Zhuge Liang Executes Ma Su and the Wu Defeats Wei at Shiting
Emperor Cao Rui sat on the imperial dragon throne and asked his ministers for strategies to deal with the Shu Kingdom.
Sun Zi, the Minister of the Department of Records, stepped forward to speak.
“Back in the day, Emperor Taizu Wudi struggled fiercely to conquer Zhang Lu. He often told us afterward that Nanzheng was practically a natural prison. The Xiegu Valley stretches five hundred li through nothing but rocky caves, utterly unfit for large-scale warfare.”
“If we mobilize the entire national army to invade Shu right now, the Eastern Wu will surely strike us from behind. Our best move is to hold and defend the critical passes, nurture our troops, and build up our strength.”
“In a few years, once we grow powerful enough, Wu and Shu will inevitably fight among themselves. We can then strike at the perfect moment. This is the safest and most steady strategy.”
Cao Rui turned to look at Sima Yi.
“What do you think of this plan?”
Sima Yi nodded in agreement.
“Minister Sun’s judgment is entirely reasonable.”
Cao Rui adopted the strategy at once. He ordered Sima Yi to deploy troops to guard all strategic passes, leaving Guo Huai and Zhang He to defend Chang’an. After rewarding his soldiers, Cao Rui returned triumphantly to Luoyang.
Meanwhile, Zhuge Liang had retreated to Hanzhong. After taking stock of his troops, he noticed that Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi’s unit had not yet returned. Worry washed over him, and he immediately sent Guan Xing and Zhang Bao with two separate armies to provide backup.
Just as the two generals were about to set off, scouts rushed in with a report: Zhao Yun and Deng Zhi had returned safely. Not a single soldier was lost, and all military supplies and equipment were intact.
Overjoyed, Zhuge Liang led his generals out of the camp in person to welcome them.
As soon as Zhao Yun saw Zhuge Liang, he dismounted hastily and knelt on the ground.
“I suffered a defeat in battle. I do not deserve the prime minister’s personal welcome.”
Zhuge Liang hurried forward to help him up, holding his hand tightly.
“This failure is my fault for misjudging the situation. All other armies suffered heavy casualties and losses, yet your unit returned without losing a single man or piece of supplies. How did you accomplish this?”
Deng Zhi spoke up from the side to explain.
“I led the troops forward on the march, while General Zhao stayed behind alone to cover our retreat. He even killed an enemy general on the way. The Wei troops were terrified of his bravery, which is why we managed to preserve all our military provisions and equipment.”
Zhuge Liang sighed with heartfelt admiration.
“Truly, you are a general of true virtue and courage!”
He immediately rewarded Zhao Yun with fifty catties of gold and ten thousand bolts of silk to distribute among his soldiers.
But Zhao Yun declined the rewards humbly.
“All our army’s troops failed to achieve victory in this campaign. My men and I deserve punishment, not rewards. If we accept these gifts now, the prime minister’s system of rewards and punishments will seem unfair. Please keep these treasures stored away, and distribute them to the soldiers this winter instead.”
Zhuge Liang sighed deeply.
“The late emperor often praised General Zhao’s noble character. Today, I see his words were absolutely true.”
From that day on, Zhuge Liang held even deeper respect for Zhao Yun.
Soon after, Ma Su, Wang Ping, Wei Yan, and Gao Xiang returned to camp one after another.
Zhuge Liang summoned Wang Ping first and questioned him sternly.
“I ordered you to assist Ma Su in defending Jieting. Why did you fail to persuade him, leading to this disastrous defeat?”
Wang Ping knelt and explained his side earnestly.
“I warned him repeatedly to build earthen fortifications and set up camp on the main road, but he refused to listen and insisted on camping on the mountain. Left with no choice, I led five thousand soldiers to set up camp ten li away from the mountain.”
“When the Wei army arrived suddenly, they surrounded the mountain completely. I charged the enemy more than a dozen times but could not break their encirclement. By the next day, Ma Su’s army collapsed and countless soldiers surrendered.”
