← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 26 · The Real Cost of America’s Railroad System

The Real Cost of America’s Railroad System

Chapter 26 of 90 · 3,018 words · Free

“America’s railroad laws were badly designed from the very beginning,” I argued. “They gave railroad companies enormous powers, but placed far too few restrictions on how those companies could raise money or protect the public.”

“In a country as large as ours, transportation costs matter enormously. Our products often have to travel hundreds or even thousands of miles to reach their markets. Railroads should therefore be built as cheaply as possible and with as little debt as possible.”

“Instead, our laws encouraged inflated financing. That mistake has made transportation more expensive than it needed to be and has damaged the reputation of American railroad securities around the world.”

“European investors once provided enormous amounts of money for American railroads. Britain, Holland, and Germany all invested heavily in our development.”

“But because our railroad companies were allowed to operate with so much secrecy, misleading financial information, and even outright fraud, American credit became a laughingstock on European stock exchanges.”

“Foreign investors began looking elsewhere. Their governments encouraged them to invest in new colonies and other countries instead of putting their money into American railroads.”

“That is the price of dishonest financing.”

“Let me explain how the system actually worked.”

“Under New York law, which was typical of many other states, a group of men could form a railroad company. They would register the proposed route, the amount of stock and bonds to be issued, and a few other basic details.”

“Then these same men would form another company to build the railroad.”

“And that is where the trouble began.”

“The men who owned the railroad company would make a construction contract with themselves.”

“They were effectively sitting on both sides of the negotiating table.”

“Of course, they made the contract as favorable to themselves as possible.”

“Typically, the construction company agreed to build the railroad for bonds worth somewhere between 80 and 100 percent of their face value, together with an equal amount of stock. Sometimes they received second-mortgage bonds as well.”

“The first mortgage was supposed to represent the actual money spent building and equipping the railroad.”

“But in reality, the cash cost of the work and materials was often only 60 to 80 percent of the amount of the first mortgage.”

“The construction company could then sell some of the bonds to the public through bankers at a higher price than it had received them for. It could also use the bonds to pay for rails, equipment, and other supplies.”

“And after making its construction profits, the builders still owned all the stock and whatever second-mortgage bonds they had received.”

“That stock was essentially a free bonus.”

“They could hold it until its value increased, use it to maintain control of the railroad, and eventually sell it in a market they could help manipulate.”

“This was how a large majority of American railroads were built.”

“The result was obvious. The railroad itself might cost less than 60 cents for every dollar of stock and bonds issued against it.”

“Yet the investors were led to believe that the railroad was worth the full amount.”

“That was the original sin of our railroad system.”

“Many of the bankruptcies, reorganizations, financial disasters, and public losses that followed were built into the system from the moment these railroads were created.”

“The foundation was already unsound.”

“Some railroads managed to overcome this burden. A few earned enough money to pay their interest, improve their properties, and even distribute dividends to shareholders.”

“But most were not so fortunate.”

“They eventually had to reorganize their finances because their debts were simply too large for the railroad to support.”

“Of the roughly 125,000 miles of railroad then in operation, carrying about $7.5 billion in stock and debt, I would not consider it an exaggeration to say that perhaps 60 percent had already gone through some form of debt reduction or financial rehabilitation.”

“The only reason the damage was not even greater was that many new railroads opened up undeveloped territory.”

“New settlements created new customers and new freight.”

“That new business helped some railroads survive debts that otherwise would have destroyed them.”

“But the very possibility of future growth also became a weapon in the hands of railroad speculators.”

“They exaggerated the prospects of new settlements and new sources of wealth to distant investors who knew little about the actual situation.”

“Those investors were then persuaded to put money into badly conceived railroad schemes.”

“The ordinary investor suffered most from this system.”

“The bondholders usually supplied nearly all the real capital.”

“The stockholders often contributed practically nothing.”

“The bondholders took the risk, while the stockholders received the upside.”

“If the railroad succeeded, the bondholders received their interest. But the stockholders, despite having invested little or nothing, could make enormous profits as the shares became valuable.”

“If the railroad failed, the bondholders lost interest and were eventually forced to accept a new mortgage for a smaller amount and at a lower interest rate.”

“The original stockholders, meanwhile, could make money by pushing the shares higher in Wall Street before the collapse.”

“These construction schemes created enormous fortunes.”

“In fact, they were one of the principal sources of the spectacular wealth accumulated by American railroad millionaires during the previous twenty years.”

“I do not hesitate to call these transactions frauds against the public.”

“Perhaps they were not technically illegal, because our laws had strangely failed to prohibit them.”

“But morally, they were clearly fraudulent.”

“They were deceptive. They were unfair. And they amounted to a hidden tax on the public for the benefit of a small group of people who had provided no equivalent value.”

“On average, American railroads were probably capitalized at about 50 percent more than their actual cost.”

“Yet railroad managers claimed that they were entitled to earn dividends on this inflated capital.”

“That meant charging the public enough money to produce a return not merely on the real investment, but also on capital that existed only on paper.”

“That is nothing less than an unfair tax on the country.”

