Zhuge Liang Debates the Wu Scholars and Persuades Sun Quan to Fight
Lu Su and Zhuge Liang bid farewell to Liu Bei and Liu Qi, then boarded a boat bound for Chaisang.
As they sailed, Lu Su warned Zhuge Liang privately.
“When you meet Lord Sun, whatever you do, don’t mention how massive Cao Cao’s army is. It will only scare him.”
Zhuge Liang smiled calmly.
“No need to remind me, Zijing. I know exactly what to say.”
Once they docked, Lu Su arranged for Zhuge Liang to rest at a guesthouse. He went ahead alone to see Sun Quan.
Sun Quan was already gathered with his civil and military officials, discussing urgent matters. When he heard Lu Su had returned, he immediately summoned him.
“What did you discover in Jiangxia? Tell me the truth.”
“I have a general picture of the situation. I will explain everything slowly,” Lu Su replied.
Sun Quan handed him a official letter from Cao Cao.
“Cao Cao sent a messenger with this yesterday. I sent the messenger away for now, but my officials and I still cannot decide what to do.”
Lu Su read the letter. It stated plainly that Cao Cao, acting on the emperor’s order, had campaigned against rebels. Liu Cong had surrendered without a fight, and all the people of Jingzhou had submitted. Now Cao Cao commanded a million soldiers and thousands of top generals. He proposed joining forces with Sun Quan to attack Liu Bei, divide the land equally, and form a permanent alliance. He demanded a quick reply and warned against hesitation.
“What is your inclination, my lord?” Lu Su asked.
“I have not yet made up my mind,” Sun Quan answered.
Zhang Zhao, the chief advisor, spoke up first.
“Cao Cao controls a million troops and acts in the emperor’s name. To resist him is to defy imperial authority. Our greatest advantage has always been the Yangtze River barrier. But now Cao Cao holds Jingzhou, so he shares that natural defense with us. We cannot stand against him. In my opinion, surrender is the only safe choice.”
All the other scholars echoed his words.
“Master Zhang speaks the truth. This is the will of heaven.”
Sun Quan fell silent, deep in thought.
Zhang Zhao pressed further.
“Do not hesitate, my lord. If you surrender, the people of Wu will live in peace, and our six prefectures will be preserved.”
Sun Quan kept his head down and said nothing. After a moment, he stood up to step outside and freshen up. Lu Su followed him quietly.
Knowing Lu Su had more to say, Sun Quan grabbed his arm.
“What is on your mind?”
“All these officials are misleading you,” Lu Su said firmly. “Every one of them can surrender to Cao Cao safely—only you cannot.”
Sun Quan frowned.
“Why is that?”
“If I surrendered, I could return home, take a government post, and gradually rise through the ranks. I would still hold a respectable position. But if you surrender? You would at best be a titled lord, with only a small carriage, a handful of riders, and a few attendants. You would never again rule as a sovereign. These men speak only for their own safety and careers. Do not listen to them. You must decide quickly.”
Sun Quan sighed with relief.
“Their words truly disappoint me. What you say matches my own thoughts. Heaven has sent you to guide me. Still, Cao Cao has absorbed Yuan Shao’s army and now the troops of Jingzhou. His power feels unstoppable.”
“I brought Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Jin’s younger brother, back from Jiangxia,” Lu Su said. “You may ask him about Cao Cao’s true strength.”
“The Sleeping Dragon is here?” Sun Quan asked in surprise.
“He is resting at the guesthouse now.”
“It is too late today,” Sun Quan decided. “Tomorrow I will gather all my officials. Let him first meet our Wu scholars, and then we will hold official council.”
The next morning, Lu Su visited Zhuge Liang again and repeated his warning.
“When you speak to my lord, do not exaggerate Cao Cao’s numbers.”
Zhuge Liang smiled.
“I will adapt to the moment. I will not make any mistakes.”
Lu Su led Zhuge Liang into the main hall. More than twenty top Wu officials sat formally in their official robes, ready to question him. Zhuge Liang greeted each one politely, exchanged names, and took his seat as a guest.
Seeing his extraordinary bearing and confident demeanor, the scholars knew he had come to persuade Sun Quan. Zhang Zhao spoke first, sharp and deliberate.
“I am but a humble scholar of Wu. I have long heard you compared yourself to Guan Zhong and Yue Yi. Is that true?”
“It is merely a modest comparison I once made,” Zhuge Liang replied.