“My small force could not hold our position, so I went to seek help from Wei Yan. On the way, we were trapped in a valley by Wei troops and barely fought our way out. When I returned to our original camp, it had already been seized by the enemy.”
“I then headed for Lieliu City and met Gao Xiang on the road. We divided our troops into three teams to raid the Wei camp and retake Jieting. But when we arrived, the enemy had set up no sentries at all, which made me suspicious.”
“I climbed a high hill to scout and saw that Wei Yan and Gao Xiang were both surrounded by Wei soldiers. I charged in to rescue them and regrouped with Ma Su’s remaining men. Fearing Yangping Pass would fall, I rushed back to defend it immediately. I did everything I could to persuade Ma Su. If Your Excellency doubts me, you may question any of the frontline generals.”
Zhuge Liang waved his hand to dismiss Wang Ping, then ordered Ma Su to be brought forward.
Ma Su entered the tent with his hands bound tightly and knelt before Zhuge Liang.
Zhuge Liang’s expression turned grave.
“You have studied military books since childhood and claim to understand warfare thoroughly. I warned you countless times that Jieting was our army’s lifeline. You swore to defend it with your entire family’s lives and volunteered for this critical mission.”
“If you had listened to Wang Ping’s advice, we would never have suffered this defeat. All our troop losses and lost territory are your sole fault. If I spare you from military punishment, how can I command the army fairly? Do not blame me for being ruthless. After your death, I will provide monthly provisions and support for your family, so you need not worry about them.”
He immediately ordered his guards to drag Ma Su outside the camp for execution.
Ma Su wept bitterly.
“Prime Minister, you have treated me like your own son, and I have always regarded you as my father. I know my crime is unforgivable. I only beg you to remember the ancient story: Emperor Shun executed Gun but appointed Gun’s son Yu to great achievements. If you spare my family and reuse my kin, I will die in peace.”
Zhuge Liang shed tears as he replied.
“We are as close as brothers. Your son will be treated as my own. I will not fail you.”
The guards dragged Ma Su to the outer gate of the military camp to carry out the execution.
Just then, Jiang Wan, the army advisor, arrived urgently from Chengdu. Seeing they were about to behead Ma Su, he shouted in shock.
“Stop the execution at once!”
He rushed into the main tent and pleaded with Zhuge Liang.
“In ancient times, the State of Chu executed its brilliant general Chen, and Duke Wen of Jin rejoiced at the news. The realm is still far from unified. Is it not a pity to put such a talented strategist to death?”
Zhuge Liang wept as he answered.
“Sun Wu was able to conquer all under heaven solely because he enforced strict military discipline. Wars rage across the land even now. If we abandon military law, how can we defeat the traitorous forces? Ma Su must be executed.”
Moments later, the soldiers brought Ma Su’s severed head before the tent steps. Zhuge Liang cried uncontrollably.
Jiang Wan asked in confusion.
“Ma Su has paid for his crimes with his life. Why does Your Excellency still grieve so deeply?”
“I do not weep for Ma Su,” Zhuge Liang replied sorrowfully. “I weep for my own foolishness. Before his passing, the late emperor warned me at Baidicheng: ‘Ma Su is boastful and overestimates his abilities; he cannot be entrusted with important duties.’ Today, his words have come true. That is why I grieve.”
All the generals and soldiers present shed tears in sorrow. Ma Su was executed at the age of thirty-nine, in the fifth month of the sixth year of Jianxing.
After the execution, Zhuge Liang ordered Ma Su’s head to be paraded through all military camps as a warning to the troops. He then sewed the head back onto the body, arranged for a proper burial in a coffin, and personally wrote a sacrificial oration for his funeral. He also took exceptional care of Ma Su’s family, providing them with monthly grain and salary without fail.
Zhuge Liang then drafted a memorial to the throne and sent Jiang Wan to deliver it to Emperor Liu Shan in Chengdu, begging to be demoted from his position as Prime Minister.
