← Fifty years in Wall Street 2026 Edition
Chapter 81 · Was Roosevelt Really to Blame for the Crisis of 1907?

Was Roosevelt Really to Blame for the Crisis of 1907?

Chapter 81 of 90 · 4,358 words · Free

“I am very pleased to be here with the members of the Cleveland Chamber of Commerce.”

“After New York, and as a New Yorker I have to make that distinction, I consider Cleveland to be home to some of the finest business people in the United States.”

“Your ancestors made an excellent choice when they settled here. The twenty miles of docks along your waterfront are proof of their wisdom, as is the fact that your people control more shipping tonnage on the Great Lakes than anyone else.”

“Your natural resources have made Cleveland a leader in coal, iron, and petroleum. Your harbors are excellent, and where nature fell short, your famous breakwaters have made up the difference.”

“Cleveland is not only a natural center of commerce. It is also a major railroad center.”

“And your Euclid Avenue is admired in the East as a model of beauty and elegance.”

“Fifty years ago Cleveland was little more than a village. If you continue to grow at your present rate, where will you be fifty years from now?”

“It was here in Cleveland that the seed was planted that eventually grew into what may be the greatest business organization in the world.”

“Today, the Standard Oil Company does business in every country on earth. As a business organization, it has become one of the greatest commercial enterprises the world has ever seen.”

“Ohio has also taken from Virginia the old title of ‘Mother of Presidents.’”

“I predict that the Republican Convention this summer will nominate your most famous and respected citizen, William H. Taft, and that he will win by an overwhelming majority.”

“I would even suggest that Mr. Taft and Mr. Roosevelt exchange positions. Let Taft be President and Roosevelt become Secretary of War—or better yet, Secretary of the Navy.”

“That way, we would keep both men in public service and remain prepared for anything that might threaten either our Atlantic or Pacific coasts.”

“Now let me turn to the subject of tonight’s discussion.”

“When the words ‘In God We Trust’ were removed from our gold coins, some people may have joked that the new motto was, ‘In President Roosevelt We Trust, but in God We Distrust.’”

“But I am certain that most Americans do not think that way.”

“They trust both God and their President.”

“If President Roosevelt puts ‘God’ back on our coins, perhaps the American people will put him back in the White House after his present term. Then our motto might become: God first, our country second, and Theodore Roosevelt third term.”

“Together, the three would stand united for another four years.”

“I do not believe there is an intelligent person in America who honestly questions Theodore Roosevelt’s motives.”

“Whatever he has done, he has done because he believes it will benefit the public and the nation.”

“His speeches may have contributed to the atmosphere of distrust, but that does not mean his motives were dishonest.”

“He is an honest man, and an honest man has often been called the noblest work of God.”

“Of course, even an honest man can make mistakes.”

“No one expects human beings to have perfect judgment. Good intentions do not always produce good consequences.”

“That is something we should all understand.”

“Now, what about President Roosevelt’s policy toward capital?”

“Has his campaign against lawbreaking railroads and industrial trusts endangered the prosperity of the country?”

“I say no.”

“He certainly never intended to damage American prosperity.”

“He helped turn on the light, but he did not create the abuses that the light exposed.”

“The real problem was the corruption and illegal conduct that had been taking place inside some railroad and industrial corporations.”

“Once those practices were exposed, public confidence in those companies naturally suffered.”

“Many people have looked at the stock market and reached a simple conclusion.”

“Last year, optimism was everywhere. Prices were high and investors were confident.”

“This year, prices have collapsed and panic has taken hold.”

“Therefore, they say, President Roosevelt must be responsible.”

“The wealthy speculators and trust magnates who have lost large fortunes naturally think this way.”

“They blame Roosevelt’s speeches and his attacks on corporate wrongdoing.”

“But that argument does not stand up very well.”

“Across the country, most people actually support what the President has done.”

“They want corporate abuses exposed and illegal business practices stopped.”

“They want higher standards of business morality.”

“Meetings like this are especially valuable during times such as these.”

“When people with different opinions come together and discuss the major issues honestly, everyone has a chance to understand the situation more clearly.”

“That kind of open discussion strengthens both friendship and public life.”

“It is particularly important now, when the country is suffering from depression and widespread distrust.”

“We were fortunate that there was no presidential election last year.”

“The public was so uncertain and frightened that many decent people might not have voted according to what they believed was best for the country.”

“Instead, they might have voted out of personal anger, financial loss, or a desire for revenge.”

“Many investors had suffered badly from the long decline in the stock market and from the disruption of credit.”

