What Wall Street Is Really Like
For years, many people—and some newspapers—had painted Wall Street as nothing more than a giant gambling hall.
They said it did little good, caused great harm, and ought to be abolished as far as possible. Wall Street speculators were casually branded as gamblers.
But Henry Clews saw it very differently.
“Anyone who actually knows Wall Street,” he argued, “knows that this picture is completely wrong.”
“The bankers, brokers, and members of the New York Stock Exchange are, by and large, some of the most responsible and honorable businessmen in the country.”
“The Exchange demands honesty and good faith more strictly than most people realize. Its constitution, by-laws, and rules leave little room for dishonest behavior.”
“And when a member is caught breaking those rules, he is punished.”
“Sometimes the punishment is suspension. Sometimes it is expulsion. The Governors have the authority to decide how severe the penalty should be, and those penalties are enforced.”
“The same is largely true of the exchanges in Boston, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and other major cities.”
Clews pointed to the financial crisis of 1907 as evidence.
“Look at what happened during the panic,” he said. “The country was shocked by one corporate scandal after another. But the members of the Stock Exchange were not behind those scandals.”
“The men who controlled the life insurance companies and were exposed for misusing other people’s money were not members of the Stock Exchange. They were not Wall Street men.”
“The men who wrecked the Metropolitan Street Railway system were not members of the Exchange either.”
“Nor were the reckless bank promoters who gained control of three chains of New York City banks so that they could use them for their own speculative purposes.”
“Those men helped create the conditions that led to the panic. But they were not representatives of the Stock Exchange.”
“Even the failure of the Knickerbocker Trust Company—the event that became one of the defining moments of the panic—was not caused by a member of the Stock Exchange.”
“And no member of the Exchange was responsible for the failures of banks, trust companies, or corporations during that crisis.”
Clews paused.
“Of course, there may be a few bad men in Wall Street that no one has discovered yet. But there are bad men everywhere.”
“You can find them sitting in church pews. Occasionally, you can even find one standing in a church pulpit.”
“That does not mean we should condemn every church in the country.”
“Why should Wall Street be treated differently?”
He was equally irritated by the common claim that buying and selling stocks was simply gambling.
“To call stock and bond trading on the Exchange gambling is to misuse the word,” he said. “The accusation usually comes from ignorance or prejudice.”
“Whether a person buys securities as an investor or as a speculator makes no difference to the brokers standing on the floor.”
“They make a contract. One side delivers the securities, the other side receives them, and payment is made at the agreed price.”
“That is a business transaction.”
“A trade may take only a moment to make on the Exchange. The written record may not even be exchanged until the brokers compare their transactions at their offices after the market closes.”
“But once the trade is made, the contract is binding.”
“A broker cannot simply change his mind because the trade has turned against him.”
“If he refuses to honor the contract, he can be suspended immediately and expelled once the violation is established.”
“That is hardly the behavior of a gambling house.”
Clews also defended the character of Exchange members.
“Members of the Stock Exchange are not random gamblers who happen to wander into Wall Street,” he said.
“They are businessmen of established solvency and respectable standing. Many are men of considerable wealth, education, and social position.”
“Many belong to the leading clubs in New York.”
“And their membership itself has considerable value.”
“At the time, a seat on the Exchange can be worth somewhere between fifty and ninety thousand dollars.”
“That means membership represents a substantial property qualification. A man who owns such a seat has something significant to lose.”
“Before he is admitted, he must also undergo a thorough examination by the Committee on Admissions.”
“And if his conduct later becomes harmful to the Exchange, the Governing Committee can investigate him and impose the appropriate punishment.”
Clews believed this system made the Exchange more disciplined, not less.
“Recent attacks on the character of the New York Stock Exchange are completely unjustified,” he said. “They are driven by ignorance or prejudice.”
“Imagine abolishing the Exchange.”
“What would happen?”
“Large enterprises would soon suffer.”
“Railroads and industrial corporations need enormous amounts of capital. Without an organized market for their securities, raising that money would become far more difficult.”
“Investors would lose an important way to put their capital to work.”
“And millions of dollars in stocks and bonds would lose their free market.”
“Take away the Exchange and you take away the mechanism that allows buyers and sellers to determine prices.”
“Then investors would know less about the true value of their property, not more.”
“And without a free market, securities could become even more vulnerable to manipulation.”
“The New York Stock Exchange is, at its core, a highly organized marketplace for securities.”
“It does not run the railroads or factories whose securities are traded there.”
“It cannot directly control the companies themselves.”
“What it can do is establish rules for its members and decide what kinds of securities may be traded on its floor.”
“Beyond that, buyers and sellers must use their own judgment.”
“But if you want to talk about business integrity, you will find few organized bodies whose standards are higher.”
“Much of the business is conducted simply by word of mouth.”