“Higher railroad charges make it harder for American farmers, manufacturers, and merchants to compete with foreigners.”

“They also slow the development of our enormous natural resources.”

“In a country as vast as America, transportation costs are one of the most important factors determining economic progress.”

“The artificially high rates created by inflated railroad capitalization have therefore done far more damage to our development than most people realize.”

“The hundreds of millions accumulated by the railroad kings are, in large measure, the product of this distorted transfer of wealth.”

“And there is another danger.”

“Such a financial system creates a powerful aristocracy of wealth.”

“The fortunes created by these methods will not simply disappear with their founders.”

“Their descendants will inherit enormous financial power.”

“They will influence banks, corporations, monopolies, commerce, and legislation.”

“Eventually, their interests may come into conflict with the political institutions of the country.”

“The public will not remain ignorant forever.”

“One day, ordinary citizens will understand how much of their own prosperity was sacrificed to create these enormous fortunes.”

“And when that day comes, our political system will face serious questions.”

“We can already see the beginning of this conflict.”

“Workers are starting to recognize that something is wrong.”

“They may not understand exactly how railroad finance has transferred wealth from the public to a small group of capitalists, but they can see who has become extraordinarily rich.”

“That helps explain some of the labor unrest we are witnessing.”

“A worker naturally asks himself, ‘If a railroad can make a handful of men tens of millions of dollars, why can't it afford to pay its workers higher wages and give them shorter working hours?’”

“Another worker may look at men accumulating fortunes of tens of millions and think, ‘Surely I can earn a few more dollars a week without seriously hurting them.’”

“That reasoning may be economically mistaken.”

“But it is an entirely understandable reaction to the spectacle of enormous fortunes being created around them.”

“Socialist and Communist ideas have already attracted large numbers of European workers.”

“They are likely to find an even easier audience among American workers who can see, with their own eyes, the enormous inequality created by organized capital.”

“If any facts could be used to support those doctrines, the sudden creation of enormous railroad fortunes would certainly be among them.”

“There is another problem created by inflated railroad capitalization.”

“It encourages artificial methods of competition.”

“When a railroad is loaded with excessive capital, it becomes difficult for the company to compete against a new railroad built more cheaply.”

“Suppose two railroads connect the same cities.”

“The older railroad carries a huge burden of debt and inflated capital.”

“A new railroad can be built for much less money.”

“It can therefore charge lower rates.”

“As more and more competing lines appeared, competition for long-distance freight became intense.”

“Eventually even strong railroads found their profits threatened.”

“Some were unable to pay their mortgages.”

“That was when the railroad pool was introduced.”

“Several railroads serving the same markets would agree to combine their long-distance traffic into one common pool.”

“Each railroad would then receive a fixed percentage of that business.”

“The idea was simple.”

“If the railroads could stop competing against one another on price, they could maintain rates high enough for all of them to survive.”

“But the cure created another problem.”

“The pool itself encouraged new railroads to be built.”

“Speculators quickly realized that they could construct a new railroad along an existing route for much less money than the older companies had spent.”

“Because the new railroad had lower capitalization, it could offer lower rates.”

“Then it could demand admission to the pool.”

“If admitted, it would receive a share of the existing traffic without having to compete openly for every customer.”

“In other words, the pool became a reward for building another railroad.”

“That led to even more unnecessary construction.”

“New lines were built, and disconnected older lines were joined together, simply to create competing routes against the major trunk railroads.”

“The purpose was not necessarily to provide better transportation.”

“The purpose was often to force the established railroads either to share their traffic or to cut their rates.”

“The history of the Nickel Plate and West Shore projects should have been enough to warn us.”

“Nearly a thousand miles of unnecessary railroad were built to compete with the Vanderbilt system.”

“The lesson is obvious.”

“A railroad should not be built merely because its owners expect an existing pool to support it.”

“Yet the Eastern trunk-line pool remains vulnerable to new competitors.”

“New combinations of existing railroads could create competing routes between major cities at much lower capitalization.”

“Such combinations may actually be more dangerous competitors than entirely new railroads because they can use existing local traffic from the moment they begin operating.”

“I would not be surprised if several new routes between New York and Chicago were established within the next few years.”

“So the very device created to protect the railroads from the consequences of excessive capitalization is helping to create new competition.”

“Competition is gradually forcing railroad earnings back toward the true value of the properties.”

“And the pool has another weakness.”

“No agreement has yet been devised that can completely prevent its members from secretly cutting rates against one another.”

“There are simply too many ways to cheat.”

“Each railroad has special advantages it does not want to surrender.”

“Each road receives only a small share of the total business.”

“And when business is slow, freight agents are under enormous pressure to find customers by almost any means necessary.”

“Even strict supervision and harsh penalties cannot completely prevent violations.”

“Railroads often have to forgive violations simply to keep the agreement alive.”

“But every such violation creates resentment.”

“Sooner or later, the members begin accusing one another of breaking faith.”

“The pattern is always the same.”

“The pool earns public confidence by maintaining peace during good times.”

“Then the public suddenly discovers that one of the members has secretly cut rates.”

“The agreement begins to fall apart.”