Jiang Wan returned to Chengdu, presented the memorial to the emperor, and Liu Shan opened it to read.
“I am a man of mediocre talent, unworthy of my high office. I took command of the army and encouraged our troops, yet I failed to uphold strict military discipline and acted without due caution. My poor judgment led to the loss of Jieting and the defeat at Jigu.”
“All blame falls solely on me. I misjudged people and mishandled state affairs. As the ancient classics state, the supreme commander must bear responsibility for military failures. I beg Your Majesty to demote me by three ranks to atone for my mistakes. I am filled with shame and await your imperial order.”
After reading the memorial, Emperor Liu Shan sighed.
“Victory and defeat are common in war. Prime Minister, you need not blame yourself so harshly.”
Fei Yi, a palace attendant, stepped forward to speak.
“Your Majesty, good governance relies entirely on strict law enforcement. If the law is ignored, the people and soldiers will never be obedient. The Prime Minister requests demotion after his military defeat, which is the proper and righteous course.”
Liu Shan agreed and issued an imperial edict. He demoted Zhuge Liang to General of the Right, allowing him to act in place of the Prime Minister and retain full command of the army. He sent Fei Yi to deliver the edict to Hanzhong.
After receiving the demotion order, Fei Yi tried to comfort Zhuge Liang, fearing he would feel disgraced.
“The people of Shu are celebrating, for our army captured four counties in this campaign.”
Zhuge Liang’s expression turned stern.
“What foolish talk! We captured those lands only to lose them again. How is that any different from gaining nothing at all? Your congratulations only bring me shame.”
Fei Yi tried again.
“His Imperial Majesty is delighted that we have recruited the talented Jiang Wei.”
Zhuge Liang snapped angrily.
“We returned in defeat with no territorial gains. This is my great failure. Gaining a single talented general means nothing to weaken the Wei Kingdom!”
Fei Yi asked one last question.
“Prime Minister, you still command hundreds of thousands of soldiers. Will you launch another campaign against Wei soon?”
Zhuge Liang replied calmly and resolutely.
“In our previous battles at Qishan and Jigu, our army outnumbered the enemy, yet we failed to win and suffered defeat. The problem lies not in the size of our army, but in the leadership.”
“From now on, I will streamline our troops, clarify rewards and punishments, reflect on my mistakes, and revise our battle strategies. No amount of soldiers will help if our command is flawed.”
“All officers and soldiers who serve the kingdom must point out my faults and shortcomings openly. Only then can we secure victory, destroy the traitorous forces, and achieve our great ambitions.”
Fei Yi and all the generals were thoroughly convinced by his words. Fei Yi soon returned to Chengdu.
During his time in Hanzhong, Zhuge Liang treated soldiers and common people with kindness and care. He trained the army rigorously, built siege and river-crossing equipment, stockpiled grain, and prepared war vessels to lay the groundwork for future campaigns.
Wei scouts observed all these preparations and reported back to Luoyang. Emperor Cao Rui summoned Sima Yi to discuss countermeasures against Shu.
Sima Yi advised the emperor.
“Now is not the time to attack Shu. The weather is sweltering, and the Shu troops will not launch an offensive. If we march deep into their territory, they will hold the mountain passes and defend firmly, leaving us stuck in a prolonged battle with no quick victory.”
Cao Rui asked.
“What if the Shu army invades us again?”
“I have already predicted Zhuge Liang’s next move,” Sima Yi answered. “He will surely attempt a tactic similar to Han Xin’s famous ‘secret march through Chencang’. I recommend a general to fortify and defend the Chencang passage, who will hold the line without fail.”
“This man stands nine feet tall, possesses immense strength, excels at archery, and is a master of strategy. He alone can block Zhuge Liang’s advance.”
Intrigued, Cao Rui asked.
“Who is this general?”
“His name is Hao Zhao, courtesy name Bodao, from Taiyuan,” Sima Yi replied. “He currently serves as a minor general guarding Hexi.”