“And in Wall Street, a man's spoken word is expected to be as binding as a signed contract.”
“If someone believes he has been treated unfairly, he can bring the matter before the Board of Governors.”
“The purpose of that board is to prevent abuses and maintain the highest possible standards.”
“Rules are enforced, and violations are punished.”
“So before anyone starts throwing stones at the Stock Exchange,” Clews concluded, “he should first make sure his own windows are not made of glass.”
He then turned to another subject that he believed had been badly misunderstood: speculation.
“Speculation itself is not evil,” he said. “Like almost anything else, it can become harmful when carried too far.”
“But within reasonable limits, speculation is extremely useful.”
“It encourages people to take risks.”
“Without that willingness to risk capital, enterprise would slow down. Trade would weaken. Industry would decline.”
“Eventually, the whole economy would become stagnant.”
“In a modern economy, speculation is one of the forces that keeps business moving.”
“And because it is part of human nature, you cannot simply eliminate it.”
Clews described speculation as a kind of balancing mechanism.
“There will always be people who want to buy when others want to sell, and people willing to sell when others want to buy.”
“That constant competition helps establish the real value of stocks and commodities.”
“Consider the short seller.”
“He sells first, hoping to buy later at a lower price. But when prices fall, he becomes a buyer.”
“In that sense, the short seller can actually provide support to a declining market.”
“Now consider the investor who owns the stock.”
“If prices rise too far, he may sell to take his profit.”
“That selling can restrain an excessive rise.”
“The result is a constant struggle between buyers and sellers, and that struggle helps discover prices.”
Clews also explained why bankers cared about an active market.
“A banker needs to know what his collateral is really worth,” he said.
“A free and active market provides that information.”
“That helps both borrowers and lenders, even when neither has any interest in speculation itself.”
“Banks make loans based on the value of assets. The market provides one of the best tests of that value.”
“So speculation does more than create opportunities for speculators. It also helps the entire credit system function.”
“But yes,” he admitted, “speculation can become excessive.”
“When that happens, people can suffer serious losses.”
“Yet those excesses are part of human nature. Experience and public opinion are often better teachers than artificial laws.”
“If a man makes a good business decision and accepts the risk involved, why should he not profit from it?”
“And if his judgment is wrong, why should someone else be blamed for his loss?”
Clews insisted that speculation and gambling were two entirely different things.
“Gambling is based on chance,” he said.
“Speculation is based on information, judgment, and expectations about the future.”
“Every business decision involving the future contains some element of speculation.”
“Buying land with one-fifth of the purchase price in cash and borrowing the rest on a mortgage is speculative.”
“Buying a house in the same way is speculative.”
“But nobody seriously argues that buying a house with borrowed money is automatically gambling.”
“Why, then, should buying stocks on margin be treated differently?”
“These are business decisions involving risk.”
“The rules of the New York Stock Exchange are designed to protect legitimate trading, and every transaction requires an actual transfer of property.”
“There will always be abuses in every business.”
“But that is precisely why people should use judgment and distinguish between legitimate business and genuine wrongdoing instead of making sweeping accusations.”
Clews then addressed President Roosevelt's recent attack on options.
“The President's criticism of options cannot reasonably be directed at the New York Stock Exchange,” he said.
“Options are not traded there.”
“They were traded many years ago, sometimes for periods of three to sixty days, but that practice was abandoned long ago.”
“Today, a purchase or sale on the floor calls for delivery on the day of the transaction or the following day, with payment made when the securities are delivered.”
“No law can prevent a broker from buying securities for a customer on part payment.”
“A dry-goods merchant can sell merchandise on credit.”
“A hardware dealer can do the same.”
“A grocery merchant can extend credit.”
“Why should a broker be forbidden to do something similar?”
“Credit is essential to modern business.”
“Much of the world's commerce could not exist without it.”
Clews then compared New York with London.
“London is different,” he explained. “Much of its securities business is effectively conducted on an option-like basis because settlements take place every two weeks.”
“There are two regular settlement periods each month, and those settlements can sometimes be extended repeatedly.”
“The American system is different.”
He made a similar argument for futures trading in agricultural markets.
“Look at the Cotton and Produce Exchanges,” he said.
“Futures trading allows those markets to function on a large scale.”
“Take the farmer.”
“Once he knows his crop is secure, he can estimate when it will be harvested, stored, processed, and shipped to market.”
“Then he can sell it for delivery in the month he expects it to arrive.”
“By doing that, he can protect himself from a sudden fall in prices.”
“That certainty can be enormously valuable.”
“Take away that market, and you send the farmer back to the old system.”
“Before these markets existed, large dealers from Liverpool, Chicago, and elsewhere could send agents directly to farmers at harvest time.”
“They could pressure farmers with gloomy predictions and other tactics until the farmer finally sold his crop for barely more than the cost of producing it.”
