The New York Stock Exchange
The New York Stock Exchange was not originally a grand building. It began in 1792 as a small group of brokers who agreed to follow the same rules when buying and selling stocks and bonds.
The agreement was made under a buttonwood tree near what is now 60 Wall Street.
The brokers promised one another that they would charge at least one-quarter of one percent commission and give fellow members preference in their business. That simple agreement became the foundation of what would eventually grow into one of the most powerful financial institutions in the world.
In America, the word “stock” could mean either shares in a corporation or government debt. In England, however, government obligations were called stocks, while ownership in companies was generally called shares.
For many years, the Exchange had no legal charter and did not want one. Its members believed they could manage their own affairs without government interference.
The Tweed Ring once tried to force a charter on the Exchange.
The plan was pushed through the New York Legislature in 1871, and the governor even signed it.
But the Exchange refused to accept it.
The politicians demanded $100,000 for their “services,” but the members rejected both the charter and the demand.
By the late nineteenth century, membership had become highly valuable. For many years the Exchange had limited its membership to 1,100 people. Later, that number was increased to 1,200.
A seat on the Exchange was no ordinary privilege. In the year before this account was written, seats were selling for between $25,000 and $30,000.
The Exchange building itself was impressive without being flashy.
It was designed by James Renwick, the architect who had also designed Grace Church and St. Patrick’s Cathedral on Fifth Avenue.
The building cost nearly $2 million.
Keeping it running was expensive as well. Nearly $200,000 a year was required to pay its officials and maintain the property.
The building had an advanced ventilation system that cost about $30,000. It supplied fresh air throughout the trading floor while also keeping the atmosphere pleasant.
Its heating and cooling systems were considered among the best available.
Three large chandeliers held 200 electric lamps, filling the interior with a soft, even light.
There were also rooms for members, lavatories, closets, and enormous vaults containing more than a thousand safes for valuable securities.
About 400 of those safes were rented to people who were not members.
The vaults were regarded as among the strongest in the country.
Yet the grandeur of the building made the Exchange's humble beginning seem almost unbelievable.
Back in 1792, there was no great financial palace.
There was only a group of brokers standing beneath a buttonwood tree.
Their agreement read:
“We, the subscribers, brokers for the purchase and sale of public stocks, do hereby solemnly promise and pledge ourselves to each other that we will not buy or sell from this date, for any person whatsoever any kind of public stocks at a less rate than one-quarter of one per cent. commission on the specie value, and that we will give a preference to each other in our negotiations.”
That was all there was at first.
The arrangement remained the only organization binding the brokers together until 1820.
That year, the brokers began meeting every day and established regular times for calling out stock prices.
But they had no permanent home.
The Board moved from place to place.
At one time it met in Samuel J. Beebee's office at 47 Wall Street.
At another time it met in a room behind Leonard Bleecker's office.
It also used a room in the offices of the old Courier and Journal.
Eventually, the brokers moved into an upper room of the old Merchants' Exchange.
The old building was destroyed in the great fire of 1835.
A new Merchants' Exchange was then constructed, and in 1842 the Stock Board moved into it.
It remained there until 1853.
Those early brokers guarded their business with extraordinary secrecy.
Outside financial news agencies had little chance of finding out what happened inside the Board.
Members were expected to keep everything secret, and anyone who broke that rule could be expelled.
There were no newspaper interviewers running around looking for inside information.
That profession simply did not exist yet.
Instead, the secrecy made outsiders even more curious.
One group of brokers eventually formed an open Board around 1837 after failing to gain admission to the regular organization.
They rented a building next door.
Then they did something almost comical.
They removed bricks from the wall separating their building from the Stock Board so they could see and hear what was happening inside.
Years later, the Stock Board moved again.
In 1853 it left the Merchants' Exchange.
Around 1857, during the great financial panic and around the time I first arrived in Wall Street, the Board moved into what was known as “Dan Lord's building,” with entrances on William and Beaver Streets.
That building became the stage for some of the greatest speculators of the era.
Daniel Drew was there.
Jacob Little was there.
So was Morse, the extraordinary mental calculator who made and lost millions in little more than a year.
Even in that building, the Exchange maintained its secrecy.
People were so desperate to hear what was happening inside that they reportedly offered $100 a day simply for the privilege of listening through the keyhole during the stock calls.
The Board remained there through the Civil War.
Then, in 1865, it finally moved into the grand building that became its permanent home.
The Exchange also played an important patriotic role during the war.
The country was fighting for its survival, and the financial system was under enormous pressure.
