The Utica Betrayal and the Road to Garfield’s Assassination
The political events that followed the Utica Convention and the nomination of General Dix for governor contain a piece of secret history that deserves to be told.
If I had not suddenly put General Dix forward at exactly the right moment, Judge Robertson would almost certainly have won the nomination.
My move came as a sudden and crushing blow to Robertson and his political friends. It destroyed some of the most promising plans Senator Conkling had ever developed.
Because events took such an unexpected turn that day, Conkling was placed in a false position with several of his closest political allies.
Some of them misunderstood what he had done and accused him of betraying friends whom they believed he had promised to support.
They assumed that Conkling had secretly engineered the surprise nomination of General Dix.
The credit for the maneuver was immediately given to Conkling.
He did not deny it.
Perhaps he was too proud to explain himself. Perhaps he simply did not care what people thought.
But if he had explained the truth, many people probably would have interpreted his explanation in the usual political way and refused to believe him.
In any case, he was in a position where it was almost impossible for him to escape responsibility for Dix's nomination.
The move seemed too clever to have come from anyone of lesser political ability.
Anyone else who tried to explain what had really happened would probably have been laughed at.
Judge Robertson, who suffered more than anyone from the sudden change of events, was the first to assume that Dix's nomination had been one of Conkling's great political maneuvers.
He never thought of looking anywhere else.
He firmly believed that Conkling had planned it.
He still believed it many years later.
I knew better.
But at the time, my explanation would probably not have been believed, and I would have been accused of boasting if I had claimed credit for the move.
Now, however, I think the truth can finally be told.
History is often described as philosophy taught through examples.
The importance of an event is not always in the event itself, but in what later generations can learn from it.
For that reason, I will now give the facts as they actually happened.
I am willing to swear on the revised edition of the Bible that, before the Utica Convention, I never once heard Senator Conkling even mention the name of General Dix.
Nor did Conkling, as far as I knew, ever seriously consider Dix as a possible candidate.
I am almost certain that before Dix's name was mentioned at the Convention, Conkling had taken no action that could have interfered with Judge Robertson's political ambitions.
With the exceptions I have already described, I am convinced that the appearance of Dix's name came as a genuine surprise to almost everyone at the Convention, including the men who were running it.
Robertson saw things very differently.
He believed Conkling had deliberately caused his defeat.
That misunderstanding created the bitterness between the two men and eventually produced consequences that helped destroy the political ambitions of both.
Because I was staying as Conkling's guest, Robertson naturally assumed that I had acted on Conkling's orders when I brought Dix forward.
But that was completely wrong.
The idea that Dix was the best candidate had originated entirely with me.
I had never even suggested the idea to Conkling before I stood before the Convention and spoke in favor of General Dix.
Robertson believed that Conkling had deliberately ruined his chances at Utica.
Naturally, he began watching for an opportunity to settle the score with the man he believed had betrayed him and blocked his political advancement.
That opportunity came at the Republican Convention in Chicago.
There, Conkling was successfully organizing the forces behind General Grant's campaign for a third presidential term.
There is an extraordinary irony in what happened.
The very political circumstances that had helped Grant win a second term eventually became one of the causes of his defeat when he sought a third.
Conkling had no idea how deeply Robertson resented him.
He had done nothing knowingly to deserve Robertson's hatred.
He expected Robertson to cooperate with him just as he had in the past.
Conkling assumed that Robertson and his political allies would once again support General Grant.
He thought he had gone to Chicago holding a winning hand.
Instead, some of his best cards were missing.
His opponents had quietly gathered them.
Conkling did not realize the danger until the Convention actually met.
Then, to his dismay, he discovered that Robertson had abandoned the Grant campaign.
Robertson first joined forces with the supporters of James G. Blaine.
But he soon realized that Blaine's faction did not have enough strength to defeat the powerful Grant organization.
So he joined John Sherman's supporters, who were being led by James A. Garfield.
Conkling stood at the head of 306 loyal delegates.
They were a disciplined and powerful group.
For days, however, the Sherman forces could not break through the Grant organization.
The deadlock continued.
Day after day passed without any decisive change.
It seemed as though Conkling's forces had adopted the old saying associated with Napoleon's Guard:
"The Guard dies, but does not surrender."
Finally, Robertson and his allies gathered together the weakened Blaine and Sherman factions.
With Garfield at their head, they launched a desperate attack against Conkling's solid bloc.
But Conkling's forces still held together.
Then the opposition united around a single battle cry:
"Anything to beat Grant!"
That slogan finally broke the deadlock.
Garfield was nominated.
Conkling withdrew from the field in good order, but he had suffered a crushing political defeat.
Robertson had embraced the cry of "Anything to beat Grant!" with almost fanatical enthusiasm.
A story from that campaign illustrates the spirit perfectly.
A religious enthusiast had predicted that the world would come to an end in early November.
One Sunday, a preacher reminded his congregation of the prediction.
He warned them that the prophecy might come true and urged everyone to be prepared.
When the sermon ended, one man suddenly stood up.
In a solemn and deeply emotional voice, he said:
"Thank God."
The minister was puzzled.
Why would anyone thank God for the end of the world?
After the service, the minister found the man and asked him why he had responded so enthusiastically to such terrible news.
The man's answer was simple:
"Anything to beat Grant."
That was essentially the spirit in which Robertson's faction fought at Chicago.
And that was the spirit in which they won.
For Robertson, however, the real objective was not Grant.
It was Conkling.
He wanted revenge against the man he believed had destroyed his chances at Utica.
In reality, he was punishing the wrong man.
I was the one who had unexpectedly brought Dix forward at Utica, yet I escaped untouched by the political consequences.
Robertson never stopped resenting Conkling.
When the new administration took office, Garfield selected Blaine for his Cabinet.
That decision intensified the hostility between Blaine and Conkling.
To Conkling, it looked like the political alliance between Robertson and Blaine at Chicago was continuing into the new administration.
The seeds of a powerful rivalry had now been planted between two of the Republican Party's most ambitious leaders.
Each wanted to become the real power behind the presidency.
After Garfield was inaugurated, Blaine became Secretary of State.
But Blaine was not the only man who deserved credit for Garfield's victory.
Judge Robertson had also played a crucial role.
Without Robertson's support, Garfield could never have secured the nomination.
So Robertson had to be rewarded as well.
He was appointed Collector of the Port of New York.
Those appointments struck directly at Conkling's political power.
Blaine had entered the Cabinet, while Robertson received one of the most important political offices in New York.
Conkling saw both appointments as attacks on his influence.
The result was dramatic.
Senator Conkling resigned.
Senator Thomas C. Platt, often mocked as "Me Too," resigned with him.
The Republican Party then split into two bitter factions.
One side became known as the Stalwarts.
The other became known as the Half-Breeds.
The political battle between these factions became increasingly intense.
In the middle of all this turmoil, a man named Charles Guiteau became consumed by political delusions.
His fanaticism eventually drove him to assassinate President Garfield.
Thus, when the chain of events is followed from one episode to the next, the consequences of that single political maneuver at Utica reach into one of the darkest tragedies in American political history.
What began as a surprise nomination for Governor eventually helped set in motion a series of political conflicts that divided the Republican Party and, through a tangled chain of events, ended in the murder of a President.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!