The Brothers’ Rivalry and the Fall of the Han
When Cao Pi heard that Cao Zhang was marching troops toward the capital, he turned anxiously to his officials. One man stepped forward, offering to reason with Cao Zhang. He was Jia Kui, the Remonstrance Doctor.
Cao Pi sent Jia Kui out to meet him.
Jia Kui rode out of the city and came face to face with Cao Zhang. Cao Zhang asked at once, “Where is the late king’s imperial seal?”
Jia Kui’s face turned stern. “The eldest son inherits the family, and the crown prince rules the state. That seal is no business of yours, Lord Marquis.”
Cao Zhang fell silent. He then entered the city with Jia Kui.
When they reached the palace gates, Jia Kui stopped him. “Have you come here to mourn the late king, or to seize power?”
“I came only to mourn. I have no other plans,” Cao Zhang replied.
“If you mean no harm, why bring your soldiers to the palace?”
Cao Zhang immediately ordered his men to stand down. He went into the palace alone to see Cao Pi. The two brothers threw their arms around each other and wept.
Cao Zhang handed all his troops over to Cao Pi. Cao Pi told him to return to Yanling and stay there.
Now secure on his throne, Cao Pi renamed the twenty-fifth year of Jian’an the first year of Yankang. He promoted Jia Xu to Grand Commandant, Hua Xin to Prime Minister, and Wang Lang to Censor-in-Chief. Every official, big and small, received a raise or reward.
He posthumously titled Cao Cao King Wu and buried him at Gaoling in Ye Commandery. He put Yu Jin in charge of tending the tomb.
When Yu Jin arrived, he saw paintings on the white plastered walls of the tomb chamber. The scenes showed the Battle of the Flooded Seventh Army: Guan Yu sitting high on his throne, capturing Yu Jin. Pang De stood proud, refusing to surrender. Yu Jin knelt on the ground, begging for mercy.
Cao Pi had always despised Yu Jin. When defeated, he had refused to die for his lord and surrendered instead, then returned later. Cao Pi had ordered the paintings made on purpose to shame him.
Yu Jin looked at the artwork. Overwhelmed by humiliation and rage, he fell ill and died.
Hua Xin spoke to Cao Pi. “Lord Marquis of Yanling has handed over his army and gone home. But Cao Zhi, Marquis of Linzi, and Cao Xiong, Marquis of Xiaohuai, did not come to mourn our late king. They must be punished.”
Cao Pi sent two messengers to bring them to account.
Soon a report came back. Cao Xiong, Marquis of Xiaohuai, feared punishment and had hanged himself. Cao Pi ordered a grand burial and granted him the posthumous title King Huai.
Another messenger returned a day later. Cao Zhi spent all his days drinking with Ding Yi and Ding Yi’s brother Ding Yi. He acted arrogant and rude. When the imperial messengers arrived, Cao Zhi did not even stand up.
Ding Yi shouted: “The late king wanted to make my lord heir. Only slanderous officials blocked it!”
Ding Yi’s brother added: “My lord is the wisest man under heaven. He should rule, yet he was denied the throne. How can all you court officials fail to recognize true talent?”
Cao Zhi shouted to his guards. They beat the messengers with sticks and drove them away.
Cao Pi flew into a rage. He ordered Xu Chu to take three thousand elite royal guards to Linzi and arrest Cao Zhi and his followers.
When Xu Chu reached Linzi, the city defender tried to stop him. Xu Chu cut him down at once. He marched straight into the manor hall. Cao Zhi, Ding Yi and Ding Yi’s brother were all dead drunk. Xu Chu tied them up, loaded them onto carts, and sent them to Ye. All of Cao Zhi’s minor officials were arrested too.
Cao Pi ordered Ding Yi and his brother executed immediately.
Cao Pi’s mother, Queen Bian, heard that Cao Xiong had killed himself. She was heartbroken. When news came that Cao Zhi had been captured and his friends killed, she was terrified. She hurried out of her chambers to see Cao Pi.
