

“When a carpenter becomes ill, he goes to a doctor and asks for a quick cure.

“Perhaps he needs an emetic, a purge, a cauterization, or surgery.

“But if someone gives him a complicated diet and tells him to wrap his head in layers of cloth and follow a long treatment, he immediately says:

‘I do not have time to be sick. What is the point of living if I spend my entire life worrying about my illness instead of doing my work?’

“So he dismisses that kind of doctor, returns to his normal life, and either recovers and continues working or dies and ends his suffering.”

“Yes,” he said. “A man in his position should use medicine only to that extent.”

“He has a job, does he not?

“What would be the point of his life if illness prevented him from doing it?”

“None.”

“But we treat the rich man differently.

“We assume that he has no particular work he must perform if he wants to live.”

“People generally think that wealthy men have nothing to do.”

“Then perhaps you have never heard Phocylides say that once a man has secured a livelihood, he should devote himself to virtue.”

“I think he should begin even earlier.”

“Let us not argue with Phocylides about that.

“Instead, let us ask whether a rich man is required to practice virtue or whether he can live without it.

“And if virtue is required of him, then we must ask whether excessive medical care—care that prevents a man from using his mind for work—does not also interfere with the practice of virtue.”

“There is no doubt about that,” he said. “Excessive concern for the body is a serious obstacle to virtue.”

“Yes.

“And it is equally incompatible with managing a household, an army, or a government.

“Most importantly, it interferes with study, thought, and self-examination.

“A man constantly imagines that every headache or dizzy spell is a sign that philosophy is making him ill.

“So he never seriously develops virtue in the higher sense because he is always worried about his body.”

“That seems very likely.”

“And therefore we may imagine that the statesman Asclepius used medicine only for people who were basically healthy and lived disciplined lives but happened to suffer a particular illness.

“He would treat them with medicines or surgery and then send them back to their ordinary lives.

“But when a person's body had been completely overwhelmed by disease, he would not try to keep him alive indefinitely through endless treatments.

“He did not want to prolong lives that could no longer contribute anything, or allow weak fathers to produce even weaker children.

“If a man could no longer live a normal life, Asclepius would not have considered it useful to prolong his existence through endless treatment.”

“Then you regard Asclepius as a statesman.”

“Certainly.

“And his sons show the same wisdom.

“They were heroes in the old days and practiced this kind of medicine during the Trojan War.

“Remember how, when Pandarus wounded Menelaus, they sucked the blood from the wound and applied soothing medicines.

“But they did not prescribe a long-term diet for Menelaus.

“They did not tell him what he should eat and drink afterward.

“They believed that simple treatment was enough for a man who had been healthy and disciplined before his injury.

“Even if such a man happened to drink a cup of Pramnian wine, he could still recover.

“But they had nothing to do with people whose unhealthy and undisciplined lives made them useless both to themselves and to the State.

“Even if such a person were as rich as Midas, the sons of Asclepius would refuse to treat him.”

“They were very sensible men,” he said.

“Of course.

“Yet the tragedians and Pindar tell a different story.

“Although they acknowledge that Asclepius was the son of Apollo, they also claim that he accepted money to heal a rich man who was dying, and that Zeus struck him with lightning for doing so.

“But according to the principles we have already established, we cannot accept both claims.

“If Asclepius was the son of a god, then he was not greedy.

“And if he was greedy, then he was not the son of a god.”

“That argument makes perfect sense, Socrates,” he said.

“But I want to ask you something.

“Shouldn't a State have excellent doctors?

“And aren't the best doctors those who have treated the greatest variety of people, both healthy and unhealthy?

“And shouldn't the best judges likewise be people who understand all kinds of moral character?”

“Yes,” I said. “I certainly want excellent doctors and excellent judges.

“But do you know what kind of people I think make the best ones?”

“Tell me.”

“I will.

“But first notice that you have placed doctors and judges together as though they were the same kind of people.”

