← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 16 · Drew’s Erie Corner—and the Trap Set by His Own Students

Drew’s Erie Corner—and the Trap Set by His Own Students

Chapter 16 of 90 · 2,180 words · Free

By the middle of April, Drew came out of hiding in Jersey City and returned openly to Wall Street. He seemed to have no fear of arrest.

The other members of the Erie clique had gone through the formal process of settling their contempt-of-court charges, but they had not yet made peace with Vanderbilt.

The situation remained tense until July, when a settlement was finally reached with the Commodore.

Under the agreement, Vanderbilt would give up 50,000 shares of Erie at $70 a share. In return, he would receive $2.5 million in cash and $1.25 million in Boston, Hartford & Erie bonds valued at 80.

He would also receive another $1 million for giving the Erie people the right to call on him within four months for another 50,000 shares at $70.

Vanderbilt was given two seats on the Erie board.

All lawsuits between the two sides were to be dropped, and all legal offenses connected with the fight were to be forgiven.

The way this settlement came about was almost as interesting as the settlement itself.

After Drew's famous Sunday evening meeting with Vanderbilt, he had prepared the way for his partners by showing deep regret over his flight to Jersey City.

Not long afterward, Gould and Fisk went to Vanderbilt's house on Washington Place early one morning.

Fisk later told the story in his usual bold and colorful style.

“Gould wanted to wait until the Commodore had gotten out of bed,” Fisk said, “but I rang the bell and went straight upstairs.”

“The Commodore was sitting on the side of the bed. One shoe was off and the other was still on.”

“He got up and put on the other shoe. I remember it because it had four buckles. I had never seen shoes like that before. I thought that if men like him wore shoes like those, I might want a pair myself.”

“The Commodore told me I would have to take things as I found them. He said his lawyers would stay on our trail, and he would keep after us unless we took the Erie stock off his hands.”

“I told him that if I had my way, I wouldn't take a single share. He had brought the trouble on himself, and he deserved it.”

“That seemed to calm him down.”

“Then I told him he was a robber.”

“He said the lawsuits would never be withdrawn until he was paid.”

“I told him that, once we had settled with him, the whole thing would amount to one hell of a robbery. We had sold ourselves to the Devil, and Gould felt exactly the same way.”

Several powerful men stood by Vanderbilt during the crisis, including William Heath, Richard Schell, Augustus Schell, and Rufus Hatch.

Richard Schell was especially useful.

The banks had refused to lend Vanderbilt money on Erie because so much Erie stock had been issued.

Schell went around this obstacle in a remarkably simple way.

He discovered that many of the banks held large amounts of New York Central stock.

He went to one banker and said:

“If you won't lend the Commodore half a million dollars on Erie at 60, he'll drive Central down to 50 tomorrow and break half the houses on Wall Street.”

“You know whether you'll be one of them.”

He repeated the same threat at other banks.

In most cases, it worked.

The Commodore got the money he needed.

But he was spending his ammunition against an enemy that seemed to have an endless supply of stock.

The Erie clique kept pouring newly issued shares into the market.

Every time Vanderbilt tried to squeeze them, more Erie appeared.

Fisk reportedly laughed about it.

“If this printing press doesn't break down,” he said, “I'll be damned if I don't give the old hog all the Erie he wants.”

The printing press never did break down.

It kept producing stock until Vanderbilt was nearly ruined.

Only his extraordinary courage and the influence he had gained over the courts saved him from bankruptcy.

Wall Street was amazed that he had survived.

Gould and Fisk were amazed as well.

They had finally met an opponent who could fight back.

Vanderbilt had spent more than $7 million trying to force the Erie clique into submission, yet he managed to keep the market alive and prevent a collapse that might have been almost as destructive as Black Friday.

Some innocent investors had been badly hurt in the battle.

To compensate them, $429,250 was eventually paid out.

The Boston group, represented by Eldridge, was also relieved of $5 million in Boston, Hartford & Erie bonds. In exchange, it received $4 million in Erie acceptances.

All told, the settlement cost Erie about $9 million.

The company's stockholders and bondholders were left carrying the burden, despite the questionable legality of the whole arrangement.

Gould and Fisk publicly acted as though they opposed the settlement.

They wanted the public to believe that Drew and Vanderbilt had arranged everything themselves.

Whatever the truth, the settlement probably helped everyone involved escape from an extremely dangerous situation.

Drew came out of the affair with a substantial reward.

The corner had produced about $7 million for him.

He did have to pay $540,000 into the Erie treasury to settle interest and any claims the company might bring against him.

Gould and Fisk, meanwhile, ended up with control of the Erie Railway.

Drew decided that he was finished with Wall Street.

He really seemed to mean it.

But Wall Street has always had a powerful grip on men who become addicted to speculation.

Once a man is deeply involved, getting out is easier said than done.

Drew might have spent the rest of his life quietly enjoying his remaining millions, reading his Bible, singing hymns, and living peacefully in the countryside.

Instead, some strange force pulled him back.

After a few months, Uncle Daniel returned to Wall Street.

And when he returned, he discovered that his former students had become masters of the game.

During his absence, Gould and Fisk had increased Erie’s capital from $34 million to $57 million.

Drew must have been stunned.

He was no longer Erie’s treasurer.

He no longer had any share in the enormous wealth being created by the company.

Yet his old instinct to speculate was still alive.

He began trading again.

But the game had changed.

The methods he had once used so successfully no longer worked.