Queen Bian wept. “Your brother Cao Zhi has always loved wine and acts recklessly. He only behaves this way because he trusts in his own talent. Spare his life, for the sake of our shared blood. Then I may rest in peace even in the underworld.”
“I admire his talent too, Mother. I would never kill him. I only wish to teach him to control his temper. Do not grieve,” Cao Pi said.
Queen Bian wiped her tears and left.
Cao Pi went to a side hall and sent for Cao Zhi.
Hua Xin came to him. “Just now, the queen begged you not to kill Zijian, did she not?”
Cao Pi nodded.
“Zijian is gifted and clever. He is no ordinary man. If you do not get rid of him soon, he will become a great threat.”
“I cannot go against my mother’s wish,” Cao Pi answered.
“People say Zijian can write poems the moment he opens his mouth. I find that hard to believe. Summon him and test his skill. If he fails, you may put him to death. If he succeeds, banish him. This way, all scholars in the realm will have nothing to complain about.”
Cao Pi agreed.
Cao Zhi entered, trembling. He knelt and begged for forgiveness.
“Though we are brothers, we stand as lord and subject. How dare you rely on your talent and disrespect me?” Cao Pi said. “When our father lived, you always bragged about your writing. I suspect someone else wrote those works for you. Now, you must compose a poem within seven steps. If you can do it, your life will be spared. If not, you will face heavy punishment.”
“Give me a subject,” Cao Zhi said.
A painted scroll hung on the hall wall. It showed two bulls fighting beneath an earthen wall. One bull fell into a well and died.
Cao Pi pointed at the painting. “Use this scene as your theme. But your poem must not contain these exact words: Two bulls fight under a wall; one bull falls into a well and dies.”
Cao Zhi took seven steps. The poem was finished. Two beasts walk side by side, With bone horns on their heads. Beneath a mound they meet, And clash in bitter fights. Neither holds back their strength, One lies in earth’s dark cave. It is not lack of power, But rage spent to the end.
Cao Pi and all the officials were stunned.
Cao Pi spoke again. “A poem in seven steps is still too slow. Can you make one instantly?”
“Name your topic,” Cao Zhi replied.
“The subject shall be us, brothers. But you must not use the word brother in your poem.”
Cao Zhi did not pause for a second. He recited: Beans are boiled on bean-stalk fire; The beans weep in the pot. We grow from one same root, Why burn each other hot?
Tears rolled down Cao Pi’s face.
Queen Bian stepped out from behind the hall screen. “Older brother, why press your younger brother so hard?”
Cao Pi quickly stood up from his seat. “The law of the state cannot be set aside.”
He demoted Cao Zhi to Marquis of Anxiang.
After Cao Pi took the throne, he pressured the Han emperor even more harshly than Cao Cao had.
Word reached Chengdu. Liu Bei was shocked. He gathered his civil and military officials. “Cao Cao is dead. Cao Pi has taken his place and bullies the emperor worse than before. Sun Quan of Wu bows to him. I wish to attack Wu first, to avenge Guan Yu. Then I will march north to destroy the traitors.”
As soon as he finished speaking, Liao Hua stepped forward, knelt and wept. “Lord Guan and his son died because of Liu Feng and Meng Da. I beg you to execute those two men.”
Liu Bei prepared to send soldiers to capture them. Zhuge Liang stopped him. “Do not strike now. Move slowly, or trouble will break out. Promote them to governors first and separate them. Then we may arrest them.”
Liu Bei ordered Liu Feng to guard Mianzhu.
Peng Yang was close friends with Meng Da. When he heard the plan, he quickly wrote a letter and sent a messenger to warn Meng Da.
The messenger left through the south gate and was caught by Ma Chao’s patrol soldiers. Ma Chao learned the whole story and went to see Peng Yang.
Peng Yang welcomed him and poured wine. After a few cups, Ma Chao tested him. “The King of Hanzhong treated you well once. Why does he seem to grow cold toward you now?”
