← The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes 2026 Edition
Chapter 5 · The Five Orange Seeds

The Five Orange Seeds

Chapter 5 of 12 · 5,940 words · Free

When I look back through my records of Sherlock Holmes’s cases from 1882 to 1890, I find far more strange and fascinating stories than I could ever hope to tell.

Some had already appeared in the newspapers. Others did not really show the particular talents Holmes possessed and which I have always tried to describe. A few cases even defeated his famous powers of deduction completely. Others were only partly solved, with their explanations resting on guesswork rather than the absolute proof Holmes valued above everything else.

There is one case, however, that was so strange and ended in such a shocking way that I cannot resist telling it, even though several details surrounding it were never completely explained and probably never will be.

The year 1887 gave us a remarkable number of cases.

Among my notes are the strange affair of the Paradol Chamber, the Amateur Mendicant Society and its luxurious club hidden beneath a furniture warehouse, the disappearance of the British ship Sophy Anderson, the bizarre adventures of the Grice Paterson family on the island of Uffa, and finally the Camberwell poisoning.

I may tell those stories someday.

But none of them compares with the extraordinary chain of events I am about to describe.

It was late September, and the autumn storms had arrived with unusual violence.

All day long, the wind had screamed around London while rain hammered against the windows. Even in the middle of that enormous city, we were forced to remember that nature still possessed powers far greater than anything mankind had built.

By evening, the storm had become even worse.

The wind howled and sobbed down the chimney like a frightened child.

Sherlock Holmes sat beside the fireplace, looking gloomy as he sorted through his collection of criminal records.

I sat opposite him, completely absorbed in one of Clark Russell’s excellent sea stories. The storm outside seemed to blend with the book. The wind sounded like the roar of the ocean, and the rain against the windows became the endless crash of waves.

My wife was visiting her mother, so for a few days I had returned to my old rooms at Baker Street.

I looked up from my book.

“Holmes, that must have been the doorbell. Who could possibly be calling on a night like this? One of your friends, perhaps?”

“Except for you, I have no friends,” he replied. “I discourage visitors.”

“Then perhaps it is a client?”

“If it is, the case must be serious. No ordinary person would come out in weather like this at such an hour. More likely it is one of our landlady’s acquaintances.”

Holmes was wrong.

A moment later we heard footsteps in the hallway, followed by a knock at the door.

Holmes stretched out his long arm and turned the lamp so that its light fell on the empty chair beside the fire.

“Come in!”

The door opened.

A young man entered. He could not have been more than twenty-two. He was neatly dressed and had a refined, almost delicate appearance.

His umbrella was dripping wet, and his long waterproof coat shone with rain. He looked around anxiously under the bright lamp.

His face was pale, and his tired eyes showed the weight of some terrible worry.

“I owe you an apology,” he said, lifting a pair of gold-rimmed glasses to his eyes. “I hope I’m not disturbing you. I’m afraid I’ve brought half the storm in with me.”

“Give me your coat and umbrella,” Holmes said. “Hang them there. They’ll dry soon.”

He studied the young man for a moment.

“You came from the southwest.”

“Yes. From Horsham.”

“I can see that from the mixture of clay and chalk on your boots. It is quite distinctive.”

The young man stared at him.

“I have come for advice.”

“That is easy enough to give.”

“And for help.”

“That is not always so easy.”

“I have heard of you, Mr. Holmes. Major Prendergast told me how you saved him during the Tankerville Club scandal.”

“Ah, yes. He was falsely accused of cheating at cards.”

“He told me you could solve anything.”

“He exaggerated.”

“He said you had never been defeated.”

“I have been defeated four times. Three times by men and once by a woman.”

“But that is nothing compared with all your successes.”

“It is true that I have generally been successful.”

“Then perhaps you can help me.”

Holmes pointed toward the chair.

“Sit by the fire and tell me what has happened.”

“It is not an ordinary case.”

“None of my cases are ordinary. I am usually the last person people turn to.”

The young man pulled his chair closer to the flames.

“And yet, sir, I doubt whether you have ever heard a more mysterious and frightening series of events than those that have happened to my family.”

Holmes leaned forward.

“You have certainly made me curious. Start at the beginning and tell me the essential facts. I will stop you whenever I need more details.”

The young man stretched his wet shoes toward the fire.

“My name is John Openshaw.”

He paused.

“My own actions have very little to do with what has happened. It is a family matter. To explain it, I have to go back many years.”

