Zhou Yu Makes Up His Mind to Fight Cao Cao
Seeing Sun Quan stuck in hesitation, Lady Wu spoke up.
“Before your sister passed away, she left a word. If internal affairs leave you unsure, consult Zhang Zhao. If foreign affairs trouble you, ask Zhou Yu. Why don’t you send for Zhou Yu to settle this?”
Sun Quan’s face lit up. He immediately ordered a messenger to summon Zhou Yu from Poyang.
Zhou Yu had been training the naval troops at Poyang Lake. As soon as he heard Cao Cao’s massive army had advanced to the Han River, he rushed back to Chaisang overnight. The messenger had not even left the city gates when Zhou Yu arrived.
Lu Su was Zhou Yu’s closest friend. He hurried to greet him and told him every detail of the conflict between surrender and resistance.
“Do not worry,” Zhou Yu said calmly. “I already have a plan. Go quickly and bring Zhuge Liang to see me.”
Right after Lu Su left, Zhang Zhao, Gu Yong, Zhang Hong and Bu Zhi came to visit.
After exchanging formal greetings, Zhang Zhao got straight to the point.
“General, do you understand the critical situation Jiangdong is facing?”
“I have not heard the details yet,” Zhou Yu replied.
“Cao Cao has amassed a million troops camped along the Han River,” Zhang Zhao explained. “He sent an official letter asking our lord to meet him for a hunt in Jiangxia. His intention to annex our land is obvious, though he hides it for now. We advised our lord to surrender temporarily to avoid disaster. But Lu Su brought Zhuge Liang, Liu Bei’s advisor, here. Zhuge Liang only wants to use our troops to avenge his master, so he goaded our lord into fighting. Lu Su is stubbornly set on war. We have been waiting for you to make the final call.”
Zhou Yu turned to the other three officials. “Do all of you share the same opinion?”
All of them nodded firmly. “We all agree that surrender is the only safe choice.”
“To tell you the truth, I have long thought surrender is best,” Zhou Yu said. “Please return to your residences for now. Tomorrow morning, I will give a definite answer before our lord.”
The four civilian officials bowed and took their leave.
Soon after, senior generals Cheng Pu, Huang Gai, Han Dang and others arrived.
After greetings, Cheng Pu spoke with heavy frustration.
“General, do you know our Jiangdong territory will soon fall into another’s hands?”
“I do not see it yet,” Zhou Yu answered.
“We have fought hundreds of battles alongside General Sun Ce to build this six-county kingdom,” Cheng Pu said bitterly. “Now our lord listens to civilian officials and plans to surrender. It is shameful and heartbreaking! We would rather die than suffer such humiliation. We beg you to persuade our lord to declare war. Every one of us will fight to the death.”
Zhou Yu surveyed the crowd. “Is this the resolve of every general here?”
Huang Gai slammed his fist to his chest, his face red with anger. “I would rather lose my head than surrender to Cao Cao!”
All the generals shouted in unison, “We refuse to surrender!”
“I have always wanted to fight Cao Cao, not surrender to him,” Zhou Yu declared. “Rest assured. Tomorrow I will convince our lord to go to war.”
The military generals then departed.
Next, Zhuge Jin, Lü Fan and other officials came to see Zhou Yu.
Zhuge Jin spoke cautiously. “My younger brother Zhuge Liang came from Jiangxia on Liu Bei’s behalf, hoping to form an alliance with us against Cao Cao. Our court is split on the decision. As his brother, I dared not speak freely, so I waited for your judgment.”
“What is your personal view?” Zhou Yu asked.
“Surrender brings peace and stability,” Zhuge Jin replied. “War brings only uncertainty and danger.”
Zhou Yu smiled faintly. “I have my own plan. We will settle this together at court tomorrow.”
After these officials left, Lü Meng, Gan Ning and more officers arrived. Some advocated war, others pushed for surrender, and a fierce argument broke out.
“No more quarreling,” Zhou Yu stopped them. “We will discuss this publicly tomorrow.”
Once everyone was gone, Zhou Yu smiled coldly to himself.
That night, Lu Su led Zhuge Liang to Zhou Yu’s mansion.
After welcoming them and taking seats, Lu Su turned to Zhou Yu urgently.
“Cao Cao’s army marches south. Our lord cannot choose between war and surrender, and everyone waits for your decision. What is your stance?”
“Cao Cao fights in the emperor’s name, and his army is too powerful to defy,” Zhou Yu said deliberately. “Fighting means certain defeat. Surrender means safety. I have decided to advise our lord to surrender tomorrow.”
Lu Su was utterly shocked.