“That could easily have distorted their judgment.”

“It is deeply unfortunate that some of the men in charge of major industrial and railroad corporations abused the trust placed in them.”

“They left the President with little choice but to order federal officials to investigate.”

“And when the evidence showed that corporations and their officers had used their power to break the law, the government had to prosecute them.”

“In cases involving practices such as railroad rebates and the questionable reorganization of the Chicago & Alton, the accused were in many instances found guilty in court.”

“That fully justified President Roosevelt’s decision to act.”

“Capital may remain nervous until all the facts are known and confidence in corporate management is restored.”

“But in the long run, this investigation will benefit the country.”

“It will remove illegal practices that have poisoned business.”

“Once that happens, both American and foreign investors will regain confidence.”

“They will once again be willing to invest heavily in American securities when they know that railroad and industrial profits will be fairly distributed among shareholders.”

“That can happen only when companies are honestly managed, obey the law, and remain subject to proper federal and state supervision.”

“Recent events proved that strong action was necessary.”

“Roosevelt was not attacking capital.”

“He was attacking corporate leaders who had abused their power for illegal purposes and, apparently, for their own personal profit.”

“Public confidence had already been damaged repeatedly.”

“Then came the revelations involving Metropolitan Securities, followed by the New York Clearing House action against the Heinze and Morse banks.”

“For more than two years, scandals involving corporate corruption and railroad rebates had been coming to light.”

“Then came the collapse of the copper manipulation.”

“And more recently, the scandals surrounding the New York traction companies.”

“Given all that, is it any wonder that people became frightened?”

“But who caused the problem?”

“Not Roosevelt.”

“Not Mr. Hughes, who became famous for exposing corruption in the insurance industry.”

“They were the people who brought the wrongdoing into the open.”

“The real responsibility belongs to those who committed the illegal acts.”

“Of course, guilty men always complain when the government begins cleaning up the financial system.”

“They say investigations destroy confidence and make innocent people suffer.”

“But that argument turns reality upside down.”

“The blame belongs to the people who committed the crimes, not to the officials who exposed them.”

“Those who abused the public trust and ignored the rights of ordinary Americans are the real offenders.”

“The lesson is becoming clearer every day.”

“When our railroads and industrial companies are known to be honestly managed, and when shareholders and investors receive what properly belongs to them, financial values will become more stable.”

“And American credit, which has fallen badly in the major financial centers of the world, will eventually recover its proper standing.”

“There is at least one encouraging sign in all these scandals.”

“Public opinion has finally awakened.”

“Americans are demanding corporations that are not only efficient, but honest.”

“These investigations can therefore raise the moral standards of corporate management.”

“Of course, people are still nervous.”

“They keep wondering what scandal will be uncovered next.”

“Some corporate managers have behaved as though the law did not apply to them.”

“They seem to believe that if someone powerful or socially important breaks the law, he should be protected, while some subordinate takes the blame.”

“But that cannot be allowed.”

“If a poor man commits a crime, he goes to prison.”

“His family may suffer terribly because of it.”

“If a powerful corporate executive commits a crime, the same principle must apply.”

“The law must not show favoritism.”

“Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed because their people violated the laws of nature.”

“Our own government, although it is the finest government known to man, could eventually be weakened or destroyed if wealthy and unscrupulous people are allowed to break the law without punishment while poor people are punished for much smaller offenses.”

“That kind of inequality cannot continue forever.”

“Many ordinary Americans have written to the President complaining about exactly this problem.”

“They see people from their own social class being sent to prison while wealthy men who appear equally guilty remain free.”

“If that continues, public anger will eventually become dangerous.”

“This is a government of the people, by the people, and for the people.”

“The ordinary people are the majority.”

“They will not tolerate a system in which wealth buys one kind of justice and poverty receives another.”

“President Roosevelt took an oath to uphold the Constitution.”

“And the Constitution requires the President to see that the laws are faithfully enforced.”

“He would therefore have failed in his duty if he had refused to enforce the Interstate Commerce Act and the Sherman Anti-Trust Act.”

“When people brought evidence of illegal corporate practices to him, he properly passed that information to the Attorney General for investigation.”

“And when those investigations repeatedly led to successful prosecutions, Roosevelt deserved credit for acting.”

“The claim that he launched indiscriminate attacks on corporations has no solid foundation.”

“He attacked dishonesty and lawbreaking, not legitimate business.”

“I fully support what Roosevelt has done in terms of reform.”

“But I do have one criticism.”