“My grandfather had two sons—my uncle Elias and my father Joseph.”

“My father owned a small factory in Coventry. When bicycles became popular, he expanded the business. He patented the Openshaw Unbreakable Tire, and the company became very successful. Eventually he sold the business and retired with a considerable fortune.”

“My uncle Elias went to America when he was a young man. He became a plantation owner in Florida and apparently did very well.”

“During the American Civil War, he fought in General Jackson’s army and later served under General Hood. He eventually became a colonel.”

“When General Lee surrendered, my uncle returned to his plantation and remained there for several years.”

“Then, around 1869 or 1870, he came back to Europe and bought a small estate near Horsham in Sussex.”

“He had made a large fortune in America. He left because he hated the Black population and strongly opposed the Republican government’s efforts to give Black people the vote.”

“He was an extremely strange man.”

“He had a violent temper, swore terribly when he was angry, and wanted absolutely nothing to do with other people.”

“During all the years he lived near Horsham, I doubt he ever went into the town.”

“He had a garden and a few fields around his house, and that was usually enough for him. Sometimes he would stay inside his room for weeks without going outside at all.”

“He drank heavily and smoked constantly.”

“He had no friends and wanted none. He barely even tolerated his own brother.”

“But he liked me.”

“When he first saw me, I was about twelve years old. That was in 1878, after he had already been living in England for eight or nine years.”

“He asked my father to let me live with him.”

“In his own rough way, he was very kind to me.”

“When he was sober, he enjoyed playing backgammon and draughts with me. He also made me deal with the servants and tradesmen on his behalf.”

“By the time I was sixteen, I practically ran the house.”

“I had all the keys. I could go wherever I wanted and do almost anything I liked, provided I never disturbed my uncle.”

“There was only one exception.”

“There was a small storage room in the attic that was always locked.”

“He never allowed me or anyone else to enter.”

“Of course, I was curious. I sometimes looked through the keyhole, but all I could see were old trunks, boxes, and bundles.”

“Then, one morning in March 1883, something happened.”

“A letter with a foreign stamp was lying beside my uncle’s breakfast plate.”

“It was unusual for him to receive letters. He paid all his bills in cash and had no friends.”

“He picked up the envelope.”

‘From India!’

“He stared at the postmark.”

‘Pondicherry. What could this be?’

“He opened it quickly.”

“Five small, dried orange seeds fell onto his plate.”

“I laughed.”

“But the laughter died instantly when I saw his face.”

“His mouth had fallen open. His eyes were bulging. His skin had turned the color of clay.”

“He stared at the envelope in his trembling hand.”

‘K. K. K.!’

“He suddenly cried out.”

‘My God! My God! My sins have finally caught up with me!’

‘What is it, Uncle?’ I asked.

‘Death.’

“He stood up and hurried to his room.”

“I remained at the table, trembling.”

“I picked up the envelope.”

“On the inside flap, just above the gum, someone had written three red K’s.”

“K. K. K.”

“There was nothing else except the five dried orange seeds.”

“I had no idea what it meant.”

“I left the breakfast table.”

“As I went upstairs, I met my uncle coming down.”

“He was carrying an old rusty key in one hand and a small brass box in the other.”

“The key looked as though it belonged to the locked attic room.”

‘They can do whatever they like,’ he muttered angrily. ‘But I’ll beat them yet.’

“Then he turned to me.”

‘Tell Mary to light a fire in my room today. And send for Mr. Fordham, the lawyer in Horsham.’

“I did exactly as he ordered.”

“When the lawyer arrived, my uncle called me upstairs.”

“The fire was burning brightly.”

“There was a pile of black, fluffy ashes in the grate, obviously the remains of burned papers.”

“The brass box was open and empty beside the fireplace.”

“I looked at it and suddenly noticed something that made me uneasy.”

“The three K’s were printed on the lid.”

‘John,’ my uncle said, ‘I want you to witness my will.’

‘You will inherit this estate through your father. I am leaving everything to him, and eventually it will pass to you.’

‘If you can live here peacefully, then fine.’

‘But if you cannot, take my advice, my boy.’

‘Give it to your worst enemy and walk away.’

‘I am sorry to leave you such a dangerous inheritance. I have no idea how things will turn out.’

‘Now sign here where Mr. Fordham indicates.’

“I signed the document.”

“The lawyer took it away.”

“The whole incident stayed in my mind.”