“How are they different?”

“The most skilled doctors are those who, from youth onward, combine medical knowledge with extensive experience of disease.

“They may even have experienced many illnesses themselves.

“After all, they do not cure the body with their own bodies. They cure the body through the mind.

“And a mind that has itself become corrupted cannot properly cure another mind or body.”

“That is true,” he said.

“But judges are different.

“A judge governs one soul through another soul.

“Therefore, he should not have spent his youth surrounded by vicious people or practicing every form of wrongdoing simply so that he can recognize evil from personal experience.

“His own soul must remain honorable and healthy.

“When a good person is young, he may seem simple and easy to deceive because he has never encountered the patterns of dishonesty that exist in corrupt people.”

“Yes,” he said. “Good people are often deceived for exactly that reason.”

“Therefore, the judge should not be young.

“He should learn about evil not by filling his own soul with it, but by observing it in others over a long period of time.

“His knowledge should come from careful observation, not personal corruption.”

“Yes,” he said. “That is the ideal judge.”

“And he will be a good man, which answers your question.

“For a good judge must have a good soul.

“The clever and suspicious criminal we discussed earlier is different.

“He has committed many crimes and thinks himself an expert in wickedness.

“When he is around other criminals, he takes extraordinary precautions because he judges them by his own standards.

“But when he meets honest and virtuous people who have grown wise through age and experience, he becomes foolish because his suspicions are inappropriate.

“He cannot recognize an honest man because he has no example of honesty within himself.

“Since he meets more bad people than good people, he believes himself—and others believe him—to be wise rather than foolish.”

“That is absolutely true.”

“Then the good and wise judge we are looking for is not that man.

“It is the other kind.

“Vice cannot understand virtue properly.

“But a virtuous nature, educated by time, can learn to understand both virtue and vice.

“The wise man is the virtuous man, not the vicious one.”

“I agree,” he said.

“This is the kind of medicine and law we should establish in our State.

“They will care for people whose souls and bodies can be restored to health.

“But people whose bodies are completely destroyed by disease will not be endlessly treated.

“And people whose souls are corrupt and beyond recovery will be removed from the community.”

“That seems best both for the patients and for the State,” he said.

“And our young people, having been educated through the simple music that develops self-control, will have little reason to spend their lives going to court.”

“Certainly.”

“And the person who combines that simple musical education with simple physical training will have little need for medicine except in extreme circumstances.”

“I completely agree.”

“The physical exercises and hardships he undergoes are meant to strengthen the spirited part of his character.

“They are not designed merely to build enormous muscles.

“He will not train like an ordinary athlete who spends his entire life developing his body through excessive exercise and strict diets.”

“Very true.”

“And the real purpose of music and physical training is not, as people often suppose, for one to train the soul and the other to train the body.”

“Then what is their true purpose?”

“I believe both are primarily intended to shape the soul.”

“How can that be?”

“Have you never noticed what happens to a person's character when he devotes himself entirely to physical training?

“And what happens when he devotes himself entirely to music?”

“How do you mean?”

“Excessive physical training can make a person hard and aggressive.

“Excessive musical training can make him soft and weak.”

“Yes,” he said. “I have certainly seen that.

“The pure athlete can become savage, while the pure musician can become softer than is healthy.”

“Exactly.

“The aggressiveness comes from the spirited part of the soul.

“If properly educated, that spirit becomes courage.

“But if it becomes too strong, it turns hard and brutal.”

“I agree.”

“On the other hand, the philosopher possesses gentleness.

“But if gentleness is taken too far, it becomes weakness.

“Proper education turns it into calmness and moderation.”

“True.”

“And our guardians need both qualities.”

“Certainly.”

“And the two must exist in harmony.”

“Without question.”

“A harmonious soul is both self-controlled and courageous.”

“Yes.”

“An unbalanced soul is cowardly and crude.”

“Very true.”