“He has spoken too passionately and too often about these matters during the present period of financial fear.”

“His speeches undoubtedly made nervous investors and depositors even more uneasy.”

“At a time like this, silence can sometimes be more valuable than words.”

“Roosevelt probably should have spoken less.”

“Still, I admire his intentions and his actions.”

“We should therefore forgive him for being too outspoken.”

“Not long ago, France was prepared to invest large amounts of money in American bonds and stocks.”

“But shortly after buying Pennsylvania Railroad bonds, French investors were confronted with one corporate scandal after another.”

“French capital immediately became suspicious of American investments.”

“Once the old abuses have been exposed and corrected, foreign and domestic investors will return.”

“And when they do, they will discover that American securities, after undergoing such strict examination, may once again be among the safest and best investments in the world.”

“It is unfair to blame President Roosevelt for the banking troubles, business failures, and stock-market losses.”

“But this is something presidents always face.”

“Whatever economic disaster occurs during a president’s administration, the president usually receives much of the blame.”

“Those of us whose hair is no longer black, brown, sandy, red—or particularly abundant—can remember what happened to Abraham Lincoln.”

“Lincoln was attacked relentlessly during the Civil War.”

“The war cost millions of lives and billions of dollars.”

“Many Americans suffered terribly.”

“Some blamed Lincoln personally and attacked him with extraordinary bitterness.”

“The attacks nearly broke that great man’s heart.”

“But they never caused him to abandon the work he believed was his duty.”

“Today, even those who once condemned Lincoln honor his memory.”

“Roosevelt may sometimes speak too forcefully about punishing people who break the law.”

“But I believe history will remember him as a man who was willing to endure unfair criticism in order to do what he believed was right.”

“And even now, most Americans support his efforts to clean up business.”

“Those capitalists who have lost heavily in the stock market naturally feel angry.”

“But even many of them privately admit that Roosevelt is right in principle.”

“They may believe that he talks too much.”

“But they also recognize that he is enforcing the law.”

“If what he is doing is wrong, then the fault lies with the law itself.”

“Roosevelt has not demanded punishment beyond what the law provides.”

“And after everything that has been exposed, it would be extremely difficult for anyone to argue that the law itself is unjust.”

“The law is supposed to provide equal justice for everyone.”

“And Americans are, by nature, a law-abiding people.”

“Still, we must not make the mistake of believing that every corporation is corrupt.”

“Most American corporations are honestly and competently managed for the benefit of their shareholders.”

“It is inevitable that some bad people will enter large organizations.”

“Every profession, church, club, and social organization contains a certain number of dishonest people.”

“When temptation offers them personal gain, some will reveal their true character.”

“But it is unfair to assume that all corporate management is corrupt.”

“That false assumption has contributed greatly to the hysteria now spreading through Wall Street and the country.”

“We should also do more to protect minority shareholders.”

“Especially in interstate railroad companies, minority shareholders should have at least one representative on the board of directors.”

“That representative should be elected by the minority shareholders at each annual meeting.”

“If that director were an honest, level-headed businessman, many of the abuses of the past could never happen again.”

“It is also deeply regrettable that some powerful men in major national banks have used their positions to promote personal schemes.”

“Their actions have destroyed confidence and forced some of them to leave their positions.”

“Of all corporations, national banks should be the last institutions to be used for illegal purposes or personal speculation.”

“A man who uses his position to endanger the solvency and reputation of a bank is a public enemy.”

“Destroy a respectable woman’s reputation and you may ruin her life.”

“Destroy confidence in a bank and you destroy one of the foundations of business prosperity.”

“Investors in railroad or industrial stocks can lose only the amount they invested.”

“But shareholders in a national bank can also be held liable for an additional amount equal to the par value of their shares.”

“That makes confidence in banking institutions especially important.”

“The greatest protection for any corporation is publicity.”

“Publicity is also the best weapon against fraud.”

“Many men will do things in secret that they would never dare to do in public.”

“If business practices that were once hidden are brought into the open, there will be less dishonesty among powerful business leaders.”

“I have been preaching this principle of publicity for years.”

“Eighteen months ago, I spoke about it at the Wharton School of Political Economy at the University of Pennsylvania.”

“Even then, I could see signs of corporate corruption, railroad rebates, and financial manipulation.”

“But at that time, I did not have the evidence necessary to prove those abuses in court.”

“Since then, so much wrongdoing has been exposed that neither the federal government nor the states could avoid taking strong action.”

“They had to investigate, prosecute, and identify the people responsible.”

“President Roosevelt led the way.”