“I thought about it again and again, but I could find no explanation.”

“Still, I could not shake the feeling that something terrible was coming.”

“Over the following weeks, however, nothing happened.”

“Gradually, the fear began to fade.”

“But my uncle changed.”

“He drank more than ever and became even more isolated.”

“He spent most of his time alone in his locked room.”

“Sometimes, however, he would suddenly burst outside in a drunken rage.”

“He would run around the garden with a revolver in his hand.”

‘No man can frighten me!’

‘No devil can lock me up like an animal!’

“Then, when the fit passed, he would rush back into the house.”

“He would slam and bolt the door behind him as though something terrifying were waiting outside.”

“I could see the fear in his face.”

“Even on cold days, sweat would cover his skin.”

“Eventually, the end came.”

“One night he went outside in another drunken rage.”

“He never came back.”

“We searched the grounds.”

“We found him lying face down in a small pool covered with green scum.”

“There were no signs of violence.”

“The water was barely two feet deep.”

“The jury knew about his strange behavior, so they concluded that he had committed suicide.”

“But I knew my uncle.”

“He was terrified of death.”

“I could hardly believe that he had deliberately gone out to die.”

“Still, the matter was closed.”

“My father inherited the estate, along with about fourteen thousand pounds in the bank.”

Holmes interrupted.

“Wait a moment. Your story is already one of the strangest I have ever heard.”

“When exactly did your uncle receive the letter?”

“And when did he supposedly commit suicide?”

“The letter arrived on March 10, 1883.”

“He died seven weeks later, on the night of May 2.”

“Thank you. Continue.”

“When my father took possession of the house at Horsham, he searched the attic at my request.”

“The room had always been locked.”

“We found the brass box there, although everything inside it had been destroyed.”

“Inside the lid was a paper label.”

“It had K. K. K. written on it.”

“Underneath were the words: ‘Letters, memoranda, receipts, and a register.’”

“We assumed those were the papers my uncle had burned.”

“Other than that, there was nothing especially important in the attic.”

“There were many old papers and notebooks about my uncle’s life in America.”

“Some were from the Civil War and showed that he had served bravely.”

“Others were from the period after the war, when the Southern states were being rebuilt.”

“They were mostly political.”

“My uncle had strongly opposed the politicians from the North who had come south during Reconstruction.”

“My father moved to Horsham at the beginning of 1884.”

“For a while, everything was peaceful.”

“Then, in January 1885, everything changed.”

“Four days after New Year’s Day, my father and I were having breakfast.”

“Suddenly he gave a sharp cry.”

“He was holding a newly opened envelope in one hand.”

“In the other was a palm containing five dried orange seeds.”

“My father had always laughed at what he called my ridiculous story about the colonel.”

“But now he looked terrified.”

‘John, what on earth does this mean?’

“My heart sank.”

‘It is K. K. K.’

“He looked inside the envelope.”

‘Yes. There are the letters.’

“Then he read the message written above them.”

‘Put the papers on the sundial.’

‘What papers? What sundial?’ he asked.

‘The sundial in the garden. There is only one.’

‘But those papers must be the ones Uncle Elias destroyed.’

‘Nonsense,’ my father said, forcing himself to laugh. ‘We are living in a civilized country. This is ridiculous. Where did the letter come from?’

“Dundee.”

“He looked at the postmark.”

‘Some stupid practical joke. What do I have to do with sundials and old papers? I am going to ignore it.’

‘I think you should tell the police.’

‘And let them laugh at me? Absolutely not.’

‘Then let me tell them.’

‘No. I forbid it. I will not have a fuss over this nonsense.’

“There was no point arguing.”

“But I could not shake the feeling that something terrible was about to happen.”

“Three days after the letter arrived, my father went away to visit an old friend, Major Freebody.”

“The major commanded one of the forts on Portsdown Hill.”

“I was actually relieved that my father had left home.”

“I thought he would be safer away from the house.”

“I was wrong.”

“On the second day of his absence, I received a telegram from Major Freebody.”

“He begged me to come immediately.”

“My father had fallen into one of the deep chalk pits in the area.”

“His skull had been badly fractured.”

“I hurried there.”

“But he died without ever regaining consciousness.”

“He had apparently been returning from Fareham at dusk.”

“He did not know the countryside well.”

“The chalk pit had no fence around it.”

“The jury therefore had no hesitation in calling it an accidental death.”

