Grant’s Second Term
I want to briefly explain the part I played in getting General Grant re-elected. At the time, many politicians—Republicans and Democrats alike—were already predicting that he would be defeated if he sought a second term.
His former supporters were badly divided, and an organized campaign had begun long before the Republican Convention in Philadelphia to block his renomination.
His enemies, disappointed office seekers, and their allies threw every bit of political machinery they could command into the fight. They used the same tactics and prejudices that would be used even more successfully against Grant four years later.
I was convinced that nominating anyone else might cost the Republican Party the election. The party needed Grant if it was to remain strong, united, and independent.
He had already served one term, and I believed he had proved himself a capable and dependable President.
“Why take a chance on another man?” I asked myself.
The country was still dealing with the difficult and unsettled problems of Reconstruction. Replacing Grant with an untested President could seriously damage both the political and economic interests of the nation.
And if the new nominee were a Democrat, I believed the danger would be even greater.
The South was not yet in a condition where I thought it safe to give its political forces any opportunity to regain decisive control of the national government.
We Republicans needed a candidate who could actually win.
I believed that candidate was Grant.
There was another reason as well.
No other man seemed more deserving of the nation’s gratitude. Grant had played the leading military role in ending the Civil War and suppressing the rebellion. His courage and determination had helped preserve the Union and the Republican form of government.
For that achievement, I believed the American people could never show him too much gratitude.
But beneath this broad public feeling, a very different political movement was taking shape.
Discontented politicians were secretly working against Grant. Behind some of them were men whose intentions were even more dangerous. Certain conspirators had been thinking about radical changes to the political order for years, and they had begun organizing their plans before Grant had even completed half of his first term.
Their goal was to shape public opinion against his renomination.
They spread scandals wherever they could.
They supplied stories to newspapers that were willing to support them.
They used every questionable political channel available.
As the election approached, the opposition became stronger and more aggressive.
Even some of Grant’s most enthusiastic supporters began to wonder whether he could actually win the Republican nomination.
There was another danger.
Everyone expected the Democrats to attract large numbers of Republicans who were dissatisfied with Grant.
The hostility of the Tribune made the situation worse, especially with the possibility that Horace Greeley might become the Democratic candidate.
Something had to be done.
We needed to organize quickly and make sure Grant had enough support at the Republican Convention.
I threw myself into the effort.
“What exactly is driving you?” someone might ask.
My answer is simple.
I believed that the security of contracts, the stability of property, the success of business, and the prosperity of the entire country depended on Grant remaining President.
And if the reader wants to know whether I also had a personal financial interest in the matter, I will be equally frank.
Of course I did.
If the country prospered, Wall Street would prosper with it. I expected to benefit from that prosperity just as other businessmen would.
That was the selfish side of my motive.
But I was not looking for political office.
Several important offices were offered to me, and I declined them. None of them could have compensated me financially for leaving my own business, and my ambition in that field had already been satisfied.
So I went to work for Grant’s re-election.
I hired a large number of canvassers at my own expense.
“Find out what the leading businessmen think,” I told them. “Talk to the men who have the most at stake in the country’s future.”
They reported to me every day.
Before long, I had a clear picture of the views held by the most influential part of New York’s business community.
I then circulated a petition calling for a public meeting in support of Grant.
The petition began:
A Public Meeting
“To the merchants, bankers, manufacturers and other business men in favor of the re-election of General Grant:
“The undersigned, desiring publicly to express their earnest confidence in the sagacity, fidelity, energy and unfaltering patriotism, so signally displayed by Ulysses S. Grant in securing the restoration of peace at home, upholding national rights abroad, and in maintaining throughout the world the honor of the American name, do hereby invite their fellow citizens to assemble in mass meeting at the Cooper Institute, on Wednesday evening, the 17th of April, 1872.”
The petition was largely the result of the personal campaign I had organized during the preceding weeks.
Every day I gave my canvassers a new list of people to visit.
“Keep going,” I told them. “Get the strongest names in the city.”
Eventually, we had secured the support of almost every reputable business firm in New York.
Among those who signed were William E. Dodge, John C. Green, Henry F. Vail, George T. Adee, Rev. Samuel Osgood, William H. Fogg, Benjamin B. Sherman, Robert L. Stewart, William Henry Anthon, E. D. Morgan, H. B. Claflin, W. R. Vermilye, Jesse Hoyt, William Barton Peake, Joseph Seligman, Theodore Roosevelt, William Orton, Peter Cooper, Samuel B. Ruggles, Cortlandt Palmer, George Opdyke, Harper & Brothers, William H. Vanderbilt, William H. Aspinwall, and many other prominent New Yorkers.
I still possessed the original signatures of these men.
Sadly, nearly all of those I have just named were already dead by the time I wrote this.
Their names nevertheless show how many of the leading men of New York had rallied to the movement.
Once we had assembled our forces, the next step was obvious.
We needed to show the opposition how much support we had.