The Exchange passed a rule forbidding members from selling government bonds short.
It also prohibited trading in gold.
The decision to stop gold trading had an important consequence.
It helped lead to the creation of the Gold Exchange.
These restrictions cost the members of the Stock Exchange millions of dollars.
They willingly accepted that loss because they believed they were helping the government during the nation's crisis.
Yet even after such sacrifices, critics continued to portray Wall Street brokers as nothing more than selfish money seekers.
I find that difficult to accept.
How many other American institutions, I ask, would have willingly sacrificed millions of dollars to support the government during wartime?
I doubt there were many.
In fact, I can think of none that did more.
But the Stock Exchange was not alone in the financial world.
In 1863, another organization called the Open Board of Brokers was established.
It first operated from a basement on William Street that everyone called the “Coal Hole.”
Its membership grew rapidly.
Business poured in.
Before long, the organization needed more space, so it moved to a larger building on Broad Street, right next to the Stock Exchange.
The competition quickly became serious.
The new Board began taking business away from the old Exchange.
By 1869, it had captured nearly half of the old Board's business.
The situation was becoming dangerous.
The leaders of the old Exchange realized that if the two organizations continued fighting, both might eventually be destroyed.
So they decided to negotiate.
The negotiations ended with an agreement to unite.
In May 1869, three major financial organizations—the Open Board, the Stock Exchange, and the United States Government Board—were consolidated into one institution.
The result was the strongest public financial organization in the country and one of the most important financial institutions in the world.
The consolidation gave the new Exchange a remarkably strong position.
William Neilson became the first president of the reorganized Exchange in its new building.
Over the decades, many men served as president.
Edw. Lyde served in 1824.
John Wicker followed in 1825.
Russell H. Nevins served in 1830.
John Ward served from 1831 through 1833.
R. D. Weeks served in 1834 and again in 1836.
E. Prime became president in 1835.
David Clarkson served from 1837 through 1850.
H. G. Stebbins served in 1851.
C. R. Marvin followed in 1852 and continued through 1856.
J. H. Gourlie served in 1857.
H. G. Stebbins returned in 1858.
W. H. Neilson served from 1859 through 1861.
A. B. Baylis served in 1862.
H. G. Stebbins returned again in 1863.
Wm. Seymour, Jr. served in 1864.
R. L. Cutting followed in 1865.
Wm. Alexander Smith served in 1866.
John Warren served in 1867.
Wm. Searles served in 1868.
W. H. Neilson returned in 1869.
Wm. Seymour served in 1870.
W. B. Clarke served in 1871.
Edw. King served in 1872.
Hy. G. Chapman served in 1873.
Geo. H. Brodhead served in 1874.
Geo. W. McLean served in 1875.
Salem T. Russell served in 1876.
Henry Meigs served in 1877.
Brayton Ives served in 1878 and 1879.
Donald Mackay served in 1880 and 1881.
F. N. Lawrence served in 1882.
A. S. Hatch served in 1883.
J. Edward Simmons served in 1884 and 1885.
James D. Smith served in 1886, 1887, and 1888.
Wm. L. Bull served in 1889 and 1890.
W. B. Dickerman served in 1891 and 1892.
F. K. Sturgis served in 1893 and 1894.
F. L. Eames served in 1895, 1896, 1897, and 1898.
R. Keppler served from 1899 through 1903.
R. H. Thomas served in 1904.
H. K. Pomroy served in 1905.
R. H. Thomas returned in 1906, 1907, and 1908.
The Exchange also had a long line of secretaries.
Jacob Isaacs served from 1824 to 1831.
Bernard Hart served from 1831 to 1855.
Geo. H. Brodhead served from 1855 to 1870.
B. Ogden White served from 1870 to 1883.
George W. Ely served from 1883 to 1900.
Wm. McClure served from 1900 to 1905.
George W. Ely then returned as secretary in 1905 and remained in the position through 1908.
By 1907, only a small group of the Exchange's oldest living members remained from the generation that had joined before July 1, 1864.
They included William Alexander Smith, Henry Clews, E. C. Benedict, John H. Jacquelin, H. S. Camblos, L. D. Huntington, J. H. Whitehouse, A. S. Clark, Edwin Corning, and L. J. Van Boskerck.
From a handful of brokers beneath a buttonwood tree to a massive financial institution occupying a multimillion-dollar building, the growth of the New York Stock Exchange reflected the extraordinary expansion of American finance.
Its history was not simply the story of a building.
It was the story of a profession, a financial system, and a city growing together.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!