“You are wrong! Jiangdong has stood for three generations. How can we abandon it overnight? General Sun Ce entrusted foreign affairs to you. The whole kingdom relies on your protection. How can you side with these cowardly officials?”
“If war breaks out, countless commoners will suffer and blame me for the disaster,” Zhou Yu insisted. “Surrender is the only merciful choice.”
“That is not true!” Lu Su argued. “With your talent and Jiangdong’s natural barriers, Cao Cao cannot win easily!”
As the two men argued back and forth, Zhuge Liang simply sat aside, smiling silently.
Noticing this, Zhou Yu asked, “Why do you smile, sir?”
“I smile at Zijing for being unable to read the current situation,” Zhuge Liang replied casually.
Lu Su was confused and annoyed. “Why do you mock me?”
“General Zhou’s choice to surrender is perfectly reasonable,” Zhuge Liang said.
Lu Su stared at him in disbelief. “Even you say this?”
“Cao Cao is a brilliant strategist who has conquered nearly everyone,” Zhuge Liang explained. “All his former rivals—Lü Bu, Yuan Shao, Yuan Shu, Liu Biao—have fallen. Only Liu Bei stubbornly resists, and now he is trapped in Jiangxia, on the brink of ruin. If General Zhou surrenders, he can protect his family, keep his wealth and status, and leave the kingdom’s fate to heaven. There is nothing to regret.”
Lu Su roared angrily, “You would have our lord bow down and submit to this traitor!”
Zhuge Liang smiled calmly. “I know a simple plan that can send Cao Cao’s million troops retreating without a single battle, no gifts, no land concessions, and no need for our lord to cross the river. We only need to send two women to Cao Cao.”
Zhou Yu frowned. “How can two women make his entire army withdraw?”
“These two women mean nothing to Jiangdong,” Zhuge Liang said. “Losing them is like a leaf falling from a great tree or a grain of rice missing from a granary. But gaining them will make Cao Cao retreat in joy.”
“Who are these two women?” Zhou Yu pressed.
“When I lived in Longzhong, I heard Cao Cao built a magnificent Bronze Sparrow Terrace by the Zhang River, filled with the most beautiful women in the land,” Zhuge Liang said. “Cao Cao is obsessed with beauty. He has long known about the two Qiao sisters of Jiangdong—Da Qiao and Xiao Qiao, whose beauty is unmatched under heaven. He once swore an oath: first, to unify the empire and become emperor; second, to take the two Qiao sisters into his Bronze Sparrow Terrace to enjoy for the rest of his days. He marched a million troops south solely for these two women. Why not buy the sisters from Lord Qiao and send them to Cao Cao? He will be satisfied and withdraw his army immediately. This is a clever strategy, just like when Fan Li offered Xi Shi to the King of Wu.”
“Do you have proof that Cao Cao wants the Qiao sisters?” Zhou Yu asked sharply.
“His son Cao Zhi is a gifted writer,” Zhuge Liang replied. “Cao Cao once ordered him to write the Ode to the Bronze Sparrow Terrace, which declares his ambition to take the two Qiao sisters.”
“Can you recite the ode?” Zhou Yu asked.
“I remember it well for its elegant wording,” Zhuge Liang said.
He began to recite the ode slowly. When he reached the line “I shall take the two Qiaos from the southeast, to enjoy their company day and night”, he raised his voice deliberately.
As soon as the words left his mouth, Zhou Yu flew into a towering rage. He stood up abruptly and shouted toward the north.
“This old villain dares to insult me beyond endurance!”
Zhuge Liang pretended to panic and tried to calm him.
“In ancient times, emperors married princesses to barbarian tribes to secure peace. Why refuse to sacrifice two ordinary women for peace now?”
Zhou Yu gritted his teeth and snapped, “You do not understand! Da Qiao was the wife of the late General Sun Ce, and Xiao Qiao is my wife!”
Zhuge Liang feigned shock and bowed repeatedly.
“I truly did not know. I spoke foolishly. Forgive me!”
“I will never reconcile with that traitor Cao Cao!” Zhou Yu swore fiercely.
“Please think carefully before you decide,” Zhuge Liang advised pretending to be cautious. “Do not act in haste and regret it later.”
“I was only testing you earlier!” Zhou Yu said firmly. “I have never intended to surrender. I swore to defend Jiangdong with my life when I took General Sun Ce’s trust. I have wanted to march north and fight Cao Cao since I left Poyang Lake. Nothing can shake my resolve! I beg you to stand with me and defeat the traitor.”
“I am willing to serve you wholeheartedly and obey all your orders,” Zhuge Liang replied.