“Imagine a man who allows music to pour into his soul through his ears—soft, sweet, sorrowful music of the kind we just rejected.

“At first, it may soften and refine his spirit, just as heat softens iron.

“That can actually make him more useful rather than brittle.

“But if he continues the process too far, his spirit begins to melt away.

“Eventually he loses the strength and energy of his character, and he becomes a weak warrior.”

“Very true.”

“If his spirit was naturally weak to begin with, this happens quickly.

“But if he has a strong spirit, excessive music can make him irritable.

“The smallest provocation makes him explode.

“He no longer possesses true courage; instead, he becomes angry, unstable, and impossible to deal with.”

“Exactly.”

“Now consider the opposite kind of person.

“He trains his body intensely, eats heavily, and spends no time studying music, philosophy, or anything that develops the mind.

“At first, his physical strength makes him proud and aggressive.

“He feels twice as powerful as before.”

“Certainly.”

“But what happens if he does nothing else?

“If he never speaks with the Muses, never learns, never investigates, never thinks, and never develops his mind, then whatever intelligence he possesses gradually becomes weak and dull.

“His mind never awakens.

“His senses remain clouded because they are never cleared by learning.”

“That is true.”

“In the end he becomes an enemy of philosophy.

“He becomes uncivilized and cannot use persuasion.

“He behaves like a wild animal, relying only on force and aggression.

“He lives without understanding, without moral judgment, without any sense of what is appropriate or graceful.”

“That is exactly what happens,” he said.

“And because human nature contains two main principles—the spirited part and the philosophical part—it seems that some god gave us two arts that correspond to them: music and physical training.

“Not directly to the soul and body, as people usually think, but to these two aspects of the soul.

“Through these arts, the two parts can be relaxed or strengthened until they are properly balanced, like the strings of a musical instrument.”

“That certainly seems to be their purpose.”

“And the person who combines music and physical training in the right proportions, shaping them properly to the soul, deserves to be called a true musician and harmonist in a much deeper sense than someone who merely tunes strings.”

“You are completely right, Socrates.”

“And such a guiding intelligence will always be necessary in our State if the government is to survive.”

“Yes, absolutely necessary.”

“Then these are our principles of education and upbringing.

“There is no need to go into every detail about our citizens' dancing, hunting, riding, and athletic competitions.

“All of these follow from the general principles we have already established.

“Once we understand the principles, the details will not be difficult.”

“I suppose that is true.”

“Good.

“Then what comes next?

“Must we not decide who should rule and who should obey?”

“Certainly.”

“There is no doubt that older people should rule the younger.”

“Clearly.”

“And the best of the older people should rule.”

“That is also clear.”

“Consider farmers.

“Are not the best farmers the people most devoted to farming?”

“Yes.”

“And if we want the best guardians for our city, should they not be those who show the greatest commitment to guarding it?”

“Yes.”

“And for that purpose they must be wise, capable, and deeply concerned about the welfare of the State.”

“True.”

“And a person is most likely to care about something he loves.”

“Of course.”

“And he is most likely to love what he believes shares his interests, and whose success or failure he feels personally affects him.”

“Very true.”

“Then we must select our guardians carefully.

“Among them, we should identify those who, throughout their entire lives, show the greatest eagerness to do what benefits their country and the strongest resistance to doing anything harmful to it.”

“Those are certainly the right people.”

“And we must watch them at every stage of life.

“We need to see whether they preserve their sense of duty and remain faithful to the State, even when they are subjected to force, temptation, pleasure, fear, or deception.”

“How could they lose that sense of duty?” he asked.

“I will explain.

“A person can lose a belief either willingly or unwillingly.

“He willingly gives up a belief when he realizes it is false and learns the truth.

“He loses it unwillingly when someone takes away a truth he previously possessed.”

“I understand willingly losing a belief.

“But I do not understand how someone can unwillingly lose one.”

“Do you not see that people are unwillingly deprived of what is good and willingly give up what is bad?

