← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 17 · Interesting Episodes in Drew’s Life

Interesting Episodes in Drew’s Life

Chapter 17 of 90 · 2,774 words · Free

I had originally planned to give only a brief account of Daniel Drew’s career as a speculator. But the more I thought about it, the more I realized that people always want to know the smaller details about men who have made their mark on history. Newspapers have encouraged that curiosity, and Drew’s life is full of details worth remembering.

So it is natural to ask: What kind of boy was Daniel Drew? How did he first make money?

Drew was one of the most unusual figures Wall Street ever produced. He represented a particular kind of American ambition—hard work, thrift, risk-taking, and an almost obsessive desire to make money. His life is especially interesting because he rose from very humble beginnings to enormous wealth, only to lose nearly everything through speculation.

Drew grew up on a small farm. His father was English and his mother was of Scottish descent. He attended school from time to time, but he learned very little from it. He was more interested in practical matters than books.

When Drew was fifteen, his father died. The boy was left with his mother and younger brother to manage the family’s poor farm.

At seventeen, Drew enlisted as a substitute in the State Militia during the second war with England. His regiment was stationed at Fort Gansevoort on the Hudson River, across from New York.

The war ended only a few months later, and the regiment was discharged. Drew returned home.

His mother had carefully saved the money he had received for serving as a substitute. It probably amounted to no more than one hundred dollars.

One day Drew said to her, “Mother, I want my substitute money.”

His mother looked at him suspiciously.

“What are you going to do with it?”

“I’m going to buy cattle and sell them in New York.”

“Are you sure you won’t lose your money?”

“I’m sure I’ll make money.”

That was the beginning of Drew’s business career.

He started buying cattle in the countryside and driving them to New York. At first his profits were small because he had so little capital.

Then he discovered that cattle were much cheaper in Ohio.

He went to Henry Astor, a Fulton Market butcher and brother of the famous John Jacob Astor, and asked him for a loan.

Astor thought the young man was taking a considerable risk, but he agreed to lend him the money.

Drew proved that his confidence was justified.

He bought cattle throughout Ohio and drove them across the Alleghany Mountains toward New York. He was said to be the first cattle drover to attempt the journey on such a large scale.

The trip took about sixty days.

The journey was brutal. Drew and his men suffered from hunger, exhaustion, bad weather, and dangerous mountain roads. Sometimes a third of a herd of six hundred or even a thousand cattle died along the way.

Yet Ohio cattle were so cheap that Drew could still make substantial profits.

On one occasion, during a violent thunderstorm, Drew took shelter beneath a tree.

Lightning struck the tree and blew it apart.

His horse was killed beneath him, and Drew himself was knocked unconscious.

But even that experience did not stop him.

He later expanded his cattle business into Kentucky and Illinois.

In 1829, Drew opened a cattle yard at Twenty-fourth Street and Third Avenue in New York. He also operated the Bull’s Head Tavern.

Then he moved into the steamboat business.

By 1834, Cornelius Vanderbilt had already been in the steamboat trade for seventeen years. Drew entered the business as a direct competitor.

His first two boats were the Westchester and the Emerald. They ran between New York and Albany against Vanderbilt’s line.

Drew immediately attacked Vanderbilt with low fares.

He cut the fare from three dollars to one.

Vanderbilt fought back.

The rate war became so fierce that passengers were eventually carried the entire one hundred miles between New York and Albany for only a shilling.

Drew continued expanding his fleet.

He added the Knickerbocker, Oregon, George Law, Isaac Newton, and New World.

He had become a serious rival to the Commodore.

In 1840, Isaac Newton organized the People’s Line on the Hudson, and Drew became its largest shareholder.

The company built the St. John, Dean Richmond, and Drew.

The Isaac Newton was later destroyed by fire, and the New World sank.

When the Hudson River Railroad opened in 1852, Drew refused to sell his steamboat stock.

The railroad president told him that the company could control its own fares.

Drew replied, “You can regulate your fares as you please. But the only way you can regulate my steamboat fares is to buy the People’s Line—and I don’t believe you have enough money to do it.”

The railroad actually helped him rather than hurting him.

More transportation created more traffic, and Drew continued to profit.

He also controlled the Stonington Line for about twenty years.

Drew entered Wall Street in 1844.

At that time I was still thirteen years away from making my own first appearance in that financial theater.

Drew formed a brokerage and banking partnership with his son-in-law, Mr. Kelly, and Nelson Taylor.

The firm had a large business and an excellent reputation for credit.

It continued for about ten years, until the deaths of his partners brought the partnership to an end.

After that, Drew became one of the boldest and most successful speculators on Wall Street.