Peng Yang was drunk. He cursed angrily. “That old fool is foolish and confused. I will make him pay for this!”
Ma Chao probed further. “I too have long felt wronged.”
Peng Yang said, “Lead your troops to join Meng Da from outside. I will raise the Sichuan soldiers to help from within. Our great plan will succeed.”
Ma Chao answered, “Your words make sense. We will speak of this another day.”
After leaving, Ma Chao sent the messenger and the letter straight to Liu Bei and told him everything.
Liu Bei flew into a rage. He arrested Peng Yang and threw him in prison for questioning. Peng Yang regretted his words, but it was too late.
Liu Bei asked Zhuge Liang what to do. “Peng Yang is a reckless man. If we spare him, he will stir up disaster sooner or later.”
Liu Bei ordered Peng Yang to kill himself in prison.
News of Peng Yang’s death reached Meng Da. Meng Da was terrified. Soon the royal order arrived, transferring Liu Feng to Mianzhu.
Meng Da called Shen Dan and Shen Yi, two brothers, to consult. “Fa Zheng and I earned great merit for the King of Hanzhong. Fa Zheng is dead now. The king forgets my service and means to harm me. What can I do?”
Shen Dan said, “I have a plan to keep the King of Hanzhong from hurting you.”
Meng Da urged him to speak.
“My brother and I have long wished to surrender to Wei. Write a letter to the King of Hanzhong to resign your post, then submit to King Wei. Cao Pi will value you highly. We will follow and surrender after you.”
Meng Da understood. He wrote his resignation letter at once and sent a messenger with it. That night, he took more than fifty riders and fled to Wei.
The messenger brought Meng Da’s letter to Chengdu. Liu Bei read it and burned with anger.
In the letter, Meng Da wrote: I bow low before you, my lord. You are building the great achievements of Yi Yin and Lü Shang, striving for glory like Duke Huan of Qi and Duke Wen of Jin. Your kingdom is still new, and men of talent flock to your side. I have served you, yet my faults pile up like mountains. I know this well, as do you. Your court is full of wise heroes. I have no skill to advise you, nor talent to lead armies. Standing beside your meritorious ministers fills me with shame.
I have read how Fan Li knew when to leave and sailed away on the lake, and how Jiu Fan begged leave to retire by the river. To step back when the time comes is to know when to stay and when to go. I am humble, with no great deeds. I have long hoped to escape disgrace.
Prince Sheng was filial yet was doubted by his father. Wu Zixu was loyal yet killed by his lord. Meng Tian opened up new lands but suffered execution. Yue Yi defeated Qi yet was struck down by slander. Every time I read their stories, tears fall. Now I live through such sorrow myself.
After the fall of Jingzhou, almost none of its officials survived. Only I kept order in Fangling and Shangyong. I begged to be sent far away. I hoped your holiness would see my heart and pity me.
I am but a small man. I cannot stay loyal forever. I know I am guilty. I have heard that even when bonds break, there is no need for cruel words. I was taught by wise men. May you prosper, my lord. I tremble as I write this.
Liu Bei finished reading. He roared. “This villain betrays me, yet dares to mock me with fancy words!”
He wanted to raise troops to capture Meng Da. Zhuge Liang stopped him. “Send Liu Feng to attack Meng Da. Let these two tigers fight. Whether Liu Feng wins or loses, he will return to Chengdu. Then we can dispose of him. One move removes both threats.”
Liu Bei sent a messenger to Mianzhu with orders for Liu Feng.
Liu Feng led his army to hunt Meng Da.
Cao Pi was meeting his officials when word came that the Shu general Meng Da had surrendered. Cao Pi wondered if this was a trick. Meng Da explained that he had failed to save Guan Yu, and Liu Bei meant to kill him, so he fled in fear.
Cao Pi still doubted him. Then another report arrived: Liu Feng marched fifty thousand men toward Xiangfan, demanding to fight Meng Da.
Cao Pi said, “If your surrender is true, bring me Liu Feng’s head and I will believe you.”