“I investigated everything as carefully as I could.”

“There were no signs of violence.”

“No footprints.”

“Nothing had been stolen.”

“No strangers had been seen on the roads.”

“Yet I could not convince myself that it had been an accident.”

“I was almost certain that someone had arranged it.”

“And so I inherited the estate.”

“You may wonder why I did not simply sell it.”

“The reason is simple.”

“I believed that our troubles were connected to something my uncle had done in America.”

“If that was true, moving to another house would not save me.”

“My father died in January 1885.”

“Two years and eight months passed.”

“During that time, I lived peacefully at Horsham.”

“I began to believe that the curse had finally ended with my father.”

“I was wrong.”

“Yesterday morning, the same thing happened to me.”

“The young man reached into his waistcoat.”

“He pulled out a crumpled envelope.”

“Then he turned toward the table and shook five small dried orange seeds onto it.”

“This is the envelope,” he said.

“The postmark is London—East London.”

“Inside are exactly the same words that appeared in my father’s letter.”

‘K. K. K.’

“And then—‘Put the papers on the sundial.’”

Holmes stared at him.

“What have you done?”

“Nothing.”

“Nothing?”

“To be honest…”

“John lowered his face into his thin, white hands.”

“I have felt helpless.”

“I feel like a rabbit watching a snake move toward it.”

“It seems as if I am trapped by some unstoppable evil.”

“No matter what I do, I cannot protect myself.”

Holmes suddenly leaned forward.

“Tut, tut! You must act, man, or you are finished.”

“Only action can save you.”

“This is no time to give in to despair.”

“I have already gone to the police.”

“Ah.”

“They listened to my story and smiled.”

“I am convinced the inspector thinks these letters are practical jokes.”

“He believes my uncle and father really died in accidents and that the warnings have nothing to do with their deaths.”

Holmes clenched his fists.

“Incredible stupidity!”

“They have given me a policeman, though.”

“He is supposed to stay at my house with me.”

“Did he come to London with you tonight?”

“No.”

“He was ordered to remain at the house.”

Holmes threw up his hands.

“Why did you come to me?”

“And why did you wait so long?”

“I did not know where else to turn.”

“I only spoke to Major Prendergast today.”

“He told me I should come to you.”

“It has already been two days since you received the letter.”

“We should have acted immediately.”

“Do you have anything else that might help us?”

“Any detail at all?”

“There is one thing.”

John searched through his coat pocket.

“He pulled out a faded sheet of blue paper and placed it on the table.”

“I remember that when my uncle burned the papers, I noticed that the small pieces left among the ashes were this same color.”

“I found this one sheet on the floor of his room.”

“I think it may have escaped from the fire.”

“Other than the mention of the seeds, I cannot see how it helps us.”

“I believe it was part of a private diary.”

“The handwriting is definitely my uncle’s.”

Holmes moved the lamp closer.

“We both leaned over the sheet.”

“Its torn edge showed that it had been ripped from a notebook.”

“At the top were the words: ‘March, 1869.’”

“Underneath were several strange entries.”

“March 4. Hudson came. Same old platform.”

“March 7. Sent the seeds to McCauley, Paramore, and John Swain of St. Augustine.”

“March 9. McCauley cleared.”

“March 10. John Swain cleared.”

“March 12. Visited Paramore. All well.”

Holmes folded the paper and handed it back.

“Thank you.”

“Now you must leave immediately.”

“We do not have another minute to waste.”

“What should I do?”

“There is only one thing.”

“You must put that sheet of paper into the brass box you told me about.”

“Then add a note explaining that all the other papers were burned by your uncle and that this is the only one left.”

“Write it clearly and convincingly.”

“Then put the box on the sundial, exactly as the letter demanded.”

“Do you understand?”

“Completely.”

“Do not think about revenge yet.”

“I believe the law may take care of that later.”

“We have a web to build.”

“Their web is already complete.”

“First, we must remove the immediate danger.”

“After that, we will uncover the truth and bring the guilty people to justice.”

“Thank you.”

“John stood and put on his coat.”

“You have given me hope again.”

“I will do exactly what you said.”

“Do not waste another second.”

“And be extremely careful on your way home.”

“I am convinced that your life is in immediate danger.”

“How will you travel?”

“By train from Waterloo.”

“It is not yet nine o’clock.”

“The streets should still be crowded.”

“I hope you will be safe.”

“But you cannot be too careful.”