“Truth is good, while ignorance is bad.

“To understand reality correctly is to possess truth.”

“Yes, I agree.”

“And people are deprived of truth against their will.”

“But how does that happen?”

“Through theft, force, or enchantment.”

“I still do not understand.”

“Perhaps I have been speaking too obscurely.

“Think of it this way.

“Some people change their minds because they are persuaded.

“Others forget what they once knew.

“Argument steals the convictions of one group, while time steals them from another.

“That is what I mean by theft.”

“Now I understand.”

“Those who are forced to change their minds are people whose opinions are overcome by pain or grief.”

“I understand that too.”

“And those who are enchanted are people whose minds change because of pleasure or fear.”

“Yes.”

“Anything that deceives us can be called a kind of enchantment.”

“Exactly.”

“Therefore, as I said, we must discover which guardians are best able to preserve their conviction that the interests of the State should govern their lives.

“We must observe them from childhood onward.

“We should place them in situations where they are likely to forget their duty or be deceived.

“Those who remember and remain firm should be chosen.

“Those who fail should be rejected.”

“That seems right.”

“And we should also give them difficult tasks, pain, struggles, and conflicts so that they can prove these qualities again.”

“Certainly.”

“And then we must test them with enchantments—the third kind of test.

“Think of people testing young horses.

“They expose them to noise and confusion to see whether they are naturally timid.

“We should do something similar with our young people.

“We should expose them to frightening situations, then to pleasurable ones.

“We must test them more carefully than gold is tested in a furnace.

“We want to know whether they can resist every temptation, whether they remain noble in every situation, whether they can govern themselves, and whether they preserve the harmonious character created by their education.

“Whoever remains strong through every stage of life—childhood, youth, and adulthood—should become a ruler and guardian of the State.

“He should be honored during his life and after his death.

“He should receive the greatest funeral honors and memorials the State can provide.

“Anyone who fails these tests should be rejected.

“That, generally speaking, is how our rulers and guardians should be selected.”

“I agree,” he said. “At least in general terms.”

“And perhaps the word ‘guardian’ in the fullest sense should belong only to the highest class.

“These are the people who protect us from foreign enemies and maintain peace among our own citizens.

“They prevent enemies from harming us from outside and prevent citizens from harming one another within.

“The younger men whom we previously called guardians might more accurately be called auxiliaries or supporters of the rulers.”

“I agree.”

“Now, how can we invent one of those useful lies we spoke about earlier?

“One royal lie that might deceive the rulers themselves, if possible, and at least persuade the rest of the city?”

“What kind of lie?” he asked.

“Nothing new.

“It is an old Phoenician story, one that poets claim has happened in other places in the past.

“I do not know whether it ever truly happened, or whether anyone today could make people believe it.”

“You seem strangely hesitant,” he said.

“You will understand my hesitation once you hear the story.”

“Then speak. Do not be afraid.”

“I will.

“Although I hardly know how to look you in the face while telling you this bold fiction.

“We will tell the citizens that everything they experienced during their youth was like a dream.

“Their education and training appeared to happen above ground, but in reality they were being formed and raised inside the earth.

“They themselves, their weapons, and everything they needed were created in the earth.

“When they were complete, the earth—their mother—sent them up into the world.

“Therefore, they must regard their country as their mother and nurse.

“They must protect her, advise her for her own good, and defend her when she is attacked.

“And they must regard their fellow citizens as their brothers and sisters, because all of them were born from the same earth.”

“You had good reason to be embarrassed about that lie,” he said.

“True.

“But that is only half the story.

“We will tell the citizens:

‘You are all brothers and sisters, but the god who created you made you different.

“In some people he mixed gold into their nature. These are the people meant to rule, and they deserve the greatest honor.

“In others he mixed silver. These are the auxiliaries who support the rulers.

“In farmers and craftsmen he mixed bronze and iron.

“Usually, these qualities will pass from parents to children.