Meng Da replied, “I can persuade him with words. No battle is needed. I will make Liu Feng surrender too.”
Cao Pi was delighted. He made Meng Da Palace Attendant, General Who Establishes Might, Marquis of Pingyangting, and Governor of Xincheng, tasked with defending Xiangyang and Fancheng. Xiahou Shang and Xu Huang were already in Xiangyang, ready to take control of Shangyong.
Meng Da traveled to Xiangyang. He learned Liu Feng had set up camp fifty li outside the city. He sent a letter to convince Liu Feng to surrender.
Liu Feng read the letter and exploded. “This traitor ruined the bond between uncle and nephew, and sowed strife between father and son. He would turn me into a man unfaithful to my lord and ungrateful to my father!”
He tore the letter to pieces and beheaded the messenger. The next morning, he led his army out to fight.
Meng Da saw Liu Feng destroy the letter and kill his messenger. Furious, he marched out to meet him.
The two armies lined up. Liu Feng pointed his sword and shouted. “Traitor to your lord! How dare you speak nonsense!”
Meng Da shouted back, “Death stands before you, yet you still refuse to see reason!”
Liu Feng rode forward, sword raised, and charged Meng Da. They fought less than three rounds before Meng Da fled. Liu Feng chased him more than twenty li.
Then war cries rang out. Hidden troops rushed forward. Xiahou Shang attacked from the left, Xu Huang from the right. Meng Da turned his horse and joined the fight. Attacked on three sides, Liu Feng’s army was crushed.
He fled through the night back to Shangyong. Wei soldiers chased close behind. Liu Feng reached the city gates and called to be let in. Arrows rained down from the walls. Shen Dan stood on the tower and shouted that he had surrendered to Wei.
Liu Feng raged and tried to storm the gate. But the Wei pursuers were closing in. He could not hold his ground. He ran toward Fangling.
The city walls flew Wei banners. Shen Yi waved a flag from the tower. Soldiers burst out from behind the city. Their standard read General of the Right Xu Huang.
Liu Feng could not resist. He fled west toward Sichuan. Only a hundred riders remained with him.
He reached Chengdu, went to Liu Bei, knelt and wept, telling the whole story.
Liu Bei shouted angrily. “You worthless son! How dare you show your face to me!”
Liu Feng pleaded. “I did not refuse to save Uncle Guan. Meng Da stopped me and talked me out of it.”
Liu Bei’s anger grew hotter. “You eat his food and wear his clothes. You are no wooden puppet. Why listen to that traitor’s lies?”
He ordered his men to drag Liu Feng out and execute him.
After Liu Feng died, Liu Bei heard how Meng Da had tried to persuade Liu Feng to surrender, and Liu Feng had torn the letter and killed the messenger. Liu Bei felt deep regret. He grieved endlessly for Guan Yu, fell ill, and halted all military plans.
Once firmly on the throne, Cao Pi rewarded his civil and military officers. He took three hundred thousand soldiers south to Peiguo Qiao County to offer sacrifices to his ancestors. The local elders lined the road, dust rising from their feet, bringing wine to honor him. He copied Emperor Gao of Han’s homecoming.
Then news came that Xiahou Dun was dying. Cao Pi hurried back to Ye. When he arrived, Xiahou Dun was already dead. Cao Pi wore mourning clothes and gave him a grand burial.
That eighth month, reports arrived. A phoenix appeared in Shiyi County. A unicorn was seen in Linzi. A yellow dragon emerged in Ye.
Li Fu, Palace Gentleman, and Xu Zhi, Grand Historian, discussed these omens. All these strange signs meant Wei would replace Han. They should arrange the throne abdication, so the Han emperor would yield his throne to Cao Pi.
Together with Hua Xin, Wang Lang, Xin Pi, Jia Xu, Liu Yi, Liu Ye, Chen Jiao, Chen Qun, Huan Jie, and more than forty other high officials, they marched straight into the inner palace. They petitioned Emperor Xian, demanding he hand over the empire to Cao Pi.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!