“Lord Liu visited your cottage three times to recruit you, believing he had gained a fish in water. He hoped to seize Jingzhou. Yet now all of Jingzhou belongs to Cao Cao. What explanation do you have?”
Zhuge Liang realized he had to defeat Zhang Zhao’s arguments first if he hoped to convince Sun Quan.
“Taking Jingzhou would have been simple. My lord Liu Bei is benevolent and righteous. He refused to seize the territory of his kinsman Liu Biao. Liu Cong foolishly listened to evil advisors and surrendered secretly, letting Cao Cao run wild. My lord now camps in Jiangxia with careful plans far beyond ordinary people’s understanding.”
Zhang Zhao sneered.
“Then your words and deeds contradict each other. Guan Zhong helped Duke Huan dominate the realm and unify the nation. Yue Yi restored the weak Yan state and captured seventy cities. They were true heroes saving their era. You lived idle in your cottage until you served Lord Liu. Before you arrived, Lord Liu still fought across the land and held territory. After gaining you, everyone hoped he would grow stronger and restore the Han. Instead, he abandons armor and flees at every Cao advance. He lost Xinye, abandoned Fancheng, was defeated at Dangyang, and fled to Xiakou. He has no safe ground. He is worse off with you than without you. Were Guan Zhong and Yue Yi such failures?”
Zhuge Liang laughed aloud.
“A great roc soars ten thousand miles. Ordinary birds cannot understand its ambition. Treating a severe illness requires gentle medicine first to stabilize the body before strong remedies. My lord arrived at Liu Biao’s side with fewer than a thousand soldiers and only Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun as generals—utterly weakened. Xinye was a tiny county with scarce supplies, merely a temporary shelter. Yet with untrained troops and weak defenses, we burned Cao’s camps at Bowang and flooded his army at Baihe, terrifying his best generals. Even Guan Zhong and Yue Yi could not have done better. Liu Cong’s surrender was unknown to my lord, who refused to seize his relative’s land out of great righteousness. At Dangyang, he refused to abandon hundreds of thousands of common people fleeing with him, choosing slow retreat and shared defeat rather than saving himself. That is true kindness. Great armies overwhelm small ones; victory and defeat are common in war. Emperor Gaozu lost repeatedly to Xiang Yu but won the final battle at Gaixia thanks to Han Xin’s strategies. No general wins every fight. State affairs and national security demand real strategists—not empty scholars who speak brilliantly in debates yet accomplish nothing in crisis. They are the true shame of the world.”
Zhang Zhao fell completely silent, unable to reply.
Yu Fan spoke up loudly from the seats.
“Cao Cao camps with a million soldiers and thousands of generals, ready to swallow Jiangxia. What do you think of his power?”
“Cao Cao commands scattered remnants from Yuan Shao and untrained troops from Jingzhou. Even a million men are nothing to fear,” Zhuge Liang answered.
Yu Fan laughed coldly.
“You were defeated at Dangyang and cornered at Xiakou. You come begging for help yet claim to fear nothing. Empty boasts!”
“My lord resisted a million brutal soldiers with a few thousand righteous troops and retreated only to wait for the right moment,” Zhuge Liang retorted. “Wu has strong troops, abundant supplies, and the Yangtze defense. Yet your officials urge your lord to kneel and surrender. That is truly shameful. My lord is the one who fears no Cao Cao.”
Yu Fan had no response.
Bu Zhi spoke next.
“Are you here to manipulate Lord Wu with the trickery of Su Qin and Zhang Yi?”
“Su Qin and Zhang Yi were true heroes, not mere talkers,” Zhuge Liang said. “Su Qin united six states, and Zhang Yi served Qin twice. Both saved nations with their strategies. You tremble at Cao Cao’s empty threats and beg for surrender—how dare you mock great diplomats?”
Bu Zhi fell silent.
Xue Zong questioned him next.
“What kind of man is Cao Cao in your view?”
“A traitor to the Han Dynasty,” Zhuge Liang replied plainly.
Xue Zong shook his head.
“You are wrong. The Han Dynasty is nearing its end. Cao Cao controls two-thirds of the realm, and people follow him. Lord Liu fights against heaven’s will, like an egg smashing against a rock. Defeat is inevitable.”
Zhuge Liang’s voice turned stern.
“How can you speak such treasonous words? Loyalty and filial piety govern all people. As a Han official, you should stand against usurpers. Cao Cao’s ancestors served the Han for generations, yet he betrays the dynasty, seizes power, and bullies the emperor. Everyone condemns his rebellion. You claim he follows heaven’s will—you have no loyalty or morals. Your words are not worth arguing over.”