Drew married Roxana Mead when he was twenty-five.

She was the daughter of a farmer.

They had three children: William H., Josephine, who died as an infant, and Catharine.

Catharine married the Rev. W. I. Clapp, a Baptist minister. After his death, she was left in comfortable circumstances.

Drew’s fears that his family would eventually be left in poverty therefore had little foundation. His surviving children treated him kindly.

His wife died in 1876.

Drew was a member of St. Paul’s Methodist Episcopal Church in New York for many years.

He gave large amounts of money to religious and educational causes.

But there was an unfortunate problem.

He often made his donations by signing notes rather than paying cash.

When his fortune disappeared and he eventually became bankrupt, many of those unpaid promises appeared on the list of his liabilities.

He founded Drew Seminary for young women at Carmel, spending $250,000 on it.

He also built Drew Theological Seminary at Madison, New Jersey, at a cost of another $250,000, and promised an additional $250,000 as its endowment.

He increased the endowment of Wesleyan University in Connecticut and contributed to the Concord Biblical Institute.

He also promised $100,000 to Wesleyan University, although again he paid only the interest rather than the principal.

Drew owned several large grazing farms in Putnam County, but they were heavily mortgaged.

After his bankruptcy in 1876, Drew thought about returning to his old home and spending the rest of his life among his grandchildren.

There was something touching about that desire.

No matter how greedy or ambitious he had been, he still had an attachment to the place where his life had begun.

He went to Putnam County in 1876 while he was already ill.

But he soon wanted to return to New York.

One day he explained why.

“I was bothered by visitors,” he said. “Some of them were nearly a hundred years old. They claimed I had bought cattle from them when I was young, on credit, and now they wanted their money.”

He laughed.

“I kept no books. How was I supposed to know whether I owed them for those cattle?”

Then he added, “It was dull out there. And in Wall Street, you never know until the next day how the shares are going to move.”

So Uncle Daniel returned to the city.

He stayed at the Hoffman House, where he could remain close to the stock ticker and follow the market.

His principal broker was David Groesbeck.

Even after losing his fortune, Drew could not break his attachment to Wall Street.

In his final years, he often spoke sadly about being too old to rebuild what he had lost.

He said he wanted peace.

But one thing troubled him more than anything else: he no longer had the money to fulfill the promises he had made to churches and schools.

He desperately wanted another chance in Wall Street.

If he could only make another lucky trade, he believed he could recover enough money to complete his charitable obligations.

His bankruptcy papers give a remarkably modest picture of his personal possessions.

His watch and chain were valued at $150.

His sealskin coat was worth another $150.

His clothing was valued at $100.

His Bible, hymn books, and other similar belongings were valued at $130.

That was the wardrobe of a man who had once controlled millions.

Drew was careful with his personal household expenses, but he was generous when entertaining friends.

His home at Seventeenth Street and Union Square was always open to Methodist ministers visiting New York from all over the world.

Some years before his death, Drew gave a journalist a frank explanation of how he had lost his fortune.

“I had been wonderfully blessed in making money,” he said. “I became a millionaire almost before I realized it.”

“I was lucky for a long time. I never believed I could lose money on a large scale.”

“I wanted to become as rich as Vanderbilt, so I tried every method I knew.”

“But eventually I got caught.”

He paused.

“I also enjoyed the excitement of making money and then giving it away. I don’t regret the money I gave away. At least some good came from it.”

“Wall Street was a wonderful place to make money, and I stayed there long after I should have left.”

“Now I know exactly what I should have done.”

“I should have left Wall Street eight or ten years earlier and paid my debts.”

“When I promised $100,000 to a school or church, I should have paid the money instead of giving them my notes.”

“I should also have given my children enough money to make them secure for life.”

“Instead, I kept the principal and paid only the interest, believing I could make more money with the principal.”

“One of the hardest things for me now is knowing that I can no longer pay the interest on the notes I gave to the schools and churches.”

Drew also explained how he had protected his daughter’s family.

“I gave my son the old family home and some other small properties in Putnam County. I hope they will at least make him independent.”

“My daughter married a wealthy man. When he died, he left considerable property to their five children, and I became executor of the estate.”

“To guarantee their property, I had to provide security.”

“So I transferred this house and the North River steamboats—the Drew, Dean Richmond, St. John, and Chauncey Vibbard—to them.”

“That makes them whole.”

“And I thank God that I never had a breach of trust on my conscience.”

“My daughter is well provided for through her children and her late husband.”

“My son is now involved in managing the boats, and he is doing quite well.”

After Drew’s disastrous Erie corner, he became a special partner in the firm of Kenyon, Cox & Co.

