More War Memories—British and French Designs
During the Civil War, Wall Street stepped forward more than once when the country faced danger. One of the most serious threats came from Napoleon III of France. He tried to take advantage of America’s internal war to interfere in Mexico and establish a European-backed monarchy there, openly challenging the Monroe Doctrine.
At the time, many Americans understood that what happened in Mexico could eventually threaten the United States itself.
One important response came through a public dinner held in New York for Matías Romero, the Mexican minister to Washington. The event took place on March 29, 1864, at Delmonico’s on Fifth Avenue and Fourteenth Street.
The dinner was organized by some of New York’s most prominent financiers, merchants, lawyers, and public figures. The purpose was clear: to show support for Mexico and to warn Europe that Americans would not quietly accept European intervention in the Western Hemisphere.
The banquet filled four large rooms.
The main dining hall was brightly lit and opened to invited families and guests. Flowers and garlands decorated the rooms, while an orchestra provided the music.
Among the guests were Mexican diplomats and prominent Americans. James W. Beekman presided over the evening, while John Jacob Astor, John W. Hamersley, and Henry Clews served as stewards.
After the guests had finished dinner, Beekman called the gathering to order.
“Tonight we are here to honor the cause of political and religious freedom in Mexico,” he said.
The first toast was to the President of the United States.
David Dudley Field rose to answer it.
“The people of this country are united in sympathy with Mexico,” Field said. “The government is simply expressing the will of the American people.”
He then attacked the French invasion.
“What France is doing in Mexico is one of the great crimes of our age,” he declared. “And I believe the reign of Maximilian will be short.”
Field then painted a picture of what he believed would happen.
“Maximilian may arrive with the Austrian eagle and the French flag. He may come with a hundred ships and march from Vera Cruz to the Mexican capital under the protection of French soldiers.”
“He may be welcomed by French trumpets in every major city.”
“But sooner or later, he will have to flee back to Europe.”
“His supporters will be driven from the country. The titles and honors he gives to his followers will become objects of ridicule.”
“And the Mexican republican flag will once again fly from the mountains.”
“After being purified by war and suffering, Mexico will recover its institutions and become free again.”
The next toast honored Benito Juárez, the constitutional president of Mexico.
Charles King, president of Columbia College, responded.
“Mexico is a friend and ally of the Union,” he said. “The struggle there is part of the larger struggle against European interference.”
Then the guest of honor, Matías Romero, stood to speak.
“I am very happy to tell you that the feelings you have expressed toward Mexico are fully returned by the Mexican people,” Romero said.
“In Mexico, we have the deepest respect for the United States. We want our two nations to become more closely connected.”
“Napoleon claims that he is interfering in Mexico because he wants to prevent Mexico from being annexed by the United States.”
“But ironically, if he succeeds in establishing a monarchy in Mexico, annexation might eventually become more likely.”
“We are willing to give the United States every commercial advantage that does not threaten our independence or sovereignty.”
“In this way, America can enjoy the benefits of close relations with Mexico without destroying Mexico’s independence.”
“If our political and commercial interests continue to grow together, the nations of this continent will eventually develop a common American policy that no European power will be able to ignore.”
Romero then turned to the situation facing the United States.
“I have almost forgotten your present troubles while thinking about the future of our two countries,” he said.
“But I believe your present difficulties are temporary. They cannot destroy the larger destiny that awaits both nations.”
“Anyone who carefully watched events could see that the European expedition against Mexico would eventually create serious problems for the United States.”
“Europe has sent an army into an American republic for the purpose of overthrowing its republican government and placing a European prince on its throne.”
“The only question is when the United States will be forced to confront this challenge directly.”
“I have complete confidence in the wisdom of American statesmen, the devotion of the American people to republican government, and the patriotism of the present administration.”
“I have no doubt that the United States will eventually act in the best interests of both America and humanity.”
Romero then raised an even more disturbing possibility.
“We may be forced to confront this issue sooner than expected,” he said.
“There are reports that Maximilian, who is preparing to call himself Emperor of Mexico, may recognize the independence of the Southern Confederacy.”
“If that is true, the danger becomes even greater.”
“Maximilian would be acting with the support of the French government. He would be nothing more than a French puppet in Mexico.”
Romero also pointed to Europe’s own instability.
“Perhaps the growing danger of war in Europe will eventually force France to abandon its intervention in Mexico.”