“I am armed.”

“Good.”

“Tomorrow I will begin investigating your case.”

“I shall see you at Horsham, then?”

“No.”

“Your secret is in London.”

“That is where I will search for the answer.”

“Then I will return in a day or two with news about the box and the papers.”

“I will follow your instructions exactly.”

“He shook hands with us and left.”

“Outside, the wind still screamed and the rain continued to hammer against the windows.”

“The story he had brought us seemed to have blown into our room from the storm itself, like a piece of seaweed carried by a violent wave.”

“And now the storm had swallowed it again.”

Holmes sat silently for several minutes.

His head was lowered, and his eyes were fixed on the glowing fire.

At last he lit his pipe and leaned back.

He watched the blue smoke curl slowly toward the ceiling.

“Watson,” he said, “I think this may be the strangest case we have ever had.”

“Perhaps, except for the Sign of Four.”

“Yes. Perhaps that one.”

“And yet John Openshaw seems to be in even greater danger than the Sholto brothers were.”

“But have you worked out exactly what kind of danger he is facing?”

“There can be no doubt about its nature.”

“Then what is it?”

“Who are K. K. K.?”

“And why are they hunting this unfortunate family?”

Holmes closed his eyes and rested his elbows on the arms of his chair.

He pressed his fingertips together.

“The perfect reasoner,” he said, “should be able to see an entire chain of events from a single fact.”

“Just as the scientist Cuvier could reconstruct an entire animal from a single bone.”

“If we completely understand one link in a chain, we should be able to work out what came before it and what will follow.”

“We have not yet learned to use reason to its full potential.”

“A clever man can solve problems in his study that others cannot solve through observation alone.”

“But there is a condition.”

“To reason perfectly, you must know every fact that might be useful.”

“That means possessing an enormous amount of knowledge.”

“Fortunately, a man does not need to know everything.”

“He only needs to know everything that may be useful in his particular work.”

“I have always tried to do that.”

“If I remember correctly, you once made a very detailed list of what I knew and did not know.”

I laughed.

“Yes.”

“It was certainly an unusual list.”

“Philosophy: zero.”

“Astronomy: zero.”

“Politics: zero.”

“Botany: uncertain.”

“Geology: excellent when it came to identifying mud within fifty miles of London.”

“Chemistry: eccentric.”

“Anatomy: unreliable.”

“Sensational literature and crime records: exceptional.”

“Then you listed me as a violinist, boxer, swordsman, lawyer, and expert in poisoning myself with cocaine and tobacco.”

Holmes grinned.

“I still stand by the principle.”

“A man should fill the little attic of his mind with the information he is likely to use.”

“Everything else can stay in the library until he needs it.”

“And for a case like this, we need every useful fact we can find.”

“Please hand me the volume of the American Encyclopedia under the letter K.”

I passed it to him.

“Thank you.”

“Now let us see what we can deduce.”

“First, Colonel Openshaw must have had an extremely strong reason for leaving America.”

“A man of his age would not willingly abandon Florida, with its warm climate, for a lonely life in the English countryside.”

“His extreme desire for isolation suggests that he was afraid of someone or something.”

“So our first assumption must be that fear drove him out of America.”

“As for what he feared, we can examine the letters sent to him and to the members of his family.”

“Did you notice the postmarks?”

“The first came from Pondicherry.”

“The second came from Dundee.”

“The third came from London.”

“East London.”

“What does that tell you?”

“They are all ports.”

“So the writer was probably on a ship.”

“Excellent.”

“That gives us our first clue.”

“The strongest possibility is that the person sending the warnings was traveling by sea.”

“Now consider something else.”

“The Pondicherry letter was followed by the death seven weeks later.”

“The Dundee letter was followed by the death only three or four days later.”

“What does that suggest?”

“The greater distance required more time to travel.”

“But the letter also had farther to travel.”

“Then I do not understand.”

“There is another possibility.”

“The people carrying out the threats may have been traveling in a sailing ship.”

“They apparently sent the warning before beginning their journey.”

“That would explain the timing.”

“The Dundee letter was followed by the attack almost immediately.”

“If they had traveled from Dundee by steamship, they would have arrived almost as quickly as the letter.”

“But seven weeks passed after the Pondicherry warning.”

“I believe those seven weeks represent the difference between the fast mail ship carrying the letter and the slower sailing ship carrying the killers.”

“That is possible.”

“More than possible.”