Cao Rui immediately issued an imperial appointment, promoting Hao Zhao to General Who Guards the West and ordering him to defend the Chencang passage.
Just as the imperial envoy prepared to depart, a new report arrived. Cao Xiu, Grand Governor of Yangzhou, had submitted a memorial stating that Zhou Fang, Administrator of Poyang in Wu, planned to surrender his entire county to Wei. Zhou Fang had also listed seven detailed strategies to prove Wu could be easily conquered, begging the Wei court to send troops immediately.
Cao Rui opened the memorial and read it alongside Sima Yi.
Sima Yi said at once. “This is a perfect opportunity to destroy Wu! I am willing to lead troops to assist Cao Xiu.”
At that moment, General Jia Kui stepped forward from the court ranks.
“The people of Wu are treacherous and unpredictable. We cannot trust their words fully. Zhou Fang is a cunning strategist; his surrender is surely a trap to lure our army into an ambush.”
“There is truth to your warning,” Sima Yi conceded. “But we cannot let this promising opportunity slip away.”
Cao Rui made his decision.
“Then Zhongda, you and Jia Kui shall lead troops to support Cao Xiu.”
The two generals accepted the imperial order and departed.
The Wei army split into three columns. Cao Xiu led the main force to advance on Wancheng. Jia Kui marched with Generals Man Chong and Hu Zhi to attack Yangcheng and approach Dongguan. Sima Yi led his own troops to assault Jiangling.
Meanwhile in Wuchang, Sun Quan gathered his officials for a military council.
“Zhou Fang has sent secret word that Cao Xiu’s Wei army plans to invade our territory. He has devised a ploy, submitting seven false surrender strategies to lure the Wei troops deep into our lands, where we will ambush and destroy them. The Wei army is advancing in three columns. What strategies do you propose?”
Gu Yong replied immediately.
“This critical mission can only be entrusted to Lu Boyan (Lu Xun).”
Delighted, Sun Quan summoned Lu Xun at once. He appointed Lu Xun Grand General Who Assists the Kingdom and Supreme Marshal of Pacifying the North, granting him command of the imperial guard and full authority over all military affairs, with even civil and military officials subject to his orders. Sun Quan personally escorted Lu Xun to his post.
After accepting his command, Lu Xun recommended two generals to serve as his left and right deputy commanders to counter the three Wei columns.
Sun Quan asked for their names.
Lu Xun answered. “Generals Zhu Huan and Quan Cong are capable of assisting me in this campaign.”
Sun Quan promptly appointed Zhu Huan Left Deputy Commander and Quan Cong Right Deputy Commander.
Lu Xun commanded over seven hundred thousand troops from the eighty-one prefectures of Jiangnan and the Jinghu region. He led the central army himself, with Zhu Huan commanding the left flank and Quan Cong the right, advancing in three formations.
Zhu Huan proposed a battle plan to Lu Xun.
“Cao Xiu gained his high position through imperial favor, not through true military talent. He has foolishly trusted Zhou Fang’s false surrender and marched deep into our territory.”
“He will surely be defeated. His only escape routes are the narrow mountain paths of Jiashi and Guache. I ask to lead troops with Quan Cong to ambush these passes, blocking the roads with fallen trees and boulders. We can capture Cao Xiu alive.”
“With Cao Xiu captured, we can march straight north, seize Shouchun, and threaten Xuchang and Luoyang. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity!”
Lu Xun shook his head.
“This plan is not ideal. I have a better strategy in mind.”
Though dissatisfied, Zhu Huan retreated without further argument.
Lu Xun ordered Zhuge Jin and other generals to defend Jiangling and hold back Sima Yi’s forces. He finalized all troop deployments for the upcoming battle.
Cao Xiu’s army soon arrived at Wancheng, where Zhou Fang came out to greet him and entered his military tent.
Cao Xiu spoke confidently.