“He is not interested in persecuting innocent people.”

“He wants guilty people prosecuted.”

“I firmly believe that his courageous campaign against corporate abuses will eventually become one of the most important achievements of his presidency.”

“He wants to punish the guilty while protecting legitimate property rights.”

“He wants to make sure that innocent people do not suffer because of the crimes of others—or suffer as little as possible.”

“Sometimes wealthy corporate defendants hire powerful lawyers who manage to avoid conviction.”

“But the American people still have a right to equal justice.”

“These events remind us of the old biblical saying that the wicked may flourish for a time, but eventually they are cut down.”

“History shows us that great cities and empires have been destroyed by the lawlessness of wealthy and powerful men.”

“The Roman Empire itself was weakened by the greed and corruption of its ruling classes.”

“America was also moving dangerously close to a system dominated by giant corporations and wealthy corporate interests.”

“But ordinary Americans still believe in equality, equal rights, and fair play.”

“They do not want a government controlled by a plutocracy.”

“President Roosevelt said in Memphis this year:”

“I will not stop pursuing a wrongdoer merely because he pretends to be a labor leader, any more than I would stop because he pretends to be a captain of industry.”

“I am against dishonest citizens whether they are wealthy capitalists who build fortunes through fraud or people who use the labor movement as an excuse to promote violence and murder.”

“Roosevelt also understood how nervous some corporate leaders had become.”

“He once joked that the mere statement ‘honesty is the best policy’ might cause people to run to the banks.”

“But when we examine the causes of the present panic, nothing could be further from the truth than to blame everything on corporate investigations and prosecutions.”

“There were many other causes behind this year’s depression.”

“Several forces combined to darken what had once looked like the brightest financial outlook the country had ever seen.”

“One major cause was the enormous railroad, industrial, and commercial expansion of the previous ten years.”

“The country had grown so rapidly that its demand for capital became greater than the available supply.”

“Bankers naturally began taking precautions.”

“They had to restrict the amount of credit they were willing to provide.”

“That caution and the resulting slowdown in business may actually prove to be the strongest protection against an even worse disaster.”

“I have been urging this kind of restraint for some time.”

“We badly needed a brake.”

“The great railroad and industrial companies had expanded their operations at enormous cost.”

“They had spent heavily on new equipment and ambitious projects.”

“They simply expanded too far.”

“They had, as the saying goes, bitten off more than they could chew.”

“When confidence was at its peak and credit seemed unlimited, such expansion may have looked reasonable.”

“But then, suddenly, the insurance scandals and other shocking revelations appeared.”

“Confidence began to disappear.”

“Timidity replaced optimism.”

“Capital became scarce.”

“Many railroads and industrial companies could no longer borrow the huge sums they needed to finance their ambitious expansion.”

“Banks had already extended too much credit in many cases.”

“They were unable to provide much more.”

“At the same time, the market was flooded with new securities.”

“Those securities no longer found buyers as easily as they had before.”

“Investors began pulling away.”

“Everyone was forced to cut back.”

“So President Roosevelt can no more be blamed for the depression and panic than he can be credited with all the prosperity that came before it.”

“The fact that the crisis reached its peak when it did was largely a coincidence.”

“Still, we cannot deny that the shocking revelations of widespread corporate wrongdoing badly damaged public confidence.”

“They helped create the conditions in which the panic became possible.”

“But the prosecution of wealthy corporations that had broken the law was simply the legal consequence of their own actions.”

“The Constitution itself makes the President’s responsibility clear.”

“Article II requires the President to swear that he will faithfully perform his office and preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution.”

“The same article requires him to make sure that the laws are faithfully executed.”

“When Theodore Roosevelt became President, he took that oath.”

“He therefore had a duty to enforce the law faithfully and courageously.”

“As an honest man, he was simply trying to do his duty.”

“He went after corporations that broke the law and the people who became rich through dishonest control of those corporations.”

“That was all.”

“If he had refused to prosecute them, he would have violated his oath and neglected his responsibility.”

“What kind of republic would America be if the law were enforced against the poor but ignored when the rich broke it?”

“That would make a mockery of our entire system of government.”

“Theodore Roosevelt would never accept such an insult to the national honor.”

“He has always been willing to defend that honor.”

“It has been said that the honor of a nation is the soul of that nation.”

“Roosevelt’s determination to defend ordinary citizens against powerful corporations that had prospered through secret wrongdoing has attracted attention and admiration around the world.”

“Yes, he has sometimes gone too far in his language.”

“But we can forgive his excessive enthusiasm.”