“I think it is very likely.”

“And now you can understand why John Openshaw is in such terrible danger.”

“The previous attacks happened after roughly the amount of time needed for the people behind them to travel from the place where the warning was sent.”

“But this latest letter came from London.”

“So there is no delay at all.”

“My God,” I cried. “What does this mean?”

“It means they want the papers Openshaw inherited from his uncle.”

“Those papers must be extremely important to them.”

“And I doubt there is only one person involved.”

“One man could not have carried out two murders so cleverly that the authorities believed both were accidents.”

“There must have been several people.”

“They must be organized, determined, and resourceful.”

“They are willing to kill anyone who possesses those papers.”

“So K. K. K. is probably not the name of one man.”

“It is the mark of a group.”

“But what group?”

Holmes leaned toward me and lowered his voice.

“Have you never heard of the Ku Klux Klan?”

“I never have.”

Holmes turned through the encyclopedia.

“Here it is.”

He read the entry.

“The Ku Klux Klan was a secret society formed by former Confederate soldiers in the Southern states after the Civil War.”

“It quickly established branches in several states, including Tennessee, Louisiana, the Carolinas, Georgia, and Florida.”

“It was used for political purposes, especially to terrorize Black voters and attack or drive away people who opposed its beliefs.”

“The group often warned its targets before attacking them.”

“The warning took different forms in different regions.”

“In some places, it was a branch of oak leaves.”

“In others, it was melon seeds or orange seeds.”

“Once the warning arrived, the victim had a choice.”

“He could abandon his political position and submit, or he could leave the country.”

“If he refused, the result was usually death.”

“The killings were often carried out in strange and unexpected ways.”

“The organization was so secret and so well organized that very few of its crimes were ever traced back to the people responsible.”

“The group continued operating despite attempts by the American government and respectable members of Southern society to destroy it.”

“Then, around 1869, the organization suddenly collapsed.”

“Although isolated incidents continued afterward.”

Holmes closed the book.

“You see the significance.”

“The collapse of the organization happened at almost exactly the same time Colonel Openshaw disappeared from America with his papers.”

“It may not have been a coincidence.”

“The disappearance of those records may have caused the organization serious trouble.”

“And now its surviving members may still be hunting the people who possess them.”

“You can understand why they would never rest until those papers were recovered.”

“Then the diary page we found…”

“Fits perfectly.”

“It probably recorded warnings being sent to several people.”

“One person escaped.”

“Another left the country.”

“And the third was visited.”

“I fear the last one did not survive.”

Holmes stood.

“I think we have finally brought some light into this dark mystery.”

“For now, John Openshaw’s only chance is to follow my instructions exactly.”

“There is nothing more we can do tonight.”

“Hand me my violin, Watson.”

“Let us forget for half an hour about this miserable storm and the even more miserable behavior of mankind.”

The next morning was clear.

The storm had passed, and a weak sunlight shone through the gray haze covering London.

Holmes was already at breakfast when I came downstairs.

“You will forgive me for not waiting,” he said. “I expect to have a very busy day investigating young Openshaw’s case.”

“What are you going to do?”

“That depends on what I discover during my first inquiries.”

“I may eventually have to go to Horsham.”

“You are not going there first?”

“No.”

“I will begin in the City.”

“Ring the bell. The maid will bring your coffee.”

While I waited, I picked up the newspaper from the table.

I had barely opened it when a headline caught my eye.

A chill ran through me.

“Holmes!”

He looked up.

“You are too late.”

He slowly put down his cup.

“I was afraid of that.”

“How did it happen?”

“My eyes went straight to the name Openshaw.”

“The headline reads: ‘Tragedy Near Waterloo Bridge.’”

I read the report aloud.

“Between nine and ten last night, Police-Constable Cook of the H Division was on duty near Waterloo Bridge when he heard a cry for help followed by a splash.”

“The night was extremely dark and stormy.”

“Despite the efforts of several people nearby, no rescue was possible.”

“The water police eventually recovered the body.”

“It was identified as a young gentleman named John Openshaw, whose address was near Horsham.”

“An envelope found in his pocket provided his name.”

“It is believed that he was hurrying to catch the last train from Waterloo.”

“Because of the darkness, he apparently lost his way and fell from one of the small river landing stages.”

“There were no signs of violence.”

“The authorities therefore believe that the young man died in an unfortunate accident.”

“The report also suggested that the condition of the riverside landing stages should be investigated.”