We also needed to give our own side confidence.
So we called a mass meeting at Cooper Institute for April 17, 1872.
The meeting was enormous.
The hall was packed.
The crowd outside was several times larger.
I had first asked A. T. Stewart to preside.
Stewart had once been a strong supporter of Grant. But by then he had become cold toward the President because one of his wife’s close relatives had failed to receive a desired promotion at the Custom House.
I spent several days trying to persuade Stewart.
“Come on, Mr. Stewart,” I urged him. “You should preside over the meeting.”
He refused.
I kept trying.
Finally, I managed to get one concession from him.
“If you won’t vote for Grant,” I said, “at least promise me you won’t vote against him.”
He finally agreed.
That was as far as I could get.
Once Stewart made up his mind, almost nothing could move him.
Even the fact that Grant had once offered him the second-highest office in the country—the Treasury Secretaryship—did not change his attitude. Stewart had been unable to accept the position because of his business interests, but he still could not forget what he considered the insult to his wife’s relative.
Since Stewart would not preside, I turned to William E. Dodge.
“Will you take the chair?” I asked.
Dodge accepted.
He proved to be an excellent chairman.
The list of vice-presidents was even more impressive.
People said that no political meeting in New York had ever assembled such a distinguished group of names.
I had also invited Frederick Douglass and P. B. S. Pinchback, two of the leading Black political speakers of the day.
Unfortunately, both were attending a convention of their own people in New Orleans and could not come.
Another Black speaker, Mr. Rainey, addressed the meeting.
His speech was powerful.
It was probably the first time since the Civil War that a Black political speaker had addressed a white political gathering in New York—or perhaps anywhere in the North.
The Black vote for Grant had previously been uncertain.
Horace Greeley was extremely popular among Black voters, and he had recently been traveling through the South trying to win their support as well as attract Democrats.
He failed at both.
As James G. Blaine later put it, no other candidate could have combined such remarkable strength and weakness.
The Cooper Institute meeting created an excitement that had not been seen in American politics for a long time.
It energized Republicans across the country.
It crushed the hopes of the so-called Independents.
It also badly damaged the Democratic Party’s prospects.
To understand how important the meeting really was, however, we must look at how the leading political figures privately reacted to it.
That part of the story was not known at the time.
Today, those private reactions have become part of history.
One incident from that night remains especially memorable to me.
It concerned Senator Henry Wilson of Massachusetts.
After the meeting, several speakers and prominent men joined me for supper at the Union League Club.
I proposed Senator Wilson’s health.
“He has spoken brilliantly tonight,” I said. “I nominate Henry Wilson for Vice-President.”
Everyone laughed at my bold prediction.
But it came true.
Wilson was later elected Vice-President.
I now want to reproduce several letters that had never before been published.
They show how important our work was considered by the men who were most deeply concerned about Grant’s political future.
The first came from the White House.
Horace Porter, Grant’s secretary, wrote:
“My Dear Clews:
“I have received your several interesting letters in regard to the great meeting in New York, and have shown them to the President, who read them with deep interest.
“You have done a great work, and this evening’s success will, I have no doubt, be the reward of your efforts.
“We shall look anxiously for the reports.”
Two days later, Porter wrote again:
“My Dear Clews:
“I have only a moment before the mail closes to say how earnestly all congratulate you upon the great success of the meeting.
“It was glorious and genuine.
“We read the proceedings in full in the Times last night.
“It has created a marked effect in Congress and elsewhere.”
Roscoe Conkling also sent me a letter.
He wrote:
“As a New Yorker and a Republican, I want to thank you for the great service you have rendered our country and our cause in conceiving and carrying forward the great meeting of night before last.
“The effect of it will be wholesome and widefelt; it was most timely, and its whole management was a success.”
The New York Herald reported the President’s reaction as well.
According to its Washington correspondent, Grant was extremely pleased by the New York demonstration.
He regarded it as evidence that the Republican Party remained popular.
There was another point that especially interested him.
Leading Democratic merchants and bankers around the country were reportedly hoping for a Republican victory because they feared that a Democratic victory might damage the nation’s credit and trigger another financial crisis.
The meeting therefore issued a formal address and a series of resolutions explaining why Grant deserved another term.
E. Delafield Smith presented the address.
It praised Grant’s administration for restoring peace, strengthening the Union, respecting the Constitution, reducing the national debt, lowering taxes, strengthening national credit, and encouraging business and industry.
The address argued that the country was enjoying security and prosperity because the rebellion had been defeated and the Union preserved.
It declared that the soldier who had won victories in war and the statesman who had helped secure peace deserved the gratitude of the nation.
It also defended Grant against the investigations and accusations being directed at his administration.
The address declared, in substance:
“Investigate him as closely as you please. The more closely you examine his record, the stronger his defense becomes.”
The supporters of Grant also dismissed the complaints of disappointed office seekers.
“Does it really matter whether one senator received more patronage than another?” the address asked.