“Today the farmer has another choice.”
“He can hold his crop and wait for a better price.”
“That is one reason the agricultural exchanges have contributed so much to the prosperity of American farmers.”
“So why destroy a system that has served producers so well?”
Clews also pointed out that failures among Exchange members were relatively uncommon.
“If a member becomes insolvent,” he said, “the rules require him to notify the Exchange immediately that he cannot meet his obligations.”
“Defaulted contracts are then closed out under the Exchange rules.”
“A failure normally results in suspension.”
“But considering that there are around eleven hundred members, failures are remarkably rare.”
“In fact, they are much less common than failures in ordinary commercial business.”
“And even when a member does fail, the matter is often followed by a satisfactory settlement, after which he may eventually be allowed to return to business.”
“To me, that says something important about the conservative nature of these firms.”
“Truly disastrous failures are uncommon.”
“Dishonest tricks and unfair dealing are extremely difficult to sustain because the Exchange is under constant supervision.”
“Members themselves also have a powerful reason to protect the system.”
“A broker who cheats does not merely risk punishment. He risks his reputation, his business, and his membership.”
“That is why the members themselves generally support strict discipline.”
“They want the occasional bad actor removed because the rules protect everyone else.”
Clews then returned to the panic of 1907.
“The recent crisis showed just how important the Stock Exchange is to the banking system,” he said.
“When banks became frightened, they began calling in loans.”
“When necessary, they had to liquidate the securities held as collateral.”
“Where could they sell those securities quickly?”
“On the Stock Exchange.”
“The Exchange provided the market that made rapid liquidation possible.”
“In doing so, it helped many banks and trust companies avoid suspension.”
“It also helped many bankers and brokers survive the crisis instead of being destroyed by it.”
“So the Exchange performs an important function in the monetary system.”
“It is also a kind of barometer of value.”
“Prices on the Exchange provide a constantly changing indication of what stocks and bonds are worth.”
“Cotton and grain exchanges perform a similar function for their commodities.”
Yet the crisis had produced a new wave of attacks on Wall Street.
“Unfortunately,” Clews said, “the panic has given Wall Street's critics fresh ammunition.”
“Some people blame Wall Street for the financial disaster.”
“Others blame President Roosevelt, arguing that his speeches and the government's prosecutions of railroad and industrial corporations caused the crisis.”
“Both accusations are unreasonable.”
“Neither can withstand serious examination.”
“But that does not stop people from making them.”
“Some people are perfectly willing to make accusations they cannot prove.”
“And prejudice often makes people far more certain than facts ever could.”
Clews was especially frustrated by people who knew nothing about speculation.
“Many of those who condemn speculation have never speculated themselves,” he said.
“Some have never even studied how Wall Street works.”
“Yet they blame speculation for almost every economic problem they can think of.”
“Some would even close the Stock Exchange simply to stop speculation.”
“They seem to forget what would happen next.”
“Investors would lose their market.”
“Banks would lose an important market for securities.”
“And all the stocks and bonds listed on the Exchange would become much harder to sell.”
“If that happened, their prices would almost certainly fall even more sharply than they did during the panic of 1907.”
Clews admitted that manipulation could occur.
“Yes, matched orders may sometimes be used to manipulate prices,” he said.
“The rules prohibit such conduct.”
“The difficulty is discovering and proving it.”
“But that does not mean the Exchange tolerates manipulation.”
“There is hardly any organized body of businessmen subject to stricter discipline.”
“And the members of the Exchange have repeatedly demonstrated their loyalty to the country.”
“Their actions during the Civil War and at other difficult moments are proof of that.”
There was another fact Clews believed critics often ignored.
“Remember the taxes they pay,” he said.
“Members of the Exchange pay the State of New York a tax of two dollars for every hundred shares of stock they sell.”
“That represents an important source of revenue for the state.”
“So the Exchange is not some useless institution sitting apart from the country.”
“It is deeply connected to the nation's financial system.”
“To me, its importance is beyond question.”
“I have been a member since 1864.”
“I have spent decades watching Wall Street from the inside.”
“And after all those years, I can say with confidence that the Exchange and its banking community are fundamentally sound and honorable.”
“So believe me when I tell you this.”
“Wall Street is not nearly as black as its critics paint it.”
“If you place your money there intelligently and handle it with good judgment, it is no less safe than money placed in any other legitimate line of business.”
“If you lose money because you made a foolish decision, you cannot simply blame Wall Street.”
“The responsibility is yours.”
“Your banker and broker, in fact, have every reason to want you to make money.”
“When a customer loses everything, the broker loses a customer as well.”
Clews ended with a touch of humor.
“So if you ever decide to take a chance in Wall Street,” he said, “I hope you come out flying high.”
“And when you do, I hope your opinion of Wall Street rises along with your profits.”
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!