Xue Zong burned with shame and bowed his head.
Lu Ji challenged him next.
“Cao Cao descends from the prime minister Cao Shen, a loyal Han official. Lord Liu’s claim as a royal descendant cannot be proven. He was only a straw sandal and mat seller. How can he rival Cao Cao?”
Zhuge Liang smiled.
“Are you the boy who stole oranges at Yuan Shu’s feast? Listen carefully. Though Cao Cao descends from a loyal official, he betrays the Han and dishonors his own ancestors. He is a traitor to both state and family. Lord Liu’s royal lineage is officially recorded and confirmed by the emperor. What doubt is there? Emperor Gaozu started as a village headman and founded an empire. What shame is there in humble beginnings? Your childish views are unworthy of a wise discussion.”
Lu Ji had nothing to say.
Yan Jun spoke up.
“You twist words to win arguments. What classic texts do you truly master?”
Zhuge Liang replied.
“Mere memorization of passages is for useless pedants. Great men like Yi Yin, Jiang Ziya, Zhang Liang, and Chen Ping saved nations and changed history. Which old texts did they rigidly study? True talent solves crises, not just writes essays.”
Yan Jun slumped in defeat.
Cheng Deshu criticized loudly.
“You talk big but have no real talent. True scholars will only laugh at you.”
“There are noble scholars and petty scholars,” Zhuge Liang explained. “Noble scholars serve their ruler loyally, uphold justice, and leave lasting good deeds. Petty scholars only obsess over words and poems their whole lives. They write thousands of lines yet have no practical strategies. Yang Xiong was a famous writer but served the traitor Wang Mang and died in disgrace. Even endless writing is useless without courage and wisdom.”
Cheng Deshu fell silent.
All the scholars looked stunned by Zhuge Liang’s quick, flawless rebuttals. Two more officials prepared to speak up when a man burst into the hall and shouted sharply.
“Zhuge Liang is a genius of our time! You shame yourselves pestering him with trivial arguments. Cao Cao’s army presses down on us. You ignore real crisis and bicker uselessly!”
Everyone turned to see Huang Gai, the military supply officer of Wu.
“Speaking too much solves nothing,” Huang Gai said to Zhuge Liang. “Why waste words debating them? Share your advice with Lord Sun instead.”
“They refuse to understand the bigger picture, so I was forced to answer,” Zhuge Liang replied.
Huang Gai and Lu Su escorted Zhuge Liang toward the inner hall. On the way, they met Zhuge Jin, Zhuge Liang’s elder brother.
“You have arrived in Wu, yet you do not visit me first?” Zhuge Jin asked.
“I serve Lord Liu, so public duty comes before family,” Zhuge Liang answered respectfully. “I cannot tend to private matters before finishing official business. Please forgive me.”
“See Lord Sun first, then we will talk,” Zhuge Jin said and stepped aside.
Lu Su whispered one last reminder.
“Remember what I told you earlier.”
Zhuge Liang nodded.
They entered the main court. Sun Quan walked down from his seat to greet Zhuge Liang with full courtesy. After exchanging formal greetings, Zhuge Liang sat. Civil and military officials stood in two rows, watching closely. Lu Su stood beside Zhuge Liang, anxiously waiting for his words.
Zhuge Liang observed Sun Quan’s striking features—green eyes and purple beard, truly regal. He thought to himself: This man is extraordinary. He must be provoked, not persuaded gently.
After tea was served, Sun Quan spoke.
“Zijing has praised your talent highly. I am honored to meet you today. Please share your wisdom.”
“I have little knowledge to offer,” Zhuge Liang replied modestly.
“You fought alongside Lord Liu in Xinye. You must know Cao Cao’s true strength. Tell me honestly.”
“Lord Liu had too few soldiers and no secure city. He could never stand against Cao Cao,” Zhuge Liang said.
Sun Quan leaned forward.
“How many troops does Cao Cao have?”
“Around 1.5 million infantry, cavalry, and marines. I only say a million to avoid frightening your people.”
Lu Su stared in shock and kept shooting urgent glances at Zhuge Liang, but Zhuge Liang pretended not to notice.
“How many top generals and advisors serve him?” Sun Quan asked.
“Over a thousand skilled commanders and clever strategists.”
“After conquering Jingzhou, does he plan to advance further east?”
“He has lined the river with camps and built warships. His only target now is Wu.”
“Should I fight or surrender?” Sun Quan asked directly. “Give me your honest judgment.”
“I fear you will not accept my advice,” Zhuge Liang said.