“Tomorrow we will persuade our lord to raise the army against Cao Cao,” Zhou Yu said.
Zhuge Liang and Lu Su then took their leave.
Early the next morning, Sun Quan held court. More than thirty civilian officials led by Zhang Zhao stood on the left, and over thirty military generals led by Cheng Pu stood on the right. All were dressed in formal court attire, waiting respectfully.
Zhou Yu entered the hall, paid his respects to Sun Quan, and stood ready.
“I hear Cao Cao has camped his army along the Han River and sent us a letter,” Zhou Yu said. “What is your decision, my lord?”
Sun Quan handed him Cao Cao’s official letter.
After reading it, Zhou Yu laughed coldly.
“This old villain thinks Jiangdong has no heroes left! How dare he insult us like this!”
“What is your plan?” Sun Quan asked.
“Have your officials discussed this matter?” Zhou Yu asked in return.
“They are split,” Sun Quan said. “Some urge surrender, some urge war. I cannot make up my mind, so I have summoned you to decide.”
“Who advises surrender?” Zhou Yu asked.
“Master Zhang and his followers,” Sun Quan replied.
Zhou Yu turned to Zhang Zhao. “Sir, please state your reasons for surrendering.”
“Cao Cao holds the emperor and commands all military actions in the empire under the imperial name,” Zhang Zhao argued. “He has just seized Jingzhou, making his power even stronger. Our only defense is the Yangtze River. Now Cao Cao has thousands of warships and can advance by land and water. We cannot resist him. Surrender now is the only wise choice to preserve our strength for the future.”
“These are the foolish words of a bookish scholar!” Zhou Yu retorted. “Jiangdong has stood firm for three generations. How can we throw it away in a single day?”
“Then what should we do?” Sun Quan asked urgently.
“Cao Cao pretends to be a loyal Han minister, but he is a traitor at heart,” Zhou Yu declared loudly. “My lord, with your extraordinary talent, your father and brother’s legacy, our fertile land and elite troops, you should march across the empire and eliminate this traitor. Surrender is unthinkable! Moreover, Cao Cao has made four fatal military mistakes. First, the north is still unstable with Ma Teng and Han Sui threatening his rear, yet he marches south. Second, his northern soldiers are unused to naval warfare and fight against our greatest advantage. Third, winter brings bitter cold, and his army lacks horse fodder. Fourth, his northern troops will fall ill from the southern river climate. Despite his numbers, his army is doomed to fail. Give me tens of thousands of elite soldiers, and I will defeat Cao Cao for you!”
Sun Quan stood up abruptly, his eyes blazing with resolve.
“This traitor has long wanted to overthrow the Han dynasty and claim the throne. He fears only Yuan Shao, Yuan Shu, Lü Bu, Liu Biao and me. All the others are gone, leaving only me standing. I will never submit to him! Your words align perfectly with my will. Heaven has sent you to help me!”
“I will fight to the death for you, my lord,” Zhou Yu said. “I only fear you still hesitate.”
Without a word, Sun Quan drew his sword and chopped off the corner of his official desk.
“Anyone who dares to speak of surrender again shall end up like this desk!”
He handed the sword to Zhou Yu, appointing him Commander-in-Chief, Cheng Pu as Deputy Commander, and Lu Su as Military Advisor. All officials and soldiers who disobeyed orders would be executed by this sword.
Holding the imperial sword, Zhou Yu addressed the crowd.
“I have been ordered to lead the army against Cao Cao. All officials and generals shall report to the riverside camp tomorrow morning. Anyone who delays or disobeys will be severely punished under military law.”
No one dared to argue. The court dispersed in silence.
Back at his residence, Zhou Yu summoned Zhuge Liang.
“The court has decided to fight Cao Cao,” Zhou Yu said. “I ask for your brilliant strategy.”
“Your lord’s heart is still not fully settled,” Zhuge Liang said. “He still hesitates.”
“What makes you say that?” Zhou Yu asked.
“He fears Cao Cao’s army is far too large and we are outnumbered,” Zhuge Liang explained. “You must clarify the true size of Cao Cao’s forces to ease his doubts. Only then can we succeed.”
“You are absolutely right,” Zhou Yu agreed.
He returned to see Sun Quan at once.
“You come at night, surely with important news,” Sun Quan said.
“I wish to resolve your lingering doubts before we deploy the army,” Zhou Yu said. “Are you still worried about Cao Cao’s troop numbers?”
“That is my only concern,” Sun Quan admitted. “I fear we are no match for his massive army.”
Zhou Yu smiled and reassured him.