“The country faces much larger questions.”
The resolutions went even further.
They declared that New York’s merchants, bankers, mechanics, and businessmen were satisfied with Grant’s administration and wanted him to remain President.
They warned that a coalition between dissident Republicans and Democrats would effectively return the Democratic Party to power.
They compared such a political reversal to bringing back the enemies of the Union after the Union had finally been saved.
They argued that Grant deserved the same kind of confidence that George Washington had received after creating the nation.
And they attacked the campaign of personal abuse against Grant.
The final resolution declared that a majority of Americans wanted Grant renominated and re-elected.
E. Delafield Smith then addressed the crowd.
“President Grant will be renominated in Philadelphia,” he said. “And it is equally clear that this is what the American people want.”
His opponents claimed that Grant’s public support came mainly from government employees.
Smith rejected the argument.
“There are always far more people seeking offices than people holding them,” he said.
Then he added:
“Every office conferred creates one grateful man and forty-nine enemies.”
The audience laughed.
Smith continued.
“Grant is so strong that his enemies have been forced to seek a coalition as their only hope of defeating him.”
He mocked the idea that dissident Republicans could simply combine with Democrats and expect to control them.
“When the Democratic organization is weakened,” he said, “thousands of Democrats will simply choose their own candidate. Many of them will rally to the hero of our armies.”
He then compared the coalition meeting to the old organization of Black troops during the Civil War.
“The officers were white men,” he said, “while the rank and file were Black soldiers. In this political coalition, the platform is covered with Republicans, while the audience is made up of Democrats.”
He concluded:
“The truly independent man is the man who is loyal to his country, true to his party, and faithful to his friends.”
I have included the address and resolutions because I believe they provide an important summary of this period in American political history.
But the strongest evidence of the meeting’s success came from an unexpected source.
The Evening Post had spent a long time attacking Grant.
Yet the day after the meeting, even the Post admitted that the gathering was extraordinary.
Its editorial essentially said:
“This meeting was unlike anything we can remember in our political history.”
It also acknowledged that the organizers had assembled an unusually impressive list of officers and supporters.
The paper admitted that the audience itself was made up largely of respectable and thoughtful voters.
That was a significant admission from one of Grant’s most persistent critics.
Our work continued throughout the summer and into the fall.
The New York Sun later declared:
“Henry Clews did more, financially, to promote Grant’s success than any Republican millionaire of the Union League Club.”
Another mass meeting was held later that year.
A few days before the election, Horace Porter wrote to me again from Washington:
“We are all greatly obliged for the documents and information which you have sent us during the campaign.
“The President says the list of vice-presidents of the last Cooper Institute meeting is the most remarkable list of prominent names he has ever seen upon one paper.
“It will of itself do great good.
“Our news is charming from all quarters, and all our hopes will, without doubt, be fully realized on Tuesday next.”
He ended with a sentence that showed how much was at stake:
“If the defeat of the enemy is overwhelming, it will be sufficient reward for all our labors.”
The business community continued to support Grant.
One of the clearest examples was a circular signed by leading merchants, bankers, and businessmen in New York.
They focused on the national debt and the financial record of Grant’s first administration.
When Grant took office on March 4, 1869, the national debt stood at about $2.525 billion.
By September 1872, approximately $348 million of the principal had been paid and canceled.
The remaining principal was about $2.177 billion.
Taxes had also been reduced substantially.
Compared with the tax rates of 1869, the annual reduction included roughly $82 million in internal revenue taxes, $30 million from the repeal of the income tax, and $58 million in customs duties.
That amounted to approximately $170 million in annual tax reductions.
The yearly interest burden on the national debt had also fallen by more than $23 million.
The businessmen who signed the circular argued that these results demonstrated the value of Grant’s financial administration.
Their conclusion was straightforward.
If the country wanted continued prosperity, stable trade, and confidence in its government securities, they believed Grant should be re-elected.
Among the signers were Phelps, Dodge & Co., George Opdyke & Co., A. A. Low & Brothers, Vermilye & Co., Jay Cooke & Co., Harper & Brothers, Frederick S. Winston, Morris Franklin, Robert H. McCurdy, William M. Vermilye, William Cullen Bryant, H. B. Claflin & Co., Moses Taylor, William H. Aspinwall, Russell Sage, Peter Cooper, E. D. Morgan & Co., Drexel, Morgan & Co., William H. Vanderbilt, J. & W. Seligman & Co., Benjamin B. Sherman, Samuel T. Skidmore, Henry F. Vail, George W. T. Lord, and Henry Clews & Co.
By then, the campaign had become much larger than one man or one political meeting.
It had become a movement involving politicians, businessmen, bankers, merchants, and ordinary Republican voters who believed that Grant represented stability after the upheaval of the Civil War.
The work we had begun at Cooper Institute had helped turn that sentiment into organized political strength.
And when the election finally came, the result was overwhelming.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!