“I received your seven-part strategy and reported your surrender to the emperor. Our three armies have marched forth. If we conquer Jiangdong, you will earn great merit. Yet some warn you are too cunning to be trusted. I choose to believe you would never deceive me.”
Zhou Fang burst into tears and snatched a sword from a guard’s hand, pretending to commit suicide.
Cao Xiu rushed to stop him in panic.
“I have laid my heart bare in these seven strategies,” Zhou Fang cried. “Yet you still doubt me. This must be slander spread by Wu’s spies. If you believe their lies, I have no reason to live! Only heaven knows my loyalty!”
He raised the sword to his throat again.
Cao Xiu hurried to embrace him.
“I was only joking! Do not take this to heart!”
To prove his sincerity, Zhou Fang cut off his own hair with the sword and tossed it to the ground.
“I offer you my utmost loyalty, yet you toy with my heart. I cut the hair given to me by my parents to swear my allegiance!”
Completely convinced, Cao Xiu hosted a grand feast in Zhou Fang’s honor. After the feast, Zhou Fang took his leave.
Moments later, Jia Kui arrived at the camp. Cao Xiu summoned him and asked coldly.
“What brings you here?”
Jia Kui warned urgently.
“I suspect the entire Wu army is amassed near Wancheng. Do not advance recklessly. Wait for my troops to join yours for a coordinated attack.”
Cao Xiu grew angry, suspecting jealousy.
“Do you seek to steal my merit?”
“Moreover,” Jia Kui continued, “Zhou Fang’s haircut oath is nothing but a trick. Just as Yu Li cut off his own arm to assassinate Qing Ji in ancient times, this is a deceit. You must not trust it.”
Enraged, Cao Xiu shouted.
“I am about to march to battle, yet you speak such defeatist words to shake my soldiers’ morale!”
He ordered his guards to drag Jia Kui outside for execution.
All the generals begged for mercy.
“Executing a top general before the battle will bring bad fortune to the army. Spare his life for now.”
Cao Xiu relented. He stripped Jia Kui of his military command, seized his troops, and left him confined in the camp. He then led his army forward to attack Dongguan.
Zhou Fang learned that Jia Kui had lost his command and smiled with delight.
“If Cao Xiu had listened to Jia Kui’s advice, Wu would have been defeated. Heaven has granted us this victory!”
He immediately sent a secret messenger to report to Lu Xun in Wancheng.
Lu Xun gathered his generals and issued his orders.
“The Shiting region has mountain roads perfect for ambushes. We will seize the open ground at Shiting and set up our formation to await the Wei army.”
He appointed Xu Sheng as vanguard and sent him forward with troops.
Cao Xiu let Zhou Fang lead the way for his army. Marching onward, Cao Xiu asked his guide.
“What place lies ahead?”
“This is Shiting,” Zhou Fang replied. “It is an ideal spot to station our army.”
Cao Xiu led his entire army and supply convoy to set up camp at Shiting.
The next day, scouts rushed in with a report.
“Wu troops are stationed at the mountain pass ahead. Their numbers are unknown.”
Cao Xiu paled in shock.
“Zhou Fang told me there were no enemy troops here! How can there be an ambush?”
He called for Zhou Fang to answer for the deception, only to find that Zhou Fang had vanished with dozens of his followers.
Cao Xiu stamped his foot in regret.
“I have fallen for the trap! But I will not retreat so easily!”
He appointed General Zhang Pu as vanguard, ordering him to lead thousands of soldiers to engage the Wu army.
The two armies formed battle lines. Zhang Pu rode forward and shouted insults.
“Surrender at once, you rebel soldiers!”
Xu Sheng galloped out to fight him. After a few rounds of combat, Zhang Pu could no longer hold his ground and retreated back to Cao Xiu’s camp.
“Xu Sheng is far too fierce!” he reported.
Cao Xiu formulated a new plan.
“I will defeat them with a surprise tactic.”
He ordered Zhang Pu to hide twenty thousand soldiers in the southern hills of Shiting and Xue Qiao to ambush with twenty thousand troops in the northern hills.
