← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 10 · The National Banks

The National Banks

Chapter 10 of 90 · 1,261 words · Free

After the government had managed to secure enough temporary loans to ease the immediate financial pressure, Secretary Chase turned to a much bigger problem: how to create a reliable national currency without throwing the country’s business system into chaos.

One of the men who played an important role in this debate was E. G. Spaulding. He later recorded the history of the legislation and the heated congressional debates that led to the creation of the national banking system.

The financial situation was already difficult. The suspension of specie payments had made matters worse, and the arrest of Mason and Slidell had brought the country dangerously close to a conflict with Great Britain. Only Seward’s careful diplomacy prevented that crisis from becoming a war.

In early 1862, Congress authorized another $10 million in government demand notes. More issues followed, eventually bringing the total to $300 million.

At first, Chase opposed making these notes legal tender for private debts.

But the government desperately needed money.

So Chase finally accepted the legal-tender provision in order to get the legislation passed.

Congress also authorized him to borrow $500 million through six-percent bonds redeemable in five to twenty years. He was given another $100 million in temporary borrowing authority, provided that the interest on the bonds would be paid in coin and that customs duties would be collected in coin for that purpose.

The first serious attempt to establish a national currency backed by United States bonds came in July 1862.

Representative Hooper introduced a bill that would create such a system.

But the bill never made it out of committee.

By December, the financial situation had become far more serious.

The war had grown enormously, and the government was spending about $2 million every day.

For the fiscal year ending June 30, 1863, the government collected about $511 million but spent approximately $788 million.

That left a deficit of $277 million.

Chase now faced a critical choice.

Should the government print another $277 million in United States notes?

Or should it borrow the money through interest-bearing bonds?

Chase strongly opposed simply printing more money.

He warned that expanding the currency would push prices higher, increase government expenses, enlarge the national debt, and eventually undermine the very war effort the policy was supposed to support.

Instead, he wanted Congress to increase the amount the government could borrow through the five-to-twenty-year bonds.

He also proposed creating national banking associations whose banknotes would be backed by deposits of United States bonds.

This plan had another important advantage.

It would create a large and dependable market for government bonds.

Congress, however, was not ready to accept the proposal.

Hooper introduced his banking bill again the following January, but the Ways and Means Committee rejected it.

Then the financial demands of the war became impossible to ignore.

Representative Thaddeus Stevens of Pennsylvania proposed another $100 million issue of United States notes.

Congress approved it.

President Lincoln signed the measure, but he did so reluctantly.

He sent a special message to the House explaining that he regretted having to add another large amount of paper money to the currency while the suspended banks were still free to expand their own circulation.

Soon afterward, Senator John Sherman introduced another bill to establish a national currency.

His proposal was based largely on the earlier ideas in Hooper’s bill.

Congress passed the Sherman bill before the end of February 1863.

That legislation effectively laid the foundation for the national banking system that followed.

To understand why the National Bank Act was so important, we also have to look at the battle between the federal government and the existing state banks.

In January 1862, the state banks offered to let the Treasury accept their own notes in payment for government bonds.

Chase refused.

He believed accepting the banks’ paper would encourage an even greater expansion of the currency.

But the amount of banknotes in circulation continued to grow anyway, rising from about $130 million to $167 million.

E. G. Spaulding became one of the strongest supporters of the National Bank Act.

He argued that the country needed a permanent and more dependable banking currency.

Not everyone agreed.

Roscoe Conkling strongly opposed the plan.

He argued that the government should not destroy the roughly 1,200 state banks operating in the free states.

He made an emotional appeal on behalf of the widows and orphans who owned stock in those banks.

Conkling proposed another solution.

He wanted the government to issue $260 million in seven-percent bonds, payable in thirty-one years, and exchange them for the notes of the suspended banks in New York, Philadelphia, and Boston.

He also proposed issuing $200 million in United States notes that would be payable in coin within one year.

Representative Bingham of Ohio attacked Conkling’s proposal.

He warned that it would leave the national currency at the mercy of powerful city bankers and brokers.

Other members of Congress also defended the state banking system.

Conkling continued to fight the National Bank Act because he believed it was designed to drive state banks out of existence by taxing them heavily.

Spaulding defended the national banking plan.

Fenton followed with a strong argument that currency backed by United States bonds would be safer and more reliable.

Senator Sherman added another powerful argument.

State banknotes were being counterfeited on a large scale.

The more successful counterfeiters became, the weaker public confidence in state bank currency became.

These arguments ultimately proved persuasive.

Congress passed the National Bank Act.

It is important to give New York credit for one of the foundations of the new system.

The National Bank Act was largely based on New York State’s banking law.

That system required banks to back their currency with public securities and made directors and stockholders personally responsible for the bank’s obligations.

The basic idea was attributed to Mr. Stillman, who was also known for the law that ended imprisonment for debt.

The new national banking law was driven above all by Secretary Salmon P. Chase.

Its effect on the nation’s credit was remarkable.

Almost immediately, it created a huge new market for United States government bonds.

The bonds rose from about 93 cents on the dollar to par.

Within roughly two months, the government was able to pay its rapidly mounting expenses through the sale of the five-to-twenty bonds.

The Treasury later declared that the Bank Act had immediately restored confidence in government securities and, more than anything else, had enabled Chase to pay soldiers and other government creditors on time.

The system was not perfect, however.

Hugh McCulloch, the Comptroller of the Currency, believed that several parts of the law needed improvement.

Congress made some of those changes in 1864.

The revised provisions became part of the Act of June 1864.

The new legislation faced strong opposition, especially over the question of whether states should be allowed to tax national banks.

Chase strongly opposed such taxation.

But Congress ultimately approved the taxation provision.

The final law also placed a limit of $400 million on the total amount of United States notes that could be issued.

An additional $50 million could be issued temporarily when needed to redeem the government’s temporary loans.

With those changes, the main structure of the national banking system became law.

The system served the country well for many years.

But I do not believe it will last forever.

As the national debt is gradually paid off, the very foundation on which the present system rests will begin to disappear.

I therefore expect a better banking system to replace it in time.

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!