“The public has therefore lost confidence in the pool's ability to control competition.”

“More importantly, railroad managers themselves are beginning to lose faith in it.”

“The real test will come when more outside competitors enter the market.”

“The pool probably cannot admit all of them.”

“There are already too many conflicting interests inside it.”

“Yet if those outsiders are excluded, they will operate as free agents, attacking the established railroads wherever they can.”

“They will offer rates low enough to force the older railroads to respond.”

“That leaves the established companies in a difficult position.”

“To my mind, their original mistakes are beginning to catch up with them.”

“They built their railroads on excessive capitalization.”

“They inflated their stock.”

“They created financial structures that depended on high rates and protected markets.”

“Now competition is coming after them.”

“And competition is a powerful enemy of commercial injustice.”

“It is the natural police force of trade.”

“Men may evade it for a while.”

“They may delay its effects.”

“They may even convince themselves that competition will never defeat their monopolies.”

“But eventually, competition restores economic balance.”

“I therefore believe that the abuses committed during the original construction of our railroads, and the later inflation of their stock, will ultimately be corrected by competition.”

“Railroad profits will eventually be pushed down toward a fair return on the real value of the property.”

“And the true value of a railroad should be measured by what it can actually earn under free competition and by what it would cost, in current cash terms, to build comparable facilities.”

“That, in my opinion, is where the railroad system is heading.”

“Neither Congress, nor the states, nor organized capital can postpone that outcome forever.”

“But what about government?” someone might ask.

“Surely legislation has some responsibility here.”

“It certainly does.”

“The history of our railroads has already demonstrated what happens when lawmakers fail to regulate construction, capitalization, and financial management.”

“State legislatures would make another serious mistake if they allowed the same abuses to continue in future railroad companies.”

“When the government gives a railroad valuable franchises and special privileges, it is effectively asking the public to surrender certain private rights for the common good.”

“In return, the railroad must be prevented from abusing those privileges.”

“If a railroad capitalizes its property at twice its actual cost and then charges the public enough to pay dividends on that inflated amount, it is abusing the privileges granted by its charter.”

“In practical terms, that is public robbery.”

“The solution is straightforward.”

“Future railroad companies should not be allowed to issue more stock and bonds than the actual cash cost of their property.”

“If they violate that rule, they should lose their charter.”

“The responsibility of railroad managers should also be clearly defined.”

“Extensions, improvements, and betterments should be financed under the same strict rules.”

“Mortgage debt should be limited to perhaps 60 percent of the property's actual cost.”

“We must also prevent the people who organize a railroad from secretly profiting by building it themselves.”

“Those incorporators should not be allowed to become the contractors.”

“Construction and equipment contracts should be awarded through open competitive bidding.”

“The lowest responsible bid should win.”

“And the contractor should be required to provide substantial guarantees that the work will actually be completed.”

“A state railroad commission should supervise these requirements and make sure they are obeyed.”

“Stock should not be issued for speculative purposes.”

“Dividends should not be paid unless they have actually been earned.”

“And the public should have full access to information about traffic, finances, debts, and operations.”

“If our original railroad laws had contained rules like these, American railroad securities would probably have become some of the safest investments in the world.”

“Our corporate reputation would have been protected.”

“Transportation would have been cheaper and more stable.”

“And America might have avoided the creation of a financial aristocracy built on questionable wealth.”

“After everything we have learned from our experience, surely it is not too late to adopt safer rules for future railroads.”

“Such legislation would protect investors and the public.”

“It would also help repair some of the damage created by the old system.”

“Consider what would happen if new railroads were built under these rules.”

“They would probably have only 50 or 60 percent as much capitalization as the older railroads.”

“That would allow them to charge much lower rates.”

“Because their finances were conservative and transparent, investors would have greater confidence in them.”

“Legitimate railroad projects would still be able to raise money.”

“But purely speculative schemes would become much harder to finance.”

“Such railroads could operate profitably and still compete fiercely with the older companies.”

“Eventually, the older railroads would have no choice but to reduce their earnings.”

“They could no longer maintain high returns on inflated capital.”

“They would have to earn interest and dividends on a capitalization closer to that of the new companies.”

“In effect, competition would squeeze the water out of the old railroad companies.”

“They might still exist in the same legal form, but financially they would be forced down to the same level as companies built honestly.”

“If my reasoning is correct, the great railroad capitalists should be worried about the future.”

“The foundation of their fortunes may not be nearly as secure as they believe.”

“Public anger against railroad monopolies and inflated capitalization is growing.”

“Once a clear solution is proposed, what guarantee is there that lawmakers will not adopt it quickly?”

“In the end, a governor's signature might be all that stands between a railroad millionaire and the destruction of a large part of his paper fortune.”

“Is that possibility unrealistic?”

“I do not think so.”

“Anyone familiar with the public mood toward railroad monopolies should take the possibility seriously.”

“The real question is whether the financial aristocracy created by the railroad system rests on a foundation as broad and secure as its members imagine.”

“And perhaps the larger railroad problem is not nearly as difficult—or as permanent—as many people have assumed.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!