“I will listen fully.”
“Once, the whole realm was chaotic. You rose in Wu, Lord Liu gathered forces in the south, and Cao Cao competed for power. Now Cao Cao has crushed all rivals and seized Jingzhou. Even heroes have no room to fight. That is why Lord Liu retreated here. Judge your own strength: if you can resist Cao Cao, break ties with him at once. If not, lay down your weapons, surrender, and serve him.”
Before Sun Quan could reply, Zhuge Liang added sharply.
“You pretend to obey while hesitating privately. Indecision will bring certain disaster.”
Sun Quan frowned deeply.
“If surrender is so wise, why does Lord Liu refuse to submit?”
“Tian Heng was only a minor noble of Qi, yet he died rather than surrender in shame. Lord Liu is a royal descendant, a hero admired by all. If he fails, it is heaven’s will. He will never bow beneath others!”
Sun Quan flew into anger. He flung his sleeves and stormed into the inner chamber. The officials all snickered and dispersed.
Lu Su reproached Zhuge Liang at once.
“Why did you speak so harshly? My lord is generous, but you insulted him openly!”
Zhuge Liang laughed loudly.
“He is far too sensitive. I have a perfect plan to defeat Cao Cao, but I will not speak unless he asks properly.”
“Truly? I will persuade him to seek your advice.”
“Cao Cao’s million soldiers are no more than ants. I can crush them with one hand.”
Lu Su hurried into the inner hall. Sun Quan was still furious.
“Zhuge Liang insulted me terribly!”
“I scolded him too,” Lu Su replied. “But he says you lack patience. He holds a winning strategy but refuses to speak casually. You should humbly ask him for help.”
Sun Quan’s anger faded instantly.
“He spoke harshly to provoke me! I was foolish to almost ruin everything.”
He returned to the outer hall personally to apologize to Zhuge Liang.
“Please forgive my rudeness earlier.”
Zhuge Liang accepted his apology politely.
Sun Quan invited him into the inner chamber for wine. After several rounds, he spoke earnestly.
“Cao Cao has destroyed all his rivals—only Lord Liu and I remain. I will never let Wu fall under his control. My mind is set on war. Yet Lord Liu has just suffered defeat. How can we stand together against such a mighty enemy?”
Zhuge Liang explained clearly.
“Lord Liu still has ten thousand elite troops under Guan Yu, and Liu Qi commands another ten thousand soldiers in Jiangxia. Cao Cao’s army is exhausted from long marches. His cavalry raced three hundred li in one day—completely spent, unable to strike hard. His northern soldiers cannot fight well on water. The Jingzhou troops follow him only out of fear, not loyalty. If you unite with Lord Liu, we will surely defeat Cao Cao. Once his army retreats north, Wu and Liu will balance each other, forming a three-way standoff. This moment decides everything.”
Sun Quan was overjoyed.
“Your words clear all my doubt! I have fully decided. We will raise troops and destroy Cao Cao together!”
He ordered Lu Su to announce the decision to all officials and sent Zhuge Liang back to the guesthouse to rest.
When Zhang Zhao heard Sun Quan planned to fight, he gathered his followers anxiously.
“Sun Quan has fallen for Zhuge Liang’s trick!”
He rushed to dissuade Sun Quan.
“Compare yourself to Yuan Shao. Cao Cao defeated Yuan Shao easily with far fewer troops. Now he commands millions. To listen to Zhuge Liang and fight is like carrying firewood to put out a blaze—disaster is certain.”
Gu Yong added his voice.
“Liu Bei fights only to save himself and borrows our troops. Do not be manipulated by him. Follow Master Zhang’s advice.”
Sun Quan sank into hesitation again and said nothing.
After the officials left, Lu Su re-entered.
“All those who urge surrender only protect their own families and futures. Do not trust them.”
Still Sun Quan hesitated.
“Your hesitation will ruin us,” Lu Su warned.
“Leave me to think quietly,” Sun Quan replied.
Civil officials insisted on surrender; military generals demanded war. The court fell into noisy argument.
Back in his private quarters, Sun Quan could neither eat nor sleep, trapped in uncertainty. His mother, Lady Wu, noticed his distress and asked him the cause.
“Cao Cao marches south to invade us,” Sun Quan explained. “My officials are split between war and surrender. I fear defeat if I fight, yet fear death if I surrender. I cannot decide.”
Lady Wu spoke gently.
“Have you forgotten the final words of my late sister?”
Sun Quan suddenly woke from his confused state.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!