“Roosevelt has shown himself to be a successful fighter against corporate dishonesty and violations of law.”

“It remains uncertain whether his policies had any major role in causing the depression and banking crisis of this remarkable year.”

“But regardless of whether they did, he has made it clear that he will not abandon his policies during the rest of his term.”

“He intends to continue.”

“And what has his administration actually done?”

“It has exposed wrongdoing.”

“Removing a cancer is painful.”

“For a while, the patient may actually feel worse.”

“But that does not mean the operation was a mistake.”

“To say that Theodore Roosevelt has declared war on capital is simply wrong.”

“He is against dishonest corporate practices and wealth acquired through dishonest means.”

“He respects people who have earned their fortunes honestly.”

“He wants their property protected and their rights defended.”

“Successful honest businessmen are good citizens, and their success deserves respect.”

“But if someone commits fraud through a railroad, industrial company, or bank, Roosevelt will oppose him just as firmly as he would oppose a violent criminal.”

“Crime is crime.”

“It does not become acceptable because the criminal is rich.”

“And it does not become less serious because the criminal is poor.”

“Suppose a man builds a railroad where the country needs one and operates it honestly.”

“Roosevelt would consider that man a public benefactor.”

“But suppose that same man manipulates the railroad’s stocks and bonds to cheat shareholders or bondholders.”

“Suppose he gives illegal rebates to one shipper and discriminates against another.”

“Then Roosevelt would consider him an enemy of the public institutions and would insist that he be punished.”

“That answers the question of whether Roosevelt’s policy toward capital is sound.”

“I say that it is—when properly understood.”

“I would go even further.”

“Federal regulation of interstate corporations should eventually become absolute.”

“Railroads and express companies that operate across state lines should be regulated by the national government rather than by a confusing mixture of state and federal authorities.”

“That would actually benefit corporations as well as the public.”

“They should be placed under national control in much the same way that national banks are.”

“One central system of regulation would eliminate much of the confusion created by overlapping federal and state authority.”

“I would extend that principle to all corporations doing interstate business.”

“I believe that change will eventually come.”

“President Roosevelt is helping prepare the country for it.”

“And he deserves credit for taking an important step in that direction.”

“But now that Roosevelt has largely accomplished what he set out to accomplish, he can afford to remain quiet.”

“He has already made his position perfectly clear.”

“The public understands what he believes.”

“If he continues repeating the same warnings in speech after speech, especially during this period of financial panic, he may only create more fear about the value of corporate stocks and bonds.”

“Capital is already extremely nervous.”

“The public is already frightened.”

“That extreme nervousness helped cause the recent runs on several New York trust companies, and to a lesser extent on banks and savings banks.”

“Many depositors withdrew their money and then hid it in safe-deposit boxes, vaults, and other places instead of putting it back into the banking system.”

“That hoarding made the situation much worse.”

“It removed money from circulation and put enormous pressure on bank reserves.”

“Between October 23 and October 31, call loans on the New York Stock Exchange averaged about 50 percent interest per year.”

“Some loans reached 75 percent or even 100 percent.”

“That gives you an idea of how desperate the shortage of money had become.”

“Large-scale hoarding is extremely dangerous.”

“It suddenly reduces the amount of money circulating through the economy and drains bank reserves.”

“In this case, it helped trigger another wave of panic and another collapse in stock prices.”

“The situation became so serious that the New York Clearing House banks unanimously agreed to issue Clearing House certificates.”

“Nothing else was likely to stop the runs on the banks and trust companies.”

“President Roosevelt certainly does not want Americans to hoard their money.”

“Hoarding hurts the entire country.”

“It is also contrary to good citizenship.”

“And it is deeply un-American.”

“But the public had become so frightened by corporate scandals and other disturbing events that many people had begun to believe that all corporations might be corrupt.”

“That loss of confidence is one of the main reasons for the prolonged selling of stocks.”

“It also helped produce the runs on banks and trust companies and the enormous financial and industrial disruption we have experienced.”

“President Roosevelt now needs to recognize what the country needs most.”

“The public—and especially investors—need reassurance.”

“They need to hear that there is still light beyond the storm.”

“They need to understand that there is no reason to lose faith in the country itself.”

“America remains just as rich in natural resources as ever.”

“The country remains powerful and productive.”

“And its future is just as promising as it was before this crisis darkened the financial sky.”

“President Roosevelt understands this.”

“He is working closely with the Secretary of the Treasury to ease the shortage of money and restore public confidence.”

Comments 0

Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!