He soon discovered that betting against the market was becoming a losing proposition.

Then Gould and Fisk invited him into a new scheme.

Drew had once been the spider who trapped other traders.

Now they wanted him to become the fly.

They invited him into a “blind pool.”

The arrangement was simple.

Drew was supposed to put up $4 million, ask no questions, and leave everything to Gould and Fisk.

They would decide what to do with his money.

Drew had spent his career pulling the strings.

Now they wanted to pull his strings.

He did not like the arrangement.

He had no intention of paying the piper without being allowed to choose the music.

So he withdrew.

But by then he had already lost $1 million.

He decided to fight his former partners instead.

It was a dangerous decision.

Gould and Fisk were furious.

They considered Drew's withdrawal a betrayal.

But in truth, Drew had merely refused to let them consume him completely.

Drew then decided to operate on his own.

As he had done so many times before, he prayed for guidance.

Then he decided to sell Erie short.

It was the worst possible decision.

The market kept rising.

Drew became desperate.

A Christian friend advised him to pray.

Drew tried.

But he could not stop watching the ticker.

Every new quotation distracted him.

Finally, with tears in his eyes, he went back to his friend.

“It’s no use, brother,” he said. “The market still goes up.”

After that, Drew gave up praying and watched the ticker instead.

In November, he contracted to deliver 70,000 shares of Erie at current prices.

The stock was then around 38.

He kept selling.

The more he sold, the more trapped he became.

Eventually, he was hopelessly caught in the corner.

Drew appealed to the courts.

An injunction was sought in the name of August Belmont.

But Gould and Fisk immediately struck back.

They obtained another injunction from Judge Barnard.

The judge not only protected Gould and Fisk from lawsuits, but also appointed Gould receiver of Erie.

He went even further.

He authorized the Erie directors to use company money to buy and cancel 200,000 shares whose legality had been questioned.

They could buy the shares at any price below par.

The irony was extraordinary.

Gould and Fisk had issued these shares while betting on a falling market at 40.

They had driven Erie down to 35.

Now, with the market turning against them, they had obtained legal authority to buy the same stock back at up to par.

A corporate law supposedly prohibited a company from trading in its own stock.

Yet the court had given them permission to do essentially that.

The law had become another weapon in the hands of the manipulators.

After this maneuver, Erie became scarce.

The stock climbed to 47.

Drew desperately tried to cover his short position.

Instead, Erie jumped from 47 to 57 between Monday and Wednesday.

Wall Street erupted.

The excitement was enormous.

Then Erie climbed again.

It reached 62.

Drew appeared to have no escape.

An incoming steamer was expected to bring a large amount of Erie stock in a few days.

But Drew might not survive that long.

His money was disappearing.

His credit was weakening.

Gould and Fisk were closing in.

The pressure became unbearable as three o'clock approached.

The two young speculators were determined to destroy their former teacher.

Then, just as Drew seemed certain to be ruined, two unexpected things happened.

First, 300,000 Erie shares had been issued in small lots of ten shares each.

The operators believed these shares were safely hidden in London and Amsterdam.

They were wrong.

When Erie reached 60, the ten-share lots suddenly began appearing on the market.

Most had never left America.

They had been bought by ordinary people—shopkeepers, mechanics, grocers, small bankers, and small brokers.

Now these holders rushed to sell and lock in their profits.

The clique tried desperately to absorb the shares before they could reach Drew.

But buying so much stock drained their reserve funds.

Then another problem appeared.

The banks refused to certify their checks.

The entire operation was beginning to strain under its own weight.

Drew was finally able to settle his contracts at 47.

But financially, he was finished.

He had come close to dragging his enemies down with him.

Erie soon fell to 42.

The stock became almost impossible to sell.

Gould and Fisk had won the battle, but their victory was expensive.

They had bought enormous quantities of Erie at inflated corner prices.

Now nobody wanted the stock.

They were stuck holding it.

To make matters worse, Erie was temporarily removed from the Stock Exchange.

Had the British investors not been so willing to believe in the stock, Erie might have remained a dead weight on the market for a long time.

Drew had been treated brutally.

Yet few people felt sorry for him.

He had become the victim of the same greed, hesitation, deception, and manipulation that he had used against others.

He had little moral ground from which to complain.

Fisk reminded him of that.

“You should be the last man,” Fisk told his former teacher with a sneer, “to complain about the position you're in at Erie.”

It was cruel, but there was truth behind it.

Drew had shown little mercy to his own victims.

He could hardly expect mercy now.

The final meeting between Drew, Gould, and Fisk in the Erie office was almost tragic.

Yet even then, none of the three displayed much concern for honor.

Drew had persuaded Vanderbilt to help him in court and in the market against Gould and Fisk.

Then he turned around and went directly to Gould.

He betrayed Vanderbilt and revealed the plans they had made together.

Drew apparently believed that this betrayal would earn him mercy.

He should have known better.

He begged Gould and Fisk for help.

He was even willing to throw the remains of his fortune into another round of stock creation.

He asked them to start the old Erie “paper mill” again—to print more stock and give him a way out of the corner.

But his former students had learned their lessons too well.

They showed him no mercy.

The men who had once learned their tricks from Drew were now using those same tricks against him.

Drew finally realized that they would not help him.

He said good night and left.

The next morning he returned to Wall Street and fought again.

This time, he lost.

The final struggle cost him nearly $2 million.

The teacher had been defeated by his own students.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!