We sat in silence.

For several minutes, neither of us spoke.

I had never seen Holmes so depressed.

At last he spoke.

“This hurts my pride, Watson.”

“It is a petty feeling, I know.”

“But it hurts.”

“This has become personal.”

“If I remain healthy, I will find these men.”

“He came to me for help.”

“And I sent him away to his death.”

Holmes suddenly sprang to his feet.

He paced back and forth across the room.

His pale face had turned red, and his long fingers opened and closed nervously.

“They must be extremely clever.”

“How did they lure him there?”

“The Embankment is not on the direct route to the station.”

“And on such a night, Waterloo Bridge would have been too crowded for them to act there.”

He stopped.

“Very well, Watson.”

“We will see who wins in the end.”

“I am going out.”

“To the police?”

“No.”

“I will be my own police.”

“Once I have spun the web, they can catch the flies.”

“But not before.”

I spent the entire day attending to my medical work.

It was late in the evening when I finally returned to Baker Street.

Holmes had not yet returned.

Nearly ten o’clock passed before he came through the door.

He looked pale and exhausted.

He went straight to the sideboard, tore off a piece of bread, and devoured it.

Then he drank a large glass of water.

“You are hungry,” I said.

“Starving.”

“I completely forgot about food.”

“I have had nothing since breakfast.”

“Nothing?”

“Not a bite.”

“I had no time to think about it.”

“How did you do?”

“Very well.”

“You found a clue?”

“I have the whole thing in the palm of my hand.”

“John Openshaw will not remain unavenged.”

Holmes suddenly smiled.

“Watson, let us send them their own trademark.”

“That is a brilliant idea.”

“What do you mean?”

He went to the cupboard and took out an orange.

He tore it apart and shook the seeds onto the table.

He selected five.

Then he put them inside an envelope.

On the inside of the flap he wrote:

“S. H. for J. O.”

He sealed the envelope.

Then he addressed it to:

“Captain James Calhoun, Barque Lone Star, Savannah, Georgia.”

“That letter will be waiting for him when he reaches port,” Holmes said with a grim smile.

“It may give him a sleepless night.”

“He will understand it as clearly as Openshaw did.”

“Who is Captain Calhoun?”

“The leader of the gang.”

“I will find the others too.”

“But I want him first.”

“How did you find him?”

Holmes pulled a large sheet of paper from his pocket.

It was covered with dates and names.

“I spent the entire day studying Lloyd’s shipping registers and old newspaper files.”

“I traced the movements of every ship that stopped at Pondicherry during January and February of 1883.”

“There were thirty-six ships of suitable size reported there during those two months.”

“One immediately caught my attention.”

“The Lone Star.”

“Why?”

“Although it was listed as having sailed from London, its name is associated with one of the American states.”

“Texas, I believe.”

“I was not completely certain.”

“But I knew the ship had some connection with America.”

“What happened next?”

“I searched the records in Dundee.”

“When I discovered that the Lone Star had been there in January 1885, my suspicion became almost certain.”

“Then I checked which ships were currently in the Port of London.”

“And?”

“The Lone Star arrived here last week.”

“I went down to Albert Dock.”

“She had already sailed down the river on the morning tide.”

“She was heading home to Savannah.”

“I sent a message to Gravesend.”

“They told me she had already passed.”

“The wind is blowing from the east, so I believe she has already passed the Goodwin Sands and is somewhere near the Isle of Wight.”

“What will you do now?”

“I already have them.”

“He and the two mates are, according to what I learned, the only native-born Americans aboard.”

“The rest of the crew are Finns and Germans.”

“I also discovered that all three men were away from the ship last night.”

“I learned that from one of the stevedores loading their cargo.”

“By the time the sailing ship reaches Savannah, the mail ship will have delivered my letter.”

“And the police in Savannah will have received a cable telling them that these three men are wanted here for murder.”

But even the best human plans can fail.

The men who killed John Openshaw never received the five orange seeds that were meant to warn them that someone just as clever and determined was now hunting them.

That year, the autumn storms were exceptionally long and violent.

We waited for news of the Lone Star of Savannah.

Nothing came.

Eventually, however, we heard one final report.

Somewhere deep in the Atlantic, sailors had seen part of a shattered stern-post floating in the waves.

The letters “L. S.” were carved into the wood.

That was all.

And that is all we will ever know about the fate of the Lone Star.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!