“Tomorrow, I will lead a thousand soldiers to provoke the enemy and feign retreat. I will lure them toward the northern mountain. At the sound of my cannon signal, we will attack from three sides and crush them completely.”
The two generals accepted the order and led their troops to set up ambushes that night.
Meanwhile, Lu Xun gave orders to Zhu Huan and Quan Cong.
“Each of you will lead thirty thousand troops to circle around the mountain paths of Shiting and attack the Wei camp from the rear. Set fire as your signal. I will lead the main army to assault their front. This will ensure Cao Xiu’s defeat and capture.”
At dusk, the two generals marched out with their troops.
By the second watch of the night, Zhu Huan’s troops had circled to the rear of the Wei camp. They stumbled upon Zhang Pu’s ambush unit. Before Zhang Pu could identify the incoming troops, Zhu Huan charged forward and cut him down from his horse.
The Wei ambush soldiers scattered in panic. Zhu Huan ordered his rear troops to light the signal fires.
Quan Cong’s army also reached the Wei rear and clashed with Xue Qiao’s troops. He routed Xue Qiao’s forces and inflicted heavy casualties on the Wei soldiers.
With both rear ambushes destroyed, Zhu Huan and Quan Cong attacked the main Wei camp from behind. The Wei army descended into total chaos, with soldiers trampling and killing each other in the panic.
Cao Xiu mounted his horse in a hurry and fled toward the Jiashi Pass. Xu Sheng led the main Wu army in a relentless frontal assault. Countless Wei soldiers died in the battle, and fleeing troops abandoned their armor and weapons everywhere.
As Cao Xiu fled desperately through the narrow Jiashi mountain path, a troop of soldiers suddenly emerged from a side road. Leading them was General Jia Kui.
Relieved and ashamed, Cao Xiu sighed.
“I refused your advice, and now I have suffered this terrible defeat.”
Jia Kui urged him urgently.
“Hurry and escape this pass! If the Wu troops block the road with boulders and trees, we will all be trapped and killed!”
Cao Xiu spurred his horse to flee while Jia Kui stayed behind to cover the retreat. Jia Kui planted countless fake banners among the dense woods and steep mountain paths to create the illusion of hidden ambushes.
When Xu Sheng’s pursuing troops saw the flickering flags on the hillsides, they suspected a trap and halted their chase, turning back to camp. Thanks to Jia Kui’s strategy, Cao Xiu escaped certain death.
Upon hearing news of Cao Xiu’s catastrophic defeat, Sima Yi also withdrew his troops and retreated to Wei territory.
Soon after, Xu Sheng, Zhu Huan, and Quan Cong returned to camp with victory reports. The Wu army captured countless carts, cattle, mules, weapons, and military supplies. Tens of thousands of Wei soldiers surrendered.
Overjoyed by the sweeping victory, Lu Xun marched back to Wuchang in triumph, accompanied by Zhou Fang and all his generals.
Sun Quan led his civil and military officials outside Wuchang City to welcome the returning army. He personally shielded Lu Xun with his imperial canopy as they entered the city, and all meritorious generals were promoted and rewarded.
Sun Quan saw Zhou Fang’s shaven head and praised him warmly.
“Your brave sacrifice of cutting your hair secured this great victory. Your deeds will be recorded in history forever.”
He immediately conferred upon Zhou Fang the title of Marquis of the Pass and held a grand feast to celebrate the victory.
After the celebrations, Lu Xun submitted a proposal to Sun Quan.
“Cao Xiu’s defeat has terrified the Wei court. We should send an envoy to Shu with a formal letter, urging Zhuge Liang to launch a new attack on Wei at this perfect opportunity.”
Sun Quan approved the plan at once and dispatched a messenger to Shu with the official diplomatic letter.
Comments 0
Share your thoughts about this chapter with other readers.
Sign in to join the discussion about this chapter.
Log in to comment
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!