When that firm failed after the Panic of 1873, Drew was forced to assign his property to his creditors.

For years he had been losing money.

Gould and Fisk had cost him between two and three million dollars in the Erie struggle.

Horace F. Clark and Gould had also trapped him in Northwestern stock, costing him another $750,000.

After the panic, Drew assigned his property to William L. Scott of Erie, Pennsylvania.

He was not legally declared bankrupt until 1876.

His liabilities totaled $1,074,131.83.

His assets were estimated at $746,499.46.

Like Vanderbilt, Drew kept his accounts largely in his head.

He considered elaborate bookkeeping a ridiculous waste of time.

A failure that might once have caused a Wall Street panic now produced barely a ripple.

After receiving his discharge in bankruptcy, Drew regained some of his old confidence.

“The boys think I’m finished,” he said, “but I’ll give them plenty of turns and twists yet.”

He still speculated in Toledo & Wabash, Canada Southern, Quicksilver Mining Company, and Canton Land Company.

William H. Vanderbilt had once worked as a clerk in Drew’s office and had received some of his early financial training there.

Despite their later differences, Vanderbilt still felt some affection for his former employer.

From time to time, he gave Drew what the old man called “pints”—small pieces of information about the market.

Drew would use those hints to make a little money.

It was said that Vanderbilt intended to give Drew another opportunity to rebuild his life.

But Drew died before that could happen.

On September 18, 1879, at 10:45 in the evening, Daniel Drew died at his son William H. Drew’s home at 3 East Forty-second Street.

His death came without warning.

He had appeared to be in normal health during the day.

At six o’clock that evening, he had dinner with Darius Lawrence of Lawrence Brothers, a Broad Street brokerage firm, at the Grand Union Hotel.

After dinner, Drew returned to his son’s house.

Around nine o’clock, he said that he felt sick.

But he refused to let anyone stay with him.

“If I get worse,” he said, “I’ll call Mr. Lawrence. He’s sleeping in the next room.”

Around ten o’clock, Drew went into Lawrence’s room.

“I feel much worse,” he said.

Dr. Woodman, the family physician, was called immediately.

But before the doctor arrived, Drew had died.

The cause was apoplexy.

Many stories were told about Drew’s strange habits.

One of the most revealing concerned the way he dealt with disappointment in the market.

When prayer failed to calm him, he sometimes drank until he became melancholy and then shut himself away in bed.

In the year of his death, two Wall Street acquaintances found him in this condition at the Sturtevant House.

All the windows were closed.

The room was unbearably hot.

Drew was buried beneath several heavy blankets.

His friends ordered a bottle of champagne.

Drew refused to drink it.

They ordered another bottle and left it with him.

They suspected that once they were gone, he might drink it without feeling embarrassed in front of them.

Another story shows just how cleverly Drew could use information that others foolishly gave him.

During the Civil War, a young man known as California Parker began buying Erie stock around par.

He pushed the price all the way up to 120.

Parker had plenty of money but very little experience.

He went to Drew with a proposition.

“I’ll let you buy the stock fifteen percent below the market,” Parker said, “if you’ll give me some money to help push the price higher.”

Drew appeared interested.

Encouraged by Drew’s reaction, Parker continued buying.

He kept pouring money into Erie until he had almost exhausted his California gold.

The next morning Parker met Drew again.

Drew looked disappointed.

“I’m sorry,” he said, “but I wasn’t able to raise the money.”

What Parker did not know was that Drew had already instructed his brokers to sell Erie short.

Drew knew Parker had nearly exhausted his resources and could not keep supporting the stock.

The market collapsed.

Drew made a large profit.

Parker left Wall Street ruined—but much wiser.

In appearance, Drew was tall, strong, and lean.

In his later years, deep lines covered his face, revealing years of intense thought and anxiety.

His eyes were restless and constantly alert.

He walked with a quiet, cat-like step.

His manner was usually pleasant, calm, and persuasive.

He also affected a modesty that was carefully designed to disarm people.

Because of this, he could move comfortably among people of every social class.

More than once, people mistook him for a simple country church deacon.

That was hardly the whole story.

Behind the mild exterior was one of the most resourceful, daring, and complicated speculators Wall Street ever produced.

Daniel Drew rose from a poor farm, made fortunes in cattle, steamboats, and stocks, gave away large sums of money, fought some of the greatest financial figures of his time, lost his fortune through speculation, and died with only a small fraction of his former wealth.

His life was filled with ambition, generosity, deception, failure, and remarkable resilience.

And perhaps the strangest part of his story is that even after everything was gone, he still could not completely leave Wall Street behind.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!