“Cao Cao’s letter claims a million soldiers to frighten you, but the truth is far different. His original northern troops are only one hundred and fifty to sixty thousand, exhausted from constant wars. The seventy to eighty thousand soldiers he seized from Yuan Shao are disloyal and uneasy. Tired soldiers leading doubtful troops are no threat at all. I only need fifty thousand elite men to defeat him. Please set your heart at ease.”
Sun Quan clapped Zhou Yu on the shoulder in relief.
“Your words have cleared all my doubts. Zhang Zhao is short-sighted and disappointing. Only you and Lu Su share my resolve. You and your men may march forward at once. I will send reinforcements and supplies continuously as your backup. If the battle turns unfavorable, you may retreat, and I will personally fight Cao Cao to the end.”
Zhou Yu thanked Sun Quan and left. As he walked, a dark thought crossed his mind.
“Zhuge Liang sees through my lord’s every hesitation. His wisdom surpasses mine. He will surely become a great threat to Jiangdong in the future. I must kill him now.”
He immediately called Lu Su to his tent and told him his plan to execute Zhuge Liang.
“You cannot do this!” Lu Su objected firmly. “Cao Cao is still our enemy. Killing a genius ally before the war is self-sabotage.”
“Zhuge Liang serves Liu Bei, not us,” Zhou Yu said. “He will destroy Jiangdong one day.”
“His elder brother Zhuge Jin serves our lord loyally,” Lu Su suggested. “We can send Zhuge Jin to persuade Zhuge Liang to join our side. Then we gain a talented advisor and reunite their brothers.”
Zhou Yu thought the idea sound and agreed.
The next morning, Zhou Yu took his seat in the central military tent, armed guards standing on both sides. All officers gathered to receive orders.
Cheng Pu was older than Zhou Yu but ranked lower in the army. He was resentful and pretended to be ill, sending his eldest son Cheng Ci in his place.
Zhou Yu issued his first military decree.
“Military law shows no favoritism. Cao Cao’s tyranny exceeds Dong Zhuo’s. He holds the emperor captive and marches his army to invade our land. We fight to restore justice. All troops shall treat civilians with kindness. Rewards and punishments will be strictly enforced without bias.”
He then divided his army into five teams and assigned duties:
Han Dang and Huang Gai would lead the vanguard navy to set camp at Sanjiangkou immediately.
Jiang Qin and Zhou Tai would command the second unit.
Ling Tong and Pan Zhang would lead the third unit.
Taishi Ci and Lü Meng would head the fourth unit.
Lu Xun and Dong Xi would lead the fifth unit.
Lü Fan and Zhu Zhi would patrol and supervise land and water troops from all six counties.
All generals left to prepare their troops and ships.
Cheng Ci returned to his father and described Zhou Yu’s clear, precise troop arrangements.
Cheng Pu was utterly astonished.
“I always thought Zhou Yu was young and inexperienced, unfit for command. But his generalship is truly extraordinary! I have been wrong to doubt him.”
He hurried to the military camp to apologize. Zhou Yu received him with humility and respect, resolving their rift.
Later that day, Zhou Yu invited Zhuge Jin to his tent.
“Your brother Zhuge Liang possesses the talent to assist a king,” Zhou Yu said. “It is a waste for him to serve Liu Bei. Persuade him to join our lord. Our kingdom gains a great advisor, and you brothers may reunite. I beg you to try.”
“I have achieved nothing since coming to Jiangdong,” Zhuge Jin replied. “I will gladly obey your order.”
He rode at once to the post house to meet Zhuge Liang.
The two brothers embraced and wept, sharing stories of their long separation.
Zhuge Jin spoke softly, “Brother, do you know of Boyi and Shuqi?”
Zhuge Liang instantly guessed his brother’s purpose, planted by Zhou Yu.
“They were ancient virtuous saints,” he replied.
“They chose to starve together at Shouyang Mountain rather than part,” Zhuge Jin said tearfully. “We are blood brothers yet serve different lords. Compared to them, are we not ashamed?”
“You speak of family affection,” Zhuge Liang replied calmly, “but I uphold righteous loyalty. We are both Han subjects. Lord Liu Bei is a royal descendant of the Han. If you abandon Eastern Wu and serve him with me, we remain loyal to the dynasty and reunite as brothers. This is the perfect choice of affection and righteousness. What do you think?”
Zhuge Jin had no words to refute him. He bowed in silence and returned to report to Zhou Yu.
“What is your decision?” Zhou Yu asked.
“I have received great kindness from Lord Sun Quan. I will never betray him,” Zhuge Jin answered firmly.
Zhou Yu nodded. “You are a loyal subject. I have my own plan to deal with Zhuge Liang.”
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!