“It is remarkable that Europe is so unstable, threatened by revolutions and struggling to protect its own governments, while the French Emperor is busy trying to rearrange the affairs of other countries.”
George Bancroft, the famous historian, was then asked to speak about Mexico’s great statesmen.
He began modestly.
“Gentlemen, I am not prepared to give a speech worthy of an audience such as this,” Bancroft said. “But I cannot refuse to express my feelings about our sister republic.”
“For many years, the Mexican people have fought against domestic tyranny. Their struggle has been heroic, and the civilized world should have openly supported them.”
Bancroft blamed Mexico’s political troubles heavily on the clergy.
“In Mexico and throughout Spanish America, the clergy have repeatedly tried to dominate the government and place the interests of the Church above those of society.”
“The Mexican struggle for religious and political liberty was therefore a just struggle.”
“And the people of the United States naturally sympathized with it, because religious liberty and separation of Church and State are fundamental principles of our own country.”
“But our sympathy for Mexico has now become even stronger.”
“Mexico is not only fighting for its independence. It is fighting against a European power that has taken advantage of our Civil War to impose a government completely opposed to our own.”
“We cannot allow Europe to do in America what it would never tolerate us doing in Europe.”
Bancroft then compared the Mexican struggle with America’s own fight.
“The Americans who help restore the power and influence of our own government, and the Mexicans who establish religious liberty and drive out the foreign invader, deserve our deepest respect.”
“The Egyptians placed a burning lamp beside the bodies of their kings.”
“But when the tomb was opened, the lamp went out.”
“Let Europe place the weak lamp of monarchy at Maximilian’s feet.”
“It will not survive in the atmosphere of this continent.”
William Cullen Bryant followed.
“We in the United States have made ourselves something like the police of the New World,” Bryant said.
“Again and again, we have warned the powerful governments of Europe to stay away from this hemisphere.”
“We told them that if they brought their old habits of conquest here, they would do so at their own risk.”
“But now, while this American police force is fighting a terrible battle at home, a Frenchman comes along, knocks down an innocent bystander, steals his property, and walks away.”
“That is what France is doing to Mexico.”
“It is cowardly, criminal, and cruel.”
“And everyone who understands the politics of our time knows that France would never have dared to do it if the United States were not already fighting a bloody war within its own borders.”
“We once believed that President Juárez was leading Mexico toward a new era of enlightened government.”
“Then the storm came from Europe.”
“May that darkness soon disappear. May liberty and peace return, and may Mexico take its rightful place among the nations.”
The speeches continued throughout the evening.
Ignacio Mariscal spoke for the Mexican legal profession.
George Folsom spoke for American diplomacy.
Dr. Willard Parker offered a toast to Dr. Navarro, once chief medical officer of the Mexican Army.
George Opdyke spoke for the merchants.
Jonathan Sturges represented the fine arts.
Washington Hunt denounced the French invasion.
Frederick De Peyster spoke for American historians and condemned French intervention.
Henry E. Pierrepont spoke for Brooklyn.
Smith Clift represented the legal profession.
Charles Astor Bristed spoke for American writers.
William E. Dodge, Jr. spoke for the young men of America.
“The French invasion is a direct insult to us,” Dodge declared.
“If our own war were over, I believe there would not be a town or village in America where men would not volunteer to help our sister republic.”
Then he raised his glass.
“To the Monroe Doctrine,” he said.
“Americans can never allow European tyranny to place its heel upon the soil of this continent.”
The audience responded enthusiastically.
Afterward, John W. Hamersley was asked to speak on behalf of the stewards.
He joked that the committee had been chosen to organize the dinner, not to make speeches.
“Our job was to bring together everything that could please the eye, the ear, and the appetite,” he said.
“But there is one kind of tyranny that the descendants of the Huguenots and the Pilgrim Fathers are willing to tolerate—the tyranny of the wine cup.”
The laughter soon gave way to a more serious tone.
“We are here to defend a principle that Americans have carried with them since childhood.”
“We stand beside our Mexican neighbors in their darkest hour.”
“Our two nations have much in common.”
“Both of us built nations out of wilderness. Both have fought against oppression.”
“And both have suffered under banners stained by the blood of patriots.”
“We have a common future.”
“I believe the rebellion in our own country is already approaching its end.”
“And when our armies triumph, perhaps the French eagles now flying over Mexico will have to leave the pyramids of Puebla and return to Paris.”