“But this is not always so.

“A golden parent may have a silver child.

“A silver parent may have a golden child.

“Therefore, the rulers must watch the children carefully.

“The most important thing they must guard is the purity of the different kinds.

“If a child born to golden or silver parents has a nature mixed with bronze or iron, the rulers must not feel sorry for him.

“He must move down to the rank of farmer or craftsman.

“And if the child of a craftsman has gold or silver in his nature, he must be raised to the position of guardian or auxiliary.

“For the oracle says that the State will be destroyed when a man of bronze or iron becomes its guardian.’

“That is the story.

“Do you think we can make our citizens believe it?”

“Not the present generation,” he said. “There is no chance.

“But perhaps their children might believe it, and then their grandchildren, and generations after them.”

“I understand the difficulty.

“Still, if such a belief could be established, it might make citizens care more deeply about their city and about one another.

“But enough of the story.

“Let it spread through the city however it may.

“Now let us arm our earth-born warriors and send them out under the command of their rulers.

“They must choose a place where they can quickly suppress any internal rebellion and defend themselves against enemies who might attack from outside like wolves attacking a flock.

“There they will establish their camp.

“They will sacrifice to the proper gods and build their homes.”

“Exactly,” he said.

“And their homes must protect them from winter cold and summer heat.”

“You mean houses.”

“Yes, but they must be soldiers' houses, not merchants' houses.”

“What is the difference?”

“I will explain.

“Imagine a shepherd keeping guard dogs.

“If the dogs become undisciplined because of hunger, poor training, or some other bad habit, and begin attacking the sheep they are supposed to protect, that would be a terrible thing.

“They would no longer behave like dogs.

“They would behave like wolves.”

“Certainly,” he said.

“And therefore we must take every possible precaution to prevent our auxiliaries, who are stronger than the rest of the citizens, from becoming too powerful.

“If they become savage, they could turn into tyrants instead of friends and protectors.”

“That requires great care.”

“And would not excellent education be the best protection against that danger?”

“They have already received a good education,” he replied.

“I am not yet confident of that, my dear Glaucon.

“I am only certain that they ought to receive one.

“Whatever true education is, it should make them civilized and humane toward one another and toward the people they are protecting.”

“That is certainly true.”

“And not only their education but also their homes and their entire way of life must be arranged so that nothing weakens their virtue as guardians or tempts them to exploit the citizens.

“Anyone with common sense would agree with that.”

“Certainly.”

“Then let us consider their way of life.

“First, none of them should own private property beyond what is absolutely necessary.

“They should not have private houses or storerooms that are closed to others.

“They should receive only the food necessary for trained soldiers who live disciplined and courageous lives.

“They should receive a fixed amount of pay from the citizens—enough for the year's needs, but no more.

“They should eat together and live together like soldiers in a military camp.

“As for gold and silver, we will tell them that they already possess these metals from the gods.

“The finest and most valuable metal is already inside them.

“Therefore, they have no need for the inferior gold and silver that ordinary people use as money.

“They must never mix their divine metal with earthly metal.

“For ordinary gold and silver have been responsible for countless crimes.

“But the metal within them remains pure.

“And so, of all citizens, they alone must never touch silver or gold.

“They must not live under the same roof as them, wear them, or drink from vessels made of them.

“By following this rule they will remain safe, and they will be the saviors of the State.

“But if they ever acquire private houses, land, or money, they will cease to be guardians.

“They will become householders and farmers.

“Instead of allies of the citizens, they will become their enemies and tyrants.

“They will hate others and be hated in return.

“They will constantly plot against others and fear being plotted against.

“They will spend their entire lives in greater fear of enemies within the State than enemies outside it.

“And at that point, the destruction of both themselves and the State will be close.

“For all these reasons, can we not say that this is how our State should be organized, and that these should be the rules governing the homes and lives of our guardians?”

“Yes,” said Glaucon.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!