“Perhaps by next Easter, the bells of Mexico will ring from mountain to mountain, from ocean to ocean, celebrating not only the resurrection of Christ, but the rebirth of a nation.”
Then Hamersley raised another toast.
“To the daughters of Mexico,” he said.
“May they be as beautiful as their sons are brave.”
The room erupted in applause.
The chairman then turned to Henry Clews, the prominent banker.
“Mr. Clews,” he said, “we must not allow your modesty to keep us from hearing from Wall Street.”
Clews stood.
“Mr. President and gentlemen, enough has already been said tonight to demonstrate the depth of sympathy felt in this city for Mexico.”
“I rise simply to say that I fully agree with those sentiments.”
“The unanimous voice of this gathering shows that Americans will not accept foreign powers taking possession of any part of this continent.”
“The principles of republican government are deeply rooted in both Mexico and the United States.”
“Neither people will willingly surrender them.”
“Human freedom and the rights of man unite Mexico with every other American nation.”
“I do not say this because I am hostile to any European government.”
“On the contrary, I believe European nations would best serve their own people by leaving the people of this continent free to determine their own future.”
“The United States has declared this principle, and we intend to defend it.”
“Under the protection of American power and influence, Mexico’s independence and security will be preserved.”
The audience cheered.
The dinner finally ended, and the guests left to the stirring music of the Marseillaise.
Only a few days later, the United States House of Representatives unanimously passed a resolution declaring that the country would never accept a European-backed monarchy established on the ruins of a republic in the Americas.
The speeches at the Romero dinner, followed by that resolution, were early signs that Maximilian’s empire was already doomed before he had even formally taken his throne.
Napoleon III soon showed how closely he had been watching the event.
When the New York Herald reached Paris with a full account of the banquet, Napoleon’s censors seized the newspaper.
It was destroyed, just as the French government had destroyed issues of La Lanterne and writings by Victor Hugo that were considered dangerous.
The reason was obvious.
The speeches made at the dinner had openly challenged Napoleon’s plans.
The incident showed how seriously the French Emperor regarded the opposition coming from America.
Wall Street leaders had been among the first to recognize the danger.
And they had acted quickly.
They followed an old principle: the safest way to avoid danger is to confront it before it grows.
In my view, the men of Wall Street were among the first Americans to make a move that helped frustrate Napoleon’s ambitions.
The long-term consequences of that meeting were far greater than they appeared at the time.
A future historian could write an entire book about the influence of that single event.
The feeling expressed at the New York dinner helped strengthen the republican cause in Mexico.
It also sent a message across the Atlantic.
Napoleon’s plans began to look increasingly unrealistic to many Europeans.
His enemies became more suspicious of his ambitions.
The German states, already uneasy about French power, accelerated their own military preparations.
Those tensions eventually helped produce the Franco-Prussian War and the crushing French defeat at Sedan.
To someone reading only the local newspapers, the connection between a New York dinner and events in Europe might seem impossible.
But to a student of history, the chain of events is much easier to see.
There was another part of this story that must not be forgotten.
England was playing the same dangerous game.
And Britain was not simply an innocent observer.
There was, I believe, a secret understanding between Napoleon and the British government.
The plan was ambitious.
The two powers hoped to weaken the United States, take advantage of the destruction caused by the Civil War, and divide the spoils between themselves.
It was an international conspiracy against American liberty.
The whole story could fill an entire volume of political history.
I can only describe its main features here.
And once again, Wall Street men would step forward when the danger became serious.
The New York draft riots of 1863 were, in my view, encouraged by a combination of British, French, and Southern interests.
The purpose was simple.
If American troops were forced to spend their time putting down riots in New York, fewer soldiers would be available to fight the Confederacy.
Southern leaders were so eager for foreign assistance that they failed to understand the larger danger.
Their supposed European allies were pursuing their own interests and were not truly their friends.
The hope was that the draft riots would spread across the North.
If that happened, Southern forces might have an opportunity to march toward Washington and seize the Capitol.
At the same time, the European powers could move against the weakened United States.
The plan was already being prepared.
European weapons and military supplies were ready to be sent across the Atlantic if the blockade could be broken.
Britain, however, moved more cautiously than Napoleon.
The French Emperor repeatedly urged the British government to act faster.
If Napoleon had succeeded in persuading Britain to move with greater speed, the consequences